What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

QB Jalen Milroe, SEA (4 Viewers)

The Next Round
“[Jalen Milroe] has a gravitational pull about the way he carries himself. Doesn’t ever walk by you in the hallway without saying hello, asking about your family…

A QB and punter are a DC’s two best friends, so I like to hang out with my friends.” @KaneWommack

@AlabamaFTBL
Click to expand...

x.com

x.com x.com

“He’s a baller, he’s a dog.“

Ryan Williams said Jalen Milroe was apologizing to the wide receivers on the sideline during the LSU game because he felt like he wasn’t getting them the ball enough.

@Ryanwms1 response: “Bro, look at your stats. We don’t care. We winning…”
Click to expand...

x.com

x.com x.com
 
Jim Nagy
It's well-established Alabama's Jalen Milroe has 𝙂𝘼𝙈𝙀-𝘾𝙃𝘼𝙉𝙂𝙄𝙉𝙂 speed for the position. We're talking Lamar & Michael Vick level wheels.

On this 72-yard TD, @JalenMilroe hit 22.5 mph 💨 for our data partners at @TelemetrySports, which equates to 4.3 40 time. Milroe's previous max speed was 22.4 earlier this season.

Simply dusts LSU's secondary here👇.

#TheDraftStartsInMOBILE™️
Click to expand...

x.com

x.com x.com
 
Recent years how many QB from Alabama have been good in the NFL, not so good when playing with the big boys.
 
refacer said:
Recent years how many QB from Alabama have been good in the NFL, not so good when playing with the big boys.
Click to expand...

Hurts is legit and Tua is good when healthy...Mac Jones is nothing more than a backup (if that) and it looks like Bryce Young is not going to work-out...none of their starting QBs before that were real pro prospects, they were all college QBs...so I would say right now they are batting .500 when playing with the "big boys."
 
Boston said:
refacer said:
Recent years how many QB from Alabama have been good in the NFL, not so good when playing with the big boys.
Click to expand...

Hurts is legit and Tua is very good...Mac Jones is nothing more than a backup (if that) and it looks like Bryce Young is not going to work-out...none of their starting QBs before that were real pro prospects, they were all college QBs...so I would say right now they are batting .500 when playing with the "big boys."
Click to expand...
Tua is very good?

Lol that’s hillarious.


VS winning teams:

7-16 lifetime vs winning teams.
0 post season wins
60% Comp percentage
28 TD’s avg of 1.33
18 INT avg of .86 a game
84.3 passer rating

Has played exactly 1 full season in 5 years.

Man your bar is really low.

This guy is not a winner in the NFL. And the Dolphins will opt out of his contract in 2026 no doubt in my mind. Unless of course he retires before that due to another head injury.

He throws a pretty ball on passes under 25 yards (average arm man). Can’t move if his life depended on it. Can rarely make any off script plays, and has had the advantage of arguably the best YAC and most explosive WR in the league with Tyreek Hill. When teams focus on minimizing Tyreeks impact and take away the middle of the field (ie winning teams) this guy is below average and can’t beat winning teams.

NFL hyped…..he is not elite.

And for the record Milroe is one heck of an NFL prospect. I really think he can be elite at the next level.
 
Todem said:
Boston said:
refacer said:
Recent years how many QB from Alabama have been good in the NFL, not so good when playing with the big boys.
Click to expand...

Hurts is legit and Tua is very good...Mac Jones is nothing more than a backup (if that) and it looks like Bryce Young is not going to work-out...none of their starting QBs before that were real pro prospects, they were all college QBs...so I would say right now they are batting .500 when playing with the "big boys."
Click to expand...
Tua is very good?

Lol that’s hillarious.


VS winning teams:

7-16 lifetime vs winning teams.
0 post season wins
60% Comp percentage
28 TD’s avg of 1.33
18 INT avg of .86 a game
84.3 passer rating

Has played exactly 1 full season in 5 years.

Man your bar is really low.

This guy is not a winner in the NFL. And the Dolphins will opt out of his contract in 2026 no doubt in my mind. Unless of course he retires before that due to another head injury.

He throws a pretty ball on passes under 25 yards. Can’t move if his life depended on it. Can rarely make any off script plays, and has had the advantage of arguably the best YAC and most explosive WR in the league with Tyreek Hill. When teams focus on minimizing Tyreeks impact and take away the middle of the field (ie winning teams) this guy is below average and can’t beat winning teams.

NFL hyped…..he is not elite.
Click to expand...

Why don't we calm down with the "hilarious" and your bar is low shots...he is a really good starting QB in the NFL...I think it is pretty obvious to see...is he Mahomes, Allen or Burrow...obviously not but he is a legit NFL QB who can get a team to the playoffs like he did last year when he passed for 4,264 yards and had 29 TDs...if you want to question his durability that is very legit but when he plays he is a quality NFL starter.
 
Last edited:
going back to milore, im a huge bama fan and dont think hes going to amount to much. hes a great athlete and throws a nice deep ball. but good defenses give him probs. i cant imagine him being able to beat pro defenses
 
Boston said:
Todem said:
Boston said:
refacer said:
Recent years how many QB from Alabama have been good in the NFL, not so good when playing with the big boys.
Click to expand...

Hurts is legit and Tua is very good...Mac Jones is nothing more than a backup (if that) and it looks like Bryce Young is not going to work-out...none of their starting QBs before that were real pro prospects, they were all college QBs...so I would say right now they are batting .500 when playing with the "big boys."
Click to expand...
Tua is very good?

Lol that’s hillarious.


VS winning teams:

7-16 lifetime vs winning teams.
0 post season wins
60% Comp percentage
28 TD’s avg of 1.33
18 INT avg of .86 a game
84.3 passer rating

Has played exactly 1 full season in 5 years.

Man your bar is really low.

This guy is not a winner in the NFL. And the Dolphins will opt out of his contract in 2026 no doubt in my mind. Unless of course he retires before that due to another head injury.

He throws a pretty ball on passes under 25 yards. Can’t move if his life depended on it. Can rarely make any off script plays, and has had the advantage of arguably the best YAC and most explosive WR in the league with Tyreek Hill. When teams focus on minimizing Tyreeks impact and take away the middle of the field (ie winning teams) this guy is below average and can’t beat winning teams.

NFL hyped…..he is not elite.
Click to expand...

Why don't we calm down with the "hilarious" and your bar is low shots...he is a really good starting QB in the NFL...I think it is pretty obvious to see...is he Mahomes, Allen or Burrow...obviously not but he is a legit NFL QB who can get a team to the playoffs like he did last year when he passed for 4,264 yards and had 29 TDs..if you want to question his durability that is very legit but when he plays he is a quality NFL starter.
Click to expand...
You are really not seeing what he is. We watch him every week.

Overall Numbers don’t always tell you what someone is.

But his numbers vs “winning” teams says everything.
 
Todem said:
Boston said:
Todem said:
Boston said:
refacer said:
Recent years how many QB from Alabama have been good in the NFL, not so good when playing with the big boys.
Click to expand...

Hurts is legit and Tua is very good...Mac Jones is nothing more than a backup (if that) and it looks like Bryce Young is not going to work-out...none of their starting QBs before that were real pro prospects, they were all college QBs...so I would say right now they are batting .500 when playing with the "big boys."
Click to expand...
Tua is very good?

Lol that’s hillarious.


VS winning teams:

7-16 lifetime vs winning teams.
0 post season wins
60% Comp percentage
28 TD’s avg of 1.33
18 INT avg of .86 a game
84.3 passer rating

Has played exactly 1 full season in 5 years.

Man your bar is really low.

This guy is not a winner in the NFL. And the Dolphins will opt out of his contract in 2026 no doubt in my mind. Unless of course he retires before that due to another head injury.

He throws a pretty ball on passes under 25 yards. Can’t move if his life depended on it. Can rarely make any off script plays, and has had the advantage of arguably the best YAC and most explosive WR in the league with Tyreek Hill. When teams focus on minimizing Tyreeks impact and take away the middle of the field (ie winning teams) this guy is below average and can’t beat winning teams.

NFL hyped…..he is not elite.
Click to expand...

Why don't we calm down with the "hilarious" and your bar is low shots...he is a really good starting QB in the NFL...I think it is pretty obvious to see...is he Mahomes, Allen or Burrow...obviously not but he is a legit NFL QB who can get a team to the playoffs like he did last year when he passed for 4,264 yards and had 29 TDs..if you want to question his durability that is very legit but when he plays he is a quality NFL starter.
Click to expand...
You are really not seeing what he is. We watch him every week.

Overall Numbers don’t always tell you what someone is.

But his numbers vs “winning” teams says everything.
Click to expand...
Actually, it's just another data point, no everything. A lot more goes into winning NFL games than the name of the person lining up under center. And that fact is going to be crucial for Milroe's future.
 
Chaka said:
Todem said:
Boston said:
Todem said:
Boston said:
refacer said:
Recent years how many QB from Alabama have been good in the NFL, not so good when playing with the big boys.
Click to expand...

Hurts is legit and Tua is very good...Mac Jones is nothing more than a backup (if that) and it looks like Bryce Young is not going to work-out...none of their starting QBs before that were real pro prospects, they were all college QBs...so I would say right now they are batting .500 when playing with the "big boys."
Click to expand...
Tua is very good?

Lol that’s hillarious.


VS winning teams:

7-16 lifetime vs winning teams.
0 post season wins
60% Comp percentage
28 TD’s avg of 1.33
18 INT avg of .86 a game
84.3 passer rating

Has played exactly 1 full season in 5 years.

Man your bar is really low.

This guy is not a winner in the NFL. And the Dolphins will opt out of his contract in 2026 no doubt in my mind. Unless of course he retires before that due to another head injury.

He throws a pretty ball on passes under 25 yards. Can’t move if his life depended on it. Can rarely make any off script plays, and has had the advantage of arguably the best YAC and most explosive WR in the league with Tyreek Hill. When teams focus on minimizing Tyreeks impact and take away the middle of the field (ie winning teams) this guy is below average and can’t beat winning teams.

NFL hyped…..he is not elite.
Click to expand...

Why don't we calm down with the "hilarious" and your bar is low shots...he is a really good starting QB in the NFL...I think it is pretty obvious to see...is he Mahomes, Allen or Burrow...obviously not but he is a legit NFL QB who can get a team to the playoffs like he did last year when he passed for 4,264 yards and had 29 TDs..if you want to question his durability that is very legit but when he plays he is a quality NFL starter.
Click to expand...
You are really not seeing what he is. We watch him every week.

Overall Numbers don’t always tell you what someone is.

But his numbers vs “winning” teams says everything.
Click to expand...
Actually, it's just another data point, no everything. A lot more goes into winning NFL games than the name of the person lining up under center. And that fact is going to be crucial for Milroe's future.
Click to expand...
Agreed 100%
 
crushedspirit said:
You know very well someone will take the leap if he declares.

There's a sucker born every minute.
Click to expand...
A random Week 13 college game is 100% a sign of how an entire NFL career will go.

He had a bad day today. Still fully think he's a future NFL starter. I think anyone drafting Milroe knows he's not a finished product. He's still the prospect with the highest ceiling in my eyes. Lamar Jackson and Josh Allen weren't anywhere near as close to a finished product to say Baker Mayfield a few years back.
 
Statistically Milroe has played the 2 worst games in the last 15 years by an Alabama QB...over the last month. That includes guys like Jacob Coker, Blake Barnett, and the converted DB Blake Sims. His floor is incredibly low.
 
travdogg said:
crushedspirit said:
You know very well someone will take the leap if he declares.

There's a sucker born every minute.
Click to expand...
A random Week 13 college game is 100% a sign of how an entire NFL career will go.

He had a bad day today. Still fully think he's a future NFL starter. I think anyone drafting Milroe knows he's not a finished product. He's still the prospect with the highest ceiling in my eyes. Lamar Jackson and Josh Allen weren't anywhere near as close to a finished product to say Baker Mayfield a few years back.
Click to expand...
I don't base it off one game. I also watched the Tenn game this year when they took away his running lanes, and he delivered another dud.

He needs to stay in College another season. If he declares and is thrust into a starting role, he's going to fall flat even though he'll have some success on the ground. If a team takes him to sit on the bench and learn for a year or two then I'll give him a chance, but this is the NFL where immediate returns are what QB desperate teams seek.
 
He’ll never be able to consistently read defenses. So can someone teach him to execute an intermediate passing game? If so, how long would it take?
 
He’s entirely too inconsistent. Highlight reel both good and bad. Basically a more mobile Jameis Winston. Or maybe a functional Malik Willis.
Late first maybe, but I wouldn’t use higher than a mid 2.
 
So, watching more than just a couple highlights, I actually didn't think Milroe was anywhere near as bad as his numbers looked against Oklahoma. His pass catchers were awful, with several drops. 2 of the INTs I'd say were not on Milroe at all. The pick-six was 100% on him. Now I'm not gonna claim he played a good game, but I think people look at the stats and get a worse impression than it really was. He had a nice deep TD throw where the WR couldn't stay in bounds.

He's inconsistent, sure. So are a lot of athletic QBs who go on to be successful in the NFL. I saw nothing in that game that made me think Milroe shouldn't be a 1st rounder, especially when contrasted with the majority of what I've seen the last 2 years.
 
travdogg said:
So, watching more than just a couple highlights, I actually didn't think Milroe was anywhere near as bad as his numbers looked against Oklahoma. His pass catchers were awful, with several drops. 2 of the INTs I'd say were not on Milroe at all. The pick-six was 100% on him. Now I'm not gonna claim he played a good game, but I think people look at the stats and get a worse impression than it really was. He had a nice deep TD throw where the WR couldn't stay in bounds.

He's inconsistent, sure. So are a lot of athletic QBs who go on to be successful in the NFL. I saw nothing in that game that made me think Milroe shouldn't be a 1st rounder, especially when contrasted with the majority of what I've seen the last 2 years.
Click to expand...
Now watch the Tennessee game...which was the worst QB performance by a Bama QB in the last 15 years. His inability to execute to mid-range wide open receivers is on display there.
 
JohnnyU said:
-OZ- said:
crushedspirit said:
a team takes him to sit on the bench and learn for a year or two then I'll give him a chance, but this is the NFL where immediate returns are what QB desperate teams seek.
Click to expand...
Maybe the packers can draft him in the 2nd?
Click to expand...
Love is 26. I don’t think they would waste a 2nd round pick on a QB. Why would they?
Click to expand...
I’m mostly joking about the packers MO in finding their next QB and the time Milroe might need to develop.
 
King of the Jungle said:
gump said:
Faust said:
2025 NFL Draft Stock Report: Should Jalen Milroe Return To Alabama?
Click to expand...
Huge assumption that he’d be welcomed back as the starter. DeBoer has a 6’6” kid who followed him from UW, along w portal $.
Click to expand...
Imagine how good he would be if he was 6’7” like Brock Osweiller was.
Click to expand...
The important part is he came with Deboer from UW...possibly over Julian Sayin, who decommitted from Bama the day after Mack transferred to Bama. Deboer clearly thinks he's a great fit for the offense he wants to run (an offense he's also said he had to scale back for Milroe).
 
gump said:
King of the Jungle said:
gump said:
Faust said:
2025 NFL Draft Stock Report: Should Jalen Milroe Return To Alabama?
Click to expand...
Huge assumption that he’d be welcomed back as the starter. DeBoer has a 6’6” kid who followed him from UW, along w portal $.
Click to expand...
Imagine how good he would be if he was 6’7” like Brock Osweiller was.
Click to expand...
The important part is he came with Deboer from UW...possibly over Julian Sayin, who decommitted from Bama the day after Mack transferred to Bama. Deboer clearly thinks he's a great fit for the offense he wants to run (an offense he's also said he had to scale back for Milroe).
Click to expand...
I understand and agree. With the portal commitments it certainly changes things a bit.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Faust
WR Jalen Royals, KC
Replies
18
Views
468
Faust
Faust
JohnnyU
QB Tyler Shough, NO
Replies
39
Views
917
Faust
Faust
Ministry of Pain
Tankathon '24-'25
2
Replies
52
Views
2K
pollardsvision
pollardsvision

Users who are viewing this thread

  • ... and 1 more.
    • Total: 3 (members: 2, guests: 1)
    Back
    Top