What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Dynasty Value Discussion Thread (7 Viewers)

Just got offered achane for my MHJ in my keeper league. Notable players on my team already by position
Rb
Gibbs
JT

WR
AJB
JJ
chase
Garrett wilson
Odunze

Not ppr
Start 1/1/2/1 plus a couple flex.

Pondering it hard at the moment
qUITE THE ROSTER. mAYBE YO
Just got offered achane for my MHJ in my keeper league. Notable players on my team already by position
Rb
Gibbs
JT

WR
AJB
JJ
chase
Garrett wilson
Odunze

Not ppr
Start 1/1/2/1 plus a couple flex.

Pondering it hard at the moment
Quite the roster. Maybe you should ask the other 3 players in your league.
 
Checking in on price of Tyreek Hill (Standard Scoring)

For my playoff push I was offered Tyreek Hill for JSN and 2 1st Round Rookie Picks (2026 and 2027)

I think that is too much to give. Would probably give JSN and 1st Rounder.

Thoughts as to Tyreek Hill's value.
That's a HUGE overpay. I'm not sure at this point if I'd give up JSN for Tyreek straight up.
 
Checking in on price of Tyreek Hill (Standard Scoring)

For my playoff push I was offered Tyreek Hill for JSN and 2 1st Round Rookie Picks (2026 and 2027)

I think that is too much to give. Would probably give JSN and 1st Rounder.

Thoughts as to Tyreek Hill's value.
That's a HUGE overpay. I'm not sure at this point if I'd give up JSN for Tyreek straight up.
AGREED! JSN is rising and this is a major overpay. Personally, I would NOT give JSN + a single 1st for Tyreek
Lockett is fading, Metcalf is hurt but will remain in SEA. JSN is part of the bright future.
 
Checking in on price of Tyreek Hill (Standard Scoring)

For my playoff push I was offered Tyreek Hill for JSN and 2 1st Round Rookie Picks (2026 and 2027)

I think that is too much to give. Would probably give JSN and 1st Rounder.

Thoughts as to Tyreek Hill's value.
That's a HUGE overpay. I'm not sure at this point if I'd give up JSN for Tyreek straight up.
AGREED! JSN is rising and this is a major overpay. Personally, I would NOT give JSN + a single 1st for Tyreek
Lockett is fading, Metcalf is hurt but will remain in SEA. JSN is part of the bright future.
Thanks for your input. Hill is a luxury not a need as I have ARSB, Collins, Aiyuk, Dell, and JSN as my main WR (start 1 or 2 max) More trying to keep him away from another contender or 2 is all.
 
Thanks for your input. Hill is a luxury not a need as I have ARSB, Collins, Aiyuk, Dell, and JSN as my main WR (start 1 or 2 max) More trying to keep him away from another contender or 2 is all.
While that has MERIT, it would have to be an "economical" move ... that is almost a future crippling deal.

While keeping 30 yo Tyreek away from other "contenders" is a :shark: move, let them overpay.

Good FBG Premium Read
 
Last edited:
Just got offered achane for my MHJ in my keeper league. Notable players on my team already by position
Rb
Gibbs
JT

WR
AJB
JJ
chase
Garrett wilson
Odunze

Not ppr
Start 1/1/2/1 plus a couple flex.

Pondering it hard at the moment
qUITE THE ROSTER. mAYBE YO
Just got offered achane for my MHJ in my keeper league. Notable players on my team already by position
Rb
Gibbs
JT

WR
AJB
JJ
chase
Garrett wilson
Odunze

Not ppr
Start 1/1/2/1 plus a couple flex.

Pondering it hard at the moment
Quite the roster. Maybe you should ask the other 3 players in your league.
Ten team league which has been around since 1986. 6/10 original owners
 
Quick question

My RB’s are Aaron Jones (1 year) and Rachaad White (3 years)

Would you trade Devonta Smith (2 years) for Chuba Hubbard (4 years)?

My other WR’s are Zay Flowers (4 years), Jayden Reed (4 years), Tank Dell (4 years), Drake London (3 years), Cedric Tillman (4 years).
 
Quick question

My RB’s are Aaron Jones (1 year) and Rachaad White (3 years)

Would you trade Devonta Smith (2 years) for Chuba Hubbard (4 years)?

My other WR’s are Zay Flowers (4 years), Jayden Reed (4 years), Tank Dell (4 years), Drake London (3 years), Cedric Tillman (4 years).
No way. I’ve ridden Chuba for the beginning of the season in one league and count myself lucky he’s done so well, but Brooks is in the mix this week and assumed to be the obvious future at RB in CAR. So you’re selling a solid WR for a soon-to-be backup RB imo.
 
Quick question

My RB’s are Aaron Jones (1 year) and Rachaad White (3 years)

Would you trade Devonta Smith (2 years) for Chuba Hubbard (4 years)?

My other WR’s are Zay Flowers (4 years), Jayden Reed (4 years), Tank Dell (4 years), Drake London (3 years), Cedric Tillman (4 years).
No way. I’ve ridden Chuba for the beginning of the season in one league and count myself lucky he’s done so well, but Brooks is in the mix this week and assumed to be the obvious future at RB in CAR. So you’re selling a solid WR for a soon-to-be backup RB imo.
And with that, the Panthers sign Chuba to a 4 yr deal. What the hell do I know?!
 
Looking to trade Calvin Ridley's expiring contract. Buyer will have his services for the rest of this season and will have the right to match in next year's auction. Barring injuries, I don't have room for him in my lineup this season, and I have no intention of re-signing him after this season due to cap/roster constraints. I prefer not to lose him for nothing.

Is a 3rd-round pick in the rookie draft fair value?
 
Looking to trade Calvin Ridley's expiring contract. Buyer will have his services for the rest of this season and will have the right to match in next year's auction. Barring injuries, I don't have room for him in my lineup this season, and I have no intention of re-signing him after this season due to cap/roster constraints. I prefer not to lose him for nothing.

Is a 3rd-round pick in the rookie draft fair value?
He is currently valued around a Late 2025 2nd/early 3rd
But with your limited options and contract restrictions, early to mid 3rd is likely his value.
I am a Ridley owner and would move him for a late 2nd, but maybe not a 3rd (no contract issues, but Depth is key to success in my league)
He is my WR4 in PPR start 2-5 WR
 
Looking to trade Calvin Ridley's expiring contract. Buyer will have his services for the rest of this season and will have the right to match in next year's auction. Barring injuries, I don't have room for him in my lineup this season, and I have no intention of re-signing him after this season due to cap/roster constraints. I prefer not to lose him for nothing.

Is a 3rd-round pick in the rookie draft fair value?
He is currently valued around a Late 2025 2nd/early 3rd
But with your limited options and contract restrictions, early to mid 3rd is likely his value.
I am a Ridley owner and would move him for a late 2nd, but maybe not a 3rd (no contract issues, but Depth is key to success in my league)
He is my WR4 in PPR start 2-5 WR
Yeah, he's my W4-5 behind Chase, Garrett Wilson, MHJ, and maybe Shakir. Also PPR, but start 2-4 WR. But I also have Bowers, Engram, and Otton, which makes the ol' lineup a little crowded.
 
Tank Dell value check please
Good receiver, would probably cook in another organization. I don't expect his production will continue at a high level when Nico comes back. If he can step into that slot roll and Diggs retires, maybe he'll have more value. He's also one of the smallest guys in the league. I'd be surprised if he's able to handle solid production for extended periods of time in the league.
 
How are y'all feeling about Nix? In a SF/TEP where my QB room is crap (Goff, Darnold, Levis), I'm considering trading Nabers for him and a minor plus. Is it worth the risk? Full disclosure, I have a slight man-crush on Nix and hate the Giants.
 
How are y'all feeling about Nix? In a SF/TEP where my QB room is crap (Goff, Darnold, Levis), I'm considering trading Nabers for him and a minor plus. Is it worth the risk? Full disclosure, I have a slight man-crush on Nix and hate the Giants.
Nix will be good. I will defer to the SF guys, but that super light for Nabers.
 
How are y'all feeling about Nix? In a SF/TEP where my QB room is crap (Goff, Darnold, Levis), I'm considering trading Nabers for him and a minor plus. Is it worth the risk? Full disclosure, I have a slight man-crush on Nix and hate the Giants.
Nix will be good. I will defer to the SF guys, but that super light for Nabers.
Absolutely want to acknowledge it's an overpay even in SF. I think my question is along the lines of, "can Nix be a perennial top 5 guy?". I'm having a hard time projecting him out beyond this season.
 
Checking in on price of Tyreek Hill (Standard Scoring)

For my playoff push I was offered Tyreek Hill for JSN and 2 1st Round Rookie Picks (2026 and 2027)

I think that is too much to give. Would probably give JSN and 1st Rounder.

Thoughts as to Tyreek Hill's value.
That's a HUGE overpay. I'm not sure at this point if I'd give up JSN for Tyreek straight up.
AGREED! JSN is rising and this is a major overpay. Personally, I would NOT give JSN + a single 1st for Tyreek
Lockett is fading, Metcalf is hurt but will remain in SEA. JSN is part of the bright future.
Thanks for your input. Hill is a luxury not a need as I have ARSB, Collins, Aiyuk, Dell, and JSN as my main WR (start 1 or 2 max) More trying to keep him away from another contender or 2 is all.
He finally came off asking for JSN and a 1st and changed to Aiyuk and a 2026 1st .... I still rejected

Was able to add Ladd for a 2026 Late 1st which I acquired for Stafford from a team needs a QB due to Dak injury
 
How are y'all feeling about Nix? In a SF/TEP where my QB room is crap (Goff, Darnold, Levis), I'm considering trading Nabers for him and a minor plus. Is it worth the risk? Full disclosure, I have a slight man-crush on Nix and hate the Giants.
Nix will be good. I will defer to the SF guys, but that super light for Nabers.
Absolutely want to acknowledge it's an overpay even in SF. I think my question is along the lines of, "can Nix be a perennial top 5 guy?". I'm having a hard time projecting him out beyond this season.
It's really hard to project him top 5. High end QB is pretty strong right now. Maybe a perennial qb1 is a strong/fair projection. I don't think you can reasonably value him with this group yet:

Lamar/Allen/Hurts/Daniels/Burrow/Mahomes/Stroud/Love
 
How are y'all feeling about Nix? In a SF/TEP where my QB room is crap (Goff, Darnold, Levis), I'm considering trading Nabers for him and a minor plus. Is it worth the risk? Full disclosure, I have a slight man-crush on Nix and hate the Giants.
Nix will be good. I will defer to the SF guys, but that super light for Nabers.
Absolutely want to acknowledge it's an overpay even in SF. I think my question is along the lines of, "can Nix be a perennial top 5 guy?". I'm having a hard time projecting him out beyond this season.
It's really hard to project him top 5. High end QB is pretty strong right now. Maybe a perennial qb1 is a strong/fair projection. I don't think you can reasonably value him with this group yet:

Lamar/Allen/Hurts/Daniels/Burrow/Mahomes/Stroud/Love
So realistically, top 10 is the ceiling, then? And I'm safe in saying that Nabers is a strong projection in the top 5 WRs moving forward? Given that, the shark move may be to keep Nabers, take a QB in the 2025 1st and risk that the group of Darnold/Levis/Howell become a serviceable QB2.
 
How are y'all feeling about Nix? In a SF/TEP where my QB room is crap (Goff, Darnold, Levis), I'm considering trading Nabers for him and a minor plus. Is it worth the risk? Full disclosure, I have a slight man-crush on Nix and hate the Giants.
Nix will be good. I will defer to the SF guys, but that super light for Nabers.
Absolutely want to acknowledge it's an overpay even in SF. I think my question is along the lines of, "can Nix be a perennial top 5 guy?". I'm having a hard time projecting him out beyond this season.
It's really hard to project him top 5. High end QB is pretty strong right now. Maybe a perennial qb1 is a strong/fair projection. I don't think you can reasonably value him with this group yet:

Lamar/Allen/Hurts/Daniels/Burrow/Mahomes/Stroud/Love
So realistically, top 10 is the ceiling, then? And I'm safe in saying that Nabers is a strong projection in the top 5 WRs moving forward? Given that, the shark move may be to keep Nabers, take a QB in the 2025 1st and risk that the group of Darnold/Levis/Howell become a serviceable QB2.
I think those assumptions are pretty safe. If you are determined to trade Nabers for Nix, then I would think you need to get back a solid WR2 along with Nix like Zay Flowers/JSN or similar value.
 
Dell or Worthy?
Full disclosure, I think Tank Dell's size will always limit his upside and be a constant source of injury risk.

Short term: Dell. Without Diggs, he'll likely slide into the slot and get a good number of targets
Long term: Worthy. Potentially next season the Chiefs could be without Nuk, Rashee Rice, Hollywood Brown and Travis Kelce. He's also shown flashes of WR1 ability.
 
Olave worth a buy low?
Weird situation. IF you're ok with holding him for the rest of the year AND another full year, then yes. It'll be that long before the Saints can rid themselves of Carr's contract.
That sounds like “buy him next year” to me then…value seems like it can only go down in the meantime, plus no reason to hold the concussion risk til closer to the cash-in point imo
 
What's the current sentiment on CMac's dynasty trade value this off-season? Let's assume he plays very well through the end of the season (even if he is not used at superman levels). His contract in my league is expiring and so I can't afford to keep him (without letting go of a younger top-end player). What would you be looking to get for him this off-season? He is still only 28. I'd ride him all the way to the sunset if I weren't in a contract league.
 
Cooper Kupp price check.

I am a RB strong team needing WR help. I am 7-3 and a bit light at WR. The Kupp owner(who trades a fair bit) is asking for a 1st plus. I am willing to part with a 2nd and a 3rd.

What does the SP think?
 
Cooper Kupp price check.

I am a RB strong team needing WR help. I am 7-3 and a bit light at WR. The Kupp owner(who trades a fair bit) is asking for a 1st plus. I am willing to part with a 2nd and a 3rd.

What does the SP think?
If not from you, then probably from someone else. A first from one of your competitors is forthcoming.
 
Cooper Kupp price check.

I am a RB strong team needing WR help. I am 7-3 and a bit light at WR. The Kupp owner(who trades a fair bit) is asking for a 1st plus. I am willing to part with a 2nd and a 3rd.

What does the SP think?
In one league where I'm currently in first place but I've already lost Godwin, Aiyuk, and Olave, the Kupp owner offered me Kupp for my 2025 1st and I turned it down. It just goes against my core dynasty values to give up a 1st for a 31 year old WR.
 
Cooper Kupp price check.

I am a RB strong team needing WR help. I am 7-3 and a bit light at WR. The Kupp owner(who trades a fair bit) is asking for a 1st plus. I am willing to part with a 2nd and a 3rd.

What does the SP think?

I don't see a 2 and 3 getting it done...I don't think you can look at a #1 in a vacuum...you need to look at the big picture...how close does this get you to being a legit title contender this year and next, how young is the rest of your roster, how many other draft picks do you have in 2025 and 2026...and what are the other WR options out there if you are willing to part with a #1...sometimes at this time of the year it's not who you want but who is available...so the long-winded answer is Kupp for a #1 can be a good trade or one that isn't that wise based on what I listed above.
 
Dell or Worthy?
Full disclosure, I think Tank Dell's size will always limit his upside and be a constant source of injury risk.

Short term: Dell. Without Diggs, he'll likely slide into the slot and get a good number of targets
Long term: Worthy. Potentially next season the Chiefs could be without Nuk, Rashee Rice, Hollywood Brown and Travis Kelce. He's also shown flashes of WR1 ability.
Dell has to prove he can step up but Metchie is looking good recently but he has a lot to prove yet
 
Dell or Worthy?
Full disclosure, I think Tank Dell's size will always limit his upside and be a constant source of injury risk.

Short term: Dell. Without Diggs, he'll likely slide into the slot and get a good number of targets
Long term: Worthy. Potentially next season the Chiefs could be without Nuk, Rashee Rice, Hollywood Brown and Travis Kelce. He's also shown flashes of WR1 ability.
Collins back this week?
 
How are y'all feeling about Nix? In a SF/TEP where my QB room is crap (Goff, Darnold, Levis), I'm considering trading Nabers for him and a minor plus. Is it worth the risk? Full disclosure, I have a slight man-crush on Nix and hate the Giants.
Nix will be good. I will defer to the SF guys, but that super light for Nabers.
Absolutely want to acknowledge it's an overpay even in SF. I think my question is along the lines of, "can Nix be a perennial top 5 guy?". I'm having a hard time projecting him out beyond this season.
I won’t let you ruin your life. Call it tough love.
 
Cooper Kupp price check.

I am a RB strong team needing WR help. I am 7-3 and a bit light at WR. The Kupp owner(who trades a fair bit) is asking for a 1st plus. I am willing to part with a 2nd and a 3rd.

What does the SP think?
In one league where I'm currently in first place but I've already lost Godwin, Aiyuk, and Olave, the Kupp owner offered me Kupp for my 2025 1st and I turned it down. It just goes against my core dynasty values to give up a 1st for a 31 year old WR.
This is how I feel about a 31 year old WR and what I communicated to the other owner. I am interested, but not a 1st.
 
Cooper Kupp price check.

I am a RB strong team needing WR help. I am 7-3 and a bit light at WR. The Kupp owner(who trades a fair bit) is asking for a 1st plus. I am willing to part with a 2nd and a 3rd.

What does the SP think?
If not from you, then probably from someone else. A first from one of your competitors is forthcoming.
This has not happened and he has tried.
 
Cooper Kupp price check.

I am a RB strong team needing WR help. I am 7-3 and a bit light at WR. The Kupp owner(who trades a fair bit) is asking for a 1st plus. I am willing to part with a 2nd and a 3rd.

What does the SP think?
If not from you, then probably from someone else. A first from one of your competitors is forthcoming.
This has not happened and he has tried.
He’s worth a late first from a contender.
 
Cooper Kupp price check.

I am a RB strong team needing WR help. I am 7-3 and a bit light at WR. The Kupp owner(who trades a fair bit) is asking for a 1st plus. I am willing to part with a 2nd and a 3rd.

What does the SP think?
If not from you, then probably from someone else. A first from one of your competitors is forthcoming.
This has not happened and he has tried.
He’s worth a late first from a contender.
I wouldn’t take less than two 2s, because he could help next year too. Not two late 2s either.
 
Cooper Kupp price check.

I am a RB strong team needing WR help. I am 7-3 and a bit light at WR. The Kupp owner(who trades a fair bit) is asking for a 1st plus. I am willing to part with a 2nd and a 3rd.

What does the SP think?
If not from you, then probably from someone else. A first from one of your competitors is forthcoming.
This has not happened and he has tried.
He’s worth a late first from a contender.
I wouldn’t take less than two 2s, because he could help next year too. Not two late 2s either.
I've had many offers of 2nds during the year for him, passed on all of them. Holding out for a late 1st or he just stays in my lineup now that he's healthy.
 
I have TLaw in a 16 team SF league I’m competitive in.

I’ve been offered Mac Jones for Mazi Smith. It’s a fair offer, and I’m deep at DT.

That said I’m not convinced Mac Jones will out-score one of my RB or WRs that I can flex in.

The same team has Drew Lock, who I kinda like and should get a chance to start in week 12, reportedly. So I’m thinking of countering for Lock.

But in torn. Would either of these dudes be worth dealing for?
 
Last edited:
Cooper Kupp price check.

I am a RB strong team needing WR help. I am 7-3 and a bit light at WR. The Kupp owner(who trades a fair bit) is asking for a 1st plus. I am willing to part with a 2nd and a 3rd.

What does the SP think?
If not from you, then probably from someone else. A first from one of your competitors is forthcoming.
This has not happened and he has tried.
He’s worth a late first from a contender.
He ended up getting a late first. Maybe I should have paid up, but oh well I will stand by my stance of not trading a 1st rounder for a 30+ year old player.
 
How are you guys ranking these WR:

Jayden Reed
Chris Olave
Rashee Rice

All 24yrs old, all with obvious pros and cons. Which are you targeting most if given the opportunity in dynasty?
 
How are you guys ranking these WR:

Jayden Reed
Chris Olave
Rashee Rice

All 24yrs old, all with obvious pros and cons. Which are you targeting most if given the opportunity in dynasty?
Probably
1. Reed
2. Rice




3. Olave

Reed has looked excellent this year. Tied to a good young QB on a team that loves to take downfield shots. He’s shown he can run a multitude of routes.

Rashee is inconsistent, and while tied to Mahomes, the Chiefs just don’t throw as much as they used to, nor do they take those shots. Also DHop muddies the water a little.

Olave has talent. The saints are a mess. The concussion was scary.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top