That's actually all I really based my drafting on--ERA and WHIP (turns out that the ERA was useless, but I didn't know that--should have used OAV instead) and OBP and SLG. As a result, I have the lowest ERA, the highest OBP, and the best record in the league ...
There's an additional layer of complexity -- the WHIPs, OAVs, OBPs, and SLG numbers not only have to be good,
but they have to be as far away from the MLB averages in a given year as possible (per some of the more knowledgable guys on WIS forums).I have three old-time pitchers with single-season stats comparable to your studs. My guys perform less well in large part because in their third WIS seasons, their stats were not quite so far above the average as in other years.
Subtle thing, but it made a big difference.