What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Five Guys thread, a 130+ page swordfight. (2 Viewers)

I didn't care for the Five Guys burger...not much flavor. My favorite will always be the tried and true Whopper.
Odd people out there.
Nuked fresh to order.
:confused: Microwaves don't leave fresh grill marks.
Burger King grills the burgers and places them in a plastic holding pin until ordered. They fix the burger and to reheat the burger/ kinda melt the cheese the nuke for a short time probably less 20 seceonds. They have done this for years. Thought this was common knowledge as one the reasons they never caught MCDonalds and have recently had Wendys catch them.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I don't know anyone who even goes to Burger King. The parking lot is always empty.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I didn't mean to create a stir. I just didn't know what QSR meant.

I'd definitely categorize Smash Burger, Five Guys, and In-N-Out all as fast food.
I'm not certain of the proper classification, but if I have to get my fat ### out of the car, I don't think of it as fast food.Also, the price. It's over $18 for a reg. cheesburger, a little cheeseburger (for the ol' lady), 2 orders of fries, and 2 ice waters. For people wasting money on a fountain drink, you're talking about at a $22-23 meal for 2.

Not crazy expensive, but more than what I normally think of from fast food. Heck, you can almost get a high quality meal at Olive Garden for that.

Since I'm wasting time over-analyzing this, here are the wikipedia classifications:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Types_of_restaurants

Fast food/QSR:

Fast food restaurants emphasize speed of service. Operations range from small-scale street vendors with carts to mega-corporations like McDonald's. Also known as a QSR or Quick Serve Restaurant.

Fast casual:

Fast casual restaurants do not offer table service, but may offer non-disposable plates and cutlery. The quality of food and prices tend to be higher than those of a conventional fast food restaurant but may be lower than casual dining.

Casual dining:

A casual dining restaurant is a restaurant that serves moderately-priced food in a casual atmosphere. Except for buffet-style restaurants, casual dining restaurants typically provide table service. Casual dining comprises a market segment between fast food establishments and fine dining restaurants. Casual dining restaurants usually have a full bar with separate bar staff, a larger beer menu and a limited wine menu. They are frequently, but not necessarily, part of a wider chain, particularly in the United States.

Fine dining:

Fine dining restaurants are full service restaurants with specific dedicated meal courses. Décor of such restaurants feature higher-quality materials, with an eye towards the "atmosphere" desired by the restauranteur, than restaurants featuring lower-quality materials and an eye away from the "atmosphere" desired by the restauranteur. The wait staff is usually highly trained and often wears more formal attire. Fine-dining restaurants are almost always small businesses and are generally either single-location operations or have just a few locations. Food portions are visually appealing. Fine dining restaurants have certain rules of dining which visitors are generally expected to follow.
High Quality?? In comparison to what? McDonalds? :X :X :lmao: :lmao:

 
I didn't care for the Five Guys burger...not much flavor. My favorite will always be the tried and true Whopper.
Odd people out there.
Nuked fresh to order.
:confused: Microwaves don't leave fresh grill marks.
Burger King grills the burgers and places them in a plastic holding pin until ordered. They fix the burger and to reheat the burger/ kinda melt the cheese the nuke for a short time probably less 20 seceonds. They have done this for years. Thought this was common knowledge as one the reasons they never caught MCDonalds and have recently had Wendys catch them.
Does McD's not also do this?Didn't McD's rise to dominance by pre-making everything and tossing quality/freshness aside for speed?Even if BK does indeed have inferior burgers to McD's (debatable at best), that wouldn't be in the top 5 reasons McD's destroyed BK.
 
I didn't mean to create a stir. I just didn't know what QSR meant.

I'd definitely categorize Smash Burger, Five Guys, and In-N-Out all as fast food.
I'm not certain of the proper classification, but if I have to get my fat ### out of the car, I don't think of it as fast food.Also, the price. It's over $18 for a reg. cheesburger, a little cheeseburger (for the ol' lady), 2 orders of fries, and 2 ice waters. For people wasting money on a fountain drink, you're talking about at a $22-23 meal for 2.

Not crazy expensive, but more than what I normally think of from fast food. Heck, you can almost get a high quality meal at Olive Garden for that.

Since I'm wasting time over-analyzing this, here are the wikipedia classifications:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Types_of_restaurants

Fast food/QSR:

Fast food restaurants emphasize speed of service. Operations range from small-scale street vendors with carts to mega-corporations like McDonald's. Also known as a QSR or Quick Serve Restaurant.

Fast casual:

Fast casual restaurants do not offer table service, but may offer non-disposable plates and cutlery. The quality of food and prices tend to be higher than those of a conventional fast food restaurant but may be lower than casual dining.

Casual dining:

A casual dining restaurant is a restaurant that serves moderately-priced food in a casual atmosphere. Except for buffet-style restaurants, casual dining restaurants typically provide table service. Casual dining comprises a market segment between fast food establishments and fine dining restaurants. Casual dining restaurants usually have a full bar with separate bar staff, a larger beer menu and a limited wine menu. They are frequently, but not necessarily, part of a wider chain, particularly in the United States.

Fine dining:

Fine dining restaurants are full service restaurants with specific dedicated meal courses. Décor of such restaurants feature higher-quality materials, with an eye towards the "atmosphere" desired by the restauranteur, than restaurants featuring lower-quality materials and an eye away from the "atmosphere" desired by the restauranteur. The wait staff is usually highly trained and often wears more formal attire. Fine-dining restaurants are almost always small businesses and are generally either single-location operations or have just a few locations. Food portions are visually appealing. Fine dining restaurants have certain rules of dining which visitors are generally expected to follow.
High Quality?? In comparison to what? McDonalds? :X :X :lmao: :lmao:
:whoosh:
 
I didn't mean to create a stir. I just didn't know what QSR meant.I'd definitely categorize Smash Burger, Five Guys, and In-N-Out all as fast food.
I'm not certain of the proper classification, but if I have to get my fat ### out of the car, I don't think of it as fast food.Also, the price. It's over $18 for a reg. cheesburger, a little cheeseburger (for the ol' lady), 2 orders of fries, and 2 ice waters. For people wasting money on a fountain drink, you're talking about at a $22-23 meal for 2. Not crazy expensive, but more than what I normally think of from fast food. Heck, you can almost get a high quality meal at Olive Garden for that.Since I'm wasting time over-analyzing this, here are the wikipedia classifications:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Types_of_restaurantsFast food/QSR: Fast food restaurants emphasize speed of service. Operations range from small-scale street vendors with carts to mega-corporations like McDonald's. Also known as a QSR or Quick Serve Restaurant.Fast casual:Fast casual restaurants do not offer table service, but may offer non-disposable plates and cutlery. The quality of food and prices tend to be higher than those of a conventional fast food restaurant but may be lower than casual dining.Casual dining:A casual dining restaurant is a restaurant that serves moderately-priced food in a casual atmosphere. Except for buffet-style restaurants, casual dining restaurants typically provide table service. Casual dining comprises a market segment between fast food establishments and fine dining restaurants. Casual dining restaurants usually have a full bar with separate bar staff, a larger beer menu and a limited wine menu. They are frequently, but not necessarily, part of a wider chain, particularly in the United States.Fine dining:Fine dining restaurants are full service restaurants with specific dedicated meal courses. Décor of such restaurants feature higher-quality materials, with an eye towards the "atmosphere" desired by the restauranteur, than restaurants featuring lower-quality materials and an eye away from the "atmosphere" desired by the restauranteur. The wait staff is usually highly trained and often wears more formal attire. Fine-dining restaurants are almost always small businesses and are generally either single-location operations or have just a few locations. Food portions are visually appealing. Fine dining restaurants have certain rules of dining which visitors are generally expected to follow.
You don't need two orders of fries, their fries are like twice the size of a large McDonald's fries. This brings your total down to a manageable $13.77 (+tax).
 
'EYLive said:
Since I'm wasting time over-analyzing this, here are the wikipedia classifications:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Types_of_restaurantsFast food/QSR: Fast food restaurants emphasize speed of service. Operations range from small-scale street vendors with carts to mega-corporations like McDonald's. Also known as a QSR or Quick Serve Restaurant.Fast casual:Fast casual restaurants do not offer table service, but may offer non-disposable plates and cutlery. The quality of food and prices tend to be higher than those of a conventional fast food restaurant but may be lower than casual dining.
What's an example of a fast casual? Supposedly, it's a cut above fast food.
Pizza and wings places might fit the bill. I worked for a place that had tables but no table service, sold pizzas/zones/bolis, wings, hoagies, salads, etc and unless you just ordered a couple of slices it would take at least 10 minutes to get your food (not sure if time should factor in here or not). Certainly higher quality than FF.
 
Also, the price. It's over $18 for a reg. cheesburger, a little cheeseburger (for the ol' lady), 2 orders of fries, and 2 ice waters. For people wasting money on a fountain drink, you're talking about at a $22-23 meal for 2.
You and the "ol' lady" really need two orders of fries at Five Guys? In my experience, one order can easily feed three people.
 
Just finished THIS off. Delicious.
Is there any meat on there? :confused:
You must not have ever had a Five Guys burger. It aint 6 inches of toppings. Double bacon cheeseburger with mayo, lettuce, tomato, ketchup, mustard, pickles, mushrooms, jalapeno slice and A-1.ETA: bottom patty covered in cheese, 2nd patty is hanging off the back of the burger but you can see the edge of it under the lettuce. Thats how it was wrapped, I didnt straighten it out for the pic.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Also, the price. It's over $18 for a reg. cheesburger, a little cheeseburger (for the ol' lady), 2 orders of fries, and 2 ice waters. For people wasting money on a fountain drink, you're talking about at a $22-23 meal for 2.
You and the "ol' lady" really need two orders of fries at Five Guys? In my experience, one order can easily feed three people.
:goodposting: Two people and two orders of fries seems silly. Maybe she should layoff the whole order of fries. When I have been there, one order of fries is usually enough for me, my wife and 3 boys 10 and under. If I go there myself, I usually just get the regular cheeseburger and a drink or if I am just picking it up (work from home), I grab a drink or two from my garage fridge and get just the burger and go home.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
went there the other day

dbl cheesburger/bacon

keychup mayo mustard onions jalapenos lettuce

:thumbup:

get small fries they give you almost 4x the amount

 
I wish they could give you half and half of the regular and cajun fries.
Have you asked? The person at the register probably won't do it, but if you watch your order being made, ask the fry boy to do it when he gets your order.
 
I wish they could give you half and half of the regular and cajun fries.
Have you asked? The person at the register probably won't do it, but if you watch your order being made, ask the fry boy to do it when he gets your order.
I have asked for cajun seasoning on the side and got it because I knew my kids wouldn't like it. I gave them each some fries and dumped the seasoning into the rest of the bag and those were mine. They give you a cup, just take the cup of fries out and season what is in the bag, heck shake it a bunch if you want to look cool.
 
I wish they could give you half and half of the regular and cajun fries.
Have you asked? The person at the register probably won't do it, but if you watch your order being made, ask the fry boy to do it when he gets your order.
The restaurant near me won't do it. Their solution was to give me regular fries with a little container of the seasoning. Although I suspect some employees would accomodate the request.
 
I wish they could give you half and half of the regular and cajun fries.
Will they do fries extra crispy? I find their thick cut is hit or miss with some having a perfect crunch skin and a hot moist center while most of the others being soft and mushy.
 
I wish they could give you half and half of the regular and cajun fries.
Will they do fries extra crispy? I find their thick cut is hit or miss with some having a perfect crunch skin and a hot moist center while most of the others being soft and mushy.
I havent had this problem some people have said about this yet. Theyre never what I would call well done, but theyre certainly cooked enough and arent mushy.
 
I wish they could give you half and half of the regular and cajun fries.
Will they do fries extra crispy? I find their thick cut is hit or miss with some having a perfect crunch skin and a hot moist center while most of the others being soft and mushy.
I havent had this problem some people have said about this yet. Theyre never what I would call well done, but theyre certainly cooked enough and arent mushy.
Same here. I always order to go and it's always reasonably crispy when I get home.
 
I wish they could give you half and half of the regular and cajun fries.
Will they do fries extra crispy? I find their thick cut is hit or miss with some having a perfect crunch skin and a hot moist center while most of the others being soft and mushy.
Always soft and mushy. Fries are definitely not what brings me there. They need to take a lesson from In N Out on fries.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I wish they could give you half and half of the regular and cajun fries.
Will they do fries extra crispy? I find their thick cut is hit or miss with some having a perfect crunch skin and a hot moist center while most of the others being soft and mushy.
I havent had this problem some people have said about this yet. Theyre never what I would call well done, but theyre certainly cooked enough and arent mushy.
Same here. I always order to go and it's always reasonably crispy when I get home.
I think this more speaks to the way normal people like me and weirdos like you two prefer their fries. I am guessing you like your steaks well done too.Kidding.
 
I wish they could give you half and half of the regular and cajun fries.
Will they do fries extra crispy? I find their thick cut is hit or miss with some having a perfect crunch skin and a hot moist center while most of the others being soft and mushy.
Always soft and mushy. Fries are definitely not what brings me there. They need to take a lesson from In N Out on fries.
More often than not, I actually only go there for the fries. Theyre a meal in itself, and only cost $3. While I think their burgers are also very tasty, I think you really need the grease of the regular (double) burger to reach their burger's full potential. That's running you $7.
 
I wish they could give you half and half of the regular and cajun fries.
Will they do fries extra crispy? I find their thick cut is hit or miss with some having a perfect crunch skin and a hot moist center while most of the others being soft and mushy.
Always soft and mushy. Fries are definitely not what brings me there. They need to take a lesson from In N Out on fries.
More often than not, I actually only go there for the fries. Theyre a meal in itself, and only cost $3. While I think their burgers are also very tasty, I think you really need the grease of the regular (double) burger to reach their burger's full potential. That's running you $7.
Only $3? For french fried potatoes? Do you know how much a potato actually costs?
 
I wish they could give you half and half of the regular and cajun fries.
Will they do fries extra crispy? I find their thick cut is hit or miss with some having a perfect crunch skin and a hot moist center while most of the others being soft and mushy.
I havent had this problem some people have said about this yet. Theyre never what I would call well done, but theyre certainly cooked enough and arent mushy.
Same here. I always order to go and it's always reasonably crispy when I get home.
I think this more speaks to the way normal people like me and weirdos like you two prefer their fries. I am guessing you like your steaks well done too.
If I was a picky richardface, Id ask them to cook my fries well done. I think theyre good enough as is. If you think theyre that bad, just go somewhere else GB (which you probably do since youre in Cali).FTR, ribeyes are my steak of choice and I like them medium rare. With steaks, you arent an ### if you complain about them being under/over cooked ;)
 
I wish they could give you half and half of the regular and cajun fries.
Will they do fries extra crispy? I find their thick cut is hit or miss with some having a perfect crunch skin and a hot moist center while most of the others being soft and mushy.
Always soft and mushy. Fries are definitely not what brings me there. They need to take a lesson from In N Out on fries.
More often than not, I actually only go there for the fries. Theyre a meal in itself, and only cost $3. While I think their burgers are also very tasty, I think you really need the grease of the regular (double) burger to reach their burger's full potential. That's running you $7.
Only $3? For french fried potatoes? Do you know how much a potato actually costs?
Dont really care. I cant make fries like that at home. However, I can make a tasty burger, cooked to my liking and size, at home.
 
I wish they could give you half and half of the regular and cajun fries.
Will they do fries extra crispy? I find their thick cut is hit or miss with some having a perfect crunch skin and a hot moist center while most of the others being soft and mushy.
I havent had this problem some people have said about this yet. Theyre never what I would call well done, but theyre certainly cooked enough and arent mushy.
Same here. I always order to go and it's always reasonably crispy when I get home.
I think this more speaks to the way normal people like me and weirdos like you two prefer their fries. I am guessing you like your steaks well done too.
If I was a picky richardface, Id ask them to cook my fries well done. I think theyre good enough as is. If you think theyre that bad, just go somewhere else GB (which you probably do since youre in Cali).FTR, ribeyes are my steak of choice and I like them medium rare. With steaks, you arent an ### if you complain about them being under/over cooked ;)
Did you really miss this part of my post?
 
I wish they could give you half and half of the regular and cajun fries.
Will they do fries extra crispy? I find their thick cut is hit or miss with some having a perfect crunch skin and a hot moist center while most of the others being soft and mushy.
I havent had this problem some people have said about this yet. Theyre never what I would call well done, but theyre certainly cooked enough and arent mushy.
Same here. I always order to go and it's always reasonably crispy when I get home.
I think this more speaks to the way normal people like me and weirdos like you two prefer their fries. I am guessing you like your steaks well done too.
If I was a picky richardface, Id ask them to cook my fries well done. I think theyre good enough as is. If you think theyre that bad, just go somewhere else GB (which you probably do since youre in Cali).FTR, ribeyes are my steak of choice and I like them medium rare. With steaks, you arent an ### if you complain about them being under/over cooked ;)
Did you really miss this part of my post?
No, semi-fast food burger discussion can be SERIOUS BUSINESSthough
 
I wish they could give you half and half of the regular and cajun fries.
Will they do fries extra crispy? I find their thick cut is hit or miss with some having a perfect crunch skin and a hot moist center while most of the others being soft and mushy.
Always soft and mushy. Fries are definitely not what brings me there. They need to take a lesson from In N Out on fries.
More often than not, I actually only go there for the fries. Theyre a meal in itself, and only cost $3. While I think their burgers are also very tasty, I think you really need the grease of the regular (double) burger to reach their burger's full potential. That's running you $7.
Only $3? For french fried potatoes? Do you know how much a potato actually costs?
Dont really care. I cant make fries like that at home. However, I can make a tasty burger, cooked to my liking and size, at home.
I'm the opposite.It's very easy with a $40 deep fryer and a fry slicer. Neither of those things are really necessary, but they make it easier.

The soak/blanch/fry method will turn out fries every bit as good as 5 Guys.

But I can't make a nice handformed burger to save my life. Even if I avoid the "softball swell" (rare), the texture still sucks (too dense).

 
Huge fan of the burgers... not at all a fan of the fries (or any natural cut fries for that matter).
I haven't heard such a thing very often. What sort of fries do you like?
Love McDonald's fries. I was a huge fan of Wendy's old fries (when they were fresh out of the fryer and crispy, not soggy). My favorite are those served in local Coney Island restaurants... specifically Kerby's Koney Island
 
Huge fan of the burgers... not at all a fan of the fries (or any natural cut fries for that matter).
I haven't heard such a thing very often. What sort of fries do you like?
Love McDonald's fries. I was a huge fan of Wendy's old fries (when they were fresh out of the fryer and crispy, not soggy). My favorite are those served in local Coney Island restaurants... specifically Kerby's Koney Island
Oh, I got ya. Now that I think about it, I know a lot of people that much prefer the thinner, (usually) crispier fries. I guess that would make sense. That McDonald's place does pretty well with their fries.

The thicker fries get screwed up more often and when they aren't done right, they are pretty worthless.

Five Guys is touch and go, from my experience.

I do much prefer skins on though. I see why a lot of places peel them for the sake of uniformity, but I like them with skins.

 
Huge fan of the burgers... not at all a fan of the fries (or any natural cut fries for that matter).
I haven't heard such a thing very often. What sort of fries do you like?
Love McDonald's fries. I was a huge fan of Wendy's old fries (when they were fresh out of the fryer and crispy, not soggy). My favorite are those served in local Coney Island restaurants... specifically Kerby's Koney Island
Same here. :bag:
 
I wish they could give you half and half of the regular and cajun fries.
Will they do fries extra crispy? I find their thick cut is hit or miss with some having a perfect crunch skin and a hot moist center while most of the others being soft and mushy.
Always soft and mushy. Fries are definitely not what brings me there. They need to take a lesson from In N Out on fries.
:crazy: You have it backwards. In-N-Out fries are always mushy unless you order them well done.I think my 5 Guys location just does a consistently good job with their fries. It's a newer location so the employees might be trying a little harder.

 
You don't need two orders of fries, their fries are like twice the size of a large McDonald's fries. This brings your total down to a manageable $13.77 (+tax).
You and the "ol' lady" really need two orders of fries at Five Guys? In my experience, one order can easily feed three people.
Two people and two orders of fries seems silly. Maybe she should layoff the whole order of fries. When I have been there, one order of fries is usually enough for me, my wife and 3 boys 10 and under. If I go there myself, I usually just get the regular cheeseburger and a drink or if I am just picking it up (work from home), I grab a drink or two from my garage fridge and get just the burger and go home.
Sounds a lot like the soda police in NYC.
 
I wish they could give you half and half of the regular and cajun fries.
Will they do fries extra crispy? I find their thick cut is hit or miss with some having a perfect crunch skin and a hot moist center while most of the others being soft and mushy.
Always soft and mushy. Fries are definitely not what brings me there. They need to take a lesson from In N Out on fries.
:crazy: You have it backwards. In-N-Out fries are always mushy unless you order them well done.I think my 5 Guys location just does a consistently good job with their fries. It's a newer location so the employees might be trying a little harder.
All fries get mushy eventually. IMO the quality of fries is all about how soon you get them after they come out of the fryer. The sooner the better. That's why I asked if you can order them well done at 5 Guys like you can at In-N-Out, that way I know I am getting them straight out of the fryer.
 
I'm the opposite.

It's very easy with a $40 deep fryer and a fry slicer. Neither of those things are really necessary, but they make it easier.
Yeah, I just use a knife and a dutch oven, but my fries are better than any fast-food fries I've tried. (Especially with my homemade ketchup.)I usually fry them in ghee, though sometimes I'll add rendered beef or pork fat as well.

My only problem is that after the first round of frying, the fries are soft and mushy and when I try to remove them from the dutch oven, some of them break. A deep fryer would solve that problem.

The soak/blanch/fry method will turn out fries every bit as good as 5 Guys.
Blanching means to put them in boiling water and then in cold water, right? I haven't tried that method.I soak them, rinse them, fry them, then let them sit on a baking sheet to cool off, then fry them again.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I wish they could give you half and half of the regular and cajun fries.
Will they do fries extra crispy? I find their thick cut is hit or miss with some having a perfect crunch skin and a hot moist center while most of the others being soft and mushy.
Always soft and mushy. Fries are definitely not what brings me there. They need to take a lesson from In N Out on fries.
:crazy: You have it backwards. In-N-Out fries are always mushy unless you order them well done.I think my 5 Guys location just does a consistently good job with their fries. It's a newer location so the employees might be trying a little harder.
All fries get mushy eventually. IMO the quality of fries is all about how soon you get them after they come out of the fryer. The sooner the better. That's why I asked if you can order them well done at 5 Guys like you can at In-N-Out, that way I know I am getting them straight out of the fryer.
Theyre always straight out da fryer regardless at 5G's
 
The fries are definetly fresh at Five Guys - I'd prefer they put the fries in the bag and then my burger so I don't have to grab a handful of hot fries to find my sandwich. For $13, I'd prefer to not burn my hand sifting through a brown paper bag. Would trays be that difficult?

 
The fries are definetly fresh at Five Guys - I'd prefer they put the fries in the bag and then my burger so I don't have to grab a handful of hot fries to find my sandwich. For $13, I'd prefer to not burn my hand sifting through a brown paper bag. Would trays be that difficult?
Tear open the bag.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top