Hmm there is a fine line between bravery and foolishness. When I have gone against the grain taking RB in a format where I really shouldn't be doing that, I was taking Adrian Peterson and Frank Gore. Due to all of the injuries to other RB Peterson was very valuable from a VBD perspective last season. There is no PPR for RB in that format, which makes him more valuable as well. I feel somewhat guilty for talking about forgoing WR with some bravado, you still need to draft to your format with consideration for ADP. 16 teams is different than 12 as well. Total points is different than best ball where you have head to head match ups. So I feel a little bit bad for talking this contrarian strategy up. Even though it worked out pretty well for me, I got lucky and what I did is not what I consider to be an ideal strategy for that format. I was more foolish than confident. Of course I been doing this a long time too and there is no money involved, just testing my projections really.
I don't think you should go into a draft with the intent of using any one strategy. You want to be flexible and take the best player for your first 3 to 5 picks before I would form a specific strategy. That strategy would be based on how the start of my draft went.
Both you and massraider were drafting from the 2 spot correct?
I think you take either Brown or OBJ for the first pick, which is nice because you get ahead of the WR run. I wouldn't consider anyone else.
the 2/3 turn gets tricky. Because you need to be thinking about who is going to be gone at the 4/5 turn.
Here is the linked draft list broken down at the two spot picks:
23 Marshall, Brandon WR NYJ 23.79 -0.61 3.32
Thomas, Demaryius WR DEN 24.68 -0.53 3.36
Hilton, T.Y. WR IND 26.24 -0.64 3.55
26 Lacy, Eddie RB GBP 26.48 1.67 3.77
Ingram, Mark RB NOS 26.49 -1.44 3.60
Watkins, Sammy WR BUF 28.53 1.63 3.98
Martin, Doug RB TBB 30.04 -0.82 3.96
30 Landry, Jarvis WR MIA 30.36 0.92 3.89
Cobb, Randall WR GBP 31.61 -2.01 4.11
Edelman, Julian WR NEP 32.64 -0.53 4.19
McCoy, LeSean RB BUF 34.64 1.39 4.44
Tate, Golden WR DET 34.65 1.72 4.32
Benjamin, Kelvin WR CAR 35.72 -0.42 4.45
36 Reed, Jordan TE WAS 36.18 1.47 4.80
Maclin, Jeremy WR KCC 36.87 -0.45 4.58
Forte, Matt RB NYJ 38.34 0.40 4.68
40 Lewis, Dion RB NEP 39.97 -1.77 4.87
Hyde, Carlos RB SFO 40.41 0.17 4.85
Anderson, C.J. RB DEN 41.98 -4.02 5.42
Moncrief, Donte WR IND 44.65 1.89 5.32
Baldwin, Doug WR SEA 45.17 -1.55 5.38
Newton, Cam QB CAR 45.24 2.57 5.80
Rawls, Thomas RB SEA 45.93 -0.75 5.46
47 Matthews, Jordan WR PHI 46.97 0.96 5.83
Floyd, Michael WR ARI 47.71 -2.60 5.53
Fitzgerald, Larry WR ARI 49.52 2.80 5.98
50 Murray, Latavius RB OAK 49.82 1.94 5.87
Decker, Eric WR NYJ 50.74 -0.42 5.86
Parker, DeVante WR MIA 54.30 3.45 6.18
Woodhead, Danny RB SDC 55.18 2.79 6.26
Johnson, Duke RB CLE 55.68 -2.30 6.36
55 Jones, Matt RB WAS 55.86 -0.28 6.29
Olsen, Greg TE CAR 55.87 -0.78 6.62
Murray, DeMarco
Brown, John WR ARI 56.85 4.75 6.41
Sanders, Emmanuel WR DEN 56.95 -1.72 6.46
60 Rodgers, Aaron QB GBP 57.04 4.42 6.63
Mathews, Ryan RB PHI 58.80 0.10 7.12
Ajayi, Jay RB MIA 60.54 -0.56 6.65
Hurns, Allen WR JAC 61.68 1.26 6.90
White, Kevin WR CHI 62.08 1.07 7.00
65 Bernard, Giovani RB CIN 64.77 2.62 7.57
Langford, Jeremy RB CHI 66.21 5.92 7.18
Coleman, Corey WR CLE 66.24 4.70 13.89
Crabtree, Michael WR OAK 66.88 -3.61 7.62
Hill, Jeremy
70 Luck, Andrew QB IND 71.11 -1.41 7.80
71 Stewart, Jonathan RB CAR 71.61 1.85 7.78
Kelce, Travis TE KCC 71.91 -0.73 7.95
Lockett, Tyler WR SEA 73.01 -1.59 8.88
74 Wilson, Russell QB SEA 74.07 -3.62 8.21
Gore, Frank RB IND 74.61 -2.27 7.94
Jones, Marvin WR DET 74.94 -0.66 8.54
Jackson, DeSean WR WAS 75.64 -1.24 8.15
Eifert, Tyler TE CIN 78.74 2.02 8.61
Abdullah, Ameer RB DET 79.27 -1.11 8.26
Yeldon, T.J. RB JAC 80.58 -0.66 8.94
Fleener, Coby TE NOS 81.22 -1.97 8.34
Walker, Delanie TE TEN 81.47 -1.55 8.73
Green-Beckham, Dorial
I see the opportunity to possibly get Russell Wilson or Luck at the 6/7 turn so I wouldn't target a QB earlier than this. I see enough viable WR and RB options that I wouldn't be married to any strategy specifically. I think it would be good to get Jordan Reed, but it is really difficult to do from this draft position without reaching too much.
Drafting in the middle is usually better for a zig/zag strategy because when you are at the turns you have to be thinking ahead more.
Kowing the run on WR is going to be early and often, I would just try to stay ahead of that drafting from the top of the order. Maybe if Miller or Peterson fell to the 2/3 turn I would consider them. It would be a hard choice if Charles was there. There are enough WR that I would expect to get 3 WR then maybe look at Jay Ajati Duke Johnson or some other RBs at picks 47 and 50.