Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.
SF
Derek Carr
For
Brian Thomas
I think Flowers is a little bit more then you are giving him credit, actually got him on a team with Devonta and feel like they are equal with respect to anticipated production. Which the point remains two solid young WR's but low end WR2 types- not even starting lineup locks and a late first for a stud young WR who has been the number one WR in redrafts since the off-season who is a foundation weekly lineup difference maker plus an extra roster spot. All day.
Give me Thomas, even in SF. It isn’t close IMO.SF
Derek Carr
For
Brian Thomas
I own both, pretty much can't give away Carr, would expect the amount of thinking time needed for the other party to press accept if I offered the same deal for Thomas to be two seconds tops. This one isn't close
Give me Thomas, even in SF. It isn’t close IMO.SF
Derek Carr
For
Brian Thomas
I own both, pretty much can't give away Carr, would expect the amount of thinking time needed for the other party to press accept if I offered the same deal for Thomas to be two seconds tops. This one isn't close
I still have Chase-Nico-Deebo as my top WRs so felt it was a risk I could take.
Because of team context, I like it from the POV of Flowers for Dotson and the 2nd...though Dotson has to re-emerge and earn targets (and most would prefer Flowers I bet). The question is Miller or Warren...I like both but prefer Miller. It's up in the air as to who will produce more. For this season, likely Warren...so another point in your favor to help make up the difference on the rest of the deal.
Just wanted to mention we probably don't see it a lot different and he's the first Ravens WR I've drafted since Lamar was the QB and it was at 1.11 and 2.4, he was not anyone I was targeting and only made an exception for him because I like his talent(and 2.4 was getting into easy button category and I also have Lamar in that league so fun pairing) . He only lasted that long because the rest of my league also hates investing in Lamar's WR's and I got Devonta in that same league because I traded for him from an owner who hated his sitiaution.
Give me Thomas, even in SF. It isn’t close IMO.SF
Derek Carr
For
Brian Thomas
I own both, pretty much can't give away Carr, would expect the amount of thinking time needed for the other party to press accept if I offered the same deal for Thomas to be two seconds tops. This one isn't close
I don’t even know how this is a trade. BTJ by a mile.
i basically traded my 2024 1st (ended up being 1.11) for him last year, BT went 2.01. QBs are hard to get in this league.
That seems like a bargain for cook.
Hard to walk away from Chase but you got the next 3 best assets in this trade after him so I like your side. I think Pickens has a pretty good year and AJB is a stud also. Chandler doesn't have much upside with Jones there so they are one asset combined really.
I will be the opposite of some of the others here. I do like Warren but I don't think its a guarantee that he will take over for Harris and is in line for a split again. I do think Kendre could take over for AK41 at some point though and I believe in Flowers over Dotson by a big margin. The 2nd makes it really close as long as its early but I probably decline this trade personally.
Both trades seem mostly fair in value but I would have taken your side in both of them. Good work.
Basically Brooks, a random 2025 1st and 2025 3rd for the 1.01 & a random 2025 2nd?
This is a terrible deal. Even if the 2nd was on the other side it wouldn't be enough. Like this should have had no 2nd going with C-Will and there should have been a 2026 1st included instead of the 3rd which isn't much as it sits.
IDK where the 2025's project to, but gotta figure 1.6 = 1 of em, so 5 2nd's and a 3rd for the other? I'll take the package you gave up.
Unless at least one of those returns a top 3 pick you gave up too much.
Let's hope they are lottery picks. Bottom 6 go into a lottery for equal shares at each spot.
I’m not a fan of a lottery for picks, especially if it isn’t weighted and the worst team isn’t guaranteed at least the 3rd pick. In dynasty bad teams need the high picks to get better. Otherwise you’re just begging for high turnover.
Yeah I wish it was a different method, but I just play in the league
How is this possible?
Is this a serious post? This trade actually went down?
Hall AND a first!
I think he equated Jacobs to the 1st. So it's Jacobs for 2025 1st and the Hall/Musgrove/Miller for Dillon/1.12/2025 3rd
I’m not complaining, been trying to get Hall for years. 20+ year Dynasty league. Draft starts next week. Owner was getting pick fever to have multiple firsts this year after sending his second last summer for Friermuth.
Not a robust Lockett guy here but 5.2 seems pretty cheap.
Yikes
Your leaguemate made an all-time horrific trade. I can’t believe you got a 1st back, too.
I’d rather have the 1.07 side, I like Dionte as a potential target vacuum in CAR.
That’s
the take-away here.
Yikes.
Just incredible.
I’m surprised you if all people being on the other side after you making a couple win now trades giving up future firsts…and most liking the other side of your trades.
Yep. I don’t protest trades but that’s horrendous
I think you’ll be starting 2 or 3 from your bench most of the year.
That’s The #2 reason these trades suck. They tend to increase the chances owners leave.
Probably, depends how they use those two firsts next week, unless Hall turns into a Dobbins/Javonte Williams etc with another injury. Knock on wood it doesn’t happen. Trading for RBs in general sucks. If Breece Hall was like a top five WR it probably looks even worse.
