Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.
****OFFICIAL DYNASTY TRADES**** (7 Viewers)
- Thread starter Gottabesweet
- Start date
JohnnyU
Footballguy
Fair deal for a COP back, but I probably prefer Schultz and the pick.
Dez
Footballguy
-OZ-
Footballguy
I’d really have to think about it. Seems fair. I wouldn’t be opposed to making stroud my cornerstone QB at that price if I’m building.
-OZ-
Footballguy
B/B imo. But then I still think Bryce can be a good QB.
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
That’s tough. I don’t love either QB. I’m probably on the Murray side because I’ve seen him play at a high level &
CAR looks like a dumpster fire.
Now that there were a couple of responses, I am the Kyler/DK side. I had a tough time pulling the trigger, but I have been building this team for 3 years after tearing it down (had won back to back and gotten old). My QBs were Caleb, Bryce, and McCarthy (ok, maybe O'Connell too, but you get the point). We only need to start 2 RBs and I had an advantage there because I also have Gibbs, but not enough to make up for the QB loss (unless Bryce really bounced back). I still have Gibbs and drafted Brooks (ok, Carolina dumpster fire, but maybe he's the exception). My WRs are solid with DK becoming my 3 after AJ and Olave. So, this becomes - is Kyler, Caleb, and Brooks enough and what does Bryce do (so, do I regret it?). But, it was good for both teams, so good trade in my mind/.
12 team - 1qb - ppr - all picks involved should be mid to late. Only start 9 (qb, 5 rb/wr, te, k, d)
Trade 1:
Give - 2025 picks - 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 5th & 2026 5th
Get - A. Richardson
Trade 2:
Give - Nabers, J Cook, R Davis, Mixon, M Thomas, Stafford
Get - CMC, E Mitchell, M Pittman, NE Def, D. Watson, 2025 2nd & 3rd.
My qb room was Stafford/Carr
.
Trade 1:
Give - 2025 picks - 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 5th & 2026 5th
Get - A. Richardson
Trade 2:
Give - Nabers, J Cook, R Davis, Mixon, M Thomas, Stafford
Get - CMC, E Mitchell, M Pittman, NE Def, D. Watson, 2025 2nd & 3rd.
My qb room was Stafford/Carr
.
JohnnyU
Footballguy
Seems a little much for AR in a start 1QB league, but I get the rushing upside IF he can stay on the field. I prefer the Nabers, side of the second trade if it's a dynasty league.12 team - 1qb - ppr - all picks involved should be mid to late. Only start 9 (qb, 5 rb/wr, te, k, d)
Trade 1:
Give - 2025 picks - 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 5th & 2026 5th
Get - A. Richardson
Trade 2:
Give - Nabers, J Cook, R Davis, Mixon, M Thomas, Stafford
Get - CMC, E Mitchell, M Pittman, NE Def, D. Watson, 2025 2nd & 3rd.
My qb room was Stafford/Carr
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
win. 5 TBD rookies with only 1 1st for a dude who went 1.02-1.04 with a massive FF ceiling? Yes please.ETA - whoops. 1 QB.
I still like it. Rushing QBs give a big advantage in 1 QB
That’s a lot to digest.Trade 2:
Give - Nabers, J Cook, R Davis, Mixon, M Thomas, Stafford
Get - CMC, E Mitchell, M Pittman, NE Def, D. Watson, 2025 2nd & 3rd.
My qb room was Stafford/Carr
getting CMC/Watson is solid, but I’m not sure I wouldn’t just roll out Carr/Stafford until I needed to make a change.
Last edited:
eighsse2
Footballguy
1.02-1.04? In 1QB? Granted I think he did go 3 or 4 in our draft, but I was shocked by that. I'm pretty sure he was taken well past 1.04 in leagues pretty frequently.
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
I play in Superflex dynasty. He was a top 4 pick in every one of my leagues.
I read that hastily and didn’t realize it was 1 QB. My bad.
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
Seems fair. Depends on team needs.
I totally assumed that's what you thought when you said that.
He went between 1.9-2.4 in all my one start QB leagues, which was 9. But I keep saying not all one start QB leagues are the same, less teams and smaller rosters make them less valuable and that's what most of my leagues would be included as being.
He's the first QB and so far only QB I've ever used a first round rookie pick on in any of these leagues and some go back 13 years. Took him at 1.11 in a league I already had Mahomes. Will say what I've said before, feel like he'd have been the QB1 last year if healthy, huge if I know, and has that potential going forward. But while I generally push back on "injury prone label" as a myth some players give me pause and make me rethink that position, and a player who left 3 games early out of 4 is that kind of player. If I remember that correctly.
In the case of that trade I'd probably have to take the picks, that's just my nature on how I value QB's in a one start QB league, at least the one's I play in, but not sure many are still left who are denying his enormous potential.
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
Yeah, the one reason I still don’t mind it is ARich rushing upside gives a team a big advantage even in that format.
With Richardson the allure is of course what he has shown in limited action but also faith in Steichen and memories of Waldman's film review saying he could be the next superstar (with added consistency). I wonder what the time spent watching from the sidelines will do for him. We will see how much he passes and if he gets to show off his deep ball. I want him everywhere with the caveat that in single QB leagues, I will want my QB2 to be among my top 20-22 ranked QB's
joey
Footballguy
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
JohnnyU
Footballguy
I expect a 6th year breakout
-OZ-
Footballguy
Very fair. I don’t think I’d give Kincaid and a first for CMC in the league it might make sense but it’s definitely fair.
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
Dez
Footballguy
FFPC 1 QB (not involved) reminder we have to cut down to 20 players before the season and down to 14 position players on March 31st every year.
The guy trading for all the players now has 31 players on his roster
Mike Evans and a 2025 2nd
for
Abanikanda, Israel (RB), NYJ
Bigsby, Tank (RB), JAC
Rodriguez, Chris (RB), WAS
Lloyd, MarShawn (RB), GB
Gore, Frank (RB), BUF
Guerendo, Isaac (RB), SF
Rice, Brenden (WR), LAC
Wilson, Roman (WR), PIT
The guy trading for all the players now has 31 players on his roster
Mike Evans and a 2025 2nd
for
Abanikanda, Israel (RB), NYJ
Bigsby, Tank (RB), JAC
Rodriguez, Chris (RB), WAS
Lloyd, MarShawn (RB), GB
Gore, Frank (RB), BUF
Guerendo, Isaac (RB), SF
Rice, Brenden (WR), LAC
Wilson, Roman (WR), PIT
JohnnyU
Footballguy
Yeah, but give the guy getting Aiyuk credit for taking advantage of Harris value while he can, even if it isn’t all that high. The 2nd was a nice gesture to help facilitate the trade.
JohnnyU
Footballguy
Roman wasn’t built in a day.
kutta
Footballguy
We only have 24 roster spots and I cut him in the offseason and he hasn’t been picked up yet.
joey
Footballguy
We have to cut down to 20 before week 1, and he’s definitely on the edge of the bench. Needs to show something in the preseason to be kept.We only have 24 roster spots and I cut him in the offseason and he hasn’t been picked up yet.
Boston
Footballguy
Very fair trade in SF.
-OZ-
Footballguy
I’ll take Caleb over AR. MHjr vs Caleb is almost a toss up in some SF, depending on scoring.
JohnnyU
Footballguy
I'm not so sure about that. AR rushing upside cannot be ignored. Of course some would have said the same thing about Justin Fields at one time, so AR must show he can be a complete QB. Let's not forget that Lamar Jackson once couldn't hit the ocean if he was standing two feet in front of it, so I think Richardson will show he's a better passer than Fields and could develop into a better passer than Jackson, which shouldn't be hard to do.
I’ll take Caleb over AR. MHjr vs Caleb is almost a toss up in some SF, depending on scoring.
-OZ-
Footballguy
I’m not sure what you’re basing this on. Other than hope. You probably watched more of his 84 nfl passes than I did, But did they really show Better accuracy than fields did as a rookie? The stats are too close and AR had better receivers to work with.
Richardson had one moderately successful year in college where his passing stats were clearly inferior to Lamar. Better conference I guess but that isn’t enough to build confidence in projecting Better accuracy in the NFL IMO. Don’t forget, AR was throwing to a future first round WR that year. Lamar had not much around him. Fields obviously did.
AR oozes of potential, but I’d sure bet on Caleb having a better career - meaning I have Caleb in one league, I’d not trade him for AR.
JohnnyU
Footballguy
I believe in Shane Steichen.
-OZ-
Footballguy
That’s fair.
Similar to why I think Levis can / will be the second best QB in the division.
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
Threw a dart.
16 team SF, TEP, IDP
I gave: Coby Parkinson
I rec’d: Trey Lance
I don’t even know if Lance wins the QB2 gig, but dude was looking for a TE, CP was my TE3, so I threw out the offer.
I figure in a 16 team SF it’s worth the cheap lottery ticket.
16 team SF, TEP, IDP
I gave: Coby Parkinson
I rec’d: Trey Lance
I don’t even know if Lance wins the QB2 gig, but dude was looking for a TE, CP was my TE3, so I threw out the offer.
I figure in a 16 team SF it’s worth the cheap lottery ticket.
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
I like Mixon a lot this year but I’m not sure I’d pay Coleman for him - I’m not the biggest believer in Coleman, but I’d want to wait to see. Seems like a player whose value could skyrocket if things break right.
Boston
Footballguy
Interesting deal because of the format...agree with your logic...that contract does make Parkinson intriguing in this format but with a 16 team SF you gotta roll the dice on Lance.
Boston
Footballguy
Good cash-out on Mixon unless your team is really close and thin at RB...if that is the case I would ride him out one more year...if not then this is a very nice deal for a rookie WR that has a ton of upside.
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
I like getting the 1et but I’d rather have Walker.The perils of making an offer before having yourin the morning. I saw the offer was accepted when I went to withdraw.
12 team SF
Ken Walker, 2025 3rd (probably late)
For
Tony pollard, 2025 1st (probably late)
-OZ-
Footballguy
Understood. I think pollard is undervalued but I should have gotten more back for Walker.I like getting the 1et but I’d rather have Walker.The perils of making an offer before having your
12 team SF
Ken Walker, 2025 3rd (probably late)
For
Tony pollard, 2025 1st (probably late)
