Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.
Meh. Even the best scouts miss from time to time. He doesn’t seem to do well against better than mediocre teams. He also has a terrible attitude and already seems to think he owed more than he’s qualified for. I’d pass personally. We don’t what he’ll be yet, but he’s far from can't miss.
Does he?
I'm not sure about that - but it proves the point being made anyway.
Yes. From my perspective it has been on certain occasions.
the more I watch and see if this guy he drops on my board. Not worth a too 10 pick maybe not even a day 1 pick. Does poor against teams he should kill, poor media and his attitude is shot when he loses. Always looking elsewhere for blame and lacks leadership qualities of a franchise QB. If I was a GM/owner he’d be taken off my board completely at this point. Unless he significantly dropped big time maybe I take a shot at him and see what he does and if the other guy does well you can use Williams as a trade asset or if the other guy flunks completely and he does well you got a back up plan.
Wut?Oh come on.
The post before mine.Wut?Oh come on.
Easy enough to reply to a post that will include that post.The post before mine.Wut?Oh come on.
he might bust. Anyone could. But you have to be kidding about the “not even day one” stuff.
While I think the poster’s post are pretty outlandish most of the time, I don’t think it a too far fetched take. No one is a sure thing, and Williams has his red flags. Mostly, he doesn’t fair well against teams better than mediocre.Oh come on.
Not a top 10 pick. Not a day one pick. If he was a GM he’s off his board completely? I know better than to pile on @DJackson10 but “oh come on” is pretty warranted for that take.While I think the poster’s post are pretty outlandish most of the time, I don’t think it a too far fetched take. No one is a sure thing, and Williams has his red flags. Mostly, he doesn’t fair well against teams better than mediocre.Oh come on.
True. I can give you that. But I wouldn’t be surprised if he didn’t pan out. We shall see, but yeah…..he’ll be a top 5 pick and probably #1.Not a top 10 pick. Not a day one pick. If he was a GM he’s off his board completely? I know better than to pile on @DJackson10 but “oh come on” is pretty warranted for that take.While I think the poster’s post are pretty outlandish most of the time, I don’t think it a too far fetched take. No one is a sure thing, and Williams has his red flags. Mostly, he doesn’t fair well against teams better than mediocre.Oh come on.
Maybe he used good judgment, rather than comment after a loss.
Plenty of guys don’t pan out, but one look at the QBs starting in the NFL today should tell you Caleb Williams is kind of draftable.True. I can give you that. But I wouldn’t be surprised if he didn’t pan out. We shall see, but yeah…..he’ll be a top 5 pick and probably #1.Not a top 10 pick. Not a day one pick. If he was a GM he’s off his board completely? I know better than to pile on @DJackson10 but “oh come on” is pretty warranted for that take.While I think the poster’s post are pretty outlandish most of the time, I don’t think it a too far fetched take. No one is a sure thing, and Williams has his red flags. Mostly, he doesn’t fair well against teams better than mediocre.Oh come on.
I’m not so sure. The smart money may be on Drake Maye.Plenty of guys don’t pan out, but one look at the QBs starting in the NFL today should tell you Caleb Williams is kind of draftable.True. I can give you that. But I wouldn’t be surprised if he didn’t pan out. We shall see, but yeah…..he’ll be a top 5 pick and probably #1.Not a top 10 pick. Not a day one pick. If he was a GM he’s off his board completely? I know better than to pile on @DJackson10 but “oh come on” is pretty warranted for that take.While I think the poster’s post are pretty outlandish most of the time, I don’t think it a too far fetched take. No one is a sure thing, and Williams has his red flags. Mostly, he doesn’t fair well against teams better than mediocre.Oh come on.
He regressed a little this year statistically, but he’s still going to be the #1 pick.
63% for the season. 22 TDs and 7 INT. 8 rushing TDs.
You make a decent argument, but I’m still not convinced he should go #1, just as Young shouldn’t have gone #1 over Stroud. There are rumblings that some teams prefer Maye.
Not true, Maye is a stud
There actually has been in a few radio segments I’ve listened to locally here in Denver and nationally.
His red flags are just too big for me. I wouldn’t touch him with a 50 ft poll. I’m curious how he interviews and does on the test though. That could be very telling for teams. Interviews might help him out but if he goes in there with the Christian hackenberg attitude where he blames everyone else, throws coaches under the bus etc like he did that’s not going to go wellWhile I think the poster’s post are pretty outlandish most of the time, I don’t think it a too far fetched take. No one is a sure thing, and Williams has his red flags. Mostly, he doesn’t fair well against teams better than mediocre.Oh come on.
He’s got major red flags where a franchise ab shouldn’t have one. I wouldn’t take my chance on himNot a top 10 pick. Not a day one pick. If he was a GM he’s off his board completely? I know better than to pile on @DJackson10 but “oh come on” is pretty warranted for that take.While I think the poster’s post are pretty outlandish most of the time, I don’t think it a too far fetched take. No one is a sure thing, and Williams has his red flags. Mostly, he doesn’t fair well against teams better than mediocre.Oh come on.
Joe burrow paid 55m almost a year on Friday stood at a podium with his season over and took it like a man and acted like a leader. Williams lost a game and couldn’t face the media? He’s a top prospect. It’s not a great look at all.
Is there a history of media relations being a predictor of success?
Maybe at the skill positions last year. Not so much this year. And that USC defense is generationally bad.
I don’t care if he talks to the media or not. I just find it funny that he has no problem with them when he does good, or give a list of teams he’s not going to play for. The Bears main job is to find the teams interested in him, and accommodate Caleb.
I haven't heard him say he won't play for someone or that he wants ownership in someone's team if they draft him. That's all speculation from other sources. People love to tear you down when you're at the top.
I don’t want him on the Bears because we have a better version of Caleb right now.
Fields has had the Bears in contention for the #1 pick two years in a row. Is none of that his responsibility?
Fields was a 1000 yard rusher last year, so there is that...
And the Bears finished the year as the worst team in the NFL, so there's that.
Next April Caleb Williams is last year's Bryce Young and Drake Maye is last year's C J Stroud.
How’s this - the bears don’t need a qb that stares down receivers, this is what Caleb does.
Bryce was thrown into the worst scenario by far. Anyone who thought they were ready to not only support a young QB with his physical limitations but could do so after trading away Moore, a 2nd and their 24 1st should be fired. Regardless of whether they’re with the franchise or media “experts”.
Murray. Fixed.
I love it. He is SPOT ON! Williams is an absolute bust, deserving of a day 2 pick at bestNot a top 10 pick. Not a day one pick. If he was a GM he’s off his board completely? I know better than to pile on @DJackson10 but “oh come on” is pretty warranted for that take.While I think the poster’s post are pretty outlandish most of the time, I don’t think it a too far fetched take. No one is a sure thing, and Williams has his red flags. Mostly, he doesn’t fair well against teams better than mediocre.Oh come on.
