What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.

Polamalu To Reprise Joe Greene's Coke Commercial (1 Viewer)

Andy Herron

Footballguy
Twenty-nine years after Joe Greene became a star in a Coca-Cola commercial, Troy Polamalu will be cast in the remake.

Polamalu, a four-time Pro Bowl strong safety, will reprise the role that Greene played in the 1980 Super Bowl ad. It too will be shown during the Super Bowl.

In the original commercial, Greene limps through a tunnel beneath the stands in obvious discomfort. A young boy offers him his Coke, and Greene finally accepts. He drinks it down and, as the kid slowly walks away, Greene breaks into a smile and says, "Hey, kid; catch!" and throws him his No. 75 game jersey.

That ad not only won a Clio, an award presented to those ads judged to be the best on television that season, but it has been judged the best Super Bowl commercial in history by many in the business.

This was an all-time classic ad. It'll be interesting to see how this turns out and/or goes over.

Being a Cowboys fan, I really, really hated the Steelers back then, but you couldn't help appreciating that commercial.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Twenty-nine years after Joe Greene became a star in a Coca-Cola commercial, Troy Polamalu will be cast in the remake.Polamalu, a four-time Pro Bowl strong safety, will revise the role that Greene played in the 1980 Super Bowl ad. It too will be shown during the Super Bowl.In the original commercial, Greene limps through a tunnel beneath the stands in obvious discomfort. A young boy offers him his Coke, and Greene finally accepts. He drinks it down and, as the kid slowly walks away, Greene breaks into a smile and says, "Hey, kid; catch!" and throws him his No. 75 game jersey.That ad not only won a Clio, an award presented to those ads judged to be the best on television that season, but it has been judged the best Super Bowl commercial in history by many in the business.This was an all-time classic ad. It'll be interesting to see how this turns out and/or goes over.Being a Cowboys fan, I really, really hated the Steelers back then, but you couldn't help appreciating that commercial.
The better ad would be for Greene to hand the coke to Polamalu. Or better yet, morph the kid from the original into Polamalu today (although the kid was white and he's Samoan, and the ages wouldn't match since he was born in '81).I just don't like blatant copies of old commericials/movies/songs etc, add some originality.
 
Here's the original commercial for all you young whippersnappers:

I wonder what the kid is going to say: "thanks, Troy P". :)

 
Not sure this will be as effective. It was "Mean" Joe Greene, and what was so good about the commercial was that this big, mean football player, who wasn't in a very good mood after getting hurt, suddenly found a soft heart after being given a Coke.

Not sure how this works with Troy. He's a pretty intense guy between the white lines, but he's pretty soft-spoken off the field.

 
Not sure this will be as effective. It was "Mean" Joe Greene, and what was so good about the commercial was that this big, mean football player, who wasn't in a very good mood after getting hurt, suddenly found a soft heart after being given a Coke.Not sure how this works with Troy. He's a pretty intense guy between the white lines, but he's pretty soft-spoken off the field.
Great commercial but I agree. He is nutty on the field and all but not sure he has a mean Joe rep.
 
Twenty-nine years after Joe Greene became a star in a Coca-Cola commercial, Troy Polamalu will be cast in the remake.Polamalu, a four-time Pro Bowl strong safety, will revise the role that Greene played in the 1980 Super Bowl ad. It too will be shown during the Super Bowl.In the original commercial, Greene limps through a tunnel beneath the stands in obvious discomfort. A young boy offers him his Coke, and Greene finally accepts. He drinks it down and, as the kid slowly walks away, Greene breaks into a smile and says, "Hey, kid; catch!" and throws him his No. 75 game jersey.That ad not only won a Clio, an award presented to those ads judged to be the best on television that season, but it has been judged the best Super Bowl commercial in history by many in the business.This was an all-time classic ad. It'll be interesting to see how this turns out and/or goes over.Being a Cowboys fan, I really, really hated the Steelers back then, but you couldn't help appreciating that commercial.
The better ad would be for Greene to hand the coke to Polamalu. Or better yet, morph the kid from the original into Polamalu today (although the kid was white and he's Samoan, and the ages wouldn't match since he was born in '81).I just don't like blatant copies of old commericials/movies/songs etc, add some originality.
:rolleyes:
 
I can't wait to see the remake. I was about the same age as the kid in the commercial, and it was the best commercial in the world (you think like that when you're 5 or whatever). I like the idea of the kid growing up to be Polamalu and then he returns the favor. Or maybe the kid grows up and has a child of his own, and he's the one who gives the Coke to Polamalu. Just thinking about this kind of brings a tear to my eye in the reminiscing of youth and growing up and simpler times sort of way.

 
"Hey Troy, I'll give you my Coke if you get a haircut."

[Michael Irvin]

Did somebody mention coke?

[/Michael Irvin]

 
I can't wait to see the remake. I was about the same age as the kid in the commercial, and it was the best commercial in the world (you think like that when you're 5 or whatever). I like the idea of the kid growing up to be Polamalu and then he returns the favor. Or maybe the kid grows up and has a child of his own, and he's the one who gives the Coke to Polamalu. Just thinking about this kind of brings a tear to my eye in the reminiscing of youth and growing up and simpler times sort of way.
I like this.
 
I remember this commercial as well. :bag: It was even remade in various countries throughout the world with their own sports heros. I know one was made ni Argentina with Diego Maradona..

As far as this new one, I agree with those who don't like re-makes. If it aint broke, don't fix it. Thats why I usually dislaike movie remakes. I don't think I can remember one movie remake that wsa better than the original. I can see them building on it though like some others mentioned.

What if Polomalu was a kid in the stands above the tunnel who SAW Mean Joe do this and as the kid approaches him, it goes into flashback mode. Of course, that means paying royalties to Mean Joe.

 
As far as this new one, I agree with those who don't like re-makes. If it aint broke, don't fix it. Thats why I usually dislaike movie remakes. I don't think I can remember one movie remake that wsa better than the original. I can see them building on it though like some others mentioned.
Ya, I agree to an extent, but there's a whole 'nother generation out there now unfamiliar with the original.
 
I loved the original and think the remake is a great idea as well....old farts will love it for the nostalgia factor and youngsters will like it simply because its a great theme. Definitely will be easy gold for a Coke commercial.

I agree though, that Mean Joe and Palumalu are 2 different breeds of people, and what made the 1st one special was the tough scary monster that was Mean Joe had a heart. Troy is my favorite NFL player but the fact he's small and softspoken doesn't work for a exact match of this commercial....I don't think the consistency of the Steeler uniform really has much to play into the commercial really though does it? I think its more about portraying the evil big monster NFL man having a heart that makes the commercial special...find the scariest monster in the NFL (that most of the nation knows by face...Ray Lewis or Urlacher perhaps) and that is what works.

 
How 'bout this:

Reverse the roles played in the original. Polamalu shows up at a local high school game out of sheer bore..., uh, love of the game. This time he rewards some gutty 17-year old hero, who of course reminds Polamalu of himself, with a Coke in the parking lot. The kid, with stars in his eyes but without loss of composure, tosses Troy his game-worn jersey out of a deep sense of mutual respect.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
find the scariest monster in the NFL (that most of the nation knows by face...Ray Lewis or Urlacher perhaps) and that is what works.
As much as I don't like Ray Lewis, I think this is the right answer.What made that commercial work was the fact that it was 'Mean" Joe Greene. Not just some great defensive guy, but a mean sum#####.Ray Lewis is the only guy I can think of right now that fits that mold. Anyone else ya think?
 
Wow that was 1980 - I said this before. You realize you're "old" when you start watching remakes, documentaries of great moments in sports etc and you remember the original. ugh. For example there is a documentary on HBO about the Villanova upset over Georgetown in 1985. I was in freaking HS. ugh

 
I was also the little kid's age around that time and I remember the ad well.

I also remember a parody of the ad. (Saturday night Live maybe?) After the kid hands Mean Joe the Coke and he drinks it down, he yells back "Hey kid", the kid turns around only to get hit in the face with the empty glass bottle!

:lmao:

 
CrossEyed said:
Not sure this will be as effective. It was "Mean" Joe Greene, and what was so good about the commercial was that this big, mean football player, who wasn't in a very good mood after getting hurt, suddenly found a soft heart after being given a Coke.Not sure how this works with Troy. He's a pretty intense guy between the white lines, but he's pretty soft-spoken off the field.
My thoughts exactly.
 
CrossEyed said:
Not sure this will be as effective. It was "Mean" Joe Greene, and what was so good about the commercial was that this big, mean football player, who wasn't in a very good mood after getting hurt, suddenly found a soft heart after being given a Coke.Not sure how this works with Troy. He's a pretty intense guy between the white lines, but he's pretty soft-spoken off the field.
My thoughts exactly.
Yep. People missed the theme of the commercial, apparently.
 
Joe Greene saved my life! :thumbup:

When I was a kid my dad took us all to the Steeler's training camp (circa 1980). I had a legal pad and was running around getting autographs of all the players I could find. I saw Joe Greene and went running towards him to get his autograph (wishing I had a coke to hand over). Halfway towards him he sees me and yells 'stay right there kid'. I stopped in my tracks... broken hearted. Then a car went zooming past. I didn't even realize he was across a street. After the traffic cleared he waved me over and signed my pad. My dad snapped a great b&w photo of me staring up at Joe Greene while he signed it. And even though I really can't stand the Steeler's these days, Joe Greene will always be one of my all-time favorite NFL players.

 
Is Troy going to belch after he downs the Coke? Saw MJG do so during one of the commercial takes on some blooper show when I was a kid. Cracked me up.

 
Joe Greene saved my life! :blackdot:When I was a kid my dad took us all to the Steeler's training camp (circa 1980). I had a legal pad and was running around getting autographs of all the players I could find. I saw Joe Greene and went running towards him to get his autograph (wishing I had a coke to hand over). Halfway towards him he sees me and yells 'stay right there kid'. I stopped in my tracks... broken hearted. Then a car went zooming past. I didn't even realize he was across a street. After the traffic cleared he waved me over and signed my pad. My dad snapped a great b&w photo of me staring up at Joe Greene while he signed it. And even though I really can't stand the Steeler's these days, Joe Greene will always be one of my all-time favorite NFL players.
Good story!
 
CrossEyed said:
Not sure this will be as effective. It was "Mean" Joe Greene, and what was so good about the commercial was that this big, mean football player, who wasn't in a very good mood after getting hurt, suddenly found a soft heart after being given a Coke.Not sure how this works with Troy. He's a pretty intense guy between the white lines, but he's pretty soft-spoken off the field.
My thoughts exactly.
Yep. People missed the theme of the commercial, apparently.
How bout this then. Have Hines Ward star in the commercial instead. He could give a Coke to the kid as peace offering after he hits him with an illegal crackback block.
 
Andy Herron said:
Twenty-nine years after Joe Greene became a star in a Coca-Cola commercial, Troy Polamalu will be cast in the remake.
oh goody :goodposting: Leave classics alone. Do your own thing Polymumu.
 
CrossEyed said:
Not sure this will be as effective. It was "Mean" Joe Greene, and what was so good about the commercial was that this big, mean football player, who wasn't in a very good mood after getting hurt, suddenly found a soft heart after being given a Coke.

Not sure how this works with Troy. He's a pretty intense guy between the white lines, but he's pretty soft-spoken off the field.
My thoughts exactly.
Yep. People missed the theme of the commercial, apparently.
How bout this then. Have Hines Ward star in the commercial instead. He could give a Coke to the kid as peace offering after he hits him with a n il legal crackback block.
 
CrossEyed said:
Not sure this will be as effective. It was "Mean" Joe Greene, and what was so good about the commercial was that this big, mean football player, who wasn't in a very good mood after getting hurt, suddenly found a soft heart after being given a Coke.

Not sure how this works with Troy. He's a pretty intense guy between the white lines, but he's pretty soft-spoken off the field.
My thoughts exactly.
Yep. People missed the theme of the commercial, apparently.
How bout this then. Have Hines Ward star in the commercial instead. He could give a Coke to the kid as peace offering after he hits him with a n il legal crackback block.
Ward is known as one of the toughest blockers in the league among wide receivers, and one unnamed coach said during the off-season that Ward is the dirtiest player in the NFL.
http://www.profootballtalk.com/2008/10/09/...sary-roughness/ :lmao:

 
Dope said:
Captain Spaulding said:
find the scariest monster in the NFL (that most of the nation knows by face...Ray Lewis or Urlacher perhaps) and that is what works.
As much as I don't like Ray Lewis, I think this is the right answer.What made that commercial work was the fact that it was 'Mean" Joe Greene. Not just some great defensive guy, but a mean sum#####.Ray Lewis is the only guy I can think of right now that fits that mold. Anyone else ya think?
Ray Lewis would drink the Coke, then have his posse turn around and shoot the kid.
 
CrossEyed said:
Not sure this will be as effective. It was "Mean" Joe Greene, and what was so good about the commercial was that this big, mean football player, who wasn't in a very good mood after getting hurt, suddenly found a soft heart after being given a Coke.Not sure how this works with Troy. He's a pretty intense guy between the white lines, but he's pretty soft-spoken off the field.
My thoughts exactly.
Yep. People missed the theme of the commercial, apparently.
How bout this then. Have Hines Ward star in the commercial instead. He could give a Coke to the kid as peace offering after he hits him with an illegal crackback block.
:excited:
 
I'm sorry, if this topic is going to stay on the front page, would the OP please correct the title? The word you're looking for is "reprise", and it's driving me crazy.

Love,

The Grammar and Language Police

Carry on.

 
Joe Greene saved my life! :thumbup:When I was a kid my dad took us all to the Steeler's training camp (circa 1980). I had a legal pad and was running around getting autographs of all the players I could find. I saw Joe Greene and went running towards him to get his autograph (wishing I had a coke to hand over). Halfway towards him he sees me and yells 'stay right there kid'. I stopped in my tracks... broken hearted. Then a car went zooming past. I didn't even realize he was across a street. After the traffic cleared he waved me over and signed my pad. My dad snapped a great b&w photo of me staring up at Joe Greene while he signed it. And even though I really can't stand the Steeler's these days, Joe Greene will always be one of my all-time favorite NFL players.
Where was your dad?
 
Dope said:
Captain Spaulding said:
find the scariest monster in the NFL (that most of the nation knows by face...Ray Lewis or Urlacher perhaps) and that is what works.
As much as I don't like Ray Lewis, I think this is the right answer.What made that commercial work was the fact that it was 'Mean" Joe Greene. Not just some great defensive guy, but a mean sum#####.Ray Lewis is the only guy I can think of right now that fits that mold. Anyone else ya think?
Ray Lewis would drink the Coke, then have his posse turn around and shoot the kid.
:thumbup:
 
There is no reason to remake the commercial. Ad execs at Coca Cola are just being lazy now. I am boycotting this commerical and will refuse to see it. Take that, COKE.

 
Wow that was 1980 - I said this before. You realize you're "old" when you start watching remakes, documentaries of great moments in sports etc and you remember the original. ugh. For example there is a documentary on HBO about the Villanova upset over Georgetown in 1985. I was in freaking HS. ugh
We are close to the same age, but i feel older as when I saw that was 1980, I thought it actually was before then.
 
showed the original to my 14 year old football crazy daughter (who loves troy p) and she thought it was great...my wife started crying when she realized that my daughter had never seen the commercial (and then said, "i'm so old"). :goodposting:

 
Last edited by a moderator:
PatrickT said:
I'm sorry, if this topic is going to stay on the front page, would the OP please correct the title? The word you're looking for is "reprise", and it's driving me crazy.

Love,

The Grammar and Language Police

Carry on.
Done.I just clipped it from the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. I probably should have caught that though. I just copied their verbage.

Found it during yesterday morning's shift and was in a hurry. I overlooked "their" headline.

http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/08326/929615-66.stm

Steelers Notebook: Step aside, Mean Joe; Polamalu will star in ad reprise

Friday, November 21, 2008

By Ed Bouchette, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

Twenty-nine years after Joe Greene became a star in a Coca-Cola commercial, Troy Polamalu will be cast in the remake.

Polamalu, a four-time Pro Bowl strong safety, will revise the role that Greene played in the 1980 Super Bowl ad. It too will be shown during the Super Bowl.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
PatrickT said:
I'm sorry, if this topic is going to stay on the front page, would the OP please correct the title? The word you're looking for is "reprise", and it's driving me crazy.

Love,

The Grammar and Language Police

Carry on.
Done.I just clipped it from the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. I probably should have caught that though. I just copied their verbage.

Found it during yesterday morning's shift and was in a hurry. I overlooked "their" headline.

http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/08326/929615-66.stm

Steelers Notebook: Step aside, Mean Joe; Polamalu will star in ad reprise

Friday, November 21, 2008

By Ed Bouchette, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

Twenty-nine years after Joe Greene became a star in a Coca-Cola commercial, Troy Polamalu will be cast in the remake.

Polamalu, a four-time Pro Bowl strong safety, will revise the role that Greene played in the 1980 Super Bowl ad. It too will be shown during the Super Bowl.
<golf clap> And they even got it right in the title. :yes:

 
phthalatemagic said:
Joe Greene saved my life! :)When I was a kid my dad took us all to the Steeler's training camp (circa 1980). I had a legal pad and was running around getting autographs of all the players I could find. I saw Joe Greene and went running towards him to get his autograph (wishing I had a coke to hand over). Halfway towards him he sees me and yells 'stay right there kid'. I stopped in my tracks... broken hearted. Then a car went zooming past. I didn't even realize he was across a street. After the traffic cleared he waved me over and signed my pad. My dad snapped a great b&w photo of me staring up at Joe Greene while he signed it. And even though I really can't stand the Steeler's these days, Joe Greene will always be one of my all-time favorite NFL players.
Where was your dad?
He wasn't too far. I was 9. It was 1980. Different world back then. I never wore a bike helmet and somehow I lived to adulthood. Thanks for worrying though. :unsure:
 
I remember seeing Rowdy Roddy Piper do a spoof of this commercial in the '80s. But the kid was replaced by a hot girl and the towel was replaced by his kilt. :thumbup:

 
I remember that ad and wishing I was that kid.

I dont like the idea of polomululuulu redoing it.

 
Guys Polamalu is a baaaaaaaad man. It is very appropriate to use him in this remake.
:no: Great player. But makes no sense in this role.
Why not? He is one of the most intense players and biggest hitters in the game. Offensive players are terrified of him and it isn't just because he makes
he is a punishing defensive players who makes offensive players pay for trying to gain yardage. Not only is he the hardest hitting safety in the game but he is also the best cover and run support safety in the NFL. He is a far more complete player than Mean Joe ever was, Mean Joe just has a better nickname.
 
I remember this commercial as well. :popcorn: It was even remade in various countries throughout the world with their own sports heros. I know one was made ni Argentina with Diego Maradona..As far as this new one, I agree with those who don't like re-makes. If it aint broke, don't fix it. Thats why I usually dislaike movie remakes. I don't think I can remember one movie remake that wsa better than the original. I can see them building on it though like some others mentioned. What if Polomalu was a kid in the stands above the tunnel who SAW Mean Joe do this and as the kid approaches him, it goes into flashback mode. Of course, that means paying royalties to Mean Joe.
That might make it work for me. And royalties would seem appropriate in any case given the inspiration.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top