Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
He converted for a 1st down, so....
fluke injury. QB sneaks aren’t usually that dangerous. This is the first time I can recall seeing a QB get hurt doing one.
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
Post here when coaches do something you disagree with (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter GreenNGold
- Start date
fluke injury. QB sneaks aren’t usually that dangerous. This is the first time I can recall seeing a QB get hurt doing one.
Ok ok... maybe I was reacting emotionally since I have Mahones in one league.
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
I get it - dynasty owner. Hurts to see a player go down like that regardless.
but I don’t blame the play call.
the Mahomes topic is filled with criticism of Reid for the play. I think that’s misguided.
cloppbeast
Footballguy
What about BB challenging that completed pass (for about 10 lousy yards) up 33 in the 4th Q?
I'm sure his reply would be along the lines of, we play the same regardless of the score, but c'mon man. And he didn't even win the challenge.
rockaction
Footballguy
He was pissed that Gase declined the delay of game and false start penalties the drive immediately before. There was a lot of coach stuff going on at the end there that I think one could be privy to if one were dead set on watching the game qua game.
dhockster
Footballguy
What about benching the Greatest Qb of all time in the 4th quarter?!! Why would you ever sit him?!! BB a genius? NO WAY!!
Not saying you're wrong but being pissed about that would be even stupider than the challenge. Gase would be getting called out in this thread had he accepted those penalties.
"Sure Bill just put the ball wherever you'd like it, no problem."
Funny you say that. I glanced at a TV to catch the score and immediately thought, why the heck is Brady still in the game right now when it's 33-0??
rockaction
Footballguy
I think Bill genuinely was. They talked about it in the booth, and you could see his rueful smile. You could also read McDaniels's lips when the NYJ went to run their two-minute drill. "What are they doing?" he mouthed to Brady on the bench.Not saying you're wrong but being pissed about that would be even stupider than the challenge. Gase would be getting called out in this thread had he accepted those penalties.
"Sure Bill just put the ball wherever you'd like it, no problem."
They wanted the Jets to take their whipping meekly, I think.
It was a weird dynamic.
rockaction
Footballguy
Bossman
Footballguy
I don't think that BB was pissed ... BB was kind of smirking that Gase was "on to him" trying to give the punter more room.
... what made it amusing to Bill is that they ran the play clock down to zero (45 seconds) while the game clock was running...
then ran another 42 seconds off the game clock before the false start.
then ran another 44 seconds off the game clock for the punt.
So over 2 mins off the game clock for one 4th down play.
rockaction
Footballguy
This is also a good take, and is as likely as my explanation. But why challenge the play up 33 and about under two minutes remaining?
Bossman
Footballguy
BB Rule Bending Again
Penalty / Clock Chewing Rule Proposal
I believe the NFL did put into place a rule to prevent this after the Ravens ran the final 11 seconds off the game clock by the entire punt team, grabbing / holding / tackling, while the punter stood there holding the ball.
15 yard unsportsmanlike and reset of game clock now I believe.
... which is probably why BB didn't just keep giving penalties to be declined.
Refs should have actually utilized this rule after the false start (second penalty).
Last edited by a moderator:
rockaction
Footballguy
BB is the man *tips cap, walks away into a frigid, nearly soulless night with the optimism only the exacting fundamentalist could imbue*
irish eyes
Footballguy
I can guarantee you 90% of the coaches in the league would not have done what Belicheck did....because they are too stupid to know about it.
rockaction
Footballguy
And do it in such a way that it doesn't tip the competitive balance of a game or season. That's actually classy.
Kinda makes me wonder why he didn't keep this trick in his back pocket until it could help him win a close game.
Bossman
Footballguy
Nothing preventing any coach from doing this at any point. Loophole in the rules and it's been around a while.
Been used by other coaches in the past. Belichick isn't the first.
Would have been funny if Pats kept "false starting" and "delay of gaming" until the refs finally enforced the unsportsmanlike 15 yards ...
and after all that time was run off the game clock, BB would have gotten more room for his punter that Gase was trying to prevent.
What a kick to the minerals that would have been for Gase. Guarantee that is what was going thru Bills mind when he had that smirk on his face.
If that were Mangini still on the Jets sideline, I guarantee Bill does that there. ... which is probably why coaches don't decline that penalty there. Except for Gase.
Steelers get a turnover on the Dolphins 30, up 10 points with 5:45 left. First down, Conner runs for 4 yards. He's been gashing them all night, he just picked up 4, so you would think you would just continue to run, use the clock, etc. right? Incomplete pass on second down. Pass to Conner for -5 on third down.
Yes I'm bitter because that -5 cost me a point and the win, but come on!
I hate these NFL coaches. Seriously, they do half of Belichick's work for him.
Yes I'm bitter because that -5 cost me a point and the win, but come on!
I hate these NFL coaches. Seriously, they do half of Belichick's work for him.
ghostguy123
Footballguy
This thread is made for the Browns
efactor
Footballguy
Few from yesterday:
-Raiders call time out with the Lions scrambling to line up with 8 seconds left (Gruden didn't call the TO apparently). Actually worked because of Lions play call after and them taking their two best offensive players out of the game.
-Lions get bailed out on Raiders time out. They then return the favor by taking their two best players (Jones and Golladay) off the field, line up in a jumbo package, and throw to their 3rd string TE. Play fake doesn't fake out anyone when you can't run the ball and when the strength of the Raider defense is stopping the run. I'll take my chance with either of my tall, talented receivers vs throwing to the back-up TEs, backup.
-Tampa Bay rushing to the line on 2nd down from the 1 and giving Seattle 45 seconds of clock left to get into field goal range. Wilson against the Tampa defense is almost unfair. Got them into easy field goal range with plenty of time to spare. Myers missed but the point still stands. Why hurry there? Let the clock go down to about 25 seconds. Plenty of time with time outs left.
-Tampa Bay not going for 2 on the road to win the game. Against the Seattle defense, I'll take my chances with one play from the two, rather than knowing if they lose the coin toss, they will never see the ball again. All Seattle had to do was keep throwing the ball at Dean, and they couldn't be stopped. Got to think one play from the two with Godwin and Evans against a less than stellar pass defense has a greater chance to succeed than winning the coin toss or scoring a TD if you do happen to win it.
-Raiders call time out with the Lions scrambling to line up with 8 seconds left (Gruden didn't call the TO apparently). Actually worked because of Lions play call after and them taking their two best offensive players out of the game.
-Lions get bailed out on Raiders time out. They then return the favor by taking their two best players (Jones and Golladay) off the field, line up in a jumbo package, and throw to their 3rd string TE. Play fake doesn't fake out anyone when you can't run the ball and when the strength of the Raider defense is stopping the run. I'll take my chance with either of my tall, talented receivers vs throwing to the back-up TEs, backup.
-Tampa Bay rushing to the line on 2nd down from the 1 and giving Seattle 45 seconds of clock left to get into field goal range. Wilson against the Tampa defense is almost unfair. Got them into easy field goal range with plenty of time to spare. Myers missed but the point still stands. Why hurry there? Let the clock go down to about 25 seconds. Plenty of time with time outs left.
-Tampa Bay not going for 2 on the road to win the game. Against the Seattle defense, I'll take my chances with one play from the two, rather than knowing if they lose the coin toss, they will never see the ball again. All Seattle had to do was keep throwing the ball at Dean, and they couldn't be stopped. Got to think one play from the two with Godwin and Evans against a less than stellar pass defense has a greater chance to succeed than winning the coin toss or scoring a TD if you do happen to win it.
CalBear
Footballguy
Jacksonville, 4th and 10 at the Houston 20, down by 16, 11:05 left. They go for it. Even if they make the first down (~30% chance) they'd still need two TDs and two 2-point conversions just to tie. If you kick the FG, you still need two TDs but now you don't need the 2-point conversions and you actually would win the game. Another example of the fallacy of a tie being equivalent to a win.
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
Patriots entire offensive game plan was whack. Arrogant is a good word for it. They thought that despite literally every sports analyst saying the best way to beat the ravens was on the ground that they should go 90% no-huddle. And that’s despite being undefeated to that point by effectively running the ball & keeping their defense fresh.
while they had some late success with that Mid-game, they also made a ton of uncharacteristic mental mistakes on 3rd downs, and tired out their own defense early with 3-and-outs.
it was a terrible game plan.
while they had some late success with that Mid-game, they also made a ton of uncharacteristic mental mistakes on 3rd downs, and tired out their own defense early with 3-and-outs.
it was a terrible game plan.
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
I’m in agreement with most of your post except this.
they had to preserve clock in case the 2nd and 1 failed.
it could have been suicide to kill all that clock & whiff. Leaving Seattle 45 seconds just happened to work out that way.
efactor
Footballguy
I was watching on red zone. Thought the announcer said they had a time out left.
Even if not, they could have let it run down. Even if they run it with 30 seconds left and don't make it, plenty of time to line up and run a pass play and make it or stop the clock with an in-completion. Just seemed bad clock management
Tampa pass defense is horrible. Seattle was just running simple crossing patterns and picking up huge chunks.
Last edited by a moderator:
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
This is the Bucs we’re talking abut though. They make enough mistakes that I understand keeping a little extra time handy.
Just about any other team I agree with you, though.
3rd & 3 at DEN 7
(6:07 - 3rd) (Shotgun) D.Hilliard up the middle to DEN 5 for 2 yards .
Yes 3rd & 3, you take your best RB out and put in the backup because you think you are being tricky and are fooling the D.
ghostguy123
Footballguy
You shoulda heard him trying to explain why. He said that play was drawn up for when Hilliard was in because they tried to trick them into thinking they wouldnt run.
They were stupid to not kick a FG to make it a 2 point game early 4th quarter.
Kitchens has been dreadful
Hankmoody
Footballguy
Don't agree at all. Raiders D was even more discombobulated as the Lions' O was. DET was close to ready to snap it and OAK has enough trouble with blown coverages as is. You don't give a guy like Stafford a free shot at your confused defense.
I do hate DET's response, however. No clue how you don't feed it to Golladay.
efactor
Footballguy
Seemed the other way around to me and Gruden seemed irritated by the time out, which he apparently didn't call.
I hate that jumbo package with everyone bunched in down by the goal line. Especially for a team like Detroit that doesn't run the ball well and against a team that has a pretty good run defense.
I’ve seen you post this or something similar in a couple threads. The Patriots average 3.3 ypc which is 30th overall. They are in the bottom quarter of the league in rushing yards per game despite playing an array of terrible teams. The Ravens allow the second fewest rushing yards per game in the league. They aren’t as efficient from a ypc standpoint but still better on paper vs the run than the pass. And that’s with Cleveland dropping almost 200 on the ground one game (in which Brandon Williams was a late inactive) that looks a lot like an outlier. Granted there have been a couple big personnel changes- Peters added, Jimmy Smith returning.
Curious as to why “literally every sports analyst” thought running the ball would be the best option. Is it just the usual rah rah run the ball grind on the defense etc? Is it the additions in the secondary? I thought the Pats hurry up was pretty good at wearing out the D and they likely would have taken the lead against an exhausted defense if Edelman hadn’t fumbled.
Last edited by a moderator:
Hankmoody
Footballguy
He may have been, but in the heat of the moment that's easy to do. As the not-defensive coach, he'd be a lot less in tune to when his guys are flustered, are not getting lined up properly, are not communicating the right signals. That's the DC's job - to make sure everything is on schedule and everyone's on the same page. He saw they weren't and wanted to reset. There's no way they would have been prepared for anything anywhere near tricky at that point, they weren't even getting every DB lined up on a receiver yet.
BobbyLayne
Footballguy
Down 16-24 on the road with 12 minutes left, the Panthers go for two (& fail to convert)
EILI5
EILI5
fred_1_15301
Footballguy
smbkrypt24
Footballguy
smcindoe
Footballguy
It's somewhat unintuitive, but going for two in that situation is apparently the right call:
https://predictivefootball.com/late-and-trailing-by-14-points-always-go-for-2-after-a-touchdown/
Cowboysfan8
Footballguy
The last 5 minutes of the Dallas game 
TakiToki
Footballguy
McVay is really stupid. The more time goes on the more its looking like the team was winning in 2018 in spite of this guy.
kittenmittens
Footballguy
Dear Bill Obrien:
Please stop calling option plays where Watson runs into linebackers to get tackled.
Thanks,
Everyone
Please stop calling option plays where Watson runs into linebackers to get tackled.
Thanks,
Everyone
barackdhouse
Footballguy
Colts spent the entire night setting up the Texans for play action on early downs and didn't pull the trigger once that I remember. They ran the ball very well but they should have (tried to) capitalize on it.
Similar threads
