Brunell4MVP
Footballguy
2. This leads me to Heinicke. And I don't want to get into a pissing contest with anyone so if you don't agree, cool please lay it on me but let's keep it civil ok? Anyways, it is these types of games that Heinicke's challenges really come out. And keep in mind I like Heinicke. I love Heinicke. I hope we keep him. But we gotta draft a guy or something. I'm tired of people saying "arm strength doesn't matter." Yes, it does. There were many throws down field where they ball took too long to get to the receiver. That gives DBs extra time to close and it does make a difference. EVen the play that McLaurin got injured. You got a guy with a stronger arm and he may get it to 17 before the close out by the DBs. And that is just one of many. The other thing is, when we get behind, he just takes too many risks and puts the ball into trouble. It's vs. Buffalo all over again. Heinicke's great run this year was when we were running lights out and playing with leads. Great. But in the NFL sometimes you have to play from behind. Your QB has to know how to do both. I just have questions about that with Heinicke. I love the guy. But don't think he can be our long term starter. I need to see more than "he's got 'it'. Here's the reality...we've seen "it" at times this year but not in many games like Buffalo or Dallas vs. a superior team. Tampa is the exception I would say...but you have to show "it" every game, not just when the game script is perfect...ok, rant off
I think we've pretty much all been saying this all season. Good guy. Fighter. Tough. Gamer. Leader. But not having the arm strength basically allows the defense to come after him as much as they want, and thus makes the OL look bad. And without McKissock and Thomas, he's missing his safety valves. I'm fine with them keeping him another year if they draft someone to groom, or trade for a player that needs time. But you could put Heinicke out there with the weapons on KC, LA, or TB and he's not winning a SB. you can look up any statistical category and he's like the 20th or worse. Except INTS where he's 5th.
This all comes down to having a QB that can win playoff games. Jonathan Allen, Chase Young, Montez Sweat, Jamin Davis, Daron Payne, Doctson, Scherff....you can 1st round draft all those guys you want but it doesn't mean a thing. You are better off swinging and missing on a Haskins and simply cutting him than you are getting players at positions that can easily be filled via FA. Young QBs under a team friendly rookie contract while you decide if they are the guy are all that matters. Everything else you can find on the open market. As for team like CHI and NYJ that roll through QBs ... the way not to be that is to draft multiple QBs or a QB every year. Within 8 games you should know if they are they guy. See WFT and Griffin/Cousins. Cousins ended up better long term.
Last edited by a moderator: