Mike Bell Knee Injury (1 Viewer)

[editor47]

i don't want to come off sounding happy to have someone get injured ... but with eddie royal's crappy performances, it will be nice to be able to pencil in pierre thomas with at least a little confidence.

i'm actually stunned they dressed thomas today and then only gave him 1 touch. the fact that he didn't get in after bell's injury and that the saints relied on bush tells me that either thomas wasn't ready or payton decided to play it safe and rest thomas for next week, knowing how severe bell's injury is.

i wish bell a good recovery as a human being.

 

[joetrow]

Hamilton

What is his upside? Short and long term?

Just read up on him from what I could find, sounds very injury prone, just 56 carries for 146 yards last 2 years of college because of ankle and knee injurys... I wonder, if Bell and Thomas are more banged up then being reported, if the Saints will look to sign a veteran back.

 

[thekidd2009]

i don't want to come off sounding happy to have someone get injured ... but with eddie royal's crappy performances, it will be nice to be able to pencil in pierre thomas with at least a little confidence. i'm actually stunned they dressed thomas today and then only gave him 1 touch. the fact that he didn't get in after bell's injury and that the saints relied on bush tells me that either thomas wasn't ready or payton decided to play it safe and rest thomas for next week, knowing how severe bell's injury is.i wish bell a good recovery as a human being.

I understand what your saying...i don't wish injury on anyone either but this situation in new orleans isn't going to get any easier if both PT and Bell are healthy. I'm hoping PT is close to 100% and ready to roll next week because I could use a solid rb2 performance.

 

[Hipple Long Ware & Peete]

So sick of hearing these Mike Bell owners the past two weeks--now you guys get to watch as Thomas comes back and becomes a fantasy force once again Yes, I own Thomas in all leagues!

I'm with you. These Bell owners have been acting like he was the second coming of Walter Payton and should keep the starting job even when Pierre Thomas comes back 100%. Mike Bell is nothing but a journeyman RB who is lucky to have a roster spot on an NFL team.

Bell looked awesome for two games. Lets not pretend that Thomas stole the job back. he got lucky plain and simple. And this coming from a Thomas owner who doesnt have Bell.

Let's not pretend that Bell stole the job from Thomas to begin with. He got lucky, plain and simple. If not for PT's initial injury.......

AWESOME SIG

 

[thekidd2009]

Hamilton

What is his upside? Short and long term?

Just read up on him from what I could find, sounds very injury prone, just 56 carries for 146 yards last 2 years of college because of ankle and knee injurys... I wonder, if Bell and Thomas are more banged up then being reported, if the Saints will look to sign a veteran back.

Hamilton looked good in preseason and I know they have PJ Hill as well.

 

[Haberdasher]

Hamilton

What is his upside? Short and long term?

Just read up on him from what I could find, sounds very injury prone, just 56 carries for 146 yards last 2 years of college because of ankle and knee injurys... I wonder, if Bell and Thomas are more banged up then being reported, if the Saints will look to sign a veteran back.

Hamilton looked good in preseason and I know they have PJ Hill as well.

PJ Hill is on their practice squad.

 

[Haberdasher]

New Orleans Saints running back Mike Bell says MRI negative

New Orleans Saints running back Mike Bell, who sprained his right knee in the fourth quarter Sunday against Philadelphia, said Monday that an MRI showed no structural damage.

Bell said he has full range of motion and hopes to play Sunday against Buffalo, but the decision is up to the team.

The injury is similar to the knee injury that sidelined running back Pierre Thomas for two preseason games and the first regular-season game, Bell said. Thomas played briefly Sunday.

"I always expect to play, but I'm not a doctor,'' Bell said. "I have to do what's best for myself, but most importantly, I have to do what's best for the team. It's a long season. We have more than enough capable running backs to get the job done. I think me missing a couple games is not going to hurt the team at all.''

"If I have to to miss a game, I don't think we're going to miss a beat. If anything, we're going to be better.''

Bell rushed Sunday for 87 yards on 17 carries and scored on a 7-yard run.

http://www.nola.com/saints/index.ssf/2009/...ning_bac_1.htmlI bet he misses at least 2 weeks.

edit: I just realized if he does in fact miss 2 weeks (and that is only MY opinion) he wouldn't be back until week 6 after New Orleans' bye in week 5.

 

[Devil in the Detail]

New Orleans Saints running back Mike Bell says MRI negative

New Orleans Saints running back Mike Bell, who sprained his right knee in the fourth quarter Sunday against Philadelphia, said Monday that an MRI showed no structural damage.

Bell said he has full range of motion and hopes to play Sunday against Buffalo, but the decision is up to the team.

The injury is similar to the knee injury that sidelined running back Pierre Thomas for two preseason games and the first regular-season game, Bell said. Thomas played briefly Sunday.

"I always expect to play, but I'm not a doctor,'' Bell said. "I have to do what's best for myself, but most importantly, I have to do what's best for the team. It's a long season. We have more than enough capable running backs to get the job done. I think me missing a couple games is not going to hurt the team at all.''

"If I have to to miss a game, I don't think we're going to miss a beat. If anything, we're going to be better.''

Bell rushed Sunday for 87 yards on 17 carries and scored on a 7-yard run.

http://www.nola.com/saints/index.ssf/2009/...ning_bac_1.htmlI bet he misses at least 2 weeks.

Hmm. The "full range of motion" bit is good for Bell's chances. Any update on Thomas's status? He didn't come in once Bell got hurt, so it sounds like the team is still treating him with kid gloves a bit.

 

[caglassc]

And you have this in your sig:

Duke 2009 ACC Champions!NCAA record for most wins in a decade!

Okay I'll bite. What is your issue with my sig? Both statements are facts.

Duke won the ACC Tournament - UNC won the ACC this year...as well as another tournament if I am not mistaken.

 

[Louisville Slugger]

New Orleans Saints running back Mike Bell says MRI negative

New Orleans Saints running back Mike Bell, who sprained his right knee in the fourth quarter Sunday against Philadelphia, said Monday that an MRI showed no structural damage.

Bell said he has full range of motion and hopes to play Sunday against Buffalo, but the decision is up to the team.

The injury is similar to the knee injury that sidelined running back Pierre Thomas for two preseason games and the first regular-season game, Bell said. Thomas played briefly Sunday.

"I always expect to play, but I'm not a doctor,'' Bell said. "I have to do what's best for myself, but most importantly, I have to do what's best for the team. It's a long season. We have more than enough capable running backs to get the job done. I think me missing a couple games is not going to hurt the team at all.''

"If I have to to miss a game, I don't think we're going to miss a beat. If anything, we're going to be better.''

Bell rushed Sunday for 87 yards on 17 carries and scored on a 7-yard run.

http://www.nola.com/saints/index.ssf/2009/...ning_bac_1.htmlI bet he misses at least 2 weeks.

Hmm. The "full range of motion" bit is good for Bell's chances. Any update on Thomas's status? He didn't come in once Bell got hurt, so it sounds like the team is still treating him with kid gloves a bit.

They didn't put Thomas in because N.O. was ahead by 3td's. He should be good to go on Sunday.

 

[gradin123]

Considering the Saints have the Bye in Week 5 it is very likely he will miss the 2 games prior to the bye and come back in week#6.

I still think he has a very good chance at reclaiming the starting job when he returns though.

 

[JuniorNB]

Considering the Saints have the Bye in Week 5 it is very likely he will miss the 2 games prior to the bye and come back in week#6.

And since everyone forgot how well Thomas played last year when Bell had two good games, everyone will forget about Bell if Thomas has two good ones.

 

[Native]

Im so upset that I bought into this debacle.

 

[Da Guru]

Good news about Mike Bell The guy is playing some great football right now, nice to see a guy who was discarded come back with a possible career type of year.

 

[Ripleys]

great news for Bell owners. I'd like to see him get back on the field and do well. And I hope Bush's TD run Sunday helps his confidence too.

 

[Ripleys]

Like TheFanatic said, no one cares. This thread is about Mike Bell, not your 2 team fantasy league with you and your mom.

What are you like 12?

 

[TheFanatic]

Im so upset that I bought into this debacle.

Why? The guy didn't blow an ACL. PT has a chance now to take that job and keep it but he hasn't been the model of health his career either. It's a set back but let's not put him in a coffin...

 

[JuniorNB]

Im so upset that I bought into this debacle.

Why? The guy didn't blow an ACL. PT has a chance now to take that job and keep it but he hasn't been the model of health his career either. It's a set back but let's not put him in a coffin...

By 'debacle', I think he meant the entire Broncos, I mean Saints backfield situation.I actually agree. If Thomas picks up where he left off last year, you're going to have three solid backs who will be giving fantasy owners headaches all year.

 

[Todem]

This is good news for Bell. I would bet he misses at least this week if PT is available. But Bell has really looked good. And for that Matter so had Reggie Bush...he is what he is a PPR machine.

 

[Two Deep]

This is good news for Bell. I would bet he misses at least this week if PT is available. But Bell has really looked good. And for that Matter so had Reggie Bush...he is what he is a PPR machine.

He may look good in your league but as an NFL running back

 

[Todem]

This is good news for Bell. I would bet he misses at least this week if PT is available. But Bell has really looked good. And for that Matter so had Reggie Bush...he is what he is a PPR machine.

He may look good in your league but as an NFL running back

He is not an NFL protype RB...but the Saints are using him the way he should be used....spilt out, swings, screens, punt returns and the occasional between the tackle work which by the way he blasted through an off tackle run for a score. By no means was he worth a 2nd overall pick....but he is a very useful player and causes match up headaches for defenses...no LB or Saftey can cover this guy....none.As far as FF he is PPR gold.

 

[editor47]

With Peterson, CJ3 and Turner, I'm hoping Pierre Thomas looks good this enough this week to trade. If he looks too good, I will keep him.

 

[mashers]

You guys have been talking up Bell non-stop the past two weeks! It's time to jump on the PT train, as there is plenty of room...I hhave both Bell and Thomas in one league and Thomas in a dynasty, so it's working fine.... Hey masher, I'll send you some tissues

How's that PT train running for you today buddy? AAALLLLL AABOOOOAAAARRRRD!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[gianmarco]

You guys have been talking up Bell non-stop the past two weeks! It's time to jump on the PT train, as there is plenty of room...I hhave both Bell and Thomas in one league and Thomas in a dynasty, so it's working fine.... Hey masher, I'll send you some tissues

How's that PT train running for you today buddy? AAALLLLL AABOOOOAAAARRRRD!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[JuniorNB]

You guys have been talking up Bell non-stop the past two weeks! It's time to jump on the PT train, as there is plenty of room...I hhave both Bell and Thomas in one league and Thomas in a dynasty, so it's working fine.... Hey masher, I'll send you some tissues

How's that PT train running for you today buddy? AAALLLLL AABOOOOAAAARRRRD!!!!!!!!!!!!

That's gonna leave a mark.

 

[gianmarco]

You guys have been talking up Bell non-stop the past two weeks! It's time to jump on the PT train, as there is plenty of room...I hhave both Bell and Thomas in one league and Thomas in a dynasty, so it's working fine.... Hey masher, I'll send you some tissues

How's that PT train running for you today buddy? AAALLLLL AABOOOOAAAARRRRD!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[Breesisdaman]

I dont own any of these backs but I will tell you this. PT has not won anything back. It will be a full blown competition when bell returns and both backs will look good and help the Saints win. To me that last sentence is all that matters.

 

[JuniorNB]

I dont own any of these backs but I will tell you this. PT has not won anything back. It will be a full blown competition when bell returns and both backs will look good and help the Saints win. To me that last sentence is all that matters.

 

[Da Guru]

Any halfway decent RB will thrive with the Saints passing game.

I have Thomas and Bell and both of them are not exactly durable goods.

 

[kd1]

I dont own any of these backs but I will tell you this. PT has not won anything back. It will be a full blown competition when bell returns and both backs will look good and help the Saints win. To me that last sentence is all that matters.

ROFL

 

[Breesisdaman]

I dont own any of these backs but I will tell you this. PT has not won anything back. It will be a full blown competition when bell returns and both backs will look good and help the Saints win. To me that last sentence is all that matters.

ROFL

OK ROTF but that doesnt change the fact that Bell looked every bit as explosive as PT did when it was he that had the opportunity. Sean Payton has stated that when Bell and PT are healthy they will share carries and the load will be distributed based off the success each has in game. They will be competing every game for carries. Disbelieve this if you want to but it is the facts. 3 headed monster is alive and well inspite of your PT euphoria.

 

[Judge Smails]

I dont own any of these backs but I will tell you this. PT has not won anything back. It will be a full blown competition when bell returns and both backs will look good and help the Saints win. To me that last sentence is all that matters.

ROFL

OK ROTF but that doesnt change the fact that Bell looked every bit as explosive as PT did when it was he that had the opportunity. Sean Payton has stated that when Bell and PT are healthy they will share carries and the load will be distributed based off the success each has in game. They will be competing every game for carries. Disbelieve this if you want to but it is the facts. 3 headed monster is alive and well inspite of your PT euphoria.

dude. enough. enough. PT is the only dual threat on that team. Bush is a receiver, Bell is a straight ahead runner. PT is the complete package. Bell and Hamilton will spell PT - that is all. Bush will go back to being a receiver. After last year, and after today, coming off an injury - there is NO way PT isn't the guy.

 

[TheFanatic]

I dont own any of these backs but I will tell you this. PT has not won anything back. It will be a full blown competition when bell returns and both backs will look good and help the Saints win. To me that last sentence is all that matters.

ROFL

OK ROTF but that doesnt change the fact that Bell looked every bit as explosive as PT did when it was he that had the opportunity. Sean Payton has stated that when Bell and PT are healthy they will share carries and the load will be distributed based off the success each has in game. They will be competing every game for carries. Disbelieve this if you want to but it is the facts. 3 headed monster is alive and well inspite of your PT euphoria.

dude. enough. enough. PT is the only dual threat on that team. Bush is a receiver, Bell is a straight ahead runner. PT is the complete package. Bell and Hamilton will spell PT - that is all. Bush will go back to being a receiver. After last year, and after today, coming off an injury - there is NO way PT isn't the guy.

With what Bush brings to the table, why do they need the dual threat? I mean PT didn't have a reception in this game. The dual threat to me isn't really all that much of a reason to place PT over MB.

 

[awesomeness]

I dont own any of these backs but I will tell you this. PT has not won anything back. It will be a full blown competition when bell returns and both backs will look good and help the Saints win. To me that last sentence is all that matters.

ROFL

OK ROTF but that doesnt change the fact that Bell looked every bit as explosive as PT did when it was he that had the opportunity. Sean Payton has stated that when Bell and PT are healthy they will share carries and the load will be distributed based off the success each has in game. They will be competing every game for carries. Disbelieve this if you want to but it is the facts. 3 headed monster is alive and well inspite of your PT euphoria.

dude. enough. enough. PT is the only dual threat on that team. Bush is a receiver, Bell is a straight ahead runner. PT is the complete package. Bell and Hamilton will spell PT - that is all. Bush will go back to being a receiver. After last year, and after today, coming off an injury - there is NO way PT isn't the guy.

With what Bush brings to the table, why do they need the dual threat? I mean PT didn't have a reception in this game. The dual threat to me isn't really all that much of a reason to place PT over MB.

when MB is in there, you know he's either running up the middle or blocking. If PT is in there, he could be running inside, outside, blocking, or running a route.

 

[Breesisdaman]

I dont own any of these backs but I will tell you this. PT has not won anything back. It will be a full blown competition when bell returns and both backs will look good and help the Saints win. To me that last sentence is all that matters.

ROFL

OK ROTF but that doesnt change the fact that Bell looked every bit as explosive as PT did when it was he that had the opportunity. Sean Payton has stated that when Bell and PT are healthy they will share carries and the load will be distributed based off the success each has in game. They will be competing every game for carries. Disbelieve this if you want to but it is the facts. 3 headed monster is alive and well inspite of your PT euphoria.

dude. enough. enough. PT is the only dual threat on that team. Bush is a receiver, Bell is a straight ahead runner. PT is the complete package. Bell and Hamilton will spell PT - that is all. Bush will go back to being a receiver. After last year, and after today, coming off an injury - there is NO way PT isn't the guy.

This is simply not the case your head is in the fantasy football clouds over one running back. Pierre Thomas is good he runs and catches, Bell also has ran well and caught the ball out of the back field. Check his stats and you will see catches. Bush also had some running plays today so he is not strictly a WR type back. The good news is there is enough to go around especially if the opponent sells out to the pass like buffalo did today. I expect decent totals from Bell and PT going forward. I do not expect to see one back get a majority of the carries outside of injury. I am simply trying to put a dose of reality on folks expectations. Bell and PT will compete each and every game for carries just like everyone else on the team like Wr's have to compete to get open for Brees to see them and throw the ball. I expect a 50/50 split between Bell and PT but those carries will be good productive carries if the opponent is selling out to the pass.

 

[Judge Smails]

I dont own any of these backs but I will tell you this. PT has not won anything back. It will be a full blown competition when bell returns and both backs will look good and help the Saints win. To me that last sentence is all that matters.

ROFL

OK ROTF but that doesnt change the fact that Bell looked every bit as explosive as PT did when it was he that had the opportunity. Sean Payton has stated that when Bell and PT are healthy they will share carries and the load will be distributed based off the success each has in game. They will be competing every game for carries. Disbelieve this if you want to but it is the facts. 3 headed monster is alive and well inspite of your PT euphoria.

dude. enough. enough. PT is the only dual threat on that team. Bush is a receiver, Bell is a straight ahead runner. PT is the complete package. Bell and Hamilton will spell PT - that is all. Bush will go back to being a receiver. After last year, and after today, coming off an injury - there is NO way PT isn't the guy.

This is simply not the case your head is in the fantasy football clouds over one running back. Pierre Thomas is good he runs and catches, Bell also has ran well and caught the ball out of the back field. Check his stats and you will see catches. Bush also had some running plays today so he is not strictly a WR type back. The good news is there is enough to go around especially if the opponent sells out to the pass like buffalo did today. I expect decent totals from Bell and PT going forward. I do not expect to see one back get a majority of the carries outside of injury. I am simply trying to put a dose of reality on folks expectations. Bell and PT will compete each and every game for carries just like everyone else on the team like Wr's have to compete to get open for Brees to see them and throw the ball. I expect a 50/50 split between Bell and PT but those carries will be good productive carries if the opponent is selling out to the pass.

First of all, a 50-50 split isn't a "3 headed monster". Last week, you said it would be a "4 headed monster" with Hamilton in the mix. Back off on the monster speak. You know how many carries Bush got in the 2nd half? 4. You know how many went for negative yardage? Two. Half. PT got 14 carries in the 2nd half. Hamilton? Zip. While Bell looked good early (and I own him as well), you don't think a healthy PT could have carved up the Lions and the like? Bell deserves to get mixed in. But PT made a statement today. Bush won't see a 10 carry game the rest of the year unless somebody else gets injured. Believe what you want - we know your stance. The only difference is how many heads the monster has. Surprised Heath Evans hasn't joined to make it an even 5 headed monster. For PT to do that in one half, on the road, in his first game back from injury at less than 100%......it's over.

 

[rjv]

I dont own any of these backs but I will tell you this. PT has not won anything back. It will be a full blown competition when bell returns and both backs will look good and help the Saints win. To me that last sentence is all that matters.

ROFL

OK ROTF but that doesnt change the fact that Bell looked every bit as explosive as PT did when it was he that had the opportunity. Sean Payton has stated that when Bell and PT are healthy they will share carries and the load will be distributed based off the success each has in game. They will be competing every game for carries. Disbelieve this if you want to but it is the facts. 3 headed monster is alive and well inspite of your PT euphoria.

dude. enough. enough. PT is the only dual threat on that team. Bush is a receiver, Bell is a straight ahead runner. PT is the complete package. Bell and Hamilton will spell PT - that is all. Bush will go back to being a receiver. After last year, and after today, coming off an injury - there is NO way PT isn't the guy.

This is simply not the case your head is in the fantasy football clouds over one running back. Pierre Thomas is good he runs and catches, Bell also has ran well and caught the ball out of the back field. Check his stats and you will see catches. Bush also had some running plays today so he is not strictly a WR type back. The good news is there is enough to go around especially if the opponent sells out to the pass like buffalo did today. I expect decent totals from Bell and PT going forward. I do not expect to see one back get a majority of the carries outside of injury. I am simply trying to put a dose of reality on folks expectations. Bell and PT will compete each and every game for carries just like everyone else on the team like Wr's have to compete to get open for Brees to see them and throw the ball. I expect a 50/50 split between Bell and PT but those carries will be good productive carries if the opponent is selling out to the pass.

By saying this, do you suggest that if someone has both on their roster, should both be started every week??

 

[Breesisdaman]

First of all, a 50-50 split isn't a "3 headed monster". Last week, you said it would be a "4 headed monster" with Hamilton in the mix. Back off on the monster speak. You know how many carries Bush got in the 2nd half? 4. You know how many went for negative yardage? Two. Half. PT got 14 carries in the 2nd half. Hamilton? Zip. While Bell looked good early (and I own him as well), you don't think a healthy PT could have carved up the Lions and the like? Bell deserves to get mixed in. But PT made a statement today. Bush won't see a 10 carry game the rest of the year unless somebody else gets injured. Believe what you want - we know your stance. The only difference is how many heads the monster has. Surprised Heath Evans hasn't joined to make it an even 5 headed monster. For PT to do that in one half, on the road, in his first game back from injury at less than 100%......it's over.

Spoken like someone that doesn't have a clue about Sean Payton and what he wants from his backs. SEAN PAYTON WILL NEVER AGAIN RIDE ONE HORSE! Never again will he do it. The season is too long and his backs are too fragile to take on the pounding. When players are hurt he does it out of necessity. The 50/50 split I am talking about isnt written in stone and it doesn't include Bush and how he will be utilized in the offense. I am considering Bush's job a whole different position from that of Bell and PT. It will start out as a 50/50 between PT and Bell for the power back share of the carries but as I said it will be a competition so if PT is clearly the better back and proves it game to game then you as a PT owner have nothing to worry about. However Bell is just as capable and could win that battle. I don't see PT having a clear advantage at all. Also what happens in the Bell/PT competition does not affect Bush at all. The only thing that affects Bush is himself. If he is affective they use him if not he disappears.

 

[Breesisdaman]

By saying this, do you suggest that if someone has both on their roster, should both be started every week??

It is never advisable to start two backs from the same team but under certain circumstances I could see it paying off.

 

[burgundy and gold]

With Peterson, CJ3 and Turner, I'm hoping Pierre Thomas looks good this enough this week to trade. If he looks too good, I will keep him.

He looked too good.

 

[brindrod]

Any updates on Bell's injury or a timetable for his return?

 

[Raiderfan32904]

Any updates on Bell's injury or a timetable for his return?

News Articles > Mike Bell Published Wed Sep 30 5:50:17 p.m. ET 2009 (RotoWire) Bell (knee) did not practice Wednesday, the New Orleans Times-Picayune's Jeff Duncan reports.Analysis: Pierre Thomas and Reggie Bush handled the rushing load quite nicely with Bell out last week against Buffalo. If Bell can't go again, look for a similar situation on Sunday, although Thomas could see an increase in work after his impressive showing. I dumped bell last week, before Pierre T blew up in just one half of football. Do you really think that M. Bell will come and take away the rock the way PT is grindin? If you can spare the space on your roster, he may be a nice handcuff way down the road. But in FF, the season is too short to sit on your roster. I recommend taking a shot on M. Morris or M. Moore of the waiver wire and see how that pans out.

 

[Mr. Mojo]

Any updates on Bell's injury or a timetable for his return?

News Articles > Mike Bell Published Wed Sep 30 5:50:17 p.m. ET 2009 (RotoWire) Bell (knee) did not practice Wednesday, the New Orleans Times-Picayune's Jeff Duncan reports.

Analysis: Pierre Thomas and Reggie Bush handled the rushing load quite nicely with Bell out last week against Buffalo. If Bell can't go again, look for a similar situation on Sunday, although Thomas could see an increase in work after his impressive showing.

I dumped bell last week, before Pierre T blew up in just one half of football. Do you really think that M. Bell will come and take away the rock the way PT is grindin? If you can spare the space on your roster, he may be a nice handcuff way down the road. But in FF, the season is too short to sit on your roster. I recommend taking a shot on M. Morris or M. Moore of the waiver wire and see how that pans out.

I'd rather keep Bell than drop him for a guy who will share the load (Morris) or a guy who is only a 3rd down back (Moore).If there is a good waiver out there, then by all means drop Bell. But not for those bums you mentioned.

 

[Native]

PT owner and huge fan here - and Im VERY hesitant to dismiss Mike Bell. Last year Deuce and Pierre split carries roughly 70/30 during the second half of the year when both players played. Bell looked great in preseason and through the first two games. At the very least, I can see Payton reverting to last years split. Pierre vs Deuce carries in weeks 11-16:

16 to 8

15 to 5

11 to 3

16 to 1

22 to (injures)

13 to 9

Now thats still a nice-sized chunk of action for Pierre in a rotation, but its not as if hes the only back in the backfield. I had him last year in week 16 vs the Lions, and I wasnt thrilled that he only got 13 touches - especially after proving himself as a viable every down back (although he did score a TD). Temper your expectations is all Im saying. This is no slam dunk.

 

[Judge Smails]

PT owner and huge fan here - and Im VERY hesitant to dismiss Mike Bell. Last year Deuce and Pierre split carries roughly 70/30 during the second half of the year when both players played. Bell looked great in preseason and through the first two games. At the very least, I can see Payton reverting to last years split. Pierre vs Deuce carries in weeks 11-16: 16 to 8 15 to 511 to 316 to 122 to (injures)13 to 9Now thats still a nice-sized chunk of action for Pierre in a rotation, but its not as if hes the only back in the backfield. I had him last year in week 16 vs the Lions, and I wasnt thrilled that he only got 13 touches - especially after proving himself as a viable every down back (although he did score a TD). Temper your expectations is all Im saying. This is no slam dunk.

I own both PT and Bell, but as a PT enthusiast I'd be very happy with an average of 15.5 carries a game, plus receiving opportunities. You don't need 25 carries a game to rack up yards and TD's in that offense.

 

[Native]

PT owner and huge fan here - and Im VERY hesitant to dismiss Mike Bell. Last year Deuce and Pierre split carries roughly 70/30 during the second half of the year when both players played. Bell looked great in preseason and through the first two games. At the very least, I can see Payton reverting to last years split. Pierre vs Deuce carries in weeks 11-16: 16 to 8 15 to 511 to 316 to 122 to (injures)13 to 9Now thats still a nice-sized chunk of action for Pierre in a rotation, but its not as if hes the only back in the backfield. I had him last year in week 16 vs the Lions, and I wasnt thrilled that he only got 13 touches - especially after proving himself as a viable every down back (although he did score a TD). Temper your expectations is all Im saying. This is no slam dunk.

I own both PT and Bell, but as a PT enthusiast I'd be very happy with an average of 15.5 carries a game, plus receiving opportunities. You don't need 25 carries a game to rack up yards and TD's in that offense.

I bring up last years splits to emphasize that carries per game is an average - there may be games when he gets 10-11 carries and other games when he gets 19-20. On that offense, it really shouldnt matter but its worth noting.

 

[el-gato-grande]

Honestly its hard to tell how any coach does his RBBC until you see it.

Some ride the hot hand, split series, or rotate based on the downs. But, I think the nightmare RBBC scenario for PT owners is that Bell becomes the inside the 20's guy and ends up vulturing all the TD's. That would be similar to how Baltimore is handling Rice and McGahee and that has really hurt Rice's value.