What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.

****OFFICIAL DYNASTY TRADES**** (4 Viewers)

Offered to me - 1/2 PPR

Get - Nabers and Pacheco
Give - CMC and 2025 1st Round Pick (should be late)
That would be a smash accept from me. This feels like one of those years that CMC is banged up all season.
I accepted…I know it was the right thing to do from an age perspective and the upside of Nabers.
Smart move. Nabers is likely a flex play at best this season, but once they jettison Danny Dimes, the sky is the limit.
 
1QB PPR

Etienne

For

Jayden Reed

Fair deal...out of curiosity what are the starting line-up positions? This deal really depends on current rosters...I can see a case made for either side based on whether you are RB-needy or WR-needy...in a vacuum I would take Reed because I am a WR-first Owner and I cash out on RBs rather early...and I am a big believer in Reed.
 
12 team ppr. No TE premium.

Gave: Bowers, 2025 3rd (early)
Received: McBride, 2025 2nd (late)

I like what you did here...they are both young so that part is a push but McBride has more of a track record and until I see the Raider QB situation actually get solved I don't think it's a bad move to pass on it for a similar talent in a better situation...the pick-swap really isn't necessary but why not take it if you can.
 
12 team ppr. No TE premium.

Gave: Bowers, 2025 3rd (early)
Received: McBride, 2025 2nd (late)

I like what you did here...they are both young so that part is a push but McBride has more of a track record and until I see the Raider QB situation actually get solved I don't think it's a bad move to pass on it for a similar talent in a better situation...the pick-swap really isn't necessary but why not take it if you can.
Interesting .... in my TE-P 12 Team (start 1-3 TE)
The McBride owner told me I had to include a mid-2nd with Bowers & Mayer (both TE) for McBride ... no pick coming back... he is in Full Rebuild
For which I declined further trade discussions
 
12 team ppr. No TE premium.

Gave: Bowers, 2025 3rd (early)
Received: McBride, 2025 2nd (late)

I like what you did here...they are both young so that part is a push but McBride has more of a track record and until I see the Raider QB situation actually get solved I don't think it's a bad move to pass on it for a similar talent in a better situation...the pick-swap really isn't necessary but why not take it if you can.
Interesting .... in my TE-P 12 Team (start 1-3 TE)
The McBride owner told me I had to include a mid-2nd with Bowers & Mayer (both TE) for McBride ... no pick coming back... he is in Full Rebuild
For which I declined further trade discussions
The other owner was in heavy pursuit.
He initially offered me Stevenson and late 2025 1st (best team in league). I declined and he kept coming. He asked about McBride and I asked for a piece on top since I knew he really wanted Bowers. I was fine keeping Bowers since my TE room is just fine without him (Pitts, Likely).
 
12 team ppr. No TE premium.

Gave: Bowers, 2025 3rd (early)
Received: McBride, 2025 2nd (late)

I like what you did here...they are both young so that part is a push but McBride has more of a track record and until I see the Raider QB situation actually get solved I don't think it's a bad move to pass on it for a similar talent in a better situation...the pick-swap really isn't necessary but why not take it if you can.
Interesting .... in my TE-P 12 Team (start 1-3 TE)
The McBride owner told me I had to include a mid-2nd with Bowers & Mayer (both TE) for McBride ... no pick coming back... he is in Full Rebuild
For which I declined further trade discussions

I actually get that request more than what happened in the deal we are breaking-down.
 
Just got an offer for Baker Mayfield in 1QB dynasty.
My other QBs are Stroud and Rodgers.
I only have Baker for one more year.
He had Tua and Russell Wilson.
Offered me a 2025 3rd rounder.
I am in Second year of a rebuild and a .500 team.
I need RBs and WRs bad now.
He had excess WRs (contract years left)
McLaurin (2)
D. Johnson (2)
Waddle (1) with very high salary
I suggested them or his 2nd for my 4th in return.
 
12 team ppr. No TE premium.

Gave: Bowers, 2025 3rd (early)
Received: McBride, 2025 2nd (late)

I like what you did here...they are both young so that part is a push but McBride has more of a track record and until I see the Raider QB situation actually get solved I don't think it's a bad move to pass on it for a similar talent in a better situation...the pick-swap really isn't necessary but why not take it if you can.
Looks like a good deal for you
 
Rebuilding FFPC team.

Mason & Dowdle for

2025 2nd (mid to late) and Luke McCaffrey

Thoughts?
I think you could have gotten better for Mason alone. I wouldn't have moved him for that package let alone putting in Dowdle.
What would you want in return for Mason? Buyer has three rbs. Has Hockenson, JSN..
If you could get JSN, I would do that deal. In dynasty, I don't view Mason or Dowdle as long term answers. With a rebuild, you can get a starter with 2nd round pick.
 
Standard FFPC:

Team A gets: MHJ and Mostert

Team B gets: Jayden Reed, Jordan Mason and projected late 2025 second round pick.
Wow. That seems really cheap for MHJ.
I'm not sure that I would be ready to give up on Harrison this quickly. He had only played one game.
100% agreement.

Jayden Reed is really good. If he ever can get to a point he stops coming off the field in 2 WR sets his upside is kind of massive. But I don't see that changing anytime soon, and even if he was the apple of your eye there are cheaper ways to go about it.

At minimum if you are going to panic on MHJ you should shop him around. That did not happen and this is just bad value and I say that with the acknowledgement there is a scenario where Jayden Reed is playing in two WR sets at some point in his career and doing prime Antonio Brown kind of things.
 
Superflex

Minshew

For

Bryce Young
I'm on the Young side. He has at least another year to get right in Carolina before they move in another direction. We know who Minshew is at this point. Solid backup, not good as a starter.
I'd be on the Young side as well except I'd be hoping Carolina moves on sooner then later, which I think is a possibility as soon as the 2025 off-season in light of fact they might be picking 1 or 2.

This should not construed as absolving Young for his poor play but I was thinking the other day that before Carolina he had only played with powerhouse football teams. Alabama and Mater Dei. He's not showing any ability to elevate a team, but perhaps being on a strong football team can get him closer to operating like how he was expected? Then I think of stuff like the Rams are taking Stafford's contract and future with them one year at a time and what could someone like Sean McVay due for his career?
 

This should not construed as absolving Young for his poor play but I was thinking the other day that before Carolina he had only played with powerhouse football teams. Alabama and Mater Dei. He's not showing any ability to elevate a team, but perhaps being on a strong football team can get him closer to operating like how he was expected? Then I think of stuff like the Rams are taking Stafford's contract and future with them one year at a time and what could someone like Sean McVay due for his career?

Do you really believe Tepper will admit the mistake and move on from his "investment" after 3-4 years at such a controlled financial impact?
I believe this has some legs.....
 
12 team superflex

Rebuilder gives Mike Evans, Josh Dobbs
Contender gives Spencer Rattler, Jameis Winston, 3rd/25, 1st/26
 

This should not construed as absolving Young for his poor play but I was thinking the other day that before Carolina he had only played with powerhouse football teams. Alabama and Mater Dei. He's not showing any ability to elevate a team, but perhaps being on a strong football team can get him closer to operating like how he was expected? Then I think of stuff like the Rams are taking Stafford's contract and future with them one year at a time and what could someone like Sean McVay due for his career?

Do you really believe Tepper will admit the mistake and move on from his "investment" after 3-4 years at such a controlled financial impact?
I believe this has some legs.....
Yes and if his play does not improve I'll actually be surprised if he's on their team in 2025.

Teams are cutting losses and moving on quickly after failed big time QB investments with increased regularity. Different trade/draft capital but Russ Wilson, Zach Wilson, Lance, Justin Fields and Josh Rosen spring to mind over the last few seasons.

Add in Tepper being short fused and most of all fact they likely are sitting on top of the draft board and I'll say Young will need to play consdierably better to remain a member of the team next year.
 
Offered to me - 1/2 PPR

Get - Nabers and Pacheco
Give - CMC and 2025 1st Round Pick (should be late)
That would be a smash accept from me. This feels like one of those years that CMC is banged up all season.
I accepted…I know it was the right thing to do from an age perspective and the upside of Nabers.
Slam dunk. I’m shocked anyone would give up Nabers like that.

Pacheco is a nice piece for this year at least - I don’t love him long term nor do I think he’s a special RB, but I’d make that trade 100/100 times.
 
Standard FFPC:

Team A gets: MHJ and Mostert

Team B gets: Jayden Reed, Jordan Mason and projected late 2025 second round pick.
Panic sell of MH2 after 1 game.

I’m betting they earned that 1.01

That said, I do like Reed. I like Mason, too, but investing in Shanny RBs is a dicey proposition for the future.
 
Last edited:
12 Team PPR TE+ 1 QB (Start 10) --> Going SF 2026

Team A gives up Sam Darnold Min QB
Team B gives up George Kittle TE + 2025 3rd (mid?)

Team B has Tua, Bryce Young and Brissett so he needed to make a move for his Compete Now Roster (ETN, Gibbs, Chase, Nico, London, Pittman)
 

This should not construed as absolving Young for his poor play but I was thinking the other day that before Carolina he had only played with powerhouse football teams. Alabama and Mater Dei. He's not showing any ability to elevate a team, but perhaps being on a strong football team can get him closer to operating like how he was expected? Then I think of stuff like the Rams are taking Stafford's contract and future with them one year at a time and what could someone like Sean McVay due for his career?

Do you really believe Tepper will admit the mistake and move on from his "investment" after 3-4 years at such a controlled financial impact?
I believe this has some legs.....
Yes and if his play does not improve I'll actually be surprised if he's on their team in 2025.

Teams are cutting losses and moving on quickly after failed big time QB investments with increased regularity. Different trade/draft capital but Russ Wilson, Zach Wilson, Lance, Justin Fields and Josh Rosen spring to mind over the last few seasons.

Add in Tepper being short fused and most of all fact they likely are sitting on top of the draft board and I'll say Young will need to play consdierably better to remain a member of the team next year.
He is lacking at RB. He has Kupp, Deebo, Lamb and JAMO at WR (and drafted Nabers at #2 this year).
 
12 Team PPR TE+ 1 QB (Start 10) --> Going SF 2026

Team A gives up Sam Darnold Min QB
Team B gives up George Kittle TE + 2025 3rd (mid?)

Team B has Tua, Bryce Young and Brissett so he needed to make a move for his Compete Now Roster (ETN, Gibbs, Chase, Nico, London, Pittman)
I’m actually on the Darnold side here.

I think he’s going to parlay this good situation into a starting gig next year.
 
12 Team PPR TE+ 1 QB (Start 10) --> Going SF 2026

Team A gives up Sam Darnold Min QB
Team B gives up George Kittle TE + 2025 3rd (mid?)

Team B has Tua, Bryce Young and Brissett so he needed to make a move for his Compete Now Roster (ETN, Gibbs, Chase, Nico, London, Pittman)
I’m actually on the Darnold side here.

I think he’s going to parlay this good situation into a starting gig next year.
What surprised me was the pick on the other side. I would have expected it to with Sam for Kittle but what do I know…:bored:
 
Standard FFPC:

Team A gets: MHJ and Mostert

Team B gets: Jayden Reed, Jordan Mason and projected late 2025 second round pick.
Panic sell of MH2 after 1 game.

I’m betting they earned that 1.01

That said, I do like Reed. I like Mason, too, but investing in Shanny RBs is a dicey proposition for the future.
No, it's a draft playoff and it was not even his original pick. I considered his team one of the main contenders entering the year, in large part because he absolutely crushed the 2023 rookie draft as well as anyone I've ever seen. But patience is not his virtue, undersold Gibbs after a few weeks last year as well.

Again I do think Reed has a lot of upside and obviously with news of today Mason's a massive help for right now. Still seems like a week one overreaction.
 
Standard FFPC:

Team A gets: MHJ and Mostert

Team B gets: Jayden Reed, Jordan Mason and projected late 2025 second round pick.
Panic sell of MH2 after 1 game.

I’m betting they earned that 1.01

That said, I do like Reed. I like Mason, too, but investing in Shanny RBs is a dicey proposition for the future.
agreed.

Reed looked Electric in the part of the game I watched but I do think MHJ is the better long term play. I assume this is some kind of Keeper/dynasty league?
 
Standard FFPC:

Team A gets: MHJ and Mostert

Team B gets: Jayden Reed, Jordan Mason and projected late 2025 second round pick.
Panic sell of MH2 after 1 game.

I’m betting they earned that 1.01

That said, I do like Reed. I like Mason, too, but investing in Shanny RBs is a dicey proposition for the future.
agreed.

Reed looked Electric in the part of the game I watched but I do think MHJ is the better long term play. I assume this is some kind of Keeper/dynasty league?
I've always assumed every trade posted here is a dynasty/keeper league.
 
Standard FFPC:

Team A gets: MHJ and Mostert

Team B gets: Jayden Reed, Jordan Mason and projected late 2025 second round pick.
Panic sell of MH2 after 1 game.

I’m betting they earned that 1.01

That said, I do like Reed. I like Mason, too, but investing in Shanny RBs is a dicey proposition for the future.
Excuse me for a minute. I'm going to go try and trade my Mason and some WR3 for MHJ.
 
Superflex

Minshew

For

Bryce Young

Easily Young...zero downside here...Young could be a bust and while it is ugly so far it is still early and all you gave up was a bridge QB for him (I don't see anyone ever committing to Minshew)...I do not understand the thinking behind this deal as far as Dynasty goes.
Young ........ Unless this is someone trying to dump a bad contract from Young's high draft position
 
FFPC Triflex

Team A gets: Ja’Marr Chase, Hockenson, Javon Baker, Musgrave

Team B gets: Nico Collins, Isaiah Likely, Ben Sinnot
Prefer chase and hock
Easily Chase and Hock. This looks like one of those "What's the worst trade you've been offered?" posts.

The balls to ask for Baker & Musgrave too!!!

I’m trying to understand your thought process because I don’t see it as egregious by any means.

Who do you think has a better season- Chase or Nico? Hock or Likely?
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top