Need some help.... (1 Viewer)

[My Ditka]

Hey - normally I feel pretty comfortable with my lineup decisions but I could use some help this year...

.5/tackle or assist

2/sack

3/int,ff,fr

3/td

LBs (choose 3)

Zach Thomas

Mike Peterson

Demeco Ryans

Dan Morgan

Kawika Mitchell

Gerald Hayes

DBs (choose 2)

Michael Lewis

Peanut Tillman

Ronde Barber

My initial thought was Morgan, Ryans and Thomas for LBs and Lewis and Barber for DBs but I am on the fence!

 

[The Gator]

I'd go

Zach Thomas

Demeco Ryans

Kawika Mitchell

Michael Lewis

Ronde Barber

 

[StuntRock]

Hey - normally I feel pretty comfortable with my lineup decisions but I could use some help this year...

.5/tackle or assist

2/sack

3/int,ff,fr

3/td

LBs (choose 3)

Zach Thomas

Mike Peterson

Demeco Ryans

Dan Morgan

Kawika Mitchell

Gerald Hayes

DBs (choose 2)

Michael Lewis

Peanut Tillman

Ronde Barber

My initial thought was Morgan, Ryans and Thomas for LBs and Lewis and Barber for DBs but I am on the fence!

I'd got Thomas, Ryans, Morgan, like you were thinking. As for DBs, I'd go with Lewis and Barber also. I find myself in a similar predicament. I've got my starters in bold.DL (Choose 3)

James, Erasmus MIN DE

Kampman, Aaron GBP DE

Kearse, Jevon PHI DE

Rucker, Mike CAR DE

Suggs, Terrell BAL DE

LB (Choose 3)

Bruschi, Tedy NEP LB

Crowell, Angelo BUF LB

Edwards, Donnie SDC LB

Haggans, Clark PIT LB

Harris, Napoleon MIN LB

Sims, Ernie DET LB

Smith, Derek M SFO LB

DB (Choose 3)

Clements, Nate BUF CB

Boulware, Michael SEA S

Dawkins, Brian PHI S

Wilson, Gibril NYG S

I'm a bit on t he fence with LBs, because I've seen no news on Donnie Edwards, and Derek Smith racks up tackles but has no big play ability it seems.

 

[My Ditka]

If Donnie Edwards plays, you have to start him......

 

[StuntRock]

If Donnie Edwards plays, you have to start him......

Is he playing is my question.

 

[alg]

I'd goZach ThomasDemeco RyansKawika MitchellMichael LewisRonde Barber

I concur.

 

[alg]

DL (Choose 3)

James, Erasmus MIN DE

Kampman, Aaron GBP DE

Kearse, Jevon PHI DE

Rucker, Mike CAR DE

Suggs, Terrell BAL DE

LB (Choose 3)

Bruschi, Tedy NEP LB

Crowell, Angelo BUF LB

Edwards, Donnie SDC LB

Haggans, Clark PIT LB

Harris, Napoleon MIN LB

Sims, Ernie DET LB

Smith, Derek M SFO LB

DB (Choose 3)

Clements, Nate BUF CB

Boulware, Michael SEA S

Dawkins, Brian PHI S

Wilson, Gibril NYG S

DL (Choose 3)James, Erasmus MIN DE

Kampman, Aaron GBP DE

Kearse, Jevon PHI DE

Rucker, Mike CAR DE

Suggs, Terrell BAL DE

A case can be made for Rucker as well.

LB (Choose 3)

Bruschi, Tedy NEP LB

Crowell, Angelo BUF LB

Edwards, Donnie SDC LB

Haggans, Clark PIT LB

Harris, Napoleon MIN LB

Sims, Ernie DET LB

Smith, Derek M SFO LB

Smith looks like a safer, more consistant bet.

DB (Choose 3)

Clements, Nate BUF CB

Boulware, Michael SEA S

Dawkins, Brian PHI S

Wilson, Gibril NYG S

Tough call, but I'd have a hard time leaving Nate's big play potential on the bench - if your scoring system is similar to the original post. And that is before accounting for the change to cover 2.

 

[StuntRock]

DL (Choose 3)

James, Erasmus MIN DE

Kampman, Aaron GBP DE

Kearse, Jevon PHI DE

Rucker, Mike CAR DE

Suggs, Terrell BAL DE

LB (Choose 3)

Bruschi, Tedy NEP LB

Crowell, Angelo BUF LB

Edwards, Donnie SDC LB

Haggans, Clark PIT LB

Harris, Napoleon MIN LB

Sims, Ernie DET LB

Smith, Derek M SFO LB

DB (Choose 3)

Clements, Nate BUF CB

Boulware, Michael SEA S

Dawkins, Brian PHI S

Wilson, Gibril NYG S

DL (Choose 3)James, Erasmus MIN DE

Kampman, Aaron GBP DE

Kearse, Jevon PHI DE

Rucker, Mike CAR DE

Suggs, Terrell BAL DE

A case can be made for Rucker as well.

LB (Choose 3)

Bruschi, Tedy NEP LB

Crowell, Angelo BUF LB

Edwards, Donnie SDC LB

Haggans, Clark PIT LB

Harris, Napoleon MIN LB

Sims, Ernie DET LB

Smith, Derek M SFO LB

Smith looks like a safer, more consistant bet.

DB (Choose 3)

Clements, Nate BUF CB

Boulware, Michael SEA S

Dawkins, Brian PHI S

Wilson, Gibril NYG S

Tough call, but I'd have a hard time leaving Nate's big play potential on the bench - if your scoring system is similar to the original post. And that is before accounting for the change to cover 2.

To clarify, turnovers are heavily weighted and points are given for passes defensed.