Instinctive
Footballguy
In following with the RB thread, here is how I got to this point: I individually project - within team context, my estimations of talent and such, changes in the past few years, career trends of the player and his team (I suppose that is all part of context), and a couple other factors - the stats for most of the fantasy relevant NFL players. Today I finished up WRs and TEs. I already made a RB post, and QB/TE should be forthcoming, depending on when I get out of class tonight and how travel goes tomorrow (for those of you looking forward to those threads).
RB Thread
QB Thread
When I finish my projections, I put them all into the DD, and I see what things I notice. Things don't always seem to fall into place like I think they will, and I'll discuss that in the observations I highlight. Here are my biggest discoveries at the WR position:
1. Hakeem Nicks is being overlooked - Projection: 81/1201/12
I was going through, making my projections, crafting them carefully, and at the end, I see that Nicks is standing out. The biggest reason is probably those 12 TDs...but they're actually in line with his career TD/rec% and fit within what I project Eli for, TD-wise. The yardage is nothing amazing, but still near the top of the league (I expect that to be a top 5-7 yardage number, though it would not have been last year). Nicks has a crazy low ADP for what I ended up having him at in my rankings. I would have taken Calvin, Fitz, AJ, Julio, Marshall, and a few others over Nicks, but:
Result: WR2. That's right, he ends up as my #2 overall wideout when it's all said and done. This is a guy it looks like I will have the pleasure of owning this year.
2. I'm lower on Julio Jones than I thought I was - Projection: 75/1148/9
I have been all over the Falcons offense, subjectively, in my mocks and preparations this year. But when I actually sat down, looked at the numbers, and made a projection of what would happen...this is what I got. I could be low on the TDs, and it is possible that he has a higher ypr (I lowered it from what he had last year, I don't think that will be sustainable)...but it looks like I will actually not own Julio at all. Just a short week ago I thought I would own him most places, and month ago I thought I would ALWAYS have him.
Result: WR11 - exactly one spot above his teammate, Roddy White. This result is going to lead into my next observation:
3. WRs are even closer together than everyone says.
My VBD results have Calvin at 60+, Nicks and Andre at 30+, and then six guys with 20-29, 2 guys at 18, and another 5 guys with 7-10 VBD. Calvin is far and away my #1 wideout, and I have him regressing a decent amount based on the unsustainability of Detroit's passing game last year as well as his TDs.
4. I love Marques Colston - Projection: 91/1274/8
Now, keep in mind that I project everyone for a full 16 games (except Mathews, Lynch types - suspended or already injured with a recovery timetable) because I think you can't predict injury. That being said: These numbers are surprisingly in line with Colston's typical targets and receptions per game, his career TD%, and his normal ypr. Meachem is gone, so I ended up giving him a little bit more on the targets side of things, but overall, these are less surprising than they first appear if you do some research (which I did when I found I had Colston in the top 10...)
Result: WR7 - Brees is literally the only QB with an extended history of throwing more than 620 times, for near/over 5000 yards. Colston is his top wideout, and with Meachem gone and none of the rookies looking healthy and able to step up, I think quite a few of the Saints players are undervalued. Lance Moore, Colston, Graham (even at his lofty ADP), and even Sproles.
5. I have both Miles Austin and Steve Johnson in the top 20 WRs, and they are the only two of mine with an ADP round 5 or later. Austin is the only guy I see in the top 15 with a round 5+ ADP. Looks like a value play to me!
Long story short: Miles Austin, when he and Romo are healthy, has always played like a top 5 wideout. I'm actually knocking him down because of Dez's improvement in placing him at WR9 or so. With Witten's potential issues, Austin could be leaned on more than ever. There's a lot of upside there, especially at his ADP.
Johnson is consistent, a clear #1 target, and on a team that will have at least a couple shootouts with their schedule. I like him a lot as a WR2/3/flex
RB Thread
QB Thread
When I finish my projections, I put them all into the DD, and I see what things I notice. Things don't always seem to fall into place like I think they will, and I'll discuss that in the observations I highlight. Here are my biggest discoveries at the WR position:
1. Hakeem Nicks is being overlooked - Projection: 81/1201/12
I was going through, making my projections, crafting them carefully, and at the end, I see that Nicks is standing out. The biggest reason is probably those 12 TDs...but they're actually in line with his career TD/rec% and fit within what I project Eli for, TD-wise. The yardage is nothing amazing, but still near the top of the league (I expect that to be a top 5-7 yardage number, though it would not have been last year). Nicks has a crazy low ADP for what I ended up having him at in my rankings. I would have taken Calvin, Fitz, AJ, Julio, Marshall, and a few others over Nicks, but:
Result: WR2. That's right, he ends up as my #2 overall wideout when it's all said and done. This is a guy it looks like I will have the pleasure of owning this year.
2. I'm lower on Julio Jones than I thought I was - Projection: 75/1148/9
I have been all over the Falcons offense, subjectively, in my mocks and preparations this year. But when I actually sat down, looked at the numbers, and made a projection of what would happen...this is what I got. I could be low on the TDs, and it is possible that he has a higher ypr (I lowered it from what he had last year, I don't think that will be sustainable)...but it looks like I will actually not own Julio at all. Just a short week ago I thought I would own him most places, and month ago I thought I would ALWAYS have him.
Result: WR11 - exactly one spot above his teammate, Roddy White. This result is going to lead into my next observation:
3. WRs are even closer together than everyone says.
My VBD results have Calvin at 60+, Nicks and Andre at 30+, and then six guys with 20-29, 2 guys at 18, and another 5 guys with 7-10 VBD. Calvin is far and away my #1 wideout, and I have him regressing a decent amount based on the unsustainability of Detroit's passing game last year as well as his TDs.
4. I love Marques Colston - Projection: 91/1274/8
Now, keep in mind that I project everyone for a full 16 games (except Mathews, Lynch types - suspended or already injured with a recovery timetable) because I think you can't predict injury. That being said: These numbers are surprisingly in line with Colston's typical targets and receptions per game, his career TD%, and his normal ypr. Meachem is gone, so I ended up giving him a little bit more on the targets side of things, but overall, these are less surprising than they first appear if you do some research (which I did when I found I had Colston in the top 10...)
Result: WR7 - Brees is literally the only QB with an extended history of throwing more than 620 times, for near/over 5000 yards. Colston is his top wideout, and with Meachem gone and none of the rookies looking healthy and able to step up, I think quite a few of the Saints players are undervalued. Lance Moore, Colston, Graham (even at his lofty ADP), and even Sproles.
5. I have both Miles Austin and Steve Johnson in the top 20 WRs, and they are the only two of mine with an ADP round 5 or later. Austin is the only guy I see in the top 15 with a round 5+ ADP. Looks like a value play to me!
Long story short: Miles Austin, when he and Romo are healthy, has always played like a top 5 wideout. I'm actually knocking him down because of Dez's improvement in placing him at WR9 or so. With Witten's potential issues, Austin could be leaned on more than ever. There's a lot of upside there, especially at his ADP.
Johnson is consistent, a clear #1 target, and on a team that will have at least a couple shootouts with their schedule. I like him a lot as a WR2/3/flex
Last edited by a moderator: