What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

If You Were Dungy, Would You Have Ever Kicked To Hester? (1 Viewer)

If You Were Dungy, Would You Have Ever Kicked To Hester?

  • I would have kicked to Hester, and kept kicking to him

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I would have kicked to Hester, but changed after the first TD and kicked away

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I would have kicked away from Hester from the start

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    0

Joe Bryant

Guide
Staff
Obviously, they wanted to challenge Hester to start. It only took a few seconds for them to realize a different course was better.

Would that have been how you played it?

Or would you have started the game off kicking away from him?

Thoughts?

J

 
I think Dungy made the right call. It was apparent early that even with good field position the Bears offense was ineffective.

 
I also thought it was good coaching on his part. He gave his special teams a chance. They blew it. So he took the game away from the special teams as much as he possibly could and put it in the hands of his offense and defense.

 
I agree with the guys on Mike and Mike this morning that once they saw what they were dealing with in Grossman, they didn't fear giving the poor field position.

I think if it were me, I probably would have played it like Dungy did. Although I would have strongly considered not kicking to him even from the start. Hester is scary good.

J

 
The Bears had a better chance of scoring with Hester than they did with Grossman starting at midfield.

No-brainer for the Colts, especially after the opening kickoff.

 
I don't see why any team ever kicks to the returner. Coffin corner on punts down? Kickoff out of the endzone down (this one is really strange; these kickers can put it through the uprights in college from the 35 = 80+yds, yet back 'em up 5yds to the 30 in the pros and they barely reach the goalline = 70yds :shrug: )?

 
The first return should make absolutely no difference to your strategy, unless you haven't watched any game film all year. The likelihood of a big return on subsequent kicks does not increase.

 
Your kicker makes his best kickoff and you take your chances - no problem with that....BUT I still don't understand why they did not have one of their best open field tacklers hang back with the kicker - most of the time the plays are made by the first five guys downfield - why not an insurance tackler waiting to take a better look as the return develops?

 
I don't see why any team ever kicks to the returner. Coffin corner on punts down? Kickoff out of the endzone down (this one is really strange; these kickers can put it through the uprights in college from the 35 = 80+yds, yet back 'em up 5yds to the 30 in the pros and they barely reach the goalline = 70yds :headbang: )?
this is because of the ball. Isnt the college FG record longer than the pros?If i was the colts i would have conceded the kickoff at the 40 every time. I would have kicked it out of bounds. They couldnt stop NE return game. Why would they stop the bears?

FYI i said it right from the get go, not after the fact.

 
I don't see why any team ever kicks to the returner. Coffin corner on punts down? Kickoff out of the endzone down (this one is really strange; these kickers can put it through the uprights in college from the 35 = 80+yds, yet back 'em up 5yds to the 30 in the pros and they barely reach the goalline = 70yds :D )?
this is because of the ball. Isnt the college FG record longer than the pros?

If i was the colts i would have conceded the kickoff at the 40 every time. I would have kicked it out of bounds. They couldnt stop NE return game. Why would they stop the bears?

FYI i said it right from the get go, not after the fact.
Not joking, I am being serious.If you would do this, would you consider on side kick everytime?

At least you get a shot a recovering the ball.

out of bounds= ball at the

CHI 40

Depending on the onside kick ball will most likely be around midfield.

 
I don't see why any team ever kicks to the returner. Coffin corner on punts down? Kickoff out of the endzone down (this one is really strange; these kickers can put it through the uprights in college from the 35 = 80+yds, yet back 'em up 5yds to the 30 in the pros and they barely reach the goalline = 70yds :hangover: )?
this is because of the ball. Isnt the college FG record longer than the pros?

If i was the colts i would have conceded the kickoff at the 40 every time. I would have kicked it out of bounds. They couldnt stop NE return game. Why would they stop the bears?

FYI i said it right from the get go, not after the fact.
Not joking, I am being serious.If you would do this, would you consider on side kick everytime?

At least you get a shot a recovering the ball.

out of bounds= ball at the

CHI 40

Depending on the onside kick ball will most likely be around midfield.
That is a very interesting thought. That is a big swing though. Give it to them at the 40 and they have to move the ball quite a bit to get into FG range. Give it to them at the other 40 and they just need one first down.
 
I agree with the guys on Mike and Mike this morning that once they saw what they were dealing with in Grossman, they didn't fear giving the poor field position.I think if it were me, I probably would have played it like Dungy did. Although I would have strongly considered not kicking to him even from the start. Hester is scary good.J
If you watched the Patriots game. The Colts coverage was horrible, including punts, and that was not going against the best return man in the NFL. I missed the kickoff, but got downstairs in time for the replay after my wife yelled. I remember after the Wayne TD, that I told my wife that they should just squib kick to the up backs. They did and got a fumble out of it.I voted that they should have gone squib kicks from the start, because I believed that the Colts defense would do exactly what they did, stop the Bears offense. The Colts defense is built to stop the big play and to be honest, the only thing that I think Grossman has done well this year was the big play. Until 7 minutes left in the game, the Bears had 1 drive of more than 20 yards, and 52 of those 57 yards were on one play. Up until 7 minutes to play, the Colts had 5 drives of 47-80 yards.It seemed like his huge games early in the season were long bombs to Berrian. I didn't think that Grossman could sustain drives and he couldn't. I think yesterday's game is a stark example of the difference between a franchise type QB that can do what needs to be done versus a QB that can't alter their style of play.If I were the Bears, I would be working on grooming a franchise type QB, because they need one. Maybe Grossman improves, but he has been in the league 4 years. In fact even though people say that this was his first starting year, he has played in more games than Philip Rivers and I don't think anyone is questioning Rivers as the future QB in San Diego.
 
I don't see why any team ever kicks to the returner. Coffin corner on punts down? Kickoff out of the endzone down (this one is really strange; these kickers can put it through the uprights in college from the 35 = 80+yds, yet back 'em up 5yds to the 30 in the pros and they barely reach the goalline = 70yds :hangover: )?
this is because of the ball. Isnt the college FG record longer than the pros?

If i was the colts i would have conceded the kickoff at the 40 every time. I would have kicked it out of bounds. They couldnt stop NE return game. Why would they stop the bears?

FYI i said it right from the get go, not after the fact.
Not joking, I am being serious.If you would do this, would you consider on side kick everytime?

At least you get a shot a recovering the ball.

out of bounds= ball at the

CHI 40

Depending on the onside kick ball will most likely be around midfield.
That is a very interesting thought. That is a big swing though. Give it to them at the 40 and they have to move the ball quite a bit to get into FG range. Give it to them at the other 40 and they just need one first down.
I know, but if you give up 1 or 2 FG's, you also have the other hand where you can get the ball in great position.

 
I don't see why any team ever kicks to the returner. Coffin corner on punts down? Kickoff out of the endzone down (this one is really strange; these kickers can put it through the uprights in college from the 35 = 80+yds, yet back 'em up 5yds to the 30 in the pros and they barely reach the goalline = 70yds :hangover: )?
this is because of the ball. Isnt the college FG record longer than the pros?

If i was the colts i would have conceded the kickoff at the 40 every time. I would have kicked it out of bounds. They couldnt stop NE return game. Why would they stop the bears?

FYI i said it right from the get go, not after the fact.
Not joking, I am being serious.If you would do this, would you consider on side kick everytime?

At least you get a shot a recovering the ball.

out of bounds= ball at the

CHI 40

Depending on the onside kick ball will most likely be around midfield.
No this is just silly. The Bears offense was bad but they're not that bad. Grossman looked ok at times but seemed to struggle with the deep ball (which from my understanding is the Bears biggest strength on offense). You give the ball to the Bears at your own 40 or midfield, Grossman (or any NFL qb) will have a field day. The Colts played it right.....
 
I don't see why any team ever kicks to the returner. Coffin corner on punts down? Kickoff out of the endzone down (this one is really strange; these kickers can put it through the uprights in college from the 35 = 80+yds, yet back 'em up 5yds to the 30 in the pros and they barely reach the goalline = 70yds :wub: )?
this is because of the ball. Isnt the college FG record longer than the pros?

If i was the colts i would have conceded the kickoff at the 40 every time. I would have kicked it out of bounds. They couldnt stop NE return game. Why would they stop the bears?

FYI i said it right from the get go, not after the fact.
Not joking, I am being serious.If you would do this, would you consider on side kick everytime?

At least you get a shot a recovering the ball.

out of bounds= ball at the

CHI 40

Depending on the onside kick ball will most likely be around midfield.
That is a very interesting thought. That is a big swing though. Give it to them at the 40 and they have to move the ball quite a bit to get into FG range. Give it to them at the other 40 and they just need one first down.
I know, but if you give up 1 or 2 FG's, you also have the other hand where you can get the ball in great position.
Yeah but the Colts were moving the ball just fine against the Bears. They didn't need great field position to score. Why give the Bears any chance at all?
 
They had two weeks to get their special teams ready for Hester. Under that circumstance no question I kick to him. After the return I do not repeat the mistake as two weeks was obviously not enough. I fire the special teams coach on the spot, and I start squibing that kick through the water just as they did since it was evident that the Bears had no offense.

 
Told the wife I would have angle kicked it to the sidelines. If it goes out of bounds :lmao: they start at the 40..

Most of the squib kicks ended up there or closer to the 50 any ways.

I know there was the one fumble recovery so that helped the odds a bit, but I still would have just said: "Fine Rexy, you get the ball at the 40, but Hester is NOT going to be the game breaker".

I LOVED how the Colts must have had someone spoting for the rest of the kickoffs. If hester was up, they kicked it deep. If he was deep they squibbed it. :rolleyes:

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Told the wife I would have angle kicked it to the sidelines. If it goes out of bounds :lmao: they start at the 40..

Most of the squib kicks ended up there or closer to the 50 any ways.

I know there was the one fumble recovery so that helped the odds a bit, but I still would have just said: "Fine Rexy, you get the ball at the 40, but Hester is NOT going to be the game breaker".

I LOVED how the Colts must have had someone spoting for the rest of the kickoffs. If hester was up, they kicked it deep. If he was deep they squibbed it. :bag:
I saw that one time as CBS zoomed in on Hester as an up back and they booted it deep. I assume that the Colts probably had it in their game plan to squib kicks and probably practiced it just because they definitely noticed when the Bears moved Hester.If I am GB, Minny or Detroit, I am working hard this off season to find a kick off specialist. I think if you take Hester out of play on kickoffs, that you probably have a real good chance of really limiting Chicago's offense. Not saying that Chicago won't be in the playoffs next year, but I think it would be worth the effort. Even when the Colts tried to kick it deep, it didn't go anywhere near the end zone.

 
Considering the weather, I would have squibbed it whenever it was reasonable to do so. Even so, Hester had difficulty fielding many kicks throughout the playoffs, so kicking to him was a gamble, but not necessarily a bad one.

Interesting stat: This was the 8th time that a kickoff was returned for a TD in the Super Bowl. The record of the teams that did so? 1-7.

 
I think Dungy played it right. Once he determined the Bears offense wasn't a serious threat he started to squib kick it. I think if Grossman was even playing average giving the ball over on the 40 every kickoff would have been more risky than kicking it to Hester.

 
I think Dungy played it right. Once he determined the Bears offense wasn't a serious threat he started to squib kick it. I think if Grossman was even playing average giving the ball over on the 40 every kickoff would have been more risky than kicking it to Hester.
Dungy's entire gameplan on offense and special teams was extremely conservative. I questioned a few of his calls (not going for it on 4th down at the Bears 36 yd line, the first squib kick, not going for the fg to completely put the game away at the end) but they turned out to be brilliant coaching. He had absolutely no fear in the Bears offense and limited the probability of losing on a fluke play. He did exactly what a good coach is supposed to do.
 
Joe,

Good question! I said in several posts prior to the game that I would have kicked every kick out of bounds! My reason was that I'd rather give them the ball at the 40 and take my chances with Rex, than giving Hester the chance to make a game-changing run.

I'm glad the Colts overcame the opening kickoff, but I was right in my opinion. That game could have been decided after 10 seconds had the Bears had a competent QB.

 
Considering the weather, I would have squibbed it whenever it was reasonable to do so. Even so, Hester had difficulty fielding many kicks throughout the playoffs, so kicking to him was a gamble, but not necessarily a bad one.Interesting stat: This was the 8th time that a kickoff was returned for a TD in the Super Bowl. The record of the teams that did so? 1-7.
Funny, because if you think about it, that makes sense to me.Hester's TD on the OPENING kickoff was the first ever. That means every other one was later on in the game.Statistics would say that the team receiving more kickoffs has a greater chance to return one for a TD. Well guess which team would receive more kickoffs during a game? The one who has been scored upon more, i.e. the losing team. Also, it would mean one less drive for the offense, which means potentially tiring out the defense more (see Bears 2/4/07). It may be a little surprising that the record is 1-7, but at best I would expect it to be a losing record of say 3-5 or 2-6, so 1-7 isn't too far off. If it were 4-4 or better, then that would be interesting because it would almost say that the kick return for a TD had a bigger psychological impact overriding the expected.
 
This thread is pretty useless coming AFTER the SB.

They had coverage issues against the Pats. They practiced it hard for 2 weeks. No team that faced the Bears squib kicked it all game. You try to kick away from him, and do your best.

Do we really need a thread analyzing Dungy's coaching? He won the SB. Get over it already.

 
Considering the weather, I would have squibbed it whenever it was reasonable to do so. Even so, Hester had difficulty fielding many kicks throughout the playoffs, so kicking to him was a gamble, but not necessarily a bad one.Interesting stat: This was the 8th time that a kickoff was returned for a TD in the Super Bowl. The record of the teams that did so? 1-7.
Jermaine Lewis and Desmond Howard both returned kickoffs for TDs. Off the top of my head, I only remember Tim Dwight (ATL), Hester and Ron Dixon doing it, so that's 2-3.
 
I agree with Dungy's strategy. Show confidence in your coverage teams and give them a chance until you are burned by it. Unfortunately for the Colts, he was burned by it on the opening kickoff.

Then, Dungy made the smart coaching strategy and kicked away from Hester the rest of the game. An excellent adjustment by Dungy IMO.

 
Joe,Good question! I said in several posts prior to the game that I would have kicked every kick out of bounds! My reason was that I'd rather give them the ball at the 40 and take my chances with Rex, than giving Hester the chance to make a game-changing run.I'm glad the Colts overcame the opening kickoff, but I was right in my opinion. That game could have been decided after 10 seconds had the Bears had a competent QB.
Hi pizza,It looks like it only took Tony Dungy about 15 seconds to start agreeing with you there. :confused:J
 
What's so frustrating for Bears fans is by this point, we were expecting some squib kicks. It didn't look like the Bears were at all.

Gabe Reed fumble :confused:

Why don't they always have Devin at the goal line and Davis at the 30? If they don't want to do that, and you're going to have tight ends and linebackers take the kick at the 30, why not have a play in mind to lateral the ball back to Devin? Is there not enough time to do that?

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I would have kicked to him and kept on kicking to him. They were lucky not to get burned by the field position they were giving. Hester is phenominal, but the likelihood of him returning multiple kicks in one game are not good.

 
The first return should make absolutely no difference to your strategy, unless you haven't watched any game film all year. The likelihood of a big return on subsequent kicks does not increase.
Maybe not, but it is still true that if you kick to him there is still a chance he could return it, and if you don't kick to him, there is no chance he can return it.
 
The first return should make absolutely no difference to your strategy, unless you haven't watched any game film all year. The likelihood of a big return on subsequent kicks does not increase.
Maybe not, but it is still true that if you kick to him there is still a chance he could return it, and if you don't kick to him, there is no chance he can return it.
Yes, but the chance isn't any different after he returned one; if you believe the chance of him returning it is high enough that you want to avoid it, you should know that before the game and never kick to him. If you don't believe the chances are high enough, you should know that before the game and kick to him all game.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top