This is a borderline useless conversation to even have. Who is on your bench right now that with a straight face you can start over a WR who has 54/869/7 through 9 games?
I have no clue whether what we've seen so far from Colston is an accurate indicator for his career, but as far as this season goes he's as much of a must-start as any player in fantasy football.
I generally agree. I don't feel any player is beyond at least
considering other players to start in their stead, based on matchups, weather, key injuries etc. That said, it'd be a VERY hard sell to keep Colston on the bench at this point. He has been so good. Even his down weeks are solid. My only point from a couple posts above is that I don't think based on the matchup (the fact that Cinci doesn't give up a ton of points to WRs) and the fact that Horn should be back, I don't think we can call Colston a virtual lock for 100+ yards this week. Believe me, I hope he can... and I think its definitely possible, but I think expectations for the guy should be tempered at least a tiny bit.
Not to belabor the point, but keep in mind that saying that somone "is not a lock for 100 yards" is hardly an epithet. Colston's not averaging 100 yards per game, and an average of "only" 80 yards per game has a player ending the year with almost 1300 yards after 16 games. In games with Horn playing Colston's averaged 5/82/1. Yes, his numbers jumped even beyond those lofty heights when Horn missed the last two games, but this guy's a stud regardless.
Yet again, I'm not really arguing anything you're saying. Its all pretty reasonable.There have simply been a couple/few comments by others in this thread that since its the Bengals defense and since Colston has been on fire the last three weeks that he will continue to produce 100 yards easily. That is the logic that I don't quite agree with. The numbers have shown that Cinci, thus far, has not yielded all that many FF points to WRs. And using Colston's produciton from the last three weeks is a bit skewed with Horn out the last two of them.
I know saying that he isn't a lock for a 100 yards this week is not at all a bold statement on my part. I usually avoid bold statements unless I feel it is absolutely warranted.
I think Colston should have a solid week, and there is of course a decent chance he could explode again this week... thats why
I'm starting him in both of the leagues that I am in. The game could potentially turn into a shootout and Colston could bust another big play late...
I just think that with Horn back and Cinci being decent against WRs so far, it isn't a safe assumption that Colston this week will be the producer he has been the last 3-4 weeks.
The basic premise of my few posts has been this: Lets think about the impact of Horn's return and consider how WRs have fared so far vs. Cinci... In doing so, I think many of us need to temper our expectations for Colston this week if we are thinking he is a lock for 100+ yds and 1 TD. Are those numbers achievable? Absolutely, just not extremely likely. And as you point out Redman, those numbers are noticeably above his season averages anyway, let alone his averages when Horn is in the lineup.
So I think we basically agree with one another here. Colston is a stud and a guy that should almost always be in your starting lineup now, he is in the upper tier of WRs. My points have more been directed toward the couple/few that have very lofty expectations for Colston this week.