Ray Rice v Jonathon Stewart (1 Viewer)

[xenon]

or better yet, who is going to have the better year and put up more fantay points?

If you were going to make a play for either, who would you make the play for and why? Any CAR or BALT HOMERS care to chime in??

I am partial to Stewart and his abilty to become #1 over Williams. However, Mcgahee in my opinion is damaged goods so there is value for Rice too.

 

[TheArchitect]

or better yet, who is going to have the better year and put up more fantay points?If you were going to make a play for either, who would you make the play for and why? Any CAR or BALT HOMERS care to chime in??I am partial to Stewart and his abilty to become #1 over Williams. However, Mcgahee in my opinion is damaged goods so there is value for Rice too.

I own both... looking at Rice as expendable if a better option presents itself (e.g., Pierre Thomas?)... holding on to Stewart and hoping he turns it on later in the season.

 

[xenon]

or better yet, who is going to have the better year and put up more fantay points?If you were going to make a play for either, who would you make the play for and why? Any CAR or BALT HOMERS care to chime in??I am partial to Stewart and his abilty to become #1 over Williams. However, Mcgahee in my opinion is damaged goods so there is value for Rice too.

I own both... looking at Rice as expendable if a better option presents itself (e.g., Pierre Thomas?)... holding on to Stewart and hoping he turns it on later in the season.

Appreciate the feedback.

 

[az_prof]

I have both and I think Stewart will have a bigger impact this season. I do think McGahee will be given a chance to take his job back whenhealthy and until or if he gets hurt again it will mostly be McGahee getting carries. But in CAR both backs will split carries and eventually I think Stewart will get more.