utah +4.5, i jumped in at 4, hope it doesn't land on 4
Williams is out and Golden State plays well at home. I don't have a side, but expect GS to win.
as long as they win by 1-3

i know they're out, line moved from gs -1.5 to 4.5.....LBJ on the cavs is worth that much.....no other player is worth 3pts. I play this situation a lot, the market over reacts to player injuries. very few players across all sports have an effect on the team/game. maybe a goalie in hockey....definitely not a single offensive baseball player and maybe a quarterback in the NFL, thats it.
Do you have your W-L for playing line movements when the starting PG is injured? In general, I agree with your other examples. Baseball is all about pitching and the overreaction to a RB injured is usually great.PManning led the league in passing attempts, but still only accounted for 31% of the Colts plays (pass attempts / (pass att + run att + def plays + ST plays). Yes, this number is more realistically like 40% since his ability to complete more passes than Painter leads to longer offensive drives/passing opportunities.Not much of a hockey fan, but the decrease in goalie talent can be "hidden" if that team is better defensively and score easier.I can't think of a position more pivotal in sports than a PG so that's why I hope you have that broken out from your other injury/line movement plays. Deron Williams career mpg is 35.5 so he can account to up to 75% of a game's plays. It's easy to quantify the drop off in scoring, assists, steals etc. But there are so many other aspects that aren't quantified such as ability to change shot (as oppose to official block) or being able to penetrate the paint so that the defense collapses and a 2 pass assist is created. Williams is a big PG and usually creates defensive problems for smaller guards. Bell and Watson not so much. If Deron still isn't worth 3 points in your opinion, you still must take into account the drop in talent from the 10-15 minutes the 3rd string PG playing to give the 2nd string PG a rest (as opposed to 2nd giving 1st a rest). My opinion would still be the same even if GS didn't cover last night. I personally would never (or very rarely) tail in this situation *only* because the line moved 3 points.