Rank the following for the ROS, R.Kelley, W.Gallman + L.Murray (1 Viewer)

[Saboo]

How would you rank these three players for the rest of the season?

L.Murray - Great situation, but somewhat limited talent and still a little banged up

Rob Kelley - Dinged up so far this year, but coach insists he is the man going forward

W.Gallman - Fairly high draft choice that could be the new Giants starting rb.

Thanks in advance. Will answer your questions

 

[wlwiles]

Just like you have them.  Murray, Kelley, Gallman

Murray has proven he can be productive as a lead back, but he's on a not great offense with Keenum at the helm (currently).  When bradford returns he should find more running room. 
Kelley is on a good offense but I don't believe Gruden that he'll be "the man" when he returns.  lead back of a committee still has value though. 
Gallman needs several things to happen for him.  Giant's O line is bad, and their offense needs to improve or else they're playing from behind and Gallman loses value.  It's also not evident yet that McAdoo realizes Perkins is no good, so Gallman's got to play 2nd fiddle for a while. 

 

[mjustin24]

To me it all depends on reports this week about Kelley's health.  Looked good on first series last night even against a solid D and Gruden has showed a desire to pound the run.  But they have other options in Wash if it turns out he is actually injured.  Murray has a chance to be good, but a bit of a crap-shoot so he would be second for me, unless of course there is bad news about Fat Rob.  I just dont trust the Giants run offense.

Mine: https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/761173-trade-opinions-too-expensive/