How do you currently rank the rookie RBs? (1 Viewer)

[eoMMan]

Assume PPR...

Very good crop this year but Fournette's toe injury worries me and that offense in Jacksonville could be rough. Had to move him down...

1. Cook

2. Mccaffrey 

3. Fournette 

4. Mixon

 

[BobbyLayne]

Assume PPR...

Very good crop this year but Fournette's toe injury worries me and that offense in Jacksonville could be rough. Had to move him down...

1. Cook

2. Mccaffrey 

3. Fournette 

4. Mixon

We doing a new one daily on this?

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/758884-whats-yours-top-10-rookie-ranking-after-week-2-of-preseason/

OK, guess that one was all rookies, just had the RBs as the consensus top 4.

Like Cook's situation a lot; might lose some RZ work to Murray but he's a good all around back. But CMC looks really special. I actually like Mixon better than Fournette as Gio is not the same guy and Hill looks very average. The Jags are going to give him volume but he's not much of a receiving threat, right? 

 

[Dr. Octopus]

We doing a new one daily on this?

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/758884-whats-yours-top-10-rookie-ranking-after-week-2-of-preseason/

OK, guess that one was all rookies, just had the RBs as the consensus top 4.

Like Cook's situation a lot; might lose some RZ work to Murray but he's a good all around back. But CMC looks really special. I actually like Mixon better than Fournette as Gio is not the same guy and Hill looks very average. The Jags are going to give him volume but he's not much of a receiving threat, right? 

and there was another a few days before that.

 

[eoMMan]

We doing a new one daily on this?

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/758884-whats-yours-top-10-rookie-ranking-after-week-2-of-preseason/

OK, guess that one was all rookies, just had the RBs as the consensus top 4.

Like Cook's situation a lot; might lose some RZ work to Murray but he's a good all around back. But CMC looks really special. I actually like Mixon better than Fournette as Gio is not the same guy and Hill looks very average. The Jags are going to give him volume but he's not much of a receiving threat, right? 

I don't spend much time in the Shark Pool but I see that thread is for non-ppr.

The Shark Pool needs more activity anyway...

 

[Jed]

Assume PPR...

Very good crop this year but Fournette's toe injury worries me and that offense in Jacksonville could be rough. Had to move him down...

1. Cook

2. Mccaffrey 

3. Fournette 

4. Mixon

For redraft PPR I would agree with this ranking. There might be a big gap between 1 and 2? Hard to count on Carolina to make sure they get it in CMC's hands.

 

[Skoo]

Thanks for making the thread, was just going to do the same but for standard.

I play in a league where we keep 2 Vets and 1 Rookie each year, have been planning on taking Fournette with my first pick if he's there but the more I hear the less excited I am. I like what I see out of McCaffery but not sure how to feel about him in standard scoring. Same goes for Cook.

 

[shadyridr]

Assume PPR...

Very good crop this year but Fournette's toe injury worries me and that offense in Jacksonville could be rough. Had to move him down...

1. Cook

2. Mccaffrey 

3. Fournette 

4. Mixon

I agree with your ranking

 

[enyce]

i've seen the college stats and the college tape, the combine, and the preseason tape.  CMC looks good but coming out of college Reggie Bush received similar hype no?