Dis he ever make a Conference Championship? I mean, the Heisman was a good start and he was putting up big numbers before it became passé.I think no personally, not a good enough resume especially in the playoffs. And he's 7th all time in pick sixes.
I was going to vote yes but then I read this and went with no.Anyone who votes 'yes' in this poll should be banned from the Shark Pool. And punished further by only being allowed to post in the P/R subforum.
In my head this seemed questionable, but then I looked up USC QB's, and its crazy how awful they have been. Sam Darnold will likely be #2 on the list if he makes it to the end of his rookie deal as a starter.His only real claim to fame in the pro game is being the best USC QB to play in the NFL.
No it was a legitimate question, here's the argument I got from USC fans:Lots of people taking this thread seriously and not seeing it for what it is (a weak troll attempt).
Well, not a single person has yet.Anyone who votes 'yes' in this poll should be banned from the Shark Pool. And punished further by only being allowed to post in the P/R subforum.
If he is then Eli Manning will be a unanimous choice:No it was a legitimate question, here's the argument I got from USC fans:
"Carson is 12th all time in pass completions
13th all time in yards, 13th all time in TDs. He’s a HOFer"
I'm going to slowly walk out of this thread with my tail between my legs. I thought you were talking about Carson Wentz lol.No it was a legitimate question, here's the argument I got from USC fans:
"Carson is 12th all time in pass completions
13th all time in yards, 13th all time in TDs. He’s a HOFer"
Of course Eli is in.If he is then Eli Manning will be a unanimous choice:
7th all time pass completions
7th all time passing yards
8th all time passing td's
I have problems enough already with the Cards letting Palmer into their ring before guys who have been in the HOF for decades -- can't even begin to conceive why Palmer should be considered for enshrinement before other former Bengals QBs (Ken Anderson, Boomer).Being added to the Cardinals ring of honor though.
That's sad enough.
Eli will be in. he has two rings.If he is then Eli Manning will be a unanimous choice:
7th all time pass completions
7th all time passing yards
8th all time passing td's
I came back to say the same thing.This thread is still going?
Same here. Can’t believe 85 people actually voted. This thing might reach Christine Michael status soon.I came back to say the same thing.
could be an interesting place.Anarchy99 said:The OP did not state which HOF. He could be a charter member of the first induction class for the People Named Carson HOF.
Since neither team has had 10 decent QB's, I limited the list to PFR's top-5 AV values, Cardinals are:SaintsInDome2006 said:The lists of Top 10 Cards & Bengals QBs would be good to see though.
Rodney Peete had a long and decent career.In my head this seemed questionable, but then I looked up USC QB's, and its crazy how awful they have been. Sam Darnold will likely be #2 on the list if he makes it to the end of his rookie deal as a starter.
It may just be because it's the first time a rhetorical question was used in a poll.I don't think I've ever seen a unanimous vote on anything on this forum, with more than like three or four voters. This one is pretty amazing.
He's under consideration for the "People named Palmer" hall of fame, but he's borderline for that.Anarchy99 said:The OP did not state which HOF. He could be a charter member of the first induction class for the People Named Carson HOF.