Is this a fair IDP trade? (1 Viewer)

[Rick Blaine]

Standard IDP scoring (i.e. 1 pt for tackles, 4 pts for sacks, etc) and all other things being equal, would you consider this trade fair (not taking into account other roster spots or area of needs)?

This trade seems odd to me, a rookie WLB for a Top-12 DE...

Your thoughts and opinions are appreciated.

 

[Beaumont]

Not fair. Osi >>>>> Ellison

ETA: I am just saying I would not consider it ...

 

[Jene Bramel]

This is like deja vu all over again.

 

[Keg]

is it fair if osi owner is hoping to catch lighting in a bottle with Ellison?

not that I would trade Osi for him but there are times that you take chances...thats part of what makes this a fun hobby. Also what might look unfair today could be much different tomorrow...if it seems like something shady is going on then its an issue otherwise imo its not

 

[bcr8f]

This is like deja vu all over again.

Hmmm. Maybe I'll prospose it in Bastages. I have Ellison. Maybe there's a virus going around.Ellison did do pretty well the last several weeks last season though.

 

[houndirish]

This is like deja vu all over again.

For the record, Mr. Blaine isn't in my league that I'm aware of!Postscript, I did do the deal for Osi and am exceedingly content with it. If I have a worry it's that Kiwanuka played so well in spot duty that the Giants might consider moving Umenyiora to Strahan's side in the event of injury or eventual retirement. Kiwanuka is the quicker player and better suited to be the blind side rusher. Maybe I should've offered Ellison to the Kiwi owner!

 

[Bob Magaw]

This is like deja vu all over again.

not only that, but i think i've seen that before...