What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

How Many Games Will McNabb Miss in 2007? (1 Viewer)

In 2007

  • None

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • 1-2

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • 3-4

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • 5-6

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • 7-8

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • More than 8

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Total voters
    0
He should be on everyone's do not draft list:

1) He can't stay healthy

2) He's got nobody to throw to

3) Eagles have three pretty good RB's and will be running a LOT more this year

 
H.K. said:
He should be on everyone's do not draft list:1) He can't stay healthy2) He's got nobody to throw to3) Eagles have three pretty good RB's and will be running a LOT more this year
Click to expand...
I couldn't disagree more on every point. Any player is susceptible to the same type of injuries McNabb has experienced. He's as tough as they come, finishing one game with a broken foot. Unless it's a major injury, he's playing...For point 2, he has plenty of receiving options - Brian Westbrook, Kevin Curtis (looked excellent during camp), Reggie Brown and LJ Smith (will start on opening day).On #3, I have no idea where you came up with this one - if anything, the team will throw more than it has in the past. Reid is definitely a "throw 1st" coach and has to constantly temper his desire to throw pretty much every single snap of the ball. McNabb looks like he'll be back this year - your mistake (and someone else's gain) for passing him up...
 
H.K. said:
He should be on everyone's do not draft list:1) He can't stay healthy2) He's got nobody to throw to3) Eagles have three pretty good RB's and will be running a LOT more this year
Click to expand...
who'd he have to throw to last year? Yet as a team they still threw for over 4000 yards.
 
I think they should change the text for :no: from '.fishing: to :HK:.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
He will miss the last 2 games of the post-season. Won't be due to injury just that is as far as he and Westbrook will be able to carry the team.

 
hi risk, hi reward. His APG is higher then Mannings when healthy!

To me quite a value as 6th ot 7th QB on board. I am rideing him

heavy this year and nice to see half the voters agree with me he will

last the season!

 
High percentage of "None" votes probably due to vote skew. McNabb owners more likely to have wishful thinking and have interest in the thread/vote. 6 games out is a lock, IMO.

 
H.K. said:
He should be on everyone's do not draft list:1) He can't stay healthy2) He's got nobody to throw to3) Eagles have three pretty good RB's and will be running a LOT more this year
Click to expand...
Over the last couple of years he's been the #1 QB on a points per game basis. Yeah, you can argue injuries sure. But "do not draft"? That's laughable.For the record I voted "none".
 
He should be on everyone's do draft list:

1) He scored the highest PPG of any QB last year

2) He's got a high-powered offense that made Jeff Garcia look like Joe Montana

3) Eagles have three pretty good RB's that will open up the passing game

 
PumpusX said:
High percentage of "None" votes probably due to vote skew. McNabb owners more likely to have wishful thinking and have interest in the thread/vote. 6 games out is a lock, IMO.
Click to expand...
Or those votes are from people that already realized that he has had several flukey injuries, and therefore picked him up as the 8th or 9th QB off the board.
 
H.K. said:
He should be on everyone's do not draft list:1) He can't stay healthy2) He's got nobody to throw to3) Eagles have three pretty good RB's and will be running a LOT more this year
Click to expand...
Are you ever right about anything?Last years injury was a freak injury.
 
getting mcnabb and an average backup qb will still likely end up as one of the 3 highest points per game average from the qb positin in most leagues

 
CiscoKid said:
H.K. said:
He should be on everyone's do not draft list:

1) He can't stay healthy

2) He's got nobody to throw to

3) Eagles have three pretty good RB's and will be running a LOT more this year
Click to expand...
I couldn't disagree more on every point. Any player is susceptible to the same type of injuries McNabb has experienced. He's as tough as they come, finishing one game with a broken foot. Unless it's a major injury, he's playing...For point 2, he has plenty of receiving options - Brian Westbrook, Kevin Curtis (looked excellent during camp), Reggie Brown and LJ Smith (will start on opening day).

On #3, I have no idea where you came up with this one - if anything, the team will throw more than it has in the past. Reid is definitely a "throw 1st" coach and has to constantly temper his desire to throw pretty much every single snap of the ball.

McNabb looks like he'll be back this year - your mistake (and someone else's gain) for passing him up...
Click to expand...
McNabb is tough? :thumbup: really??...hmm..maybe thats why he's failed to complete a full 16-game schedule, 3 times out of the past 5 years?!? every single injury McNabb has had, has been 'major'. Sans T.o. , Mcnabb is really just an avg QB..he's also a flake.

he has not been the same Qb since taking that shot to the head in the SB..outside of the T.O. season, he's thrown for 21 or more TD's only twice in a season. His lifetime comp % is at 58.2%. yawn.

Now, his biggest weapon , his legs, have abandoned him, he is no longer the running threat he used to be, and he's not a particularly good pocket passer..

the guy is a piece of glass..he's on the wrong side of 30. Obviously,the Eagles felt it important enough to take Kolb in round two, because of the inconsistencies in McNabb's ability to play every week..

you can use all the bravado terms you wish in regards to McNabb,the fact is, the guy cannot play a full 16 game schedule,

he's always nicked up, and without T.O., he's an Average Joe QB.

oh, and did I mention he's a flake?

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I expect him to finish 9-10 games before getting knocked out by some 'fluke' major injury as per the course.

 
nygiants56 said:
CiscoKid said:
H.K. said:
He should be on everyone's do not draft list:

1) He can't stay healthy

2) He's got nobody to throw to

3) Eagles have three pretty good RB's and will be running a LOT more this year
Click to expand...
I couldn't disagree more on every point. Any player is susceptible to the same type of injuries McNabb has experienced. He's as tough as they come, finishing one game with a broken foot. Unless it's a major injury, he's playing...For point 2, he has plenty of receiving options - Brian Westbrook, Kevin Curtis (looked excellent during camp), Reggie Brown and LJ Smith (will start on opening day).

On #3, I have no idea where you came up with this one - if anything, the team will throw more than it has in the past. Reid is definitely a "throw 1st" coach and has to constantly temper his desire to throw pretty much every single snap of the ball.

McNabb looks like he'll be back this year - your mistake (and someone else's gain) for passing him up...
Click to expand...
McNabb is tough? :popcorn: really??...hmm..maybe thats why he's failed to complete a full 16-game schedule, 3 times out of the past 5 years?!? every single injury McNabb has had, has been 'major'. Sans T.o. , Mcnabb is really just an avg QB..he's also a flake.

he has not been the same Qb since taking that shot to the head in the SB..outside of the T.O. season, he's thrown for 21 or more TD's only twice in a season. His lifetime comp % is at 58.2%. yawn.

Now, his biggest weapon , his legs, have abandoned him, he is no longer the running threat he used to be, and he's not a particularly good pocket passer..

the guy is a piece of glass..he's on the wrong side of 30. Obviously,the Eagles felt it important enough to take Kolb in round two, because of the inconsistencies in McNabb's ability to play every week..

you can use all the bravado terms you wish in regards to McNabb,the fact is, the guy cannot play a full 16 game schedule,

he's always nicked up, and without T.O., he's an Average Joe QB.

oh, and did I mention he's a flake?
Click to expand...
last years #1 QB in terms of ppg?call him glass, that's fine and a defendable position; arguing he does not have skills and is not a premeir QB (even w/o TO) when healthy is flat out wrong.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Joe Bryant
  • Poll Poll
Las Vegas Setting Lines - What they think will happen vs Equal bets on both sides
Replies
42
Views
888
Leroy Hoard
Leroy Hoard
JohnnyU
Are these Risky players a sell?
2
Replies
74
Views
2K
Hot Sauce Guy
Hot Sauce Guy
JohnnyU
Are you a cliff dweller in Dynasty? A Dynasty Locust?
Replies
36
Views
487
spurs44
S

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 0, guests: 1)
Back
Top