I think he is right. I think the reason those of us that have come back time despite being ignored or kicked in the ### is because we see something we can identify with, or have been through the same thing like McGarnicle. And having been through something like that or having seen people we care about go through such terrible struggles, it's something we don't wish on anyone, like the person or not. So the instinct and the reflex for some of us is to keep trying. It's got to get through at some point. Maybe, maybe not, but we hope so so we keep posting our long posts not really saying anything new but hoping that someone's post will be good timing and click. Then there is needing to take care of ourselves. He obviously needs a place to speak and great idea, his own thread. 1 thread out of 1000s. So why do some people who can't stand the guy, really don't care deep down bother showing up in here knowing full well from the past what you may get. Is it a guy thing? I don't get it and no one has given a good answer. This is a room in this house....well ok, it's his room. He has permission to do almost anything in his own room. As a kid if you were driving your parents nuts, they sent you to your room to act out in there. And banning him when he's obviously very troubled, alone, appears high risk for suicide is not the answer. Fighting with him does no good. Giving great advice isn't doing much either. So I think it's healthy for all of us to step away from this thread, some for good, others at least for awhile. We can control that. And my sharing about my issues and how I've felt is not coming from anger at all. I was using examples of how I felt to try and drive a point home, but it got misunderstood. The joy of not being a good communicator. Rok should go through this thread and copy the posts which give great advice and info into a word document on his computer for future reference. Going through all these pages and more to come will be quite a chore. Hopefully some day he will turn himself around like McGarnicle did. Some people do take a lot longer than others, but with not even reaching out for help beyond this thread, sadly it won't happen. I hope he'll surprise us as I do wish him well and don't consider my time and effort a waste. It's out there for him to go back to, but it's on him.