Rookie comparison to current NFL players (1 Viewer)

[jeter23]

Found this in ESPN NFL Draft preview magazine and I thought I would share.

Leinart ---> Brady

Cutler ---> Favre

Young ---> Vick

Jacobs ---> Brunell

Bush ---> M Faulk

Williams --> LT

White ---> Lewis

Maroney --> Portis

Calhoun ---> JJones

Drew --> Westbrook

Addai --> A Green

Holmes --> Evans

C Jackson --> Stallworth

S Moss --> S Smith

Hagan --> Holt

Stovall --> Burress

Avant --> Ward

V Davis --> Crumpler

Pope --> Witten

Byrd --> McMichael

Lewis --> Gonzo

Fasano --> Franks

 

[caul]

do we need more proof espn sucks

 

[fruity pebbles]

Wow. This rookie class is full of superstars from top to bottom.

 

[Kleck.]

They really take high-side comparisons to a new level here. I'd like to see who they feel are the low-side comparisons as well.

 

[wannabee]

tell Canton that we need to get a construction project going so there will be room in a few years

 

[KarmaPolice]

Found this in ESPN NFL Draft preview magazine and I thought I would share.

Young ---> Vick

That's all I needed. :X

 

[-OZ-]

Holmes --> Evans

C Jackson --> Stalloworth

S Moss --> S Smith

Hagan --> Holt

Stovall --> Burress

Avant --> Ward

V Davis --> Crumpler

Pope --> Witten

Byrd --> McMichael

Lewis --> Gonzo

Fasaon --> Franks

Strange to see the consensus #1 WR and #1 TE being compared to lesser players than the others. (Ok, Alge > Bubba, but still)

 

[trader jake]

S Moss --> S Moss

obvious answer down?

 

[jeter23]

They really take high-side comparisons to a new level here. I'd like to see who they feel are the low-side comparisons as well.

I agree 100%, they are going best case scenario on most of these guys. I just thought it would be interesting for some.You're right, the lower ranked prospects are a little more interesting.

Marcus Vick ---> Mike McMahon

Quinton Porter ---> Todd Collins

Bryson Sumlin ---> Reno Mahe

Quinton Ganther ---> Joe Burns

Sean Coffey ---> Justin Gage

Jared Ellerson ---> Ricky Proehl

 

[Donnybrook]

Holmes --> Evans

C Jackson --> Stallworth

S Moss --> S Smith

Hagan --> Holt

Stovall --> Burress

Avant --> Ward

In that case, it's a good year to trade down.

 

[DoctorDetroit]

They really take high-side comparisons to a new level here.  I'd like to see who they feel are the low-side comparisons as well.

I agree 100%, they are going best case scenario on most of these guys. I just thought it would be interesting for some.You're right, the lower ranked prospects are a little more interesting.

Marcus Vick ---> Mike McMahon

Quinton Porter ---> Todd Collins

Bryson Sumlin ---> Reno Mahe

Quinton Ganther ---> Joe Burns

Sean Coffey ---> Justin Gage

Jared Ellerson ---> Ricky Proehl

To whom? If I was a GM drafting Marcus Vick and I said, "he's gonna be better than Mike Mcmahon." I wouldn't be expecting to keep my job. Todd Collins has thrown like 12 passes in his career. I'm likely to be a better NFL Qb than he is.

 

[ExaltedOne]

Other than being black and a good runner, what do Vick and Young have in common?

Seriously. Vick is left-handed and super short while Young is right handed and 6'4". I'd liken Young more to Culpepper personally.

 

[jeter23]

They really take high-side comparisons to a new level here. I'd like to see who they feel are the low-side comparisons as well.

I agree 100%, they are going best case scenario on most of these guys. I just thought it would be interesting for some.You're right, the lower ranked prospects are a little more interesting.

Marcus Vick ---> Mike McMahon

Quinton Porter ---> Todd Collins

Bryson Sumlin ---> Reno Mahe

Quinton Ganther ---> Joe Burns

Sean Coffey ---> Justin Gage

Jared Ellerson ---> Ricky Proehl

To whom? If I was a GM drafting Marcus Vick and I said, "he's gonna be better than Mike Mcmahon." I wouldn't be expecting to keep my job. Todd Collins has thrown like 12 passes in his career. I'm likely to be a better NFL Qb than he is.

I was thinking more interesting, as in entertaining/comical.

 

[ExaltedOne]

They really take high-side comparisons to a new level here.  I'd like to see who they feel are the low-side comparisons as well.

I agree 100%, they are going best case scenario on most of these guys. I just thought it would be interesting for some.You're right, the lower ranked prospects are a little more interesting.

Marcus Vick ---> Mike McMahon

Quinton Porter ---> Todd Collins

Bryson Sumlin ---> Reno Mahe

Quinton Ganther ---> Joe Burns

Sean Coffey ---> Justin Gage

Jared Ellerson ---> Ricky Proehl

To whom? If I was a GM drafting Marcus Vick and I said, "he's gonna be better than Mike Mcmahon." I wouldn't be expecting to keep my job. Todd Collins has thrown like 12 passes in his career. I'm likely to be a better NFL Qb than he is.

Actually he's thrown 546 passes in his carreer.

But only 27 in the last 8 years.

 

[Sea Bass]

I keep reading the comparrisons, but I see more differences than similarities in Vick and VY.

 

[DoctorDetroit]

They really take high-side comparisons to a new level here.  I'd like to see who they feel are the low-side comparisons as well.

I agree 100%, they are going best case scenario on most of these guys. I just thought it would be interesting for some.You're right, the lower ranked prospects are a little more interesting.

Marcus Vick ---> Mike McMahon

Quinton Porter ---> Todd Collins

Bryson Sumlin ---> Reno Mahe

Quinton Ganther ---> Joe Burns

Sean Coffey ---> Justin Gage

Jared Ellerson ---> Ricky Proehl

To whom? If I was a GM drafting Marcus Vick and I said, "he's gonna be better than Mike Mcmahon." I wouldn't be expecting to keep my job. Todd Collins has thrown like 12 passes in his career. I'm likely to be a better NFL Qb than he is.

I was thinking more interesting, as in entertaining/comical.

Not familiar with your style. It is, very comical.

 

[pinequick]

Todd Collins has thrown like 12 passes in his career. I'm likely to be a better NFL Qb than he is.

I've got 20 bucks that says you're not.

 

[DoctorDetroit]

Todd Collins has thrown like 12 passes in his career.  I'm likely to be a better NFL Qb than he is.

I've got 20 bucks that says you're not.

Bet. Off to Chiefs training camp.

 

[Sea Bass]

Todd Collins has thrown like 12 passes in his career.  I'm likely to be a better NFL Qb than he is.

I've got 20 bucks that says you're not.

Bet. Off to Chiefs training camp.

What are your wonderlic scores?I might take a flyer and draft you late for my fantasy team. Trent Green can't play forever.

 

[DoctorDetroit]

Todd Collins has thrown like 12 passes in his career.  I'm likely to be a better NFL Qb than he is.

I've got 20 bucks that says you're not.

Bet. Off to Chiefs training camp.

What are your wonderlic scores?I might take a flyer and draft you late for my fantasy team. Trent Green can't play forever.

31 but I like to party and touch the wimmens. :beware:

 

[GRIDIRON ASSASSIN]

I wish they'd have comparisons of bad prospects with bad NFL players too:

Marcus Vick > Rae Carruth with a throwing arm

 

[wannabee]

I wish they'd have comparisons of bad prospects with bad NFL players too:

Marcus Vick > Rae Carruth with a throwing arm

POTD