Yes, really. Nobody promised this guy 4 million dollars a year for life when he was born, nor is that part of his set of fundamental rights as a human being. He was in the entertainment industry, and made himself poisonous to the public. He isn't being punished for hitting his wife/fiancee by having money taken away; he's being fired from his job as an entertainer because the public has cried out that they no longer want to be entertained by him.Really? 30% in this case is upwards of 4 million dollars minimum. At 100K per year (which is far more than he would earn at the jobs you suggest), it would take 40 years just to make up for the lost money.He has lost some huge percent of his lifetime professional running back earning potential, but like any other pariah, he's more than welcome to peddle his wares for a working man's wage. Plenty of warehouses and construction sites out there that would happily take a strong, healthy 30 year old without giving a second thought to the PR hit. He hasn't lost anything remotely like 30-50% of his lifetime earning timeline. He's just put himself in a position where those earnings probably can't come in a PR intensive industry.True, but you'd find a similar job with similar income and benefits before too long. If it took you two years to get back to your prestige/income, that would represent only a small fraction of your lifetime earning potential.It's a public relations league. He's one of the faces of a franchise. If I were in the news in a video knocking out my wife, I'd be fired by my job in about ten seconds, and I'm not the face of the law firm.Yes. He rightfully deserves punishment. Making him a pariah and taking away his job, along with literally millions of dollars, is not in line with the offense.Really?Absurd
An NFL RB has no other "similar job" to turn to, and has only a few short years to his career to begin with. Two years represents up to 30% of his LIFETIME EARNINGS ....and that's assuming he can come back in two years to a paycheck similar to what he would have had if this hadn't happened.
Domestic assault is an ugly thing that needs to be taken seriously, but taking away 30-50% of a man's lifetime earnings is harsh for an offense that in the end is a simple assault. Far too harsh IMHO.
30% takes into account the money he's already made in the NFL...his true lifetime earnings. If you count just earnings going forward, if he is never allowed back into the NFL the figure is closer to 75%.
But that doesn't mean he has to live out the rest of his life without being gainfully employed. He has 30 or 40 good earning years left if he sees fit to use them. If he's especially motivated and creative, he can even use that time to earn far more than he did playing football. He probably won't, but let's not confuse that with the idea that his ability to support himself has been permanently severed. Men lose professional football jobs all the time because they don't help the team entertain their clientele -- i.e., they don't make the team more likely to win. He just lost his because he hurt the team in pursuit of that goal in a somewhat different way.
He'll get on with his life just like the rest do. Or he won't. I won't shed a tear either way, just like I didn't when the Falcons cut poor Cupcake.
Last edited by a moderator: