Lets talk Caddy (1 Viewer)

[Capella]

people who are saying he's a bust -- please name me any and all RBs who would be able to run well behind an Oline with two rookies starting full-time and one starter (Buenning) out for most of the year, AND a QB named Bruce Gradkowski who was absolutely miserable. I mean, MISERABLE.

I'll hang up and listen.

 

[EBF]

If he's healthy, he's a player. The bust talk is silly at this point. He won Rookie of the Year.

I think the only way he'll be a long-term disappointment is if he continues to have nagging injuries.

 

[Sabertooth]

people who are saying he's a bust -- please name me any and all RBs who would be able to run well behind an Oline with two rookies starting full-time and one starter (Buenning) out for most of the year, AND a QB named Bruce Gradkowski who was absolutely miserable. I mean, MISERABLE.I'll hang up and listen.

Everybody faces adversity.

 

[Sabertooth]

If he's healthy, he's a player. The bust talk is silly at this point. He won Rookie of the Year. I think the only way he'll be a long-term disappointment is if he continues to have nagging injuries.

Or he has chronic back pain. Which to people that suffer from it, can be far worse than a nagging problem.

 

[MelKiperJr]

people who are saying he's a bust -- please name me any and all RBs who would be able to run well behind an Oline with two rookies starting full-time and one starter (Buenning) out for most of the year, AND a QB named Bruce Gradkowski who was absolutely miserable. I mean, MISERABLE.I'll hang up and listen.

I don't think HE is a bust --- it looks like the 2005 NFL draft was relatively a bust, though. I don't think he's the worst RB in the league --- but given where he was drafted in dynasty & redraft leagues, it's safe to say he is a huge disappointment. I wouldn't feel comfortable going into 2007 with him even as a #2 on my team.

 

[Capella]

people who are saying he's a bust -- please name me any and all RBs who would be able to run well behind an Oline with two rookies starting full-time and one starter (Buenning) out for most of the year, AND a QB named Bruce Gradkowski who was absolutely miserable. I mean, MISERABLE.I'll hang up and listen.

Everybody faces adversity.

how did you figure out how to breathe?

 

[Sabertooth]

people who are saying he's a bust -- please name me any and all RBs who would be able to run well behind an Oline with two rookies starting full-time and one starter (Buenning) out for most of the year, AND a QB named Bruce Gradkowski who was absolutely miserable. I mean, MISERABLE.I'll hang up and listen.

Everybody faces adversity.

how did you figure out how to breathe?

 

[ashybaby]

What's his value now in a dynasty league. Who are some comparable WRs for instance?

 

[gman8343]

I'm cautiously optimistic he'll bounce back, and I'm currently trying to aquire him in a dynasty league (for Lamont Jordan and a draft pick).

He may struggle a bit next year, but with better QB play and an even moderately improved line, he should be a very good #2 with #1 potential.