Foster or McGahee (1 Viewer)

[jviddy]

just curious as to which back you think will put up better #s from here on out. I think they're pretty even.

 

[Swing 51]

Portis

 

[Warpig]

Pro'ly ACF, but...

McGahee will get you the yards but no TD's. Foster won't get you either. His TD this week was a miracle and probably won't happen again this year. He's not getting many opportunities and when he is, he doesn't make anything of them.

McGahee's cursed on a bad team.

 

[laughinboy_2000]

Is this even necessary to discuss? McGahee is SOOOO much better than Foster. Once DWILL returns for the Cats, he will slowly start losing carries and eventually his job. McGahee has a nice schedule in front of him and should be productive in the 2nd half of the season.

 

[*****]

I was just starting to think that Foster was becoming useful. In my PPR league, he has scored 70 pts in his last 5 games. That is almost as good as Frank Gore's last 5 games. Foster's schedule gets a bit easier too, except his matchups in weeks 15-16 stink for the fantasy playoffs.

I think Williams' ship has sailed for the year. He will be a bigger factor next year but Carolina is gonna focus on winning games down the stretch and I think will rely more on Foster to do it.

 

[Kiddnets]

I have both - so I approach this question as who would I start since S Jax is #1

Willis - much better talent - better schedule and no other RB breathing down his neck

Foster - pass first team - marginal talent - D Wiliams still around

I like willis for the above. FWIW - I think Foster will keep his job and put up decent #2/3 RB stats from here on out - but with Willis' schedule he can go on a nice run. I have him pegged as a strong finish candidate that can help you make a late push.

 

[cormanman]

I have both - so I approach this question as who would I start since S Jax is #1Willis - much better talent - better schedule and no other RB breathing down his neckFoster - pass first team - marginal talent - D Wiliams still aroundI like willis for the above. FWIW - I think Foster will keep his job and put up decent #2/3 RB stats from here on out - but with Willis' schedule he can go on a nice run. I have him pegged as a strong finish candidate that can help you make a late push.

I have the exact same backfield and I 100% agree with everything you said.