If Feeley continues this... (1 Viewer)

[beaglemac]

So if McNabb is healthy next week, does Feeley start for the Eagles after keeping the Eagles in/winning this game?

McNabb has been avg, but Feeley looks good. Does he need to win? Just keep it up? Or no chance in Hell?

 

[3C's]

No. But McNabb might not be totally healthy next week.

 

[nashua55]

Watching this game I was wondering what D. Mcnabb is thinking. Too me this might be the worst case situation for the guy.Through out the season the fans have been getting on Mcnabb for his very inconsistent play. With the performance the Eagles passing game is displaying, I can only imagine what the Philly fans are going to be saying on radio in the morning on WIP610.

 

[-OZ-]

They may not rush McNabb back.

They may feel more comfortable losing McNabb in the off-season.

But, I don't see McNabb sitting the rest of the year.

 

[hammerva]

If I was McNabb right now I would just pack my bags and head to the Bears or Vikings because there is no way in hell people in Philly want to see #5 in the starting lineup now. Even if I think this Feely game is one of those career games that won't happen that much, to Eagles fans right now this is better than everything McNabb has done for 5 years.

 

[Chickenskin]

Reid has made QB's look good - Feeley, McNabb, Garcia.

I like McNabb and he has won a lot of games and put up great stats.

Question is... how good would have McNabb been in Miami? As bad as Feeley?

 

[nashua55]

Reid has made QB's look good - Feeley, McNabb, Garcia.I like McNabb and he has won a lot of games and put up great stats. Question is... how good would have McNabb been in Miami? As bad as Feeley?

Very good point, but I would give Garcia a pass because he has played well for two other teams. It is pretty bad that Donnie Mac is being compared to a 2nd string QB. Wow, how the mighty have fallen.

 

[beaglemac]

Reid has made QB's look good - Feeley, McNabb, Garcia.I like McNabb and he has won a lot of games and put up great stats. Question is... how good would have McNabb been in Miami? As bad as Feeley?

Very good point, but I would give Garcia a pass because he has played well for two other teams. It is pretty bad that Donnie Mac is being compared to a 2nd string QB. Wow, how the mighty have fallen.

I think he has more talent, but I know how the city seems to put a lot of preasure on him, and would love a change. Or at least that is the impression I get.

 

[AndersonToEdwards]

Yes.

/thread

 

[Chickenskin]

Reid has made QB's look good - Feeley, McNabb, Garcia.I like McNabb and he has won a lot of games and put up great stats. Question is... how good would have McNabb been in Miami? As bad as Feeley?

Very good point, but I would give Garcia a pass because he has played well for two other teams. It is pretty bad that Donnie Mac is being compared to a 2nd string QB. Wow, how the mighty have fallen.

I just hope McNabb would do well with another team. I am not comparing McNabb to Culpepper, but I always thought Culpepper was only "great" because of Moss & Carter. It would be interesting to see how well McNabb could do on a team like Chicago.

 

[renesauz]

NO

 

[coolnerd]

Think we have seen the extended play version of AJ Feely. Should not even be a legitimate thought.

 

[TCFF]

The Eagles are a better team when someone other than McNabb is under center. For whatever reason, at this point in his career in Philly, McNabb has no heart and the team does not rally around him. While I don't think it will happen, Philly wins more games this year if McNabb rides the pine.

 

[Fantaholic]

He really needs to get out of Philly. He will be ripped on the airwaves tomorrow. Leave it to Feely to play his best game of his career against the Patriots in Foxboro in his only start of the year. The Philly fans will read too far into Feely's performance tonight and Mcnabb will pay dearly again.