timschochet
Footballguy
A comment @djmich made in another thread, quoting Bertrand Russell about uncertainty, prompted this admission. I have been way too adamant in recent days about the involvement of Black Lives Matter in last summer’s rioting. Because I believed (and still do) that referring to those riots as “BLM/Antifa riots” was a deliberately false narrative designed to denigrate all of those who marched last summer in peaceful protest of the treatment of black youths by the nations’ police forces, I went too far in the other direction and attempted to absolve BLM of ALL involvement in the looting, rioting and violence.
The truth, as usual, appears to be murkier. I still believe that the majority of the violence was random and caused by young thugs unaffiliated with BLM or any other group. But in certain instances BLM members were involved, especially, it appears in the more organized Seattle and Portland protests. BLM’s leadership has also, sadly, gone out of its way at times to justify some of the violence and has made other extreme comments that could be viewed as encouragement. So I’m forced to acknowledge that I was at least partially wrong about this.
I’m still not sure about Antifa. My feeling is that their involvement this last summer is way overblown, as is their involvement in American society period. I see them as sort of a new version of the Weather Underground but in name only without specific incidents that can be laid at their feet. But I have no idea if I’m right about this.
The truth, as usual, appears to be murkier. I still believe that the majority of the violence was random and caused by young thugs unaffiliated with BLM or any other group. But in certain instances BLM members were involved, especially, it appears in the more organized Seattle and Portland protests. BLM’s leadership has also, sadly, gone out of its way at times to justify some of the violence and has made other extreme comments that could be viewed as encouragement. So I’m forced to acknowledge that I was at least partially wrong about this.
I’m still not sure about Antifa. My feeling is that their involvement this last summer is way overblown, as is their involvement in American society period. I see them as sort of a new version of the Weather Underground but in name only without specific incidents that can be laid at their feet. But I have no idea if I’m right about this.