I missed this article earlier but here it is:
http://www.profootballweekly.com/PFW/Comme...spins020305.htm
Feb. 3, 2005
Is Alexander a great free-agent pickup?
ProFootballWeekly.com asks associate editor Jeff Reynolds for his thoughts on the hottest topics in the NFL.
Scouts have mixed feelings about breaking bank to sign RB Alexander
If the game is about production, there is no doubt that Seahawks RB Shaun Alexander is one of the best running backs in the NFL. Alexander ran for 1,696 yards last season, averaged 1,406 rushing yards in four years as the Seattle starter and has scored 72 career touchdowns. Alexander, set to become an unrestricted free agent on March 2, is the source of much front-office debate in Seattle and beyond.
PFW: What is there to debate about Alexander?
Reynolds: He’s a fine running back with decent hands who fits the West Coast offense. Alexander is recognized as a goal-line runner but at 5-11, 225, he shows less toughness in converting critical short-yardage situations than scouts would like. In December, one scout described Alexander as “an athlete not a running back. You see some tough runs, he’ll lower his shoulder. It’s not that he fears contact. But I don’t like that he can’t get the tough yards.”
Often, the Seahawks used FB Mack Strong as an I-back in some short-yardage situations, like 3rd-and-2 or less. Alexander, according to STATS, Inc., was third in the NFL in “stuffs,” which is being stopped when needing two or fewer yards. But Alexander was also third in the NFL in rushing first downs with 77, behind Curtis Martin and Corey Dillon. There is a thought that Alexander isn’t built to last and won’t hold up as well as Martin has. But others say Alexander just needs the right situation to be considered among the best in the NFL.
Alexander thrived in the second half of games, gaining 5.2 yards per carry in the regular season after halftime. In a division that didn’t have a rushing defense in the top 19, Alexander made his hay against many lesser opponents. Against Atlanta (19 carries, 80 yards), New England (16-77), Tampa Bay (17-45) and Buffalo (13-39), he was ordinary.
Arizona, Miami and Cincinnati might have interest in Alexander according to reports. But in an offseason where the position is well stocked with options, both in free agency and the draft, don’t expect any of those teams to give Alexander a contract in the neighborhood of the $50.5-million deal Clinton Portis signed with Washington or the $60-million deal LaDainian Tomlinson grabbed from San Diego.