Interesting
I may finally switch to a different company for rentals. I've gone with Enterprise because it's comfortable - you pretty much know what you're going to get. Baloney is right about the customer service being so over the top sometimes that it's almost mocking the customer. If it's not over the top awesome, you're usually stuck with someone who's having a miserable day - there is no in between.
National Emerald Aisle sounds like the way to go and I just might try it.
The rewards and corporate programs for Enterprise mean nothing - a lot of the time, if you know how to work the system, you can get a car for cheaper than the "corporate" discount. In fact, about 95% of the time. The corporate discounts, unless they are a huge national fleet company, are good for holidays when prices are so bloated. Otherwise, you can work a better price almost every time on your own. Enterprise doesn't have set rates...if you call a branch directly, most of the time they are just pulling a number out of thin air based on how many cars they have idle on the lot.
Used to travel a buttload for work, still do occasionally, and I'll never use anyone but National.
I booked the compact rate, but since I'm Emerald Club (just sign up and go) I was told to pick anything in the Emerald Aisle, which included SUVs, mid-sized cars, etc. I rocked a brand new Jetta (no rainbow stickers, however) for a few days in Austin. Really nice.