RB Keeper decision- J.Taylor or J.Dobbins. (1 Viewer)

[Raylove]

Hello all. I have to decide who to keep between J.Taylor for my 2nd rd pick or J.Dobbins for my 4th rd pick.  I drew the #2 pick (12 team league), so its the back end of both rounds presenting even more value.. Taylor would be the #23 pick, Dobbins the #47.

Which RB would you keep? Thanks in advance. Go...

 

[King of the Jungle]

I have a similar decision with Taylor (2nd) and Dobbins (5th). Currently leaning Dobbins.

 

[jwsbowler]

Scoring???  Lineups???   To me they are both right around their pick area.  Non PPR, I am keeping Taylor...  PPR, probably would keep Taylor here too, but a bit closer.

 

[danashort]

dobbins and you may be able to redraft taylor

 

[Gally]

In a one keeper league I keep the best player.  To me that is Taylor.  

 

[Raylove]

Thanks for the time everyone.

I didn't think the lineup requirements mattered because it was a one keeper option and both players are RBs, but it is a PPR league.  Imo, they both are decent value but both bring question marks.

J.Taylors- injury concerns with Wentz and the O-line and the return of Mack (not Craig. haha) will hold him back a bit.

Dobbins- lack of targets and Lamar Jackson's propensity to steal short goal line situations has me concerned.

 

[Raylove]

dobbins and you may be able to redraft taylor

I'm sorry... did you say something? I can't get past the profile pic.