What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

HBO - Song of Ice&Fire Series -Varsity Thread - no TV only whiners (6 Viewers)

So why is Varys a Targaryan supporter? In Jaime's speech he stated how Varys told the mad king not to open the gates. If Varys is all about whats best for the realm, you'd have to think the mad king being taken out was a step in that direction. Especially with Raegar dead already.
Because the Mad King was the exception, not the rule. With the Targaryens in charge, the Realm experienced 300+ years of relative peace. Before their time, the 7 kings fought with each other and with lesser lords constantly. The common folk in that time were nothing but pawns in the chess game their lords played with other lords. After the Targaryens conquered the land, the life of the common man improved immeasurably. If Varys is truly for Targaryen rule, it has to do with this.
Or maybe he's a Targaryen himself.

 
So why is Varys a Targaryan supporter? In Jaime's speech he stated how Varys told the mad king not to open the gates. If Varys is all about whats best for the realm, you'd have to think the mad king being taken out was a step in that direction. Especially with Raegar dead already.
Because the Mad King was the exception, not the rule. With the Targaryens in charge, the Realm experienced 300+ years of relative peace. Before their time, the 7 kings fought with each other and with lesser lords constantly. The common folk in that time were nothing but pawns in the chess game their lords played with other lords. After the Targaryens conquered the land, the life of the common man improved immeasurably. If Varys is truly for Targaryen rule, it has to do with this.
They say the gods flip a coin to determine whether a Targaryan is going to be mad or brilliant. Some other Targs ate wildfire etc. Plenty of crazies with purple eyes.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Why do you think Arya is important to the storyline? I think its just some wierd tangent that Martin got on and cannot seem to end it. He has stated numerous times that he put way too many "balls in the air" and doesnt know how to wrap up certain storylines. I am assuming Arya is one because she has no interaction or advancement to the other characters or main plot.
I enjoy her chapters immensely, but I agree that she seems too far away from the main conflict to come into play with her new skills.

Y'all are nuts. She's becoming a super-assassin. Easy to see her getting involved again at some point...knocking off other "key" characters left and right!
 
Arya is my favorite POV - in a non-homer kind of way.

When she entered the faceless men world she gave up her "rights" as a stark - so she won't really play a direct role in that game of thrones going forward. She presumably will be fully trained enough to also eliminate revenge from her vocabulary. So, other than carrying out silent assassinations, I am not sure that she will play a big role.Sansa or Rickon will represent the StarksStannis (Gendry?)- BaratheonDaenerys - TargaryenTommen - LannisterI think that the reaction to Arya's TV character may drive a more significant story plot in the future books - I am looking forward to her future with the faceless men and whatever gifts she may bestow.
 
Arya is my favorite POV - in a non-homer kind of way.

When she entered the faceless men world she gave up her "rights" as a stark - so she won't really play a direct role in that game of thrones going forward. She presumably will be fully trained enough to also eliminate revenge from her vocabulary. So, other than carrying out silent assassinations, I am not sure that she will play a big role. She hasn't truly given up her alliance to her family imo. I think she'll end up hooking up with Dany and helping her in plans to take back the Iron Throne. Then just when it looks like they'll all destroy each other, they'll all have to get along to fight the Others.

Sansa or Rickon will represent the Starks

Stannis (Gendry?)- Baratheon

Daenerys - Targaryen

Tommen - Lannister

You are forgetting Rob's unknown lineage. No doubt that will play a major role in resolving the story - if it ever reaches resolution, that is.

I think that the reaction to Arya's TV character may drive a more significant story plot in the future books - I am looking forward to her future with the faceless men and whatever gifts she may bestow.
 
Arya is my favorite POV - in a non-homer kind of way.

When she entered the faceless men world she gave up her "rights" as a stark - so she won't really play a direct role in that game of thrones going forward. She presumably will be fully trained enough to also eliminate revenge from her vocabulary. So, other than carrying out silent assassinations, I am not sure that she will play a big role. She hasn't truly given up her alliance to her family imo. I think she'll end up hooking up with Dany and helping her in plans to take back the Iron Throne. Then just when it looks like they'll all destroy each other, they'll all have to get along to fight the Others.Sansa or Rickon will represent the StarksStannis (Gendry?)- BaratheonDaenerys - TargaryenTommen - LannisterYou are forgetting Rob's unknown lineage. No doubt that will play a major role in resolving the story - if it ever reaches resolution, that is. I think that the reaction to Arya's TV character may drive a more significant story plot in the future books - I am looking forward to her future with the faceless men and whatever gifts she may bestow.
I think you mean Jon's lineage. Also, Arya is
holding on to her identity despite what the faceless man has said or done. She's using him.
 
Arya is my favorite POV - in a non-homer kind of way.

When she entered the faceless men world she gave up her "rights" as a stark - so she won't really play a direct role in that game of thrones going forward. She presumably will be fully trained enough to also eliminate revenge from her vocabulary. So, other than carrying out silent assassinations, I am not sure that she will play a big role. She hasn't truly given up her alliance to her family imo. I think she'll end up hooking up with Dany and helping her in plans to take back the Iron Throne. Then just when it looks like they'll all destroy each other, they'll all have to get along to fight the Others.Sansa or Rickon will represent the StarksStannis (Gendry?)- BaratheonDaenerys - TargaryenTommen - LannisterYou are forgetting Rob's unknown lineage. No doubt that will play a major role in resolving the story - if it ever reaches resolution, that is. I think that the reaction to Arya's TV character may drive a more significant story plot in the future books - I am looking forward to her future with the faceless men and whatever gifts she may bestow.
I think you mean Jon's lineage.Also, Arya is
holding on to her identity despite what the faceless man has said or done. She's using him.
I think so too.

I predict Arya winds up being Lord commander of the white cloaks for Jon and Dany... or becomes a succesful pirate :pirate:
 
Arya is my favorite POV - in a non-homer kind of way.

When she entered the faceless men world she gave up her "rights" as a stark - so she won't really play a direct role in that game of thrones going forward. She presumably will be fully trained enough to also eliminate revenge from her vocabulary. So, other than carrying out silent assassinations, I am not sure that she will play a big role. She hasn't truly given up her alliance to her family imo. I think she'll end up hooking up with Dany and helping her in plans to take back the Iron Throne. Then just when it looks like they'll all destroy each other, they'll all have to get along to fight the Others.Sansa or Rickon will represent the StarksStannis (Gendry?)- BaratheonDaenerys - TargaryenTommen - LannisterYou are forgetting Rob's unknown lineage. No doubt that will play a major role in resolving the story - if it ever reaches resolution, that is. I think that the reaction to Arya's TV character may drive a more significant story plot in the future books - I am looking forward to her future with the faceless men and whatever gifts she may bestow.
I think you mean Jon's lineage.Also, Arya is holding on to her identity despite what the faceless man has said or done. She's using him.
I think so too.

I predict Arya winds up being Lord commander of the white cloaks for Jon and Dany... or becomes a succesful pirate :pirate:
And I believe she gets captured and escapes a few more times imo.
 
Arya is my favorite POV - in a non-homer kind of way.

When she entered the faceless men world she gave up her "rights" as a stark - so she won't really play a direct role in that game of thrones going forward. She presumably will be fully trained enough to also eliminate revenge from her vocabulary. So, other than carrying out silent assassinations, I am not sure that she will play a big role. She hasn't truly given up her alliance to her family imo. I think she'll end up hooking up with Dany and helping her in plans to take back the Iron Throne. Then just when it looks like they'll all destroy each other, they'll all have to get along to fight the Others.Sansa or Rickon will represent the StarksStannis (Gendry?)- BaratheonDaenerys - TargaryenTommen - LannisterYou are forgetting Rob's unknown lineage. No doubt that will play a major role in resolving the story - if it ever reaches resolution, that is. I think that the reaction to Arya's TV character may drive a more significant story plot in the future books - I am looking forward to her future with the faceless men and whatever gifts she may bestow.
I think you mean Jon's lineage.Also, Arya is
holding on to her identity despite what the faceless man has said or done. She's using him.
Yeah. My bad.

 
Arya is my favorite POV - in a non-homer kind of way.

When she entered the faceless men world she gave up her "rights" as a stark - so she won't really play a direct role in that game of thrones going forward. She presumably will be fully trained enough to also eliminate revenge from her vocabulary. So, other than carrying out silent assassinations, I am not sure that she will play a big role. She hasn't truly given up her alliance to her family imo. I think she'll end up hooking up with Dany and helping her in plans to take back the Iron Throne. Then just when it looks like they'll all destroy each other, they'll all have to get along to fight the Others.Sansa or Rickon will represent the StarksStannis (Gendry?)- BaratheonDaenerys - TargaryenTommen - LannisterYou are forgetting Rob's unknown lineage. No doubt that will play a major role in resolving the story - if it ever reaches resolution, that is. I think that the reaction to Arya's TV character may drive a more significant story plot in the future books - I am looking forward to her future with the faceless men and whatever gifts she may bestow.
I think you mean Jon's lineage. Also, Arya is
holding on to her identity despite what the faceless man has said or done. She's using him.
:goodposting:

 
I've been touting to my friends all year that this season of Thrones may go down as one of the best seasons of tv period. It's still on track for that, but I've been thinking that next season may be even better. Based on

the red wedding happening late this season, there isn't time for joffrey's wedding. If the show stays true to next season bring the second half of Swords, Joffrey will meet his demise relatively early. Like episode 3. This will be a huge event to happen so early. Then we have Arya traveling with the hound and he meeting his demise. Dany continuing to rampage and then settle and rule. Tyrion being locked away, meeting the red viper, the trial by combat, and a finale with Tywin biting the dust? That's a lot of main characters dying off in just 10 episodes. Not to mention everything at the wall?!? Action packed season 4 is coming!
 
I've been touting to my friends all year that this season of Thrones may go down as one of the best seasons of tv period. It's still on track for that, but I've been thinking that next season may be even better. Based on

the red wedding happening late this season, there isn't time for joffrey's wedding. If the show stays true to next season bring the second half of Swords, Joffrey will meet his demise relatively early. Like episode 3. This will be a huge event to happen so early. Then we have Arya traveling with the hound and he meeting his demise. Dany continuing to rampage and then settle and rule. Tyrion being locked away, meeting the red viper, the trial by combat, and a finale with Tywin biting the dust? That's a lot of main characters dying off in just 10 episodes. Not to mention everything at the wall?!? Action packed season 4 is coming!
Martin is going to have to write some new material relatively soon, because the series will have just about caught up at that point.
 
I've been touting to my friends all year that this season of Thrones may go down as one of the best seasons of tv period. It's still on track for that, but I've been thinking that next season may be even better. Based on

the red wedding happening late this season, there isn't time for joffrey's wedding. If the show stays true to next season bring the second half of Swords, Joffrey will meet his demise relatively early. Like episode 3. This will be a huge event to happen so early. Then we have Arya traveling with the hound and he meeting his demise. Dany continuing to rampage and then settle and rule. Tyrion being locked away, meeting the red viper, the trial by combat, and a finale with Tywin biting the dust? That's a lot of main characters dying off in just 10 episodes. Not to mention everything at the wall?!? Action packed season 4 is coming!
Martin is going to have to write some new material relatively soon, because the series will have just about caught up at that point.Well I think Crows and Dragons will be done chronologically and that they will get 3 seasons, if not 4, out of the 2 books.
 
I've been touting to my friends all year that this season of Thrones may go down as one of the best seasons of tv period. It's still on track for that, but I've been thinking that next season may be even better. Based on

the red wedding happening late this season, there isn't time for joffrey's wedding. If the show stays true to next season bring the second half of Swords, Joffrey will meet his demise relatively early. Like episode 3. This will be a huge event to happen so early. Then we have Arya traveling with the hound and he meeting his demise. Dany continuing to rampage and then settle and rule. Tyrion being locked away, meeting the red viper, the trial by combat, and a finale with Tywin biting the dust? That's a lot of main characters dying off in just 10 episodes. Not to mention everything at the wall?!? Action packed season 4 is coming!
The Tyrion/Sansa marriage should make for some good scenes. Those were dry moments in the book, but I think it'll come across as comedic on screen.
 
Why do you think Arya is important to the storyline? I think its just some wierd tangent that Martin got on and cannot seem to end it. He has stated numerous times that he put way too many "balls in the air" and doesnt know how to wrap up certain storylines. I am assuming Arya is one because she has no interaction or advancement to the other characters or main plot.
I enjoy her chapters immensely, but I agree that she seems too far away from the main conflict to come into play with her new skills.
Given all the people who have wronged the Starks over the first five books, I'm pretty sure Martin can find a way to get a Stark/master assassin on a boat back to westeros and involved in the main conflict.
For sure. She's still a work in progress at this point. Can't wait to see her final set of skills.

Yah, I love Arya's PoVs, and look forward to her storyline. One of the really interesting things about the way these books are written is that different people like and identify with different characters, more so that in "traditional" books that aren't written from a PoV perspective.

 
I've been touting to my friends all year that this season of Thrones may go down as one of the best seasons of tv period. It's still on track for that, but I've been thinking that next season may be even better. Based on

the red wedding happening late this season, there isn't time for joffrey's wedding. If the show stays true to next season bring the second half of Swords, Joffrey will meet his demise relatively early. Like episode 3. This will be a huge event to happen so early. Then we have Arya traveling with the hound and he meeting his demise. Dany continuing to rampage and then settle and rule. Tyrion being locked away, meeting the red viper, the trial by combat, and a finale with Tywin biting the dust? That's a lot of main characters dying off in just 10 episodes. Not to mention everything at the wall?!? Action packed season 4 is coming!
Martin is going to have to write some new material relatively soon, because the series will have just about caught up at that point.the show is going to pass the books

 
I've been touting to my friends all year that this season of Thrones may go down as one of the best seasons of tv period. It's still on track for that, but I've been thinking that next season may be even better. Based on

the red wedding happening late this season, there isn't time for joffrey's wedding. If the show stays true to next season bring the second half of Swords, Joffrey will meet his demise relatively early. Like episode 3. This will be a huge event to happen so early. Then we have Arya traveling with the hound and he meeting his demise. Dany continuing to rampage and then settle and rule. Tyrion being locked away, meeting the red viper, the trial by combat, and a finale with Tywin biting the dust? That's a lot of main characters dying off in just 10 episodes. Not to mention everything at the wall?!? Action packed season 4 is coming!
Martin is going to have to write some new material relatively soon, because the series will have just about caught up at that point.
Well I think Crows and Dragons will be done chronologically and that they will get 3 seasons, if not 4, out of the 2 books.I'm not seeing it. I think they are going to (rightly) cut out a lot from those two books. If they make those books into 4 seasons, the show is getting canceled.
 
The whole age thing and Arya being too old for her part was discussed many pages ago. Dany in the show is played by a 25 year old but in the books she is 16. I believe Robb is also supposed to be 16ish from the books but he is much older in the show. I don't see any changing of actors.

 
I've been touting to my friends all year that this season of Thrones may go down as one of the best seasons of tv period. It's still on track for that, but I've been thinking that next season may be even better. Based on

the red wedding happening late this season, there isn't time for joffrey's wedding. If the show stays true to next season bring the second half of Swords, Joffrey will meet his demise relatively early. Like episode 3. This will be a huge event to happen so early. Then we have Arya traveling with the hound and he meeting his demise. Dany continuing to rampage and then settle and rule. Tyrion being locked away, meeting the red viper, the trial by combat, and a finale with Tywin biting the dust? That's a lot of main characters dying off in just 10 episodes. Not to mention everything at the wall?!? Action packed season 4 is coming!
Martin is going to have to write some new material relatively soon, because the series will have just about caught up at that point.
Well I think Crows and Dragons will be done chronologically and that they will get 3 seasons, if not 4, out of the 2 books.
I'm not seeing it. I think they are going to (rightly) cut out a lot from those two books. If they make those books into 4 seasons, the show is getting canceled.Disagree. I think those books get a bad rep because of the wait time in between and wanting the story to pay off. Crows is great.
 
I've been touting to my friends all year that this season of Thrones may go down as one of the best seasons of tv period. It's still on track for that, but I've been thinking that next season may be even better. Based on

the red wedding happening late this season, there isn't time for joffrey's wedding. If the show stays true to next season bring the second half of Swords, Joffrey will meet his demise relatively early. Like episode 3. This will be a huge event to happen so early. Then we have Arya traveling with the hound and he meeting his demise. Dany continuing to rampage and then settle and rule. Tyrion being locked away, meeting the red viper, the trial by combat, and a finale with Tywin biting the dust? That's a lot of main characters dying off in just 10 episodes. Not to mention everything at the wall?!? Action packed season 4 is coming!
Martin is going to have to write some new material relatively soon, because the series will have just about caught up at that point.
Well I think Crows and Dragons will be done chronologically and that they will get 3 seasons, if not 4, out of the 2 books.
I'm not seeing it. I think they are going to (rightly) cut out a lot from those two books. If they make those books into 4 seasons, the show is getting canceled.
Disagree. I think those books get a bad rep because of the wait time in between and wanting the story to pay off. Crows is great.We'll have to agree to disagree here. Crows and Dragons should have been one book, IMO.
 
I've been touting to my friends all year that this season of Thrones may go down as one of the best seasons of tv period. It's still on track for that, but I've been thinking that next season may be even better. Based on

the red wedding happening late this season, there isn't time for joffrey's wedding. If the show stays true to next season bring the second half of Swords, Joffrey will meet his demise relatively early. Like episode 3. This will be a huge event to happen so early. Then we have Arya traveling with the hound and he meeting his demise. Dany continuing to rampage and then settle and rule. Tyrion being locked away, meeting the red viper, the trial by combat, and a finale with Tywin biting the dust? That's a lot of main characters dying off in just 10 episodes. Not to mention everything at the wall?!? Action packed season 4 is coming!
Martin is going to have to write some new material relatively soon, because the series will have just about caught up at that point.
Well I think Crows and Dragons will be done chronologically and that they will get 3 seasons, if not 4, out of the 2 books.
I'm not seeing it. I think they are going to (rightly) cut out a lot from those two books. If they make those books into 4 seasons, the show is getting canceled.
Disagree. I think those books get a bad rep because of the wait time in between and wanting the story to pay off. Crows is great.Crows wasn't bad, but I did have issue with none of my favorite characters being in the book.

 
I've been touting to my friends all year that this season of Thrones may go down as one of the best seasons of tv period. It's still on track for that, but I've been thinking that next season may be even better. Based on

the red wedding happening late this season, there isn't time for joffrey's wedding. If the show stays true to next season bring the second half of Swords, Joffrey will meet his demise relatively early. Like episode 3. This will be a huge event to happen so early. Then we have Arya traveling with the hound and he meeting his demise. Dany continuing to rampage and then settle and rule. Tyrion being locked away, meeting the red viper, the trial by combat, and a finale with Tywin biting the dust? That's a lot of main characters dying off in just 10 episodes. Not to mention everything at the wall?!? Action packed season 4 is coming!
Martin is going to have to write some new material relatively soon, because the series will have just about caught up at that point.
Well I think Crows and Dragons will be done chronologically and that they will get 3 seasons, if not 4, out of the 2 books.
I'm not seeing it. I think they are going to (rightly) cut out a lot from those two books. If they make those books into 4 seasons, the show is getting canceled.
Disagree. I think those books get a bad rep because of the wait time in between and wanting the story to pay off. Crows is great.
Crows wasn't bad, but I did have issue with none of my favorite characters being in the book. I think that's why people hate on it. Then dragons was so many years later when everybody thought he would have had it out quick given it originally was all supposed to be a part of Crows. Having the benefit of reading all 5 books consecutively for the first time I think let me enjoy those two more and not be as annoyed.
 
Those who dislike Crows/Dragons; were you early readers of the series and had the long wait?

As a late comer, i was able to go straight from Crows to Dragons and thought it worked well or they were at least quite a bit better than what I heard they would be.

 
I've been touting to my friends all year that this season of Thrones may go down as one of the best seasons of tv period. It's still on track for that, but I've been thinking that next season may be even better. Based on

the red wedding happening late this season, there isn't time for joffrey's wedding. If the show stays true to next season bring the second half of Swords, Joffrey will meet his demise relatively early. Like episode 3. This will be a huge event to happen so early. Then we have Arya traveling with the hound and he meeting his demise. Dany continuing to rampage and then settle and rule. Tyrion being locked away, meeting the red viper, the trial by combat, and a finale with Tywin biting the dust? That's a lot of main characters dying off in just 10 episodes. Not to mention everything at the wall?!? Action packed season 4 is coming!
Well, 2.5 seasons in, it's already amongst the top 10 greatest TV shows ever. So your prediction seems plausible.

 
Was losing the Karstarks the reason for returning to the Freys in the books? I love how there was swelling, triumphant music rising when Robb was laying out his plan to go to the Freys and recruit them and SMASH the Lannisters in their own house. Perfectly setting everyone up for the RW. I think they have to let everyone stew about Joffrey's apparent victory over the off season though. No way they can kill him this season, IMO.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'm reading through Swords again and came to the part before the Red Wedding where Robb legitimizes Jon and names him heir. He has his lords fix their seals to the document as witness to his decision. The Red Wedding happens right after, but it is possible that document survives. I wonder if anything will come from that in the future...
 
The Gator said:
Those who dislike Crows/Dragons; were you early readers of the series and had the long wait?

As a late comer, i was able to go straight from Crows to Dragons and thought it worked well or they were at least quite a bit better than what I heard they would be.
I am a late bloomer - I started reading the books after seeing the 1st season.

I think the problem for me was a combination of how much crap went down in book 3 and loving that one so much combined with book 4 not having characters I liked and focusing on areas I wasn't overly interested in - Iron Islands and Dorne. Started reading 5, but lost steam. I already had started losing track of what was happening to the characters who weren't in book 4. I am currently about 800pgs into book 3 and picking up on a lot more details, so hopefully I will have more success on the 2nd go through and when I get to Dragons again.

 
mad sweeney said:
Was losing the Karstarks the reason for returning to the Freys in the books? I love how there was swelling, triumphant music rising when Robb was laying out his plan to go to the Freys and recruit them and SMASH the Lannisters in their own house. Perfectly setting everyone up for the RW. I think they have to let everyone stew about Joffrey's apparent victory over the off season though. No way they can kill him this season, IMO.
I think that was some of the reason of going back to the Freys, but I felt as though they focuses on it more for the show and spelled it out a little more. Either format, the Freys are about the only house left that hadn't pledged a side but have a crapload of soldiers.

As I am reading through book 3 again, I think you are right. Based on episode 9s in the past couple seasons, I would bet that is the Red Wedding and episode 10 will be King's Landing, Stannis, etc.. getting the news and set up for season 4. Joffrey will probably happen in the first few episodes, and we go from there and end with Tywin getting it and Tyrion on the lamb at the end of the season?
 
The Gator said:
Those who dislike Crows/Dragons; were you early readers of the series and had the long wait? As a late comer, i was able to go straight from Crows to Dragons and thought it worked well or they were at least quite a bit better than what I heard they would be.
I was an early reader and waited for both Crows and Dragons but I have since done a couple of rereads straight through. My beefs:
Up until Crows, the plot was fast moving and exciting. Crows was like putting two feet on the brake. There are huge portions of those books which would have been better off omitted or signifigantly truncated. We have Brienne looking for Sansa when the reader knows where Sansa is and knows Brienne isn't going to find her. We have the Martell fool's errand which predictably ends in disaster and doesn't move the plot. Finally, Dany is basically in the exact same position she was at the end of Swords until the last 50 pages of Dragons. They aren't terrible books, but instead of two 1000 page books, it should have been one 1200 page book. I feel like this was easier to get away with in print than it will be on the show. Do you think non-book readers are going to keep interest in the show if the next 4 seasons Dany just sits around? I don't see it.
 
I was an early reader and waited for both Crows and Dragons but I have since done a couple of rereads straight through. My beefs:

Up until Crows, the plot was fast moving and exciting. Crows was like putting two feet on the brake. There are huge portions of those books which would have been better off omitted or signifigantly truncated. We have Brienne looking for Sansa when the reader knows where Sansa is and knows Brienne isn't going to find her. We have the Martell fool's errand which predictably ends in disaster and doesn't move the plot. Finally, Dany is basically in the exact same position she was at the end of Swords until the last 50 pages of Dragons.

They aren't terrible books, but instead of two 1000 page books, it should have been one 1200 page book. I feel like this was easier to get away with in print than it will be on the show. Do you think non-book readers are going to keep interest in the show if the next 4 seasons Dany just sits around? I don't see it.
They're going to throw a fit when "OMG she has an awesome army and DRAGONS" turns into :yawn:
 
mad sweeney said:
Was losing the Karstarks the reason for returning to the Freys in the books? I love how there was swelling, triumphant music rising when Robb was laying out his plan to go to the Freys and recruit them and SMASH the Lannisters in their own house. Perfectly setting everyone up for the RW. I think they have to let everyone stew about Joffrey's apparent victory over the off season though. No way they can kill him this season, IMO.
I think that was some of the reason of going back to the Freys, but I felt as though they focuses on it more for the show and spelled it out a little more. Either format, the Freys are about the only house left that hadn't pledged a side but have a crapload of soldiers.

As I am reading through book 3 again, I think you are right. Based on episode 9s in the past couple seasons, I would bet that is the Red Wedding and episode 10 will be King's Landing, Stannis, etc.. getting the news and set up for season 4. Joffrey will probably happen in the first few episodes, and we go from there and end with Tywin getting it and Tyrion on the lamb at the end of the season?
IIRC, in the book Robb decides to retreat back to the North to retake Winterfell and the other places siezed by the iron-born. Basically to get his house back in order, because losing your seat of power is a major political blow (the King Who Lost the North) and being spread out too far in the Westerlands & Riverlands would get them wiped out once Stannis was defeated & the Lannisters/Tyrell's joined forces. In order to retreat North he has to go back thru the Frey's territory so he has to get them back on his side. Contributing factors are because of the Karstark defection but mainly Edmure Tully's screwups.

They changed it in the show, but it wasn't the Mountain that Robb was trying to lure West and surround to kill, it was Tywin himself. Robb actually was already on his way to Casterly Rock and had won resounding victories in Tywin's home territory which was to draw Tywin either away from King's Landing (to make it ripe for the Baretheon's to attack) or to force Tywin to give up Casterly Rock (which would have been a major political and financial blow.) Edmure going against orders delayed Tywin's advance enough that he got word of the attack on King's Landing and was able to turn around and escape, meet up with the Tyrell's and stop Stannis from taking King's Landing. Had Edmure not delayed Tywin, King's Landing would have fallen to the Baratheon's, Tywin would have been surrounded and likely wiped out and the war would have been over for the Lannisters. They also left out in the show that Edmure had a 2nd major blunder which was he dispersed all of the Riverlands bannermen/forces so they could go back and retake their personal seats of power. So the troops were all spread across the burned up, war-ruined countryside instead of gathered into an organized fighting force.
 
I was an early reader and waited for both Crows and Dragons but I have since done a couple of rereads straight through. My beefs:

Up until Crows, the plot was fast moving and exciting. Crows was like putting two feet on the brake. There are huge portions of those books which would have been better off omitted or signifigantly truncated. We have Brienne looking for Sansa when the reader knows where Sansa is and knows Brienne isn't going to find her. We have the Martell fool's errand which predictably ends in disaster and doesn't move the plot. Finally, Dany is basically in the exact same position she was at the end of Swords until the last 50 pages of Dragons.They aren't terrible books, but instead of two 1000 page books, it should have been one 1200 page book. I feel like this was easier to get away with in print than it will be on the show. Do you think non-book readers are going to keep interest in the show if the next 4 seasons Dany just sits around? I don't see it.
They're going to throw a fit when "OMG she has an awesome army and DRAGONS" turns into :yawn:
Have seen the part about Dany discuss on other forums and it's almost 100% in line with what you guys have said. Things may have to be changed/moved along.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I was an early reader and waited for both Crows and Dragons but I have since done a couple of rereads straight through. My beefs:

Up until Crows, the plot was fast moving and exciting. Crows was like putting two feet on the brake. There are huge portions of those books which would have been better off omitted or signifigantly truncated. We have Brienne looking for Sansa when the reader knows where Sansa is and knows Brienne isn't going to find her. We have the Martell fool's errand which predictably ends in disaster and doesn't move the plot. Finally, Dany is basically in the exact same position she was at the end of Swords until the last 50 pages of Dragons.They aren't terrible books, but instead of two 1000 page books, it should have been one 1200 page book. I feel like this was easier to get away with in print than it will be on the show. Do you think non-book readers are going to keep interest in the show if the next 4 seasons Dany just sits around? I don't see it.
They're going to throw a fit when "OMG she has an awesome army and DRAGONS" turns into :yawn:
:goodposting:edited because quoting on the new site is a pain.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I was an early reader and waited for both Crows and Dragons but I have since done a couple of rereads straight through. My beefs:

Up until Crows, the plot was fast moving and exciting. Crows was like putting two feet on the brake. There are huge portions of those books which would have been better off omitted or signifigantly truncated. We have Brienne looking for Sansa when the reader knows where Sansa is and knows Brienne isn't going to find her. We have the Martell fool's errand which predictably ends in disaster and doesn't move the plot. Finally, Dany is basically in the exact same position she was at the end of Swords until the last 50 pages of Dragons.They aren't terrible books, but instead of two 1000 page books, it should have been one 1200 page book. I feel like this was easier to get away with in print than it will be on the show. Do you think non-book readers are going to keep interest in the show if the next 4 seasons Dany just sits around? I don't see it.
They're going to throw a fit when "OMG she has an awesome army and DRAGONS" turns into :yawn:
This is my biggest contention with those two books as well. What really happens during the time line of those two books? Nothing. The only plot line even advancing is the north. Bran's continued education and Jon and Stannis at the wall/attacking Bolton is the only thing moving the plot forward. Arya, Dany, Cersei and Marge, Littlefinger and Sansa, Martells, etc. are all pretty stagnant throughout both books. The last half of ADWD we see everything set up to move fast in the next book, but otherwise it was just Martin putting words to a page to appease his readers. I really wish he would've just stuck with the 5 years gap he originally planned after Swords.
 
I was an early reader and waited for both Crows and Dragons but I have since done a couple of rereads straight through. My beefs:

Up until Crows, the plot was fast moving and exciting. Crows was like putting two feet on the brake. There are huge portions of those books which would have been better off omitted or signifigantly truncated. We have Brienne looking for Sansa when the reader knows where Sansa is and knows Brienne isn't going to find her. We have the Martell fool's errand which predictably ends in disaster and doesn't move the plot. Finally, Dany is basically in the exact same position she was at the end of Swords until the last 50 pages of Dragons.They aren't terrible books, but instead of two 1000 page books, it should have been one 1200 page book. I feel like this was easier to get away with in print than it will be on the show. Do you think non-book readers are going to keep interest in the show if the next 4 seasons Dany just sits around? I don't see it.
They're going to throw a fit when "OMG she has an awesome army and DRAGONS" turns into :yawn:
This is my biggest contention with those two books as well. What really happens during the time line of those two books? Nothing. The only plot line even advancing is the north. Bran's continued education and Jon and Stannis at the wall/attacking Bolton is the only thing moving the plot forward. Arya, Dany, Cersei and Marge, Littlefinger and Sansa, Martells, etc. are all pretty stagnant throughout both books. The last half of ADWD we see everything set up to move fast in the next book, but otherwise it was just Martin putting words to a page to appease his readers. I really wish he would've just stuck with the 5 years gap he originally planned after Swords.
Quite a bit happens.

Cersei and Margaery are imprisoned.

The Faith are rearmed.

Arya begins her training.

Tyrion gets an army.

Dany tries to rule.

Jaime becomes more like Tywin

Sansa becomes more of a savvy player.

There may be another claim to the throne by a Targaryen.

Dany will have support in Westeros by the Martells.

The only plot thread that really didn't have anything important happen was Brienne's. She may or may not kill/capture Jaime.
 
pantherclub said:
Why do you think Arya is important to the storyline? I think its just some wierd tangent that Martin got on and cannot seem to end it. He has stated numerous times that he put way too many "balls in the air" and doesnt know how to wrap up certain storylines. I am assuming Arya is one because she has no interaction or advancement to the other characters or main plot.
Seems like the free cities are more the arena of action than Westeros in DOD. I think she will return to reclaim the throne of House Stark rather than Bran or Rickon. I see her in a Bloddy Mary type role, most likely taking up cause with Danaerys once she finally gets off her ### and returns to Westeros to claim her throne.
 
pantherclub said:
Why do you think Arya is important to the storyline? I think its just some wierd tangent that Martin got on and cannot seem to end it. He has stated numerous times that he put way too many "balls in the air" and doesnt know how to wrap up certain storylines. I am assuming Arya is one because she has no interaction or advancement to the other characters or main plot.
Because she's the only one with a POV in all five books.

 
I was an early reader and waited for both Crows and Dragons but I have since done a couple of rereads straight through. My beefs:

Up until Crows, the plot was fast moving and exciting. Crows was like putting two feet on the brake. There are huge portions of those books which would have been better off omitted or signifigantly truncated. We have Brienne looking for Sansa when the reader knows where Sansa is and knows Brienne isn't going to find her. We have the Martell fool's errand which predictably ends in disaster and doesn't move the plot. Finally, Dany is basically in the exact same position she was at the end of Swords until the last 50 pages of Dragons.They aren't terrible books, but instead of two 1000 page books, it should have been one 1200 page book. I feel like this was easier to get away with in print than it will be on the show. Do you think non-book readers are going to keep interest in the show if the next 4 seasons Dany just sits around? I don't see it.
They're going to throw a fit when "OMG she has an awesome army and DRAGONS" turns into :yawn:
This is my biggest contention with those two books as well. What really happens during the time line of those two books? Nothing. The only plot line even advancing is the north. Bran's continued education and Jon and Stannis at the wall/attacking Bolton is the only thing moving the plot forward. Arya, Dany, Cersei and Marge, Littlefinger and Sansa, Martells, etc. are all pretty stagnant throughout both books. The last half of ADWD we see everything set up to move fast in the next book, but otherwise it was just Martin putting words to a page to appease his readers. I really wish he would've just stuck with the 5 years gap he originally planned after Swords.
Quite a bit happens.Cersei and Margaery are imprisoned.The Faith are rearmed.Arya begins her training.Tyrion gets an army.Dany tries to rule.Jaime becomes more like TywinSansa becomes more of a savvy player.There may be another claim to the throne by a Targaryen.Dany will have support in Westeros by the Martells. The only plot thread that really didn't have anything important happen was Brienne's. She may or may not kill/capture Jaime.
These aren't exactly made for tv moments.

 
mad sweeney said:
Was losing the Karstarks the reason for returning to the Freys in the books? I love how there was swelling, triumphant music rising when Robb was laying out his plan to go to the Freys and recruit them and SMASH the Lannisters in their own house. Perfectly setting everyone up for the RW. I think they have to let everyone stew about Joffrey's apparent victory over the off season though. No way they can kill him this season, IMO.
I think that was some of the reason of going back to the Freys, but I felt as though they focuses on it more for the show and spelled it out a little more. Either format, the Freys are about the only house left that hadn't pledged a side but have a crapload of soldiers.

As I am reading through book 3 again, I think you are right. Based on episode 9s in the past couple seasons, I would bet that is the Red Wedding and episode 10 will be King's Landing, Stannis, etc.. getting the news and set up for season 4. Joffrey will probably happen in the first few episodes, and we go from there and end with Tywin getting it and Tyrion on the lamb at the end of the season?
Hmmm, I thought there were 12 eps this year...

I figured Coldheart (whatever they call it) would be the final image of the season, giving it a few eps to sink in before jumping there, but with only 1 ep after it, I am not so sure now.

Last night I realized that Neil Marshall, who's directed some decent but not great horror-type thrillers with some pretty hot badass wimmins directed the Blackwater episode. He did Descent, Doomsday with Rhona Mitra, Centurion with Olga Kurylenko as a badass Pict warrior. I'd like to see him do more, but it doesn't look like he's got one this season. Then again he is working on a new TV show called Black Sails, about the pirates from Treasure Island prior to the book.

 
pantherclub said:
Why do you think Arya is important to the storyline? I think its just some wierd tangent that Martin got on and cannot seem to end it. He has stated numerous times that he put way too many "balls in the air" and doesnt know how to wrap up certain storylines. I am assuming Arya is one because she has no interaction or advancement to the other characters or main plot.
Seems like the free cities are more the arena of action than Westeros in DOD. I think she will return to reclaim the throne of House Stark rather than Bran or Rickon. I see her in a Bloddy Mary type role, most likely taking up cause with Danaerys once she finally gets off her ### and returns to Westeros to claim her throne.
I can see this. They make a bunch of references to Nymeria in Arya's storyline - wasn't she a joan of arc style female conqueror or something in the GOT universe? I'm sure there will be some parallels developed there.
 
mad sweeney said:
Was losing the Karstarks the reason for returning to the Freys in the books? I love how there was swelling, triumphant music rising when Robb was laying out his plan to go to the Freys and recruit them and SMASH the Lannisters in their own house. Perfectly setting everyone up for the RW. I think they have to let everyone stew about Joffrey's apparent victory over the off season though. No way they can kill him this season, IMO.
I think that was some of the reason of going back to the Freys, but I felt as though they focuses on it more for the show and spelled it out a little more. Either format, the Freys are about the only house left that hadn't pledged a side but have a crapload of soldiers.

As I am reading through book 3 again, I think you are right. Based on episode 9s in the past couple seasons, I would bet that is the Red Wedding and episode 10 will be King's Landing, Stannis, etc.. getting the news and set up for season 4. Joffrey will probably happen in the first few episodes, and we go from there and end with Tywin getting it and Tyrion on the lamb at the end of the season?
IIRC, in the book Robb decides to retreat back to the North to retake Winterfell and the other places siezed by the iron-born. Basically to get his house back in order, because losing your seat of power is a major political blow (the King Who Lost the North) and being spread out too far in the Westerlands & Riverlands would get them wiped out once Stannis was defeated & the Lannisters/Tyrell's joined forces. In order to retreat North he has to go back thru the Frey's territory so he has to get them back on his side. Contributing factors are because of the Karstark defection but mainly Edmure Tully's screwups.

They changed it in the show, but it wasn't the Mountain that Robb was trying to lure West and surround to kill, it was Tywin himself. Robb actually was already on his way to Casterly Rock and had won resounding victories in Tywin's home territory which was to draw Tywin either away from King's Landing (to make it ripe for the Baretheon's to attack) or to force Tywin to give up Casterly Rock (which would have been a major political and financial blow.) Edmure going against orders delayed Tywin's advance enough that he got word of the attack on King's Landing and was able to turn around and escape, meet up with the Tyrell's and stop Stannis from taking King's Landing. Had Edmure not delayed Tywin, King's Landing would have fallen to the Baratheon's, Tywin would have been surrounded and likely wiped out and the war would have been over for the Lannisters. They also left out in the show that Edmure had a 2nd major blunder which was he dispersed all of the Riverlands bannermen/forces so they could go back and retake their personal seats of power. So the troops were all spread across the burned up, war-ruined countryside instead of gathered into an organized fighting force.
Thanks. I figured the reasons had been truncated but couldn't remember the details. Pretty good way of wrapping a bunch of book-interesting stuff into a cogent and simplified show reason.

 
I was an early reader and waited for both Crows and Dragons but I have since done a couple of rereads straight through. My beefs:

Up until Crows, the plot was fast moving and exciting. Crows was like putting two feet on the brake. There are huge portions of those books which would have been better off omitted or signifigantly truncated. We have Brienne looking for Sansa when the reader knows where Sansa is and knows Brienne isn't going to find her. We have the Martell fool's errand which predictably ends in disaster and doesn't move the plot. Finally, Dany is basically in the exact same position she was at the end of Swords until the last 50 pages of Dragons.They aren't terrible books, but instead of two 1000 page books, it should have been one 1200 page book. I feel like this was easier to get away with in print than it will be on the show. Do you think non-book readers are going to keep interest in the show if the next 4 seasons Dany just sits around? I don't see it.
They're going to throw a fit when "OMG she has an awesome army and DRAGONS" turns into :yawn:
This is my biggest contention with those two books as well. What really happens during the time line of those two books? Nothing. The only plot line even advancing is the north. Bran's continued education and Jon and Stannis at the wall/attacking Bolton is the only thing moving the plot forward. Arya, Dany, Cersei and Marge, Littlefinger and Sansa, Martells, etc. are all pretty stagnant throughout both books. The last half of ADWD we see everything set up to move fast in the next book, but otherwise it was just Martin putting words to a page to appease his readers. I really wish he would've just stuck with the 5 years gap he originally planned after Swords.
Quite a bit happens.

Cersei and Margaery are imprisoned.

The Faith are rearmed.

Arya begins her training.

Tyrion gets an army.

Dany tries to rule.

Jaime becomes more like Tywin

Sansa becomes more of a savvy player.

There may be another claim to the throne by a Targaryen.

Dany will have support in Westeros by the Martells.

The only plot thread that really didn't have anything important happen was Brienne's. She may or may not kill/capture Jaime.


If all of that happened in 1 book, it would've been a great read. And it still would've been less than what happened in Swords. Don't get me wrong, I love the series. Still is my favorite series of all time, but the last 2 books were much slower than the first 3.
 
Crows and dragons are no slower than Kings. I'd argue that but for the Blackwater chapters and some cool #### in the house of the undying (which was cut from the show) Kings is worse than them both.

 
I was an early reader and waited for both Crows and Dragons but I have since done a couple of rereads straight through. My beefs:

Up until Crows, the plot was fast moving and exciting. Crows was like putting two feet on the brake. There are huge portions of those books which would have been better off omitted or signifigantly truncated. We have Brienne looking for Sansa when the reader knows where Sansa is and knows Brienne isn't going to find her. We have the Martell fool's errand which predictably ends in disaster and doesn't move the plot. Finally, Dany is basically in the exact same position she was at the end of Swords until the last 50 pages of Dragons.They aren't terrible books, but instead of two 1000 page books, it should have been one 1200 page book. I feel like this was easier to get away with in print than it will be on the show. Do you think non-book readers are going to keep interest in the show if the next 4 seasons Dany just sits around? I don't see it.
They're going to throw a fit when "OMG she has an awesome army and DRAGONS" turns into :yawn:
This is my biggest contention with those two books as well. What really happens during the time line of those two books? Nothing. The only plot line even advancing is the north. Bran's continued education and Jon and Stannis at the wall/attacking Bolton is the only thing moving the plot forward. Arya, Dany, Cersei and Marge, Littlefinger and Sansa, Martells, etc. are all pretty stagnant throughout both books. The last half of ADWD we see everything set up to move fast in the next book, but otherwise it was just Martin putting words to a page to appease his readers. I really wish he would've just stuck with the 5 years gap he originally planned after Swords.
Quite a bit happens.Cersei and Margaery are imprisoned.The Faith are rearmed.Arya begins her training.Tyrion gets an army.Dany tries to rule.Jaime becomes more like TywinSansa becomes more of a savvy player.There may be another claim to the throne by a Targaryen.Dany will have support in Westeros by the Martells. The only plot thread that really didn't have anything important happen was Brienne's. She may or may not kill/capture Jaime.


If all of that happened in 1 book, it would've been a great read. And it still would've been less than what happened in Swords. Don't get me wrong, I love the series. Still is my favorite series of all time, but the last 2 books were much slower than the first 3.

I think the potential problem with the TV seasons of books 4 and 5 are that:

there's such an overhaul of the characters that have more or less driven the narrative of the first three seasons. Losing Tywin, Tyrion, Robb, Cat, Joffery...that's a lot. Tommen ain't exactly going to cut it as a good TV character. Same with the group Cat leads. You're pushing major TV time to people such as Bolton, Stannis, Sam, Brienne and the Martells.......that's a lot for a TV viewership to accept.At the very least; Tyrion isn't going to dissappear for an entire television season; they'll blend and expand his storyline so that its less of a shock to the casual viewer when just about everyone they've grown accustomed to seeing is gone
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Has there been any talk of the show taking a year or two off Sopranos style? I don't see any way around it, I think we'll be lucky to get another book this decade.

 
Martin has about 4.5 years to pound out 2-3 books to finish it all up. I could see there bring a 1-2 year hiatus before the seventh (and hopefully final) book comes out.

Next season is still book 3. Crows and Dragons is at least 2, if not 3 seasons. They can take their time, perhaps on purpose for Martin, to get into newer characters etc. there's plenty of material.

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top