Im starting _________ over _________ week 8 (1 Viewer)

[AZhardballz]

Thinkin bout benchin him for Droughns but can't pull the trigger.

 

[BustedKnuckles]

There`s a reason guys like Rudi gain 1,500 yards and 12 td`s a season.......never bench your money players.

 

[tmackin1]

Never bench RUDI....

 

[jurrassic]

I am torn on this as well. Currently starting C. Taylor and T. Jones over Rudi, Deshaun, and L Washington.

 

[PlebsforPresident]

Henry over C. Taylor

Coles and Berrian over D. Jackson

 

[The Football Freak]

Kennison over Mason... Playing in KC is a good thing, but now it's a hard decision if Brodie Croyle is starting...

It looks like Huard is starting after warming up and looking good enough.

 

[lord_helmet]

Housh & Walker over Coles, Ward, Branch & A.Bryant

 

[tomarken]

Well here goes.Starting Rivers over Manning - Yes, I think the Denver D is going to come to play, and I just don't see Manning getting it done this week.

I'm doing the same exact thing.

 

[kncks12]

HOrn over Coles (weather concerns me)

and possibly

Leinart over Brady

 

[seahawk 17]

Starting Wallace over Vick and Brees.

Vick wwas hot last week, so he'll be horriable this week. Brees against the Ravens(scary D).

Seattle's run game sucks, they will be playing from behind, and Wallace will pile up passing/running yards today.

 

[NCPanthersFan]

(Wind) Akers go to the waiver wire. Going with Kostkowski for the dome and for a possible close game by NE.

 

[Stingdiddy]

Deuce over Marion Barber III as my RB3. Any thoughts?

 

[redman]

This wind in NY and Philly sounds like it's going to be a major problem for all four QB's. McNabb is hands-down the #1 QB in every fantasy league to date. Do you consider benching him this week, and if so for who?

 

[seahawk 17]

Deuce over Marion Barber III as my RB3. Any thoughts?

Good idea as Deuce should get more carries.

 

[norton17]

This wind in NY and Philly sounds like it's going to be a major problem for all four QB's. McNabb is hands-down the #1 QB in every fantasy league to date. Do you consider benching him this week, and if so for who?

My backups are Brad Johnson vs NE and V.Young vs HOUI'd love to start V.Young to see him tear apart Houston but there is just no way I can

 

[Hoodlumman]

This wind in NY and Philly sounds like it's going to be a major problem for all four QB's. McNabb is hands-down the #1 QB in every fantasy league to date. Do you consider benching him this week, and if so for who?

I think if you have Peyton Manning as your back up, you bench McNabb.Don't be silly.

 

[blenderfrog]

This wind in NY and Philly sounds like it's going to be a major problem for all four QB's. McNabb is hands-down the #1 QB in every fantasy league to date. Do you consider benching him this week, and if so for who?

I don't have him in any league, bu would consider sitting him this week for P Manning. He'll probably get 100 yards and 2 TDs on the ground.

 

[Kiddnets]

have rivers and was toying with the idea of benching McNabb for him but just couldn't do it - guy has been all world!

 

[Dvorak]

Well here goes.Starting Rivers over Manning - Yes, I think the Denver D is going to come to play, and I just don't see Manning getting it done this week.

I'm doing the same exact thing.

I would be #3 on that list.

 

[Mongolian Cow Sour Sour Yogurt]

David Carr over Eli Manning

 

[Thumper]

have rivers and was toying with the idea of benching McNabb for him but just couldn't do it - guy has been all world!

I don't think you guys understand just how windy it is in the northeast today. From Phily up to New England there are consistant cross winds of 25-30 mph. With gusts up to 50 mph in some places.If I had a decent #2 option I would go with it.

 

[shadyridr]

Im keeping McNabb in there instead of Rivers. I also have Brown and Williams in my lineup becuase I have no other choices. So Im probably gonna lose anyway.

 

[redman]

have rivers and was toying with the idea of benching McNabb for him but just couldn't do it - guy has been all world!

I don't think you guys understand just how windy it is in the northeast today. From Phily up to New England there are consistant cross winds of 25-30 mph. With gusts up to 50 mph in some places.

I'm not suggesting that you should categorically replace any of these guys, just pointing out that it's not ridiculous to examine your options.

 

[Dulymus Mudhounds]

I'm starting the Giants D over Baltimore - Giants on fire on D and windy

And

Mushy Muhammed over Cotchery and Toomer - don't like the wind in Cle and NY

 

[WookieBooger]

I am playing Brees over McNabb. Live in Pittsburgh and we had that weather system yesterday.

Nasty winds! Have to go with the gut and start Drew.

 

[The Kansas Comet]

Looks like it will take an act of God to slow McNabb down. I guess he'll just have to run a few in, then.

I would think about sitting him, but my two other QB's are on a bye.

 

[shadyridr]

Starting Reggie Williams over Kennison despite the wind

 

[redman]

Looks like it will take an act of God to slow McNabb down. I guess he'll just have to run a few in, then. I would think about sitting him, but my two other QB's are on a bye.

I'm basically in the same boat. My two alternatives are Romo (@ Carolina) and Walter (vs. Pittsburgh). Romo is the only conceivable replacement, but I just can't bring myself to bench McNabb for Romo in his first start against Peppers and company.

 

[njxbean]

i got favre and im really tempted to put him in over mcnabb...... going back and forth.

 

[Stingdiddy]

Starting Reggie Williams over Kennison despite the wind

I'd probably stick with Eddie if I were you...just my two cents. Huard is starting and that Seattle D is less than average. Like you said, it's going to be windy in Philly and who knows how Garrard is going to look (I actually think he will have a good game). Good luck.

 

[The Big Guy]

i got favre and im really tempted to put him in over mcnabb...... going back and forth.

I have the same dilemma and will stay with McNabb for 2 reasons. First, I always believe in going with who got you there. Secondly, because of McNabb, my team can afford a loss, so see rule #1 again.

 

[Nemesis]

I've got Vick at CINN as my #2....but I heard that winds in Cinn aren't great either. (not that I would be counting on Vick's passing)

 

[Chaz McNulty]

Leon Washington over Steven Jackson.

 

[The_Hoser]

I'm starting Travis Taylor at a flex over D. Stallworth and LenDale White. Am I nuts?

 

[Shag]

Starting Ahman over Rudi. Hope I don't end up regretting that last-minute decision...

 

[seahawk 17]

Starting Wallace over Vick and Brees.Vick wwas hot last week, so he'll be horriable this week. Brees against the Ravens(scary D).Seattle's run game sucks, they will be playing from behind, and Wallace will pile up passing/running yards today.

At halftime, I look smart.

 

[redman]

Looks like it will take an act of God to slow McNabb down. I guess he'll just have to run a few in, then.

I would think about sitting him, but my two other QB's are on a bye.

I'm basically in the same boat. My two alternatives are Romo (@ Carolina) and Walter (vs. Pittsburgh). Romo is the only conceivable replacement, but I just can't bring myself to bench McNabb for Romo in his first start against Peppers and company.

Wow, I figured McNabb would take a hit today from this wind, but I never figured he'd look this bad!!9/20/68 0/0 through 3 quarters. GB his 30 yards rushing on scrambles, because otherwise he'd be in Alex Smith territory today.

 

[shadyridr]

Looks like it will take an act of God to slow McNabb down. I guess he'll just have to run a few in, then.

I would think about sitting him, but my two other QB's are on a bye.

I'm basically in the same boat. My two alternatives are Romo (@ Carolina) and Walter (vs. Pittsburgh). Romo is the only conceivable replacement, but I just can't bring myself to bench McNabb for Romo in his first start against Peppers and company.

Wow, I figured McNabb would take a hit today from this wind, but I never figured he'd look this bad!!9/20/68 0/0 through 3 quarters. GB his 30 yards rushing on scrambles, because otherwise he'd be in Alex Smith territory today.

And the wind has nothing to do with it.

 

[crimsonrebel]

benched bush over barlow.....so far so good

 

[Righetti]

David Carr over Eli Manning

 

[Hamburglar]

Tom Brady over Peyton Manning

Pretty much a push

 

[blueboys21]

Well here goes.Starting Rivers over Manning - Yes, I think the Denver D is going to come to play, and I just don't see Manning getting it done this week.On that same note:Starting Berrian over Wayne - Berrian against the worst D in the league, and Wayne against the best. Going with the matchup.This is one of those weeks where I made the hard decision and went against "always start your studs." We'll see how this works out.

Ah dude I hope you didn't.....

 

[Wingnut]

Well here goes.

Starting Rivers over Manning - Yes, I think the Denver D is going to come to play, and I just don't see Manning getting it done this week.

On that same note:

Starting Berrian over Wayne - Berrian against the worst D in the league, and Wayne against the best. Going with the matchup.

This is one of those weeks whereI made the hard decision and went against "always start your studs." We'll see how this works out.

Ah dude I hope you didn't.....

It sucks when you have to learn the hard way.