Lamont, Caddy, Ronnie (1 Viewer)

[harrycarey]

discuss these as a group and make an argument to sway me toward one or the other.

 

[AcerFC]

I would say Lamont, Ronnie and then Caddy.

The reason for Lamont first is because he can catch balls out of the backfield. He wont catch as many this year but he is still a threat. Brown is a 2nd year player with huge upside and no Ricky this year. If you look at games 3 and 5 last year when Ricky was still suspended, Brown rushed for 132 and a TD and then 97. When Ricky came back he didnt really get more then 12-15 touches. Caddy cant catch the ball and he loses TD looks to Alstott and 3rd downs to Pittman

 

[jdraiders]

discuss these as a group and make an argument to sway me toward one or the other.

PPR?

 

[jaylasoul14]

Ronnie Brown has a great shot at getting double digit td's. I highly doubt Culpepper attacks the goal line the way he used to, knowing how important he is as a passer. I don't play in ppr leagues, so my vote is for brown, then lamont, then cadillac, who get vultured by alstott

 

[Mahoney]

They are the three worst #1 runningbacks in the NFL from a Fantasy Production standpoint.

I can't make an argument for any of the three that is contrary to the first sentence, they are interchangeable. A perfect "group" if you will.

 

[Lemmiwinks]

They are the three worst #1 runningbacks in the NFL from a Fantasy Production standpoint.I can't make an argument for any of the three that is contrary to the first sentence, they are interchangeable. A perfect "group" if you will.

Ronnie Brown is one of the worst starting RB's?

 

[laughinboy_2000]

They are the three worst #1 runningbacks in the NFL from a Fantasy Production standpoint.I can't make an argument for any of the three that is contrary to the first sentence, they are interchangeable. A perfect "group" if you will.

Ronnie Brown is one of the worst starting RB's?

But he is definately better than both Jordan and Caddy. Jordan will never return to his elite status unless the coaching staff makes some changes. Caddy seems to always get hurt and is notorious for his 15 carry for 40 yard games. I'm not saying Brown is great by any means, but I like Ronnie's long term value more than Jordan and Caddy's.

 

[Ron_Mexico]

For future reference

1. Caddy

2. RBrown

3. Jordan

-----------------------

Caddy has been hampered by back spasms, a spleenless QB,

and a gutless offensive line. This guy was the rookie

of the year last year, and should display the same talent

he did last season once the rest of the offensive pieces are in place.

 

[FrostBite]

They are the three worst #1 runningbacks in the NFL from a Fantasy Production standpoint.I can't make an argument for any of the three that is contrary to the first sentence, they are interchangeable. A perfect "group" if you will.

Let me guess Mahoney... your season is over and your bitter so your drudging up old posts of players you have? Mahoney

 

[SproutDaddy]

For future reference1. Caddy2. RBrown3. Jordan-----------------------Caddy has been hampered by back spasms, a spleenless QB,and a gutless offensive line. This guy was the rookieof the year last year, and should display the same talenthe did last season once the rest of the offensive pieces are in place.

I'd rank them the same.

 

[Colin Dowling]

I have been appalled by the relative lack of production by WIlliams,Brown, and Benson. I think that at least one of them (Williams) will pull out of it with an improved O-line and QB play, and Brown should be servicable as well, but I thought this crew would be super strong really quick,.

 

[Lemmiwinks]

Ronnie should not be mentioned in the same paragraph as Caddy, Jordan, Benson, whoever. The guy is doing quite well given the crap team around him. Caddy is TERRIBLE! BIG difference here.

 

[Slider]

Caddy lost 2 Olineman and a QB in week 1. I think he's easily in the best O and will bounce back huge next year. Should improve the rest of this year a little.