How would you rank these RBs? (1 Viewer)

[davidwb]

FBGs has them right next to each other in their rest-of-the-season rankings. What do you think? Is one of these guys likely to outperform the other two? Is one of them likely to underform the other two? Would your rankings be different in PPR vs non-PPR? What about their playoff schedules:

Bradshaw: @Minn, Phi, @GB

Hillis: @Buf, @Cin, Bal

McCoy: @Dal, @NYG, Min

How would you rank them, and is there a meaningful difference between them?

My rankings: Bradshaw, McCoy, Hillis -- with Bradshaw and McCoy pretty close to each other in value.

 

[bobfreakinvilla]

I am in a 1 point per 5 receptions league and I would rank them the same way.

 

[Hugonel]

So hard to start Bradshaw over McCoy right now due to Jacobs stealing carries and the goal line. But that's the only reason I ever start McCoy over Bradshaw.

 

[Resident A]

I'd take Hillis over either Bradshaw Or McCoy.

 

[Pickle Rody]

McCoy

Hillis

Bradshaw

edit: To reply to post #7 by the OP, I think they are all pretty closely ranked together in all of my varying leagues, so having them bunched together in the rankings here seems appropriate. I'm okay with FBG's order of rank, so I guess I view the players values similarly to FBG, even though my order of rank is different.

 

[The Redbeard]

I rate them as a ACF question.

 

[davidwb]

I rate them as a ACF question.

It could be, but it's not. It would be great if I could actually have all 3 of these RBs, but hard to do in practice. I noticed that they were ranked together with FBGs -- and with two other good pay FFB services. Didn't see any other grouping of 3 that were this close (not even the top 3 -- who is #3?). Hence the question. Do the sharks here view their values similarly to the "professionals" who run the good FFB sites?

 

[plyka]

FBGs has them right next to each other in their rest-of-the-season rankings. What do you think? Is one of these guys likely to outperform the other two? Is one of them likely to underform the other two? Would your rankings be different in PPR vs non-PPR? What about their playoff schedules:Bradshaw: @Minn, Phi, @GBHillis: @Buf, @Cin, BalMcCoy: @Dal, @NYG, MinHow would you rank them, and is there a meaningful difference between them?My rankings: Bradshaw, McCoy, Hillis -- with Bradshaw and McCoy pretty close to each other in value.

It's no doubt that their relative values are the same or around the same area. The first question should be dynasty format or redraft? In dynasty i think Mccoy flies far ahead of the other 2. In redraft it is far closer. I would probably take Mccoy still, but that's just because i like watching him play.In PPR redraft:Mccoy, Hillis, BradshawNon-ppr redraft:Mccoy, bradshaw, HillisAlthough i do have a disease of continuously undervaluing Bradshaw, I did take Celek over him in my ppr keeper league with a draft pick in the 80's! Horrible decision.

 

[bweiser]

McCoy

Bradshaw

Hillis

I own Bradshaw and would trade him so quick it would make your head spin if I could get McCoy. Just isn't happening.

 

[Chaka]

By height.

 

[ttea]

Too much Bradshaw kool aid. Between Nicks and Jacobs, his TDs will come sparingly. And this is coming from a Bradshaw supporter.

I rank them McCoy, Hillis, Bradshaw.

Hell I'd rank Hillis and McCoy 1a and 1b if Cleveland's schedule didn't suck so bad.

 

[Iwannabeacowboybaby!]

Non PPR

Bradshaw

Hillis

McCoy

PPR

McCoy

Bradshaw

Hillis