What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Emmanuel Sanders or Antonio Brown (1 Viewer)

Who has the better year?

  • Emmanuel Sanders

    Votes: 36 42.4%
  • Antonio Brown

    Votes: 49 57.6%

  • Total voters
    85

Ministry of Pain

Footballguy
Sanders played in the last preseason game, is back at practice but you could not miss Brown in the preseason. What are your thoughts? Do both take a back seat to Hines Ward? Can one of them make an impact at the WR3 slot? Are we being a little too reactionary to Brown's preseason?

 
For lack of a better place to post this, Dodds currently has zero stats posted for Antonio Brown this week.

 
I think until pre-season games we would have all said Sanders but Brown was VERY impressive and Sanders is slowly coming off an injury

I think Brown will have better numbers this year but I would be unlikely to own either unless a keeper/dynasty league or in bestball leagues (Brown was my last pick in both FIX redraft and FBG Ultimate Survivor drafts last month)

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I drafted Mendenhall and Wallace in my auction draft this year, lost out on Big Ben, but also covered my bases by picking up Ward, Brown and Sanders in our pre-season supplemental waiver. It was hard settling on just one of either Sanders or Brown, so I scooped up both. I just have a real good feeling regarding the Pittsburgh offense. Ward is Ward, but as for Brown and Sanders either one really has the potential to bust out big this year. I just wanted to make sure I reaped the benefits over someone else.

 
What is the deal with Sander's need for 3 separate surgeries this off season? I just don't see how foot surgery at such a young age bodes well for a young WR whose game is predicated on being fast/quick/elusive. Not a good start to a young career. My vote is for Brown in the short and long term opposite Wallace.

 
What is the deal with Sander's need for 3 separate surgeries this off season? I just don't see how foot surgery at such a young age bodes well for a young WR whose game is predicated on being fast/quick/elusive.
This is the best reason to avoid him. Any time you hear things like "not recovering as expected" or "not healing as fast as doctors projected", it isn't a good sign. linkI'd go with Brown as a late round lottery pick. Sanders had a bit of hype last season but he didn't put up any significant numbers until Week 10, and he ended the season with 28/376/2. I think Brown can easily top those numbers this year, because I also predict Hines Ward to fade a bit.

 
Steelers in good hands of top 3 receiversNFL Preseason: Steelers vs. PanthersThursday, September 01, 2011By Gerry Dulac, Pittsburgh Post-GazetteIn his 14th season with the team that drafted him in the third round in 1998, Hines Ward knows he is not going to play many more seasons. But, when he leaves, the club's all-time leading receiver knows his position will be in good hands, literally and figuratively.

That's because the Steelers might have the best trio of young receivers in the NFL.

"It's a real sign the future of the wideouts that we have," Ward said. "We didn't go out and draft any guys because we're comfortable with the young guys we have. When I do leave, we'll be in good hands. They're very talented."

And they are very different.

Mike Wallace, who enters his third season, already is one of the league's top deep threats with his sprinter's speed.

Emmanuel Sanders, a No. 3 pick in 2010, might be the best route-runner on the team and reads defenses as well as the coaching staff.

And Antonio Brown has spent the preseason showing off his big-play ability and turning his mistakes into touchdowns.

The Steelers have to go back to 2000 when they had Ward, Plaxico Burress and Troy Edwards to find a more talented trio of young receivers on their roster.

"They can be special," said safety Ryan Clark, who has to cover them in practice. "The good thing about them is they have three different skill sets. Each of them is very talented, but they're all so different. And what makes them a strong trio is that they're not like the trio Green Bay would have.

"Green Bay has kind of the same guy, different numbers. Whereas, with these guys, you're able to line them all over the field in different spots and you have to try to stop them all."

Just like Ward, who needs 46 catches to become only the eighth player in NFL history to have 1,000 career receptions, the Steelers found all three in the third round or later.

Throw in newcomer Jerricho Cotchery, a fourth-round pick of the New York Jets in 2004, and the Steelers have the potential to have maybe the deepest corps of receivers in the league without a No. 1 draft pick among them.

"You don't always have to find players in the first round," said Wallace, a third-round pick. "Look at Hines."

And, sometimes, you find them in the sixth round, such as Brown.

Sanders and Brown did not compile prolific numbers as rookies, combining for 44 catches, 543 yards and 2 touchdowns. But, with Sanders' precise route-running and assimilation of the offense and Brown's penchant for big plays -- especially after his performance last week against the Atlanta Falcons -- the Steelers merely are waiting for each to have breakout seasons.

Couple that with Wallace, who had a team-high 1,257 yards and 10 touchdowns and led the AFC with a 21-yard average in 2010, and the Steelers have the nucleus of a talented and diverse receiving trio, none of whom have been in the league longer than three years.

"Those guys are great players," Wallace said. "Coming in, they were much better route-runners than I was. I was really raw. Those guys could really run routes already, especially Sanders. [brown] was probably more explosive, but they were kind of a mixed-and-match set. The sky is the limit for them."

Sanders missed nearly all training camp at Saint Vincent College and has not played in the preseason because his surgically repaired left foot was slow to heal. But, he returned to full practice this week and is expected to play, barring a setback, in the preseason finale tonight at Carolina.

Asked to evaluate the young receivers, Ward gave the following assessment:

Wallace: "He has that one thing you can't teach -- speed. But I want Mike to become an all-around receiver, not just the speed, the deep guy. You can be an explosive wide receiver by catching curls catching digs, things like that."

Sanders: "He's probably more polished than all of them. He has the understanding of the offense. He could play inside and outside. The slot guy is the quarterback of the wideouts."

Brown: "A.B. has that dog in him, that mentality, I see him playing with that chip on his shoulders. He's always trying to prove to someone he can play. He plays with a little more anger. I really like working with him."

Read more: http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/11244/1171290-66-0.stm#ixzz1XCHcwuqr

 
I like the fact that A. Brown has been targeted by BigBen in some seriously important moments and Brown has come through. I think developing that kind of trustworthiness with his QB bodes really well for his future.

Good read on that scouting report from Hines... thanks for posting that Kitrick.

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top