It's not my gut, and it wasn't my gut with Barry
specifically regarding the New Orleans area. It was specific bits of information coming from meteorologists combined with knowledge of how storms typically form and behave. You had to read between the hedges, and you had to look past the "
New Orleans gotta evacuate NOW!" sensationalism, but the
information necessary for New Orleanians to come to a sense of ease about Barry was available and disseminated by last Thursday evening.
We'll have to come to a common definition of "take seriously". When Barry was still Invest 92 back on Sunday 7/7 - Tuesday 7/9, "taking it seriously" meant watching the forecasts and gathering information. It did not mean packing the car right then and there and leaving town. When Wednesday's news of dry air choking the system came out, "taking it seriously" meant continuing to watch and gather information -- mainly checking to see if the dry air intake was being maintained, and checking on the storm's movement. Also on Wednesday, I took Barry seriously by countenancing an extended power outage and thus stocked up on non-perishable groceries, batteries, and fresh water -- preparations to shelter in place in our
X-zone neighborhood (more
information -- I know our immediate area's flood risk).
So Thursday comes, and Barry finally limps to TS strength, but keeps drifting westward and keeps taking in dry air and keeps failing to form an eyewall. It was also noted by then that the rainfall amounts observed over the Gulf reduced significantly when those same bands passed over land. Still keep watching, of course ... but IMHO by Thursday evening the threat to New Orleans was reasonably known to be significantly minimized, even if a pro meteorologist would never
guarantee it on air.
Please keep in mind that my focus here -- as was much of the media's -- is and was on the outcome in the New Orleans area. I never said nowhere, anywhere would get any kind of real effect from Barry.
Henry Ford and I were discussing the rain models last Thursday night and during the day Friday in this thread -- models that I linked to in this thread for others to view. I never wrote "
Those models are BS!" I wrote that those models showed that Barry would spare New Orleans of city-wide flood-event rainfall and that the worst impacts would be some distance west of the city. Repeating on the theme from above, those models were yet more
information -- not gut -- leading to a sense of ease
specifically for the New Orleans area.
...
The story of the pregnant lady and her son losing their life in a flash flood is crushingly sad, to be sure. But those kinds of situations are categorically different than an impending tropical storm. That kind of flash flood doesn't give you three or four days notice. You can't watch it progressively and see what's coming. What happened to that lady and her son was more akin to a meteor strike -- just cruel fate.