GB - I respect you a lot. I’m sad we disagree on this topic, but we do
I do not believe it is the govt responsibility to find me a job that a like. I don’t believe it is their responsibility to let me live in the place I want to live and spend the way I want to spend.
I believe in personal responsibility. I believe there will be times the govt needs to step in to help. I believe that is healthy.
However, I think what you are describing is unhealthy. What I’m hearing you say is that if I can’t find the job I like, in the place I want to live, the the govt should step in and help.
However, if there are zero jobs, that’s a huge difference between not having a job you like. For example, if Costco or Amazon is hiring nearby and you were a waitress that was laid off and collecting unemployment, well ... get to the store and start stocking shelves.
All that said, I think this highlights why in our country we need a living wage and not a minimum wage.
I don't believe we disagree as much as you think. Not sure if my point is being poorly communicated or not, but I'll try to clarify.
You suggested that the folks in the hospitality industry "get another job" - that's 15 MILLION people. My contention is WHAT other job will they get? It has nothing to do with willingness to work, which seems to be what you suggest (almost every one of my friends is looking to do anything, that includes stocking shelves, and they'd be ecstatic to get $15 bucks an hour for it right now - they are also busting their asses trying to come up with innovative ways to make some scratch. One-on-one video or in person cocktail making tips, private server or bartending services while people are camped up at home... but that doesn't work for even the best of servers, who can make $60-150k a year).
My point is willing or not, there are $15 million people, mostly unemployed / furloughed right now. There will be what, a few hundred thousand temporary jobs at Costco, WalMart, Grocery chains? What do you suggest for the other 10 or so million?
You seem to assume these people aren't willing to work stocking shelves. They are. That was my point, that you don't seem to understand the reality of how certain industries (hospitality in this case) are being hit. There are very few other jobs to go to, and other than what we agree upon re: stocking shelves, which is limited in number, almost no one is hiring.
To your last point, I agree THOUSAND percent. These people work hard. Harder than most I know. Often 15 hour days. They deserve a living wage. Not only deserve it, but for the economic standing of our nation, we have made ourselves WEAK because our economy is in no position to withstand any such jolt as we are seeing today. Because folks have low wages, multiple jobs, too much $$ spent on housing and transportation (and what is left is spent too often on materialism fed by the constant push of commercialism and greed in our nation) AND no health insurance. The result is what we see now...
When there are no - or very few - other jobs available, there is no outlet. Even for folks willing to work as hard as anyone.
Hope that helps clarify my point.