What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

FBG Mock Draft '25 #49 Jack Sawyer Edge, Ohio State (39 Viewers)

I think Bri thought the Scourton pick was valid.
Tennessee was trying to trade this pick to me (KC), just a couple hours ago. I replied that I would take the deal. I will accept the offer and pick unless anyone objects.
I will post the trade if it's gonna be accepted.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bri
Nick Scourton please @Ministry of Pain
I like this kid and his mock draft data fluctuates way too much to be accurate without some negative news to make it change.
Some dislike, some love.
He was once a first round prospect.

I tried to trade down but...that's my type I like. It's worked with AJB and Henry famously and I think there's something to "guys dropping out of the first" over the years.

I would like a zillion third round picks or like mid second to mid third and think I can feast. I didn't get to trade down w the number one.

I think slot WRs stink in TEN and I don't know what's in Nashville's water to cause that. Also second is too early for a slot. Kupp or Puka aside, I think they're way over drafted and projected to be over drafted again.

Trading for two picks but one I can't use because we only go three rounds is no fun. I didn't realize I did that.

I've had a bizarre weekend and have been unattentive here and it's very unlike me l. I apologize for being that guy, again.
I like the pick. That’s why I made it about 10 picks ago . . .
Seriously?
Oof
 
2.41 KC Chiefs select RB TreVeyon Henderson, Ohio State

Isiah Pachecho has been a steal as a 7th round pick, but injuries and mileage have started taking a toll. 3.7 ypc last season isn't enough. He's also in the final year of his contract.

While we have bigger "needs", spending our extra 3rd rounder on a back of this caliber could be huge. With Rashee Rice possibly missing a good portion of the early season, we will need to rely on the run game a lot more.

Henderson brings fresh legs with game breaking ability. His pass pro is maybe best in class and that trait was the deciding factor.

While the trade calculator will show we paid a 8-9% premium, that won't matter if he performs as expected.
 
2.41 KC Chiefs select RB TreVeyon Henderson, Ohio State

Isiah Pachecho has been a steal as a 7th round pick, but injuries and mileage have started taking a toll. 3.7 ypc last season isn't enough. He's also in the final year of his contract.

While we have bigger "needs", spending our extra 3rd rounder on a back of this caliber could be huge. With Rashee Rice possibly missing a good portion of the early season, we will need to rely on the run game a lot more.

Henderson brings fresh legs with game breaking ability. His pass pro is maybe best in class and that trait was the deciding factor.

While the trade calculator will show we paid a 8-9% premium, that won't matter if he performs as expected.

I didn't expect he would get there, but I would have taken him at 55.
 
42 - NY Jets - Mason Taylor - TE - LSU

The Jets take a player rising up draft boards after his pro day. Taylor, the son of Hall of Famer Jason Taylor, is a fluid athlete who runs solid routes and catches the football well. He has good hands, high points the football, and has very good instincts on the football field when plays break down on his quarterback. He is a competent blocker who can improve, but he shows a willingness to get in the trenches and give maximum effort, which is important because the Jets will be running the football often with Justin Fields at QB and a strong RB room, the recent Breece Hall concerns notwithstanding. Taylor not only suits the Jets' biggest need; he is one of the best players still on the board.

From The Athletic:

"Taylor was Mr. Reliable in the LSU offense. He is a loose mover, which shows in his route running and at the catch point, and he has the hand-eye coordination to make natural adjustments and finish in traffic.

In the run game, he is more of a wall-off blocker than violent people-mover, but his toughness and athleticism at the point of attack — especially out in space as a move blocker — help him execute his assignments."

From The Ringer:

"Taylor has a muscular frame with long arms and a powerful core. A three-year starter for the Tigers, he is deployed all over the formation and accelerates quickly off the line to overtake linebackers or defensive backs. He sells his route fakes well with shoulder shimmies and head fakes and brings a big catch radius, showing the ability to go up high and bring down off-target passes. He has very reliable hands, with just one drop all of last season, per PFF. He’s a smooth mover who catches the ball and turns upfield to pick up yards after the catch in one fluid motion. He is tough and physical and flashes the ability to seal and sustain blocks in space. Taylor lacks top-end burst and separation skills in the passing game. He has buildup speed when given room to run after the catch but is not especially elusive in traffic, with just five missed tackles forced last year. His production has been middling, with just two touchdown receptions last year (and a total of six in three seasons).

WHY HE COULD RISE:

Taylor is big and tough and catches everything in his vicinity; he is a smooth mover at tight end who gives his quarterback a reliable target over the middle of the field.

WHY HE COULD FALL:

He lacks top-end explosiveness as a route runner; he’s still developing as an in-line blocker."

rockaction note: I passed on somebody I also had written up in detail, but after seeing some more highlights (and tape) and reading scouting reports I couldn't pull the trigger. Just too far away and the Jets' cupboard is bare enough to need players, not projects. The Jets still need a WR, a DB, a DT, and a developmental QB—in that order, IMO.

eta* My mock so far is an exact copy of The Athletic's latest mock draft for the Jets done by Zack Rosenblatt. Either that's a good thing, or I'm a lemming going off of a cliff. Seriously, the two guys I picked are both who I wanted for the Jets, and the mock has worked out pretty nicely and neatly so far.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, more important things to worry about like the complete collapse of the world economy tomorrow.

Escapism is your friend. It's my friend also so please embrace it.

42 - NY Jets - Mason Taylor - TE - LSU

The Jets take a player rising up draft boards after his pro day. Taylor, the son of Hall of Famer Jason Taylor, is a fluid athlete who runs routes and catches the football well. He has good hands, high points the football, and has very good instincts on the football field when plays break down for his quarterback. He is a competent blocker who can improve, but he shows a willingness to get in the trenches and give maximum effort, which is important because the Jets will be running the football often with Justin Fields at QB and a strong RB room, the recent Breece Hall concerns notwithstanding. Taylor not only suits the Jets' biggest need; he is one of the best players still on the board.

From The Athletic:

"Taylor was Mr. Reliable in the LSU offense. He is a loose mover, which shows in his route running and at the catch point, and he has the hand-eye coordination to make natural adjustments and finish in traffic.

In the run game, he is more of a wall-off blocker than violent people-mover, but his toughness and athleticism at the point of attack — especially out in space as a move blocker — help him execute his assignments."

From The Ringer:

"Taylor has a muscular frame with long arms and a powerful core. A three-year starter for the Tigers, he is deployed all over the formation and accelerates quickly off the line to overtake linebackers or defensive backs. He sells his route fakes well with shoulder shimmies and head fakes and brings a big catch radius, showing the ability to go up high and bring down off-target passes. He has very reliable hands, with just one drop all of last season, per PFF. He’s a smooth mover who catches the ball and turns upfield to pick up yards after the catch in one fluid motion. He is tough and physical and flashes the ability to seal and sustain blocks in space. Taylor lacks top-end burst and separation skills in the passing game. He has buildup speed when given room to run after the catch but is not especially elusive in traffic, with just five missed tackles forced last year. His production has been middling, with just two touchdown receptions last year (and a total of six in three seasons).

WHY HE COULD RISE:

Taylor is big and tough and catches everything in his vicinity; he is a smooth mover at tight end who gives his quarterback a reliable target over the middle of the field.

WHY HE COULD FALL:

He lacks top-end explosiveness as a route runner; he’s still developing as an in-line blocker."

rockaction note: I passed on somebody I also had written up in detail, but after seeing some more highlights (and tape) and reading scouting reports I couldn't pull the trigger. Just too far away and the Jets' cupboard is bare enough to need players, not projects. The Jets still need a WR, a DB, a DT, and a developmental QB—in that order, IMO.

eta* My mock so far is an exact copy of The Athletic's latest mock draft for the Jets done by Zack Rosenblatt. Either that's a good thing, or I'm a lemming going off of a cliff. Seriously, the two guys I picked are both who I wanted for the Jets, and the mock has worked out pretty nicely and neatly so far.
Finally some escapism!!
 
He's the nephew of another former Dolphin too isn't he?
The NFL needs a rule that the Fins get him and forego their second round pick.
The Jets? That's so wrong.

(Nice writeups btw)
 
With pick 2.11 (pick 43) SF takes Donovan Jackson, G, Ohio State

While I know Lynch and Shanahan claim they are happy with the O-line, I don't believe them. Jackson will help the running game and keep Brock upright.

Tough choice. OT is probably a bigger immediate need, but like Jacksons profile better than the tackles available (but what do I really know). Looked at DT and Edge as well, but lets protect our soon to be wealthy QB.
 
With pick 2.11 (pick 43) SF takes Donovan Jackson, G, Ohio State

While I know Lynch and Shanahan claim they are happy with the O-line, I don't believe them. Jackson will help the running game and keep Brock upright.

Tough choice. OT is probably a bigger immediate need, but like Jacksons profile better than the tackles available (but what do I really know). Looked at DT and Edge as well, but lets protect our soon to be wealthy QB.
The Niners are a team predicated on the ability to run the football.
I haven't heard any updates on CMC but assuming he gets 250-280 carries the Niners want to maximize what he can do and whoever they draft behind him
I like the pick and it makes sense
Is he a sure thing? It's all a crapshoot, half these 1st round picks relatively are gonna bust or come in below expectations
These types of picks tend to work well along the OL especially the IOL with G/C in the 2nd and 3rd round

I loved O'Cyrus Torrence at Guard a couple seasons back, he's started since he entered the league, needs some more coaching and work as he doesn't rate super high but...
The Bills Offense has been impressive and Cook had his best season last year, Torrence is a good run blocker IMHO, maybe he needs some work in pass protection

Solid pick
 
42 - NY Jets - Mason Taylor - TE - LSU

The Jets take a player rising up draft boards after his pro day. Taylor, the son of Hall of Famer Jason Taylor, is a fluid athlete who runs solid routes and catches the football well. He has good hands, high points the football, and has very good instincts on the football field when plays break down on his quarterback. He is a competent blocker who can improve, but he shows a willingness to get in the trenches and give maximum effort, which is important because the Jets will be running the football often with Justin Fields at QB and a strong RB room, the recent Breece Hall concerns notwithstanding. Taylor not only suits the Jets' biggest need; he is one of the best players still on the board.

From The Athletic:

"Taylor was Mr. Reliable in the LSU offense. He is a loose mover, which shows in his route running and at the catch point, and he has the hand-eye coordination to make natural adjustments and finish in traffic.

In the run game, he is more of a wall-off blocker than violent people-mover, but his toughness and athleticism at the point of attack — especially out in space as a move blocker — help him execute his assignments."

From The Ringer:

"Taylor has a muscular frame with long arms and a powerful core. A three-year starter for the Tigers, he is deployed all over the formation and accelerates quickly off the line to overtake linebackers or defensive backs. He sells his route fakes well with shoulder shimmies and head fakes and brings a big catch radius, showing the ability to go up high and bring down off-target passes. He has very reliable hands, with just one drop all of last season, per PFF. He’s a smooth mover who catches the ball and turns upfield to pick up yards after the catch in one fluid motion. He is tough and physical and flashes the ability to seal and sustain blocks in space. Taylor lacks top-end burst and separation skills in the passing game. He has buildup speed when given room to run after the catch but is not especially elusive in traffic, with just five missed tackles forced last year. His production has been middling, with just two touchdown receptions last year (and a total of six in three seasons).

WHY HE COULD RISE:

Taylor is big and tough and catches everything in his vicinity; he is a smooth mover at tight end who gives his quarterback a reliable target over the middle of the field.

WHY HE COULD FALL:

He lacks top-end explosiveness as a route runner; he’s still developing as an in-line blocker."

rockaction note: I passed on somebody I also had written up in detail, but after seeing some more highlights (and tape) and reading scouting reports I couldn't pull the trigger. Just too far away and the Jets' cupboard is bare enough to need players, not projects. The Jets still need a WR, a DB, a DT, and a developmental QB—in that order, IMO.

eta* My mock so far is an exact copy of The Athletic's latest mock draft for the Jets done by Zack Rosenblatt. Either that's a good thing, or I'm a lemming going off of a cliff. Seriously, the two guys I picked are both who I wanted for the Jets, and the mock has worked out pretty nicely and neatly so far.
I haven't had a chance to reply but people are interested where Taylor lands and the Jets are a great spot.
I know you all have tried several out in recent seasons and the offense as a whole with good skill players at RB and also Garrett at WR, Taylor would round out the offense and I think he can provide some help to the OL when running plays are called. That would keep him on the field almost all the time and what I'm saying is the starting TE position is open for him to take over.

What Taylor lacks is explosiveness or stretching the defense but he should be a safe spot for Fields to find easy first downs. Fields ability to scramble will also allow Taylor who might not be explosive but can create some space underneath by drifting around with his QB waiting for the space to open up and then boom you got a first down. Jets are not going to out score teams week in and week out, they need to be able to run the ball and make first downs to shorten the games. Taylor will help in all those areas, another solid pick
 
Last edited:
With pick 2.11 (pick 43) SF takes Donovan Jackson, G, Ohio State

While I know Lynch and Shanahan claim they are happy with the O-line, I don't believe them. Jackson will help the running game and keep Brock upright.

Tough choice. OT is probably a bigger immediate need, but like Jacksons profile better than the tackles available (but what do I really know). Looked at DT and Edge as well, but lets protect our soon to be wealthy QB.

I haven't heard any updates on CMC but assuming he gets 250-280 carries the Niners want to maximize what he can do and whoever they draft behind him
The health of CMC is the million dollar question (both for real and FF). Reports are out that he is 100 percent, but I think the draft will be telling there. They seem happy with Guerrando as his backup but if they spend a day 2 pick on a RB, maybe CMC isn't as healthy as they say. They have a lot of holes to fill on defense, so hoping they wait until the 5th to go RB shopping.
 
With pick 2.11 (pick 43) SF takes Donovan Jackson, G, Ohio State

While I know Lynch and Shanahan claim they are happy with the O-line, I don't believe them. Jackson will help the running game and keep Brock upright.

Tough choice. OT is probably a bigger immediate need, but like Jacksons profile better than the tackles available (but what do I really know). Looked at DT and Edge as well, but lets protect our soon to be wealthy QB.

I haven't heard any updates on CMC but assuming he gets 250-280 carries the Niners want to maximize what he can do and whoever they draft behind him
The health of CMC is the million dollar question (both for real and FF). Reports are out that he is 100 percent, but I think the draft will be telling there. They seem happy with Guerrando as his backup but if they spend a day 2 pick on a RB, maybe CMC isn't as healthy as they say. They have a lot of holes to fill on defense, so hoping they wait until the 5th to go RB shopping.
Funny though, this year’s fifth round RBs have a good chance to make an impact.
 
With pick 2.11 (pick 43) SF takes Donovan Jackson, G, Ohio State

While I know Lynch and Shanahan claim they are happy with the O-line, I don't believe them. Jackson will help the running game and keep Brock upright.

Tough choice. OT is probably a bigger immediate need, but like Jacksons profile better than the tackles available (but what do I really know). Looked at DT and Edge as well, but lets protect our soon to be wealthy QB.

I haven't heard any updates on CMC but assuming he gets 250-280 carries the Niners want to maximize what he can do and whoever they draft behind him
The health of CMC is the million dollar question (both for real and FF). Reports are out that he is 100 percent, but I think the draft will be telling there. They seem happy with Guerrando as his backup but if they spend a day 2 pick on a RB, maybe CMC isn't as healthy as they say. They have a lot of holes to fill on defense, so hoping they wait until the 5th to go RB shopping.
Funny though, this year’s fifth round RBs have a good chance to make an impact.
Agreed and while they aren't typically successful when drafted late, even with a loaded class, RBs will sit a little bit longer than many think, Hampton might not go in the 1st
Martinez a big bruiser I like and likely going to be drafted into a 1-2 punch at RB with Martinez being the thunder and short yardage guy, very little tread has come off the tires
The RB I just mentioned might not go until the 5th or 6th round although he's been gaining. a lot of traction in recent weeks thru social media and places like YT jockeys

I think Martinez could easily develop into a 250 carry type in the NFL
 
That would keep him the field almost all the time and what I'm saying is the starting TE position is open for him to take over.

That's the hope. It might take some time to get adjusted, but we're hoping sooner than later because all we have at TE is the disappointing Jeremy Ruckert and Stone Smartt, who is more of a pass-catching TE.

What Taylor lacks is explosiveness or stretching the defense but he should be a safe spot for Fields to find easy first downs.

That was the knock on him but then he went out and ran a 4.65 at his pro day at 6'5", 251 lbs., which put him in the 75th percentile for tight ends in raw forty time and gives him a speed score of in-between 103-107 (depending on how you adjust for a pro day time). He also ran the gauntlet at the NFL Combine flawlessly, hitting upwards of 19-20 MPH during the drill while staying straight and catching every ball, earning him an "A" from CBS Sports. His Relative Athletic Score is a 8.88 out of 10, which puts him 150th out of 1331 TEs from 1987 to the present.

So he's definitely athletic, but there are weaknesses. His short shuttle time wasn't very good and his ten-yard split in the forty was average, so yeah, he's got to work on his explosion off of the line and then on deep routes, too. But of his 546 yards receiving in 2024, 45% of them were after the catch, so that bodes really well and tells you about his athleticism. 202 yards came after contact, too, which is even more telling.

So I'm happy with the pick. He's not Loveland or Warren, but he's good, he's got room to grow and even more potential than people think because . . . get this—he's only twenty years old. He's still developing and still learning how to run routes, etc. So we will see.
 
Last edited:
Anyone looking to trade up for Dallas pick at 44 ?
Seattle 52 & 82
NYG 50 & 99
Jacksonville 67 & 70
Almost had a deal, then it was pulled away so I will make the pick here. Most people think Dallas will have a RB by now. Henderson just went and Judkins was a possibility, but without a decent o- line it would not make any difference. Since Donovan Jackson was just taken, at 2.12 I move to:
Jonah Savaiinaea OG Arizona
 
That would keep him the field almost all the time and what I'm saying is the starting TE position is open for him to take over.

That's the hope. It might take some time to get adjusted, but we're hoping sooner than later because all we have at TE is the disappointing Jeremy Ruckert and Stone Smartt, who is more of a pass-catching TE.

What Taylor lacks is explosiveness or stretching the defense but he should be a safe spot for Fields to find easy first downs.

That was the knock on him but then he went out and ran a 4.65 at his pro day at 6'5", 251 lbs., which put him in the 75th percentile for tight ends in raw forty time and gives him a speed score of in- between 103-107 (depending on how you adjust for a pro day time). He also ran the gauntlet at the NFL Combine flawlessly, hitting upwards of 19-20 MPH during the drill while staying straight and catching every ball, earning him an "A" from CBS Sports. His Relative Athletic Score is a 8.88 out of 10, which puts him 150th out of 1331 TEs from 1987 to the present.

So he's definitely athletic, but there are weaknesses. His short shuttle time wasn't very good and his ten-yard split in the forty was average, so yeah, he's got to work on his explosion off of the line and then on deep routes, too. But of his 546 yards receiving in 2024, 45% of them were after the catch, so that bodes really well and tells you about his athleticism. 202 yards came after contact, too, which is even more telling.

So I'm happy with the pick. He's not Loveland or Warren, but he's good, he's got room to grow and even more potential than people think because . . . get this—he's only twenty years old. He's still developing and still learning how to run routes, etc. So we will see.
i didn't know he ran a 4.65, that's by no means slow especially for a TE matched up against LBs, NB and Safeties, that should be plenty to create the space he needs in the NFL
 
Anyone looking to trade up for Dallas pick at 44 ?
Seattle 52 & 82
NYG 50 & 99
Jacksonville 67 & 70
Almost had a deal, then it was pulled away so I will make the pick here. Most people think Dallas will have a RB by now. Henderson just went and Judkins was a possibility, but without a decent o- line it would not make any difference. Since Donovan Jackson was just taken, at 2.12 I move to:
Jonah Savaiinaea OG Arizona
Ha. That was the other guy I was debating on. Looks like he could play tackle eventually, which I liked. Jackson just seemed a better fit for SF as far as playing guard.
 
Anyone looking to trade up for Dallas pick at 44 ?
Seattle 52 & 82
NYG 50 & 99
Jacksonville 67 & 70
Almost had a deal, then it was pulled away so I will make the pick here. Most people think Dallas will have a RB by now. Henderson just went and Judkins was a possibility, but without a decent o- line it would not make any difference. Since Donovan Jackson was just taken, at 2.12 I move to:
Jonah Savaiinaea OG Arizona
:rant:
I thought he would slide down thru the 2nd round, guess people have heard of him.
Solid IOL that has played other positions
 
Let’s keep the Offensive Line train rolling - with pick #45, the Colts select Tate Ratledge, RG Georgia

Despite having a tall frame for an interior lineman (6-6 320 pounds), Ratledge excels at keeping his pads low and maintaining proper leverage to control opposing defenders at the point of attack. He uses his size and power to absorb bull rushes, keeping a wide, active base and refusing to give any ground. Ratledge has shown the ability to effectively read complex pass-rushing games with switching defenders, passing off and picking up the right assignments to keep the quarback clean. He’s got enough athleticism to climb to the second level, and his size allows Ratledge to engulf back-seven defenders to spring ball-carriers for big gains. A highly experienced player with a ton of reps under his belt against top competition.

Ratledge is huge, athletic and powerful, with a ton of experience against the best defensive trench talent the college ranks have to offer. He lacks positional versatility, and needs to improve his hand usage, but Ratledge should be a plug-and-play starter at right guard who can make an immediate impact at a position he knows well.
 
Anyone looking to trade up for Dallas pick at 44 ?
Seattle 52 & 82
NYG 50 & 99
Jacksonville 67 & 70
Almost had a deal, then it was pulled away so I will make the pick here. Most people think Dallas will have a RB by now. Henderson just went and Judkins was a possibility, but without a decent o- line it would not make any difference. Since Donovan Jackson was just taken, at 2.12 I move to:
Jonah Savaiinaea OG Arizona
:rant:
I thought he would slide down thru the 2nd round, guess people have heard of him.
Solid IOL that has played other positions
I was trying to research and put together an offer for this spot for Houston to take this exact player but I was too slow
 
Let’s keep the Offensive Line train rolling - with pick #45, the Colts select Tate Ratledge, RG Georgia

Despite having a tall frame for an interior lineman (6-6 320 pounds), Ratledge excels at keeping his pads low and maintaining proper leverage to control opposing defenders at the point of attack. He uses his size and power to absorb bull rushes, keeping a wide, active base and refusing to give any ground. Ratledge has shown the ability to effectively read complex pass-rushing games with switching defenders, passing off and picking up the right assignments to keep the quarback clean. He’s got enough athleticism to climb to the second level, and his size allows Ratledge to engulf back-seven defenders to spring ball-carriers for big gains. A highly experienced player with a ton of reps under his belt against top competition.

Ratledge is huge, athletic and powerful, with a ton of experience against the best defensive trench talent the college ranks have to offer. He lacks positional versatility, and needs to improve his hand usage, but Ratledge should be a plug-and-play starter at right guard who can make an immediate impact at a position he knows well.
Dang
 
All four of my "next choice" got sniped. Bastards! With 2.whatever, 46 overall, the Browns select Xavier Watts, S, ND.

Hey @daveR, I'd like to say something if you'll indulge me. I had gently criticized your trade involving the 1.2 (potentially Travis Hunter) because I didn't think you got enough in return. Well, I did some diving into different charts that analytics guys in front offices use and there were at least two charts wherein if we're looking at raw picks and not assigning a player value to the deal, then you made out quite well.

One of the charts or valuation techniques is called the Fitzgerald-Spielberger point system and it had your net gain in value equivalent to the #21 pick overall in the draft. Another chart, the Harvard Trade Value Chart, had you gaining significant value and equaled what was equivalent to the #33 overall pick in the draft, which is a pretty nice pick.

Now, there are other charts that had you not getting as much value as you gave—and one had you giving value by quite a bit, but the existence of the aforementioned value charts is interesting to me and hopefully to you also.

So man, I apologize for publicly dissenting, even if it was a mild dissent with nothing personal behind it.

I still think Hunter is more than the valuation that the charts are assigning the #2 pick, but that's subjective.
 
All four of my "next choice" got sniped. Bastards! With 2.whatever, 46 overall, the Browns select Xavier Watts, S, ND.
Love Watts. I'd bet on him being more likely to be a quality NFL starter than Emmanwori, even if he has a lower ceiling.

ETA: I probably would have taken him with 1 of the picks I dealt you in the Hunter deal.
 
All four of my "next choice" got sniped. Bastards! With 2.whatever, 46 overall, the Browns select Xavier Watts, S, ND.

Hey @daveR, I'd like to say something if you'll indulge me. I had gently criticized your trade involving the 1.2 (potentially Travis Hunter) because I didn't think you got enough in return. Well, I did some diving into different charts that analytics guys in front offices use and there were at least two charts wherein if we're looking at raw picks and not assigning a player value to the deal, then you made out quite well.

One of the charts or valuation techniques is called the Fitzgerald-Spielberger point system and it had your net gain in value equivalent to the #21 pick overall in the draft. Another chart, the Harvard Trade Value Chart, had you gaining significant value and equaled what was equivalent to the #33 overall pick in the draft, which is a pretty nice pick.

Now, there are other charts that had you not getting as much value as you gave—and one had you giving value by quite a bit, but the existence of the aforementioned value charts is interesting to me and hopefully to you also.

So man, I apologize for publicly dissenting, even if it was a mild dissent with nothing personal behind it.

I still think Hunter is more than the valuation that the charts are assigning the #2 pick, but that's subjective.
As the other half of that #2 trade, the trade charts I looked at had me coming out with fewer trade points than what I was giving up. Which was why I felt good offering it, because what's the point in trying to rip someone off in a mock draft that doesn't mean anything?
 
At pick 47, the Arizona Cardinals select CB Benjamin Morrison, Notre Dame

@Long Ball Larry up next for PHI
Benjamin Morrison was getting a lot of first-round buzz before an October hip injury knocked him out for the season. He was a freshman starter for Notre Dame and is an early declare. His coverage stats are very good, both in limiting receiving production and in generating passes defensed & interceptions, and tape guys are generally pretty high on his movement skills, instincts, and ball skills. Hip surgery also means no athletic testing, but he had 99th percentile PFF GAS (a measure of on-field athleticism) and was projected to run in the 4.39-4.47 range by the various sources that I checked. Pretty good length, below average thickness, not a good tackler. Obviously some risk in how he'll recover from the hip injury, but he has a better chance at turning into a Pro Bowler at an important position than most mid second rounders. Positive scouting reports from Daniel Jeremiah, nfldraftbuzz, and PFF (video, source of the GAS number).

The Cardinals don't have any good outside corners (Garrett Williams is good in the slot). They were set to have a 3-way competition for the 2 starting outside corner spots between 2024 2nd rounder Max Melton (bad in 2024 but he could develop), 2023 UDFA Starling Thomas (has been a pleasant surprise, but that means he has been a below average CB and not someone who looks like he doesn't belong on an NFL field), and stopgap veteran Sean Murphy-Bunting. Morrison gives them 3 shots at young corners who could exceed the Murphy-Bunting bar and be average or better starters, which drastically increases their chances of hitting on 2, and I think that Morrison has the best shot of the 3 at hitting that level and at being significantly better.
 
At pick 47, the Arizona Cardinals select CB Benjamin Morrison, Notre Dame

@Long Ball Larry up next for PHI
Benjamin Morrison was getting a lot of first-round buzz before an October hip injury knocked him out for the season. He was a freshman starter for Notre Dame and is an early declare. His coverage stats are very good, both in limiting receiving production and in generating passes defensed & interceptions, and tape guys are generally pretty high on his movement skills, instincts, and ball skills. Hip surgery also means no athletic testing, but he had 99th percentile PFF GAS (a measure of on-field athleticism) and was projected to run in the 4.39-4.47 range by the various sources that I checked. Pretty good length, below average thickness, not a good tackler. Obviously some risk in how he'll recover from the hip injury, but he has a better chance at turning into a Pro Bowler at an important position than most mid second rounders. Positive scouting reports from Daniel Jeremiah, nfldraftbuzz, and PFF (video, source of the GAS number).

The Cardinals don't have any good outside corners (Garrett Williams is good in the slot). They were set to have a 3-way competition for the 2 starting outside corner spots between 2024 2nd rounder Max Melton (bad in 2024 but he could develop), 2023 UDFA Starling Thomas (has been a pleasant surprise, but that means he has been a below average CB and not someone who looks like he doesn't belong on an NFL field), and stopgap veteran Sean Murphy-Bunting. Morrison gives them 3 shots at young corners who could exceed the Murphy-Bunting bar and be average or better starters, which drastically increases their chances of hitting on 2, and I think that Morrison has the best shot of the 3 at hitting that level and at being significantly better.
He was on my short list for the Packers at 54. Thought about trading up but really feel this is draft want more picks, not less
 
  • Like
Reactions: ZWK

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top