the moops said:
Smarge said:
There's not one GM in the league that would choose Melo over Rose at this point when building a team.
I am quite sure there are at least a few who would do so.Carmelo Anthony is only 26 years old. His previous 2 years, and this year, have been better than Rose's.Yes, Derrick Rose has the chance of being a better ball player than Carmelo. He isn't there yet though, and he may never get there.
Rose is four years younger, and plays a premium position. He's improved every season, and is playing near MVP level this season. He's been better than Melo this season. I like Melo and think he's probably worth a max contract for the Nets if they can get him, but I just had to interject when I saw your comments about Rose.
A premium position that nearly half of the NBA has an All Star level talent (Paul, Williams, Nash, Westbrook, Rose, Harris, Curry, Parker, Rondo, Wall, Billups, Kidd) plus another half dozen or so that can legitimately start for a playoff team (Felton, Stuckey, Miller, Jennings, Nelson, M Williams, Collison, Conley, Brooks, Arenas) plus another few that could be very good starters soon (Lawson, Holliday, Bledsoe), while there are 6-7 all star level SFs (Lebron, Durant, Melo, Pierce, Gay, Grander and maybe Wallace) and another 7-8 solid starters (Chandler, Marion, Batum, Deng, AK 47, Artest, Jefferson and maybe Maggette) and only a couple up and comers (Aminu, Budinger, and I still like Terrence Williams).And I've made this argument against Rose before and I'll do it again quickly here, he as improved two things significantly in his game in 3 years. He has gone from being one of the worst defenders in the NBA to merely just a below average defender and he has improved his shot taking (not making) ability. You see these huge per game stats because he is playing 40 minutes per game and taking more shots per game than anybody since Melo and Kobe in 2006-2007 (who shot 0.4 and 0.8 more shots per game respectively and scored 2.3 and 5 points more per game). He has nearly three times as many shots per game as assists, that is an incredible statistic for a PG. He is 46th is Assist Ratio, 19th in TO ratio, and 18th in rebound rate. As a rookie he was 39th, 18th, and 25th.