'Allo Guvnuh's why don't you pour yourselves a cuppa or maybe a pint of your best bitter while I talk about Jolly Olde, yeah?
I have to admit that I find this England team fascinating. On paper, it might be the least accomplished England team that I can remember, but on the other hand, Ithink Gareth Southgate has put a lot of thought into how he wants the team to play and has constructed a roster that makes sense. This is really a test about the adage of whether its' about picking the best players or picking the best team. So let's get to it.
Formation: Southgate is going with a very un-English 3-5-2/5-3-2. And he's playing one of the best attacking right backs in the world as a right-sided center back. Gutsy! But I figure they'll burn him in effigy if England underperforms in any way so he might as well not throw away his shot.
GK - Jack Butland, Jordan Pickford, Nick Pope
Yikes! Remember when England was known for churning out world class goalkeepers? Gordon Banks, Peter Shilton, David Seaman, Ray Clemence, heck even David James. This lot, ..., is a step down. Butland got relegated with Stoke this year. Pickford was relegated with Sunderland last year (and didn't really set the world on fire this season with Everton although I suppose he passed the "better than Joel Robles" test). I had to wiki to remeber that Pope started for the Ginger Mourinho's Burnley side. Pickford started the Nigeria friendly and has been tabbed as England's next great goalkeeper ever since he was being kept on the bench by Vito Mannone and Costel Pantillimon. I am unconvinced. Butland and Pope are, to me, perfectly acceptable goalkeepers. You can make a decent run in the World Cup with perfectly acceptable goalkeeping. Jesper Cillison and the Netherlands did so in Brazil. But I don't think you can count on one of these guys to stand on his head to steal a victory from an otherwise dominating team.
Defenders: Gary Cahill, John Stones, Kyle Walker, Kieran Trippier, Ashley Young, Danny Rose, Harry Maguire, Phil Jones, Trent-Alexander Arnold
Southgate has played Walker as a RCB in the last two friendlies. He's stated that he wants Walker's skill on the ball in that position. It's a ballsy move, but I understand the rationale. It also leaves room for Trippier. Whatever else you can say about Kieran Trippier, he hits an exquisite right-footed early cross. And Harry Kane positively feeds on those type of crosses. In the early part of this last season, John Stones put together an amazing run of form for Pep Guardiola. He finally seemed to be putting together all the potential that everyone saw in him. He got injured, though, and was not nearly as good after coming back. Stones, like Walker, is extremely comfortable on the ball. Some might say he's too confident on the ball, but with three good distributors in the back (Cahill is also a very good passer out of the back), Southgate saves the need to start a distributing holding midfield and can just play a pure anchor man and two attacking CM's. Young started the Nigeria friendly at LWB. Rose has been penciled in that slot for a while, even as he rotted away on Spurs's bench. Rose dealt with a ton of stuff this year, from his injury, to a family suicide, to his mum getting racially abused. So I'm pulling for him.
Midfield: Eric Dier, Jessie Lingard, Dele Alli, Jordan Henderson, Ruben Loftus-Cheek, Fabian Delph
Dier will play as the 6. As I mention above, because the center backs all pass the ball well, a distributor like Henderson isn't necessary. Which allows Southgate to play two CAMs in Alli and Lingard. Lingard seemed to take an inordinate amount of #### from Man U fans for the sin of being the second-best offensive threat on the second-best team in the league. Weird. Alli was in Southgate's doghouse and had lost his job to Lingard, but they looked bright playing together. You could easily see Henderson, Delph, or Loftus-Cheek playing in a game where Southgate might not expect to have a lot of the ball, but he seems to be inclined to go for it in general. This is another example of whether "fit" matters more than sheer talent. There's not a Scholes, a Lampard, or a Gerrard here. Alli may have that type of career, but he's still young. But you can see how this group fits together, which you often couldn't in the years that managers were constantly trying to find a way to play Gerrard and Lamps together.
Forwards: Harry Kane, Raheem Sterling, Marcus Rashford, Jamie Vardy, Danny Welbeck
So much pressure will be on Kane. He's England's one uncontested world-class player and this formation has been tweaked to suit his strengths. I love the idea of playing Sterling centrally to stretch the CBs. The four attackers are going to be very fluid, and Kane's underrated passing should mesh well with Sterling's excellent movement. Welbeck is a bit of a surprise, but he's been excellent for England, for whatever reason. Almost any one of these forwards can play on at least one wing if Southgate has to change a system.
Projected Lineup:
Pickford
Walker Stones Cahill
Trippier Dier Rose
Lingard Alli
Sterling Kane
Projected Finish:
I like England as surprise group G winners over Belgium. But the draw seems destined to leave them with either Brazil or Germany in the quarterfinals. I think they'll be credible quarterfinalists, but that's a far as they'll go.