Shoe Recommendations (1 Viewer)

[cubd8]

Looking for a recommendation on shoes;

The primary use is walking and wearing to work so looking for maximum comfort. Shoes can be gym shoes or business casual and can be worn with jeans, etc.

Would like to be able to purchase at DSW type place, would like them to last so nothing cheap, but also nothing crazy expensive. Would prefer a brand that is highly rated.

Thoughts!??

 

[nirad3]

Not sure if they carry them at DSW, but Skechers probably fits the bill here.

 

[Fat Nick]

Likely not something you can get at DSW, but I absolutely love my Allbirds Tree Runners. The most comfortable shoes I have for the office (jeans, dress shirt/polo). I don't run/exercise in them, but I did wear them when we went to Thailand last year and put tons of walking/trekking miles on them.

 

[higgins]

Not sure if they carry them at DSW, but Skechers probably fits the bill here.

This was gonna be my response — I wear them most of the time.

 

[MTskibum]

crocs with socks

basically the same as shoes, except you can wash them when they get dirty.

 

[odin33]

I was always a Nike guy from childhood on. I had sciatica several years ago. After dealing with it for months and a week long trip to Disneyworld on the horizon I went to get a cortisone shot to make it bearable. Asked the pediatrist how to make it through and they recommended Brooks for gym shoes and a good pair of quality dress shoes for work.

Dropped $400+ on a couple pairs of dress shoes, and went to fleet feet and got a pair of Brooks Beasts which is their most supportive, rigid/heavy duty one they make. 3-4 weeks later the sciatica pain was gone (it was manageable with the cortisone- but noticeable). I've purchased Adrenaline (next step down) or Beasts ever since and have been pain free.

 

[Zow]

I suffer from arch issues (plantar fasciitis) and the Brooks Adrenaline is by far the best shoe for that. Glycerin is pretty good, too.

For casual, I like the Cole Haan shoes with the Zoom bottom.

The above notwithstanding, I have found that buying quality insoles also makes a big difference.

 

[Gally]

Hoka has worked well for me. I have a pair of Brooks (not sure what model) but they didn't seem to help much. Hoka has been better.

 

[Mister CIA]

Ooh, these Vivobarefoot Motus Flex (bright-white only) are marked down to $114. Barefoot design shoes are not for everyone, but I like them, and in the name of looking good, this model is top-shelf. Quieter than a ninja too.

 

[nirad3]

Hoka has worked well for me. I have a pair of Brooks (not sure what model) but they didn't seem to help much. Hoka has been better.

Yeah, if you're looking for a solid pair of shoes to walk in, I can't recommend Hoka enough.

 

[BeTheMatch]

Pikolinos for work. Best shoe I've ever owned.

 

[Mookie]

My go to business casuals are True Ripstops - I hate them as a golf shoe (not enough support) but they are lightweight and breathable, which also makes them a great travel shoe.

 

[acarey50]

Love my Hoka Cliftons for walking/regular wear, and if you get the more plain colorways, can do them with jeans for a more casual workplace look. Brooks Beasts are very supportiv and were my preferred walking/regular wear show before I tried the Hokas.

Really like Cole Haan for the more business casual look, and they are comfortable.

It also helps that both of those brands carry extended sizes, as I am a 15 Wide for most shoes. The sizing is usually the biggest limiting factor for me.

 

[urbanhack]

Ooh, these Vivobarefoot Motus Flex (bright-white only) are marked down to $114. Barefoot design shoes are not for everyone, but I like them, and in the name of looking good, this model is top-shelf. Quieter than a ninja too.

If your feet are in good shape, these are the best for you.

 

[Zow]

Ooh, these Vivobarefoot Motus Flex (bright-white only) are marked down to $114. Barefoot design shoes are not for everyone, but I like them, and in the name of looking good, this model is top-shelf. Quieter than a ninja too.

If your feet are in good shape, these are the best for you.

And if they aren't they're a terrible choice.

 

[Hastur]

On Men's Cloud running shoe

Most comfortable running/tennis/sneaker I've ever worn.

 

[eoMMan]

Skechers, All Birds, Adidas, lots of options. Try a bunch out. Your feet could be totally from our feet.

 

[snellman]

Another one for the Brooks. I am not supposed to have my left foot because every bone was broken in it in a car accident. I had 8 surgeries on it over a 2 year period and the doctor told me at the time that I shouldn't be on it more than 2 hours a day. That was 20+ years ago and for the most part it hasn't given me issues but every once in a awhile when I have over done it, it will give me fits. I was always a Nike man, but I wore Skechers slip ins for work (Automotive Service Manager). They were decent, but a pair would only last 6 months before my foot started bothering me and I would have to get a new pair.

I went to a local athletic store and the clerk suggested I try Brooks and Hoka. Nothing against the Hokas, but they didn't fit my foot well and the brooks did. I bought a pair of Ghost Max and wow what a difference! They lasted over a year of everyday wear and were still in good shape, I could just tell with my foot that it was time for a new pair. This time I bout a pair of Glycerin GTS with more arch support and they have been great so far. I have always had a hard time paying over $100 for a pair of shoes (Probably because when I was young and the Air Jordans first came out, I had to pay for most of them myself because my parents were the type that they would only pay so much for clothes and if we wanted "Name Brand" we had to pay the difference), but the Brooks are some of the best shoes I have owned.

 

[kupcho1]

Likely not something you can get at DSW, but I absolutely love my Allbirds Tree Runners. The most comfortable shoes I have for the office (jeans, dress shirt/polo).

Sharp

 

[Payne]

On Men's Cloud running shoe

Most comfortable running/tennis/sneaker I've ever worn.

In all seriousness, have you tried Hoka's? I also had On shoes and was frustrated with the shoelaces.
Tried Hoka's and I feel they are far superior to On.

As far as work shoes or casual, I have had great luck with Ecco. They seem to last forever.

 

[SofaKings]

Suffered from plantar fascitis for a few years. A two week hospital stay cured it. I only buy Merrell and Hoka's now and only wear them for a year before they are replaced. Have not had a recurrence.

 

[Ron Swanson]

Suffered from plantar fascitis for a few years. A two week hospital stay cured it. I only buy Merrell and Hoka's now and only wear them for a year before they are replaced. Have not had a recurrence.

Two week hospital stay for plantar fasciitis or not related hospital stay but you were off your feet?

 

[Nigel]

I bought these Reef sneakers recently on a whim, super comfortable and look decent enough for work. Already bought a 2nd pair as "back up" in case they stop selling them.

 

[Don Quixote]

I’ll voice support for the Brooks too. I wear the Ghost’s. Wear them everyday when I work from home, on the weekend, etc.

I found the Glycerin and Adrenaline had a bit too much support, and the Ghost has more of a neutral feel. I don’t have the arch support issues that others mentioned, which may push more to the other Brooks’ brands. The Brooks web site has a quiz that can take to help you find the right type of shoe.

 

[northern exposure]

I suffer from arch issues (plantar fasciitis) and the Brooks Adrenaline is by far the best shoe for that. Glycerin is pretty good, too.

For casual, I like the Cole Haan shoes with the Zoom bottom.

The above notwithstanding, I have found that buying quality insoles also makes a big difference.

Most podiatrists recommend Brooks Adrenaline or Asics Kayano shoes for people with plantar fasciatis. Oofos sandals or clogs are a great choice to wear around the house if you have this condition.

 

[Zow]

Oofos are great for around the house. I don't wear them in public much so I didn't mention them given the parameters laid out by the OP.

 

[SpurrierisisGod]

I work for a "comfort shoe" retailer for a long time. Numerous training sessions on fit and support. Finally had a podorthist come in (dot the doctor podiatrist) as a person that specializes in fit and support. The recommendation? Go cheap on the shoes and spend on an insert.

Shoes are done after 6 months. Doesn't matter the brand. Done. Buy multiple cheap shoes and rotate them. Invest in a good supportive insole.

Not cheap but the best, most comfortable shoe that lasted I've ever owned - new balance 991. About $130 now.

My shoe hawlking days are long gone but now... I'll find a $40 special and use birko sport insoles ($60ish).

 

[SofaKings]

Suffered from plantar fascitis for a few years. A two week hospital stay cured it. I only buy Merrell and Hoka's now and only wear them for a year before they are replaced. Have not had a recurrence.

Two week hospital stay for plantar fasciitis or not related hospital stay but you were off your feet?

Non plantar related, but was off my feet for the time of stay

 

[Nugget]

I bought these Reef sneakers recently on a whim, super comfortable and look decent enough for work. Already bought a 2nd pair as "back up" in case they stop selling them.

Ordered

 

[Brunell4MVP]

I like P448 shoes. They are dress casual. But very comfy for not too long walks. Nordstrom Rack has them available online. Gotta grab the ones on sale otherwise a bit expensive. I'm sure they are elsewhere also.

https://www.nordstromrack.com/brands/p448?srsltid=AfmBOooMHGjJ8w1HyCMPgVSL_SclOxYGtLZQHlLN9DHw6koeBTgXEtlP

 

[Uncle Leo]

I bought these Reef sneakers recently on a whim, super comfortable and look decent enough for work. Already bought a 2nd pair as "back up" in case they stop selling them.

Ordered

No bottle opener at the bottom was the deal breaker.

 

[Gally]

I bought these Reef sneakers recently on a whim, super comfortable and look decent enough for work. Already bought a 2nd pair as "back up" in case they stop selling them.

Ordered

No bottle opener at the bottom was the deal breaker.

Never understood the appeal of the bottle opener on the bottom of your shoe. Do you know what the bottom of your shoe touches? Just have a bottle opener on your key chain. Goes with you everywhere.

 

[belljr]

On cloud

The Cloud 6: Men's All-Day Lifestyle Shoe

Our signature all-day shoe, upgraded. Meet the men's Cloud 6 – your new staple that grounds any style. Free shipping & returns.

www.on.com

 

[belljr]

On Men's Cloud running shoe

Most comfortable running/tennis/sneaker I've ever worn.

Guess I should have read more closely!;;;

 

[Johnnie Nepal]

For pavement walking; Brook's are a good one, but I've moved into Hoka's the past couple of shoe's that I've purchased.

For trail hiking; I've put a ton of miles on Salomon hiking shoe over the past four years and will be getting another pair.

Other than a sneaker; Ecco's have been my go to for a couple of decades now.