Manning vs. Brady (1 Viewer)

[gianmarco]

Peyton just turned 35.

Brady will be turning 34 in a few months.

We're getting to the end of their careers despite both still playing at a high level. Which guy retires first? Does winning another SB matter for either? Will they keep trying beyond their time if the other is still around?

 

[LBH]

I think Brady will hang around longer. I'm a jets fan and that's just how lucky we are

 

[adrenaline]

I have to go with Manning because of age & he's on a perennially worst team.

 

[gianmarco]

I have to go with Manning because of age & he's on a perennially worst team.

Colts -- 9 yrs in a row with 10+ wins

109 wins over that time

Pats -- 8 yrs in a row with 10+ wins

110 wins over that time (9 yrs)

 

[FreeBaGeL]

I have to go with Manning because of age & he's on a perennially worst team.

Colts -- 9 yrs in a row with 10+ wins

109 wins over that time

Pats -- 8 yrs in a row with 10+ wins

110 wins over that time (9 yrs)

I think he meant the team/coaches around them.The Pats won 11 games without Brady. How many do you think the Colts would win without Peyton?

 

[gianmarco]

I have to go with Manning because of age & he's on a perennially worst team.

Colts -- 9 yrs in a row with 10+ wins

109 wins over that time

Pats -- 8 yrs in a row with 10+ wins

110 wins over that time (9 yrs)

I think he meant the team/coaches around them.The Pats won 11 games without Brady. How many do you think the Colts would win without Peyton?

Hmm, I didn't read it that way. But if that's the case, then yes, I definitely agree.

 

[gandalas]

I voted Brady. I think Peyton will stick around to try and break all Favre's records, just to show him who is the better QB.

Brady I don't think cares as much, or is even close to the all-time records like Peyton is.

 

[adrenaline]

I have to go with Manning because of age & he's on a perennially worst team.

Colts -- 9 yrs in a row with 10+ wins

109 wins over that time

Pats -- 8 yrs in a row with 10+ wins

110 wins over that time (9 yrs)

You're forgetting the most important stat.