We returned Tuesday from our 10-day trip through Italy ... we had a great time, and really appreciated some of the suggestions from
@Chemical X and others in this thread. Recall this was the trip where my wife and I took our two moms to Italy (their bucket list trip, first time out of the USA in their lives!). We had a blast, they get along together great, and we couldn't have been happier with how the trip played out (good weather, smooth logistics, great wine & food). This ended up being a longer write-up than I thought, but hope it helps someone out as you plan!
Flew via AA into FCO; Rental car via National (LocAuto)
Drove up to
Gaiole in Chianti; lunch & stretch break in
Lubriano on the way (cool view of Civita di Bagnoregio)
Stayed 3 nights @
Castella di Spaltenna - excellent, would recommend, higher end property but worth it to ease in to the time-change ... brand new infinity pool overlooking vineyards, top-notch service, rustic hill-town setting ... really liked spending our first few days in Chianti / Toscana as the pace was slower
Chianti Highlights:
Avignonese Winery (all-day event: cooking class, wine tasting & lunch, winery tour) ... this was incredible, our group of 4 was hosted by Caroline and chef Veronica all morning ... the ladies were able to pick items from the gardens and use them in the cooking class (pici pasta, bruschetta, tiramisu) and we had fun drinking wine, tasting & chatting during the class. later was the winery/farm tour with some additional folks, then a 3-course lunch w/ wine pairings in the most beautiful setting overlooking the property (
@Chemical X you were right!!). well worth the splurge and a highlight of the trip.
Day trip to
Siena: I love this town, and it was really fun to explore again ... Rick Steves City Walk audio guide, Duomo tour (climb to top of duomo and the unfinished church), a great dinner at
Trattoria la Torre (family run, hand made pasta, excellent)
Driving & Eating: one evening we drove from Castella di Spaltenna to
Officina della Bistecca in Panzano - the route took us over gravel roads through hilltop vineyards at times, and was breath-taking ... the dinner was incredible - suggest you watch the Netflix Chef's table episode - community table and incredible cuts of beef cooked over open fire in front of you. It does look like they have/are expanding, so I'd suggest being sure to get seating in the original dining room above the butcher shop as it was a more intimate experience vs. what the other area appeared to be. Friendly, lively, great steak, wow!
Winery stop en route to Florence:
Colle Bereto - we were able to book a tour & tasting for just the 4 of us before they had an event coming later that day. Pricey (35 euro/pp) but we had a wonderful experience - personal tour, and a light-lunch and 7-bottle wine tasting at another gorgeous setting (outdoor patio surrounded by gardens and views). some fantastic chianti expressions and again they treated us and the ladies like new best friends.
Florence Highlights:
Stayed 3 nights at
B&B Il Bargello: this was 'pretty good' ... perfect location to walk everywhere, but no elevator and up on the 4th floor so buyer beware ... the service was friendly and the rooms were fine, some street noise at night but white noise machine did wonders ... they had a 2 bedroom apartment setup which worked great for us
Sights: be sure to
book tickets in advance for the
Duomo climb, Uffizi Gallery, Accademia and Bargello Museums ... no waiting in lines and this made for a flawless experience. Incredible art and experiences all around at these stops ... We booked the
first appointment of the day for the Duomo climb (fresh legs) and Accademia (ensure you see Michaelangelo's David without a crowd surrounding it). We also really enjoyed the
Medici Chapel, Botanical Gardens for a change of pace, and walking through the
rose gardens en route to Michaelangelo's square for a sunset view.
Food: best gelato find was Antonio's at
Festival del Gelato. Had really nice dinners at
Rose's and
Osteria Antica Mescita San Niccolo. We went to each Festival and San Niccolo twice! Had a really fun lunch experience (and good food) at the indoor
Mercado Centrale farmer's market / food hall.
Rome Highlights:
Stayed 3 nights at
QuodLibet B&B and would definitely recommend. Gianluca was a wonderful host, 4th floor but elevators and quieter here, and he has an awesome rooftop terrance and breakfast sunroom setup. Had a bottle of wine up there the last night with some snacks. Clean and small property - great location near vatican and walkable w/ public transit options. Also a nice little 24-hour bakery just two doors down which was dangerous
Vatican day: we paid extra to book a guided tour through
vatican museum & sistine chapel that started 30min before it opened, so we had a
much less crowded experience. tour was 730a-930a, then you get breakfast (slightly above average, but fine and convenient) in the pinecone courtyard. we did the
archaeological tour of the necropolis and tombs underneath the vatican at 1130a-100p and that was really cool - highly recommend this, it was with small groups of 8-10 people, you have to book in advance and pass through the swiss guard & police security to walk to the scavi offices behind the walls. another good thing about this tour is when you finish you can
skip the LONG line to visit the duomo and just pop right up into the church.
Galleria Borghese: a smaller building, must buy tickets in advance (they were sold out day-of), and an incredible collection of art / sculpture in the midst of a park setting. nice breath of fresh air to escape the intensity & crowds of Rome.
Colosseum / Roman Forum day: all i can say here is that we booked a private tour with "
LivTours" and had Fabrizio as our tour guide ... he took us underneath the colosseum, and we had access to balcony views that the public could not access ... they were opening ropes and gates along the way for us the whole time. took us through the roman forum and palantine hill - was an awesome 3 hour tour and he is an archaeologist by profession. highly recommend, as I learned so much more this time vs. when we tried to do this on our own 14 years ago. their max group sizes are limited to 6 people so it was easy to chat with him and ask questions / hear clearly along the way.
Food: highlights were '
Il Duca' in Trastevere (such a cool neighborhood), and we had a nice meal at
Da Vito e Dina near our B&B. Best gelato in the city did not disappoint -
Giolitti, which is north of the Pantheon neighborhood.