If Peyton Manning were putting up #s like Brady this year.. (1 Viewer)

[The Jerk]

Nice try at parsing, but even in this effort you failed. In that same time frame, both QBs have one SB win. Obviously he had two before, but that still means that in the past 3+ seasons, the "winning" angle has been virtually identical, with a slight edge to Peyton. If Brady is so clearly superior, one would think he would have a significant edge from any and all perspectives.

I failed? But you can start the calendar whenever you choose? Yeah, lets just ignore the first two Super Bowls because it doesn't work out for your argument.You are becoming a bigger joke every time you post.

Once again, nice try. I notice that you are only capable of responding to very small parts of my posts. I freely admitted starting at a specific point in time, and my point was to show that in the past 3+ years there is virtually no difference between the two QBs in W/L record. Since you couldn't figure it out for yourself, the point was to ask did Peyton get that much better, or did the team around him, especially the defense, improve? As soon as Peyton did not need to do it all himself, the Colts record improved significantly, and especially in big games. It appears that you are incapable of looking beyond the QB position in terms of understanding what wins and loses football games. Let's try this one again. Although I suspect you will choose not to address it, these are the facts concerning the first Patriot Super Bowl run. And I'll expand it to include all three playoff games. How many TD drives did the fabulous Tom Brady engineer in the AFC divisional playoff, AFC championship game and SB XXXVI? Two. Combined. In over 150 minutes of game time.How many TD drives did Drew Bledsoe lead in roughly 35 minutes of game time? One.How many TDs were scored by defense and special teams in those three games? Three.Yeah. Those wins were all about Tom Brady.