SSL3 Post Draft commentary (1 Viewer)

[bicycle_seat_sniffer]

Good job guys we should be wrapped up by tomorrow

Team Sniffer:

SSL3 - 16th pick

QB- Matt Hasslebeck(5), Alex Smith(7)

Hasslebeck is as solid as it gets, Alex smith only has to score for me one week, week 5 Hass's bye, and on that week I will have everyone left on my roster. Not a great option at QB2.

QB Grade B

RB- Brian Westbrook(9), Corey Dillon(6), Ron Dayne(4), Marshall Faulk(7)

I was stoked to get Westy at 1.16, if heathly he can go 800/700 with 70 catches.

I bought some of the Dayne hype after the draft with Shanny not draft another RB. Dillon at 3.16 was too good not to take. Between the two I should get solid RB2 points. Faulk can score just enough in any given week with dump off passes to make a difference.

RB Grade : B+

WR- Eddie Kennison(3), Drew Bennett(7), Reggie Brown(9), Braylon Edwards(6),Marty Booker(8), Robert Ferguson(6), Charles Rogers(8)

The obvious week point of the squad, I have 7 of them a few with nice upside. Taking Kennison as a WR1 is flawed but everyone except Rogers will start and be an everydown player. Braylon is injured, we'll see when he comes back if the pick was value or not.

If I could have it all back I'd probably take Mushin or TJ Hous (my muslim brothers) instead of Dayne in round 6. Oh well.

WR Grade : C- I'm sure others will give me lower marks

TE- Antonio Gates(3)

The joy of getting Gates plus and early bye week means I'm only taking one. I think Phil hits him & LT2 early and often.

TE Grade : B+ Not an A because I didn't draft a backup, but with my lack of WR's I really couldn't.

K- Jeff Wilkins(7), Ted Nugent(9)

A dome kicker and no bye week issues

K Grade : B

D- Tampa Bay(4), Buffalo(8)

Loves these two D's, Tampa always gets sacks and turnovers, with Dicky J and TKO Spikes healthy this Buffalo group looks solid. Buffalo was a high scoring FF D two years ago.

Def Grade: A

Overall need a break or two at WR, but I think I have a good mix of Vets and youngsters to produce on any given week. With Hass, Westy,Gates and a solid R2 punch, if I can survive Gates bye on week 3, I can make a run.

Boy picking at 16 is tough and it's not rounds 1,2,3,4, that get ya, it's much later on I felt the pinch in this draft.

Overall: B-

Good luck to all

 

[Chaz]

I pretty much agree with BSS's assessment of his team. What I found refreshing is the grading honesty. It seems that every time I read someone review their own team, the grades are overlyinflated. Even self proclaimed "weak areas" get graded a B.

If I were to look for problems (isn't that what makes this fun? )...While I like the RB stable assembled, there are potential risks surrounding all of the players, most notably Dillon, who has had a tendency to be banged up and a game time decision recently. Dayne is Dayne. Hopefully he is able to take advantage of his opportunity.

The WRs may be better than you give them credit for. As you mentioned, most have some sort of potential to score. Given that there are seven, this area may not be as weak as planned.

Tough call, but the correct one, to go it alone with Gates. While a BYE or any type of injury will really hurt, at some point you have to take a stand and hope for the best.

Correct grade for D and K.

Overall, a solid team. I wouldn't mind having it.

 

[bicycle_seat_sniffer]

I pretty much agree with BSS's assessment of his team. What I found refreshing is the grading honesty. It seems that every time I read someone review their own team, the grades are overlyinflated. Even self proclaimed "weak areas" get graded a B.

If I were to look for problems (isn't that what makes this fun? )...While I like the RB stable assembled, there are potential risks surrounding all of the players, most notably Dillon, who has had a tendency to be banged up and a game time decision recently. Dayne is Dayne. Hopefully he is able to take advantage of his opportunity.

The WRs may be better than you give them credit for. As you mentioned, most have some sort of potential to score. Given that there are seven, this area may not be as weak as planned.

Tough call, but the correct one, to go it alone with Gates. While a BYE or any type of injury will really hurt, at some point you have to take a stand and hope for the best.

Correct grade for D and K.

Overall, a solid team. I wouldn't mind having it.

Thanks for the input Chaz. I agree Dillon has issues and he seemed to slide heavily even in drafts before the drafting of Maroney.

 

[rzrback77]

Good job guys we should be wrapped up by tomorrow

Team Sniffer:

SSL3 - 16th pick

QB- Matt Hasslebeck(5), Alex Smith(7)

Hasslebeck is as solid as it gets, Alex smith only has to score for me one week, week 5 Hass's bye, and on that week I will have everyone left on my roster. Not a great option at QB2.

QB Grade B

RB- Brian Westbrook(9), Corey Dillon(6), Ron Dayne(4), Marshall Faulk(7)

I was stoked to get Westy at 1.16, if heathly he can go 800/700 with 70 catches.

I bought some of the Dayne hype after the draft with Shanny not draft another RB. Dillon at 3.16 was too good not to take. Between the two I should get solid RB2 points. Faulk can score just enough in any given week with dump off passes to make a difference.

RB Grade : B+

WR- Eddie Kennison(3), Drew Bennett(7), Reggie Brown(9), Braylon Edwards(6),Marty Booker(8), Robert Ferguson(6), Charles Rogers(8)

The obvious week point of the squad, I have 7 of them a few with nice upside. Taking Kennison as a WR1 is flawed but everyone except Rogers will start and be an everydown player. Braylon is injured, we'll see when he comes back if the pick was value or not.

If I could have it all back I'd probably take Mushin or TJ Hous (my muslim brothers) instead of Dayne in round 6. Oh well.

WR Grade : C- I'm sure others will give me lower marks

TE- Antonio Gates(3)

The joy of getting Gates plus and early bye week means I'm only taking one. I think Phil hits him & LT2 early and often.

TE Grade : B+ Not an A because I didn't draft a backup, but with my lack of WR's I really couldn't.

K- Jeff Wilkins(7), Ted Nugent(9)

A dome kicker and no bye week issues

K Grade : B

D- Tampa Bay(4), Buffalo(8)

Loves these two D's, Tampa always gets sacks and turnovers, with Dicky J and TKO Spikes healthy this Buffalo group looks solid. Buffalo was a high scoring FF D two years ago.

Def Grade: A

Overall need a break or two at WR, but I think I have a good mix of Vets and youngsters to produce on any given week. With Hass, Westy,Gates and a solid R2 punch, if I can survive Gates bye on week 3, I can make a run.

Boy picking at 16 is tough and it's not rounds 1,2,3,4, that get ya, it's much later on I felt the pinch in this draft.

Overall: B-

Good luck to all

One comment I will make is that I agree with you that the bottom is a very tough spot in a 16-teamer. I personally had 13 RBs targeted and felt there was a significant drop after that. In SSL 2 those 13 went 1-13. I think that you caught a break getting Westbrook where you did. But still, I think that you had hard choices not just at the first turn, but at several. My 1.15 S Smith WR and 2.02 Gates TE left me with top performers at those two positions, but a gaping hole at RB, which in turn forced me to continually look there. I would be interested in your comments on my squad since you drafted from a similar spot, assuming we ever finish.

 

[bicycle_seat_sniffer]

Will do rzr.

 

[Footballhead]

Team Footballhead

Weakest Week: Week 6

QB: P. Manning (1.13, 6), K. Holcomb (13.13, 8), J.P. Losman (16.04, 8)

Grade A: Manning is all I rely on. Hopefully Holcomb or Losman will have soemthing for me during his bye week. I didn't mean to draft 2 reserves to cover Manning's bye but in the later rd when I was targetting for a no 2 QB, it was picked up. I didn't think I need to sacrifice another high pick on this position for a no 2.

WR: T. Owens (2.04, 3), R.Smith (6.04, 4), N. Burleson (8.04, 5), Br. Johnson (17.13, 9), A. Davis (18.04, 8)

Grade B-: These guys are risky for me. Best scenario, TO shuts up and play, Rod Smith is prime target with Walker still recovering, and Nate Burleson will give the Hawks a dependable reciever besides oft injured D-Jax. Br. Johnson was always a Warner favorite and Andre Davis had connection with Holcombe at the Browns.

RB: F. Taylor (3.13, 6), C. Benson (4.04, 7), D. Williams (5.13, 9), D. Staley (7.13, 4)

Grade B-: Current word is Taylor is running well, Benson may get 20+ carries, DeAngelo may share carries with Foster and Duce may get all Bettis's short goal-line carries. By August, these may still hold true or I'll have notha here.

TE: K. Winslow Jr. (11.13, 6), Des. Clark (15.13, 7)

Grade B-: Winslow has shown nothing in the league yet, but getting two pass catching TE's in the later round is priceless.

K: M. Stover (12.04, 7), J. Brown (14.04, 5)

Grade A: Should be top 10 kickers by the end of the year.

D/ST: Chicago (9.13, 7), Carolina (10.04, 9)

Grade A: Should be top 5 Def by the end of the year.

Overall Grade B: Picking from the 13 spot, I decided I need to against the flow and pick best players available and not get caught into positional runs. We'll see how far this strategy take me into the season. If everything pans out as planned, week 6 would be the weak week for my team, but there are 6 teams in the NFL with bye on this week, so maybe I could survive it.

 

[Family Matters]

Team Family Matters:

Quarterback:

Bulger (7)

Frerotte (7)

Brunell(8)

The key with these 2 will be health. Clearly Bulger will be the more productive of the 2. But can he play all year for the first time?

Grade: B

Running Back:

Barber (4)

Foster (9)

White (7)

Davenport (6)

Barber is a great RB in this format. Foster & Davenport have their annual health questions. Of healthy Foster will likely produce respectable RB2 numbers. Davenport has a chance to put up a few good games. If Green is not healthy he might be the starter but only if he's healthy himself. White is wildcard. Sure they want to build around him and Young but that may not happen this year.

Grade C

Wide Receiver:

Harrison (6)

Coles (9)

Parker (3)

Jenkins (5)

Jennings (6)

Harrison is a no brainer. Coles is a good fit with his receptions but will he have a QB that can get hom the ball? If so he's a nice WR2. After that there are too many question marks. Parker might do decent if Rivers does well. Jenkins is in a hopel;ess situation with Vick who wants to run even more. Jennings could surprise but few rookies actually do.

Grade D

Tight Ends:

Stevens (5)

Watson (6)

Together these 2 might do well. Stevens and Hasselbeck have grown well together. Watson is finally showing what he's capable of and with Given gone he might see a few more bones this year.

Grade C

Kickers:

Tynes (3)

Hanson (8)

These 2 make a good combo abd should fine.

Grade B

D/ST:

Baltimore

Philly

These 2 D's are awesome in this format.

Grade A

Overall this is a middle of the road team. I will need for several things to go my way in order to have a shot:

1. Healthy QB's.

2. Foster & Davenport to be healthy. And maybe Davenport or White to be the starter.

3. Parker, Jenkins and Jennings to make some sort of impact as a WR3.

4. A healthy, decent NYJ QB for Coles.

Overall grade is a C-. If the planets align, maybe a B. If this team makes it to the final 4 it'll be a big surprise. So here's to surprises.

Edit to add QB Frerotte

 

[Chaz]

FBHead,

Hindsight being 20/20, I would have shot a little earlier for a 2nd QB. However, I picked 16th in SSL2 and know how difficult it can be to predict who will fall.

Can't argue with QBs led by Manning. Just concerned that the other two may be wasted roster spots. Like I mentioned in an earlier review, sometimes it's better to ride one guy and hope for the best, especially given the poor options available.

RBs are a dicey bunch. Taylor as the most reliable option speaks volumes. I don't know where you heard that Benson will be getting 20+ carries. Great if he does. Other two are basically backup types, far as I know. Stars will have to align for this group.

WRs look pretty good. Two solid selections and a little wr by committee at #3.

TE: I do not share your enthusiasm here. Let me see production from Winslow before this find is considered priceless.

D and K are fine.

Not a bad group. Just tough to get excited about.

 

[joffer]

RB: F. Taylor (3.13, 6), C. Benson (4.04, 7), D. Williams (5.13, 9), D. Staley (7.13, 4)

Grade B-: Current word is Taylor is running well, Benson may get 20+ carries, DeAngelo may share carries with Foster and Duce may get all Bettis's short goal-line carries. By August, these may still hold true or I'll have notha here.

can't see this group as a B-, gotta be a C at best. I think Peyton can carry you as I think he's in for another big year, but you need a lot to break your way with these RBs.

 

[Footballhead]

Not a bad group. Just tough to get excited about.

Agreed.

 

[Footballhead]

can't see this group as a B-, gotta be a C at best.  I think Peyton can carry you as I think he's in for another big year, but you need a lot to break your way with these RBs.

I graded on best case scenario. ONce we have all the other teams roster together and compare them sid eby side, we can get a better picture. I agree my season banks on how this group looks like in August. Picking at 13, I had to take these risks and make tough choices. After Manning and Owens as my first 2, there weren't many RB's left. Picking the other way would've left me with Westbrook and Owes. I liked Manning and Ownes better.

 

[Chaz]

Team Family Matters:

Quarterback:

Bulger (7)

Brunell(8)

The key with these 2 will be health. Clearly Bulger will be the more productive of the 2. But can he play all year for the first time?

Grade: B

Running Back:

Barber (4)

Foster (9)

White (7)

Davenport (6)

Barber is a great RB in this format. Foster & Davenport have their annual health questions. Of healthy Foster will likely produce respectable RB2 numbers. Davenport has a chance to put up a few good games. If Green is not healthy he might be the starter but only if he's healthy himself. White is wildcard. Sure they want to build around him and Young but that may not happen this year.

Grade C

Wide Receiver:

Harrison (6)

Coles (9)

Parker (3)

Jenkins (5)

Jennings (6)

Harrison is a no brainer. Coles is a good fit with his receptions but will he have a QB that can get hom the ball? If so he's a nice WR2. After that there are too many question marks. Parker might do decent if Rivers does well. Jenkins is in a hopel;ess situation with Vick who wants to run even more. Jennings could surprise but few rookies actually do.

Grade D

Tight Ends:

Stevens (5)

Watson (6)

Together these 2 might do well. Stevens and Hasselbeck have grown well together. Watson is finally showing what he's capable of and with Given gone he might see a few more bones this year.

Grade C

Kickers:

Tynes (3)

Hanson (8)

These 2 make a good combo abd should fine.

Grade B

D/ST:

Baltimore

Philly

These 2 D's are awesome in this format.

Grade A

Overall this is a middle of the road team. I will need for several things to go my way in order to have a shot:

1. Healthy QB's.

2. Foster & Davenport to be healthy. And maybe Davenport or White to be the starter.

3. Parker, Jenkins and Jennings to make some sort of impact as a WR3.

4. A healthy, decent NYJ QB for Coles.

Overall grade is a C-. If the planets align, maybe a B. If this team makes it to the final 4 it'll be a big surprise. So here's to surprises.

Have to agree with the health Qs around the QBs. If they both play 16, no sweat. If one misses an extended period, trouble.RB: Couldn't agree more with the assessment. The annual "Tiki will lose goalline carries" can't help but be of some concern.

WR: An iffy group. D is a fair grade. I'm sure that others would put it at a B- if it were their own. Honest assessment. Harrison will be the foundation and hope for the best elsewhere.

Decent job at setting up TE,D and K.

Overall, this team can actually compete! I just cannot put my finger on "why?" Maybe because FMs four criteria for competing aren't THAT far from the realm of possibility.

 

[Winston Smith]

Good job guys we should be wrapped up by tomorrow

Team Sniffer:

SSL3 - 16th pick

QB- Matt Hasslebeck(5), Alex Smith(7)

Hasslebeck is obviously your guy, and very likely to finish top 5. Smith isn't much of a backup option, so you will have to hope Hass stays healthy.

QB Grade B

RB- Brian Westbrook(9), Corey Dillon(6), Ron Dayne(4), Marshall Faulk(7)

Westbrook is money in this format, and I think Dillon still has one good year left in him. I'm not drinking the Ron Dayne kool-aid, but he's very nice as a RB3. Faulk is a servicable RB4. I like this group.

RB Grade : A-

WR- Eddie Kennison(3), Drew Bennett(7), Reggie Brown(9), Braylon Edwards(6),Marty Booker(8), Robert Ferguson(6), Charles Rogers(8)

Clearly the weak spot, as there just isn't a #1 here. Kennision and Bennett are servicable #2/3 guys, but I'd hate to have to rely on them every week. Brown/Edwards/Rogers are all hit or miss 4/5 types.

WR Grade : D+

TE- Antonio Gates(3)

I don't care if you don't have a backup...you still get an A with Gates.

TE Grade : A-

K- Jeff Wilkins(7), Ted Nugent(9)

Two kickers. They don't have the same bye week. Carry on.

K Grade : A

D- Tampa Bay(4), Buffalo(8)

Two solid D's here.

Def Grade: A

This team will go as far as its WR let it. You look great at every other position. I think this team will make it to at least week 7 or 8, even if the WR don't pan out. If you catch some breaks at WR, this team could contend.

Overall: B

I think you were a bit hard on your team. Nice work.

 

[Winston Smith]

Team Footballhead

Weakest Week: Week 6

QB: P. Manning (1.13, 6), K. Holcomb (13.13, 8), J.P. Losman (16.04, 8)

Grade A-: Manning is in a class by himself. Backups are scary, and you'll take a bit of a risk on the week Manning is gone, which is the only thing that keeps you from getting an A or A+.

WR: T. Owens (2.04, 3), R.Smith (6.04, 4), N. Burleson (8.04, 5), Br. Johnson (17.13, 9), A. Davis (18.04, 8)

Grade B-: Loads of risk with TO, but also high reward. Rod is a reasonable #2. However, the depth scares me. I wouldn't want to have to rely on Burleson, Johnson, or Davis to score points week in and week out. Your B- is right on the money.

RB: F. Taylor (3.13, 6), C. Benson (4.04, 7), D. Williams (5.13, 9), D. Staley (7.13, 4)

Grade D: Hate to slam you, but Fred is in no way a #1 RB. I think the team liked what it saw out of Greg Jones, and as a result, Fred will see his carries diminish even if healthy. The lack of goal line touches is also a concern. Benson is also a huge risk, given the success of Thomas Jones. I do like DeAngelo Williams, but his role is extremely murky at this point. Duce is likely to take over the Bettis role...the problem is, I fear he may wind up your RB2 before its all said and done.

TE: K. Winslow Jr. (11.13, 6), Des. Clark (15.13, 7) We have no idea what Winslow will do. He's essentially a rookie. Des Clark is a servicable backup, but this position leaves something to be desired.

Grade: C :

K: M. Stover (12.04, 7), J. Brown (14.04, 5)

Grade A: Two good kickers.

D/ST: Chicago (9.13, 7), Carolina (10.04, 9)

Grade A+: You can't do much better than this.

Overall Grade C-: Obviously, picking from the 13 spot made things tough. However, I really think you needed to come away with at least one back in the first two picks. In my opinion, RB woes, combined with the questionable TE situation, will send this team home early.

 

[Footballhead]

Hey Winston thanks for your honest assesment. Do you think the edge in QB, K, D will be enuff to make up for the lack for as you said RB#1. Lets says all my RB's will end up being #2's.

 

[Winston Smith]

Team Family Matters:

Quarterback:

Bulger (7)

Brunell(8)

Some concern with Mike Martz leaving that Bulger's numbers may suffer. He's also had injury issues. Still, I like him, and think he'll be a solid performer. Brunell is solid depth. I agree with your B.

Grade: B

Running Back:

Barber (4)

Foster (9)

White (7)

Davenport (6)

Barber is a stud in this format. I'm just concerned about the depth. It's possible that none of your other three RB will contribute much. Having Tiki takes some of the sting off.

Grade C

Wide Receiver:

Harrison (6)

Coles (9)

Parker (3)

Jenkins (5)

Jennings (6)

I think you are a bit too hard on yourself here. Harrison and Coles are pretty solid as #1 and #2. Obviously, there are serious concerns about who will score every week as your #3, however. Probably should have grabbed a 6th WR.

Grade C-

Tight Ends:

Stevens (5)

Watson (6)

I like Stevens, and he should be a solid starter. Who knows with Watson, but he's a decent reserve.

Grade C+

Kickers:

Tynes (3)

Hanson (8)

Again, two kickers who don't share a bye. You get an A.

Grade A

D/ST:

Baltimore

Philly

Very nice

Grade A

Overall, this is a middle of the road team. Other than K and D, there's not one position without some considerable question marks, but, at the same time, I don't think any position is in really bad shape. A tough one to call. Could go out early, could stick around quite a while with the right breaks.

Overall: C

 

[Winston Smith]

Hey Winston thanks for your honest assesment. Do you think the edge in QB, K, D will be enuff to make up for the lack for as you said RB#1. Lets says all my RB's will end up being #2's.

Oh, if all of your RB's wind up being #2 types, you have a great shot to contend. You are loaded at most other positions, except for TE, which IS pretty important in this format. I didn't do so hot there, either (Heath Miller/D. Graham).

 

[glumpy]

Kinda hard to evaluate these sometimes since luck and timing will always have such a huge effect--but here goes!

Once again this year I ended up drafting from near the tail end, and once again decided against following the RB's in favor of WR. I couldn't pull off what razr did with SS/Gates this time but I am really interested in seeing how that plays out too after pulling it off in the WSL.

QB: Tom Brady (3.15, 6), Ben Roethlisberger (5.15, 4), Matt Leinart (17.15, 9)

The second and seventh QB's taken since I was leery of the anticipated run on them, and I'm happy with this group. Leinart was a late shot just in case he gets pt with that Arizona offense.

Grade: A

RB: Willie Parker (2.02, 4), Mike Anderson (8.15, 7), Brandon Jacobs (10.02, 4), Kevin Faulk (11.15, 6)

BSS was obviously the beneficiary of me passing off on Brian Westbrook in the 1st, but I was just as happy with Willie Parker as a followup in the second. I had actually anticipated him taking both of them and I'd have gone with Gates. Anderson, Jacobs, and Faulk are all questionmarks from whom I'm hoping to get enough play to support the other positions. Hopefully the double on bye week 4 is early enough not to shoot this team down.

Grade: C

WR: Steve Smith (1.15, 9), TJ Houshmandzadeh (6.02, 5), Isaac Bruce (7.15, 7), Antwaan Randle El (9.15, 8), Arnez Battle (12.02, 7)

I might should have gone with another one or two WR's here, but having 4--maybe 5--anticipated starters starting out with SS (yup--homeboy here!) and I'm confident with the output of this group.

Grade: B+

TE: Jason Witten (4.02, 3), Chris Baker (18.02, 9)

Up until the last minute I was real happy playing only Witten at TE, particularly with his bye week. If Baker comes back with any kind of the spark he showed early last year then it's worth the late round flyer.

Grade: A-

D/ST: Miami (13.15, 8), NYG (14.02, 4)

PK: Ryan Longwell (15.15, 6), Olindo Mare (16.02, 8)

The #11 & 12 defenses taken; and #16 & 18 kickers. They should get their chances at least, and if not kick it over the top at worst they won't cost me the week!

Grades: B

Overall: ?? That's so hard to figure--I could have the highest scoring team but if they all fall at once it could be curtains week 3.

Guess I'd go with the average B+

 

[Chaz]

Kinda hard to evaluate these sometimes since luck and timing will always have such a huge effect--but here goes!

Once again this year I ended up drafting from near the tail end, and once again decided against following the RB's in favor of WR. I couldn't pull off what razr did with SS/Gates this time but I am really interested in seeing how that plays out too after pulling it off in the WSL.

QB: Tom Brady (3.15, 6), Ben Roethlisberger (5.15, 4), Matt Leinart (17.15, 9)

The second and seventh QB's taken since I was leery of the anticipated run on them, and I'm happy with this group. Leinart was a late shot just in case he gets pt with that Arizona offense.

Grade: A

RB: Willie Parker (2.02, 4), Mike Anderson (8.15, 7), Brandon Jacobs (10.02, 4), Kevin Faulk (11.15, 6)

BSS was obviously the beneficiary of me passing off on Brian Westbrook in the 1st, but I was just as happy with Willie Parker as a followup in the second. I had actually anticipated him taking both of them and I'd have gone with Gates. Anderson, Jacobs, and Faulk are all questionmarks from whom I'm hoping to get enough play to support the other positions. Hopefully the double on bye week 4 is early enough not to shoot this team down.

Grade: C

WR: Steve Smith (1.15, 9), TJ Houshmandzadeh (6.02, 5), Isaac Bruce (7.15, 7), Antwaan Randle El (9.15, 8), Arnez Battle (12.02, 7)

I might should have gone with another one or two WR's here, but having 4--maybe 5--anticipated starters starting out with SS (yup--homeboy here!) and I'm confident with the output of this group.

Grade: B+

TE: Jason Witten (4.02, 3), Chris Baker (18.02, 9)

Up until the last minute I was real happy playing only Witten at TE, particularly with his bye week. If Baker comes back with any kind of the spark he showed early last year then it's worth the late round flyer.

Grade: A-

D/ST: Miami (13.15, 8), NYG (14.02, 4)

PK: Ryan Longwell (15.15, 6), Olindo Mare (16.02, 8)

The #11 & 12 defenses taken; and #16 & 18 kickers. They should get their chances at least, and if not kick it over the top at worst they won't cost me the week!

Grades: B

Overall: ?? That's so hard to figure--I could have the highest scoring team but if they all fall at once it could be curtains week 3.

Guess I'd go with the average B+

A good draft. IMO, thisclose to being an excellent draft all around. A little weak at RB, but you have to be weak somewhere. Jacobs should have some weeks where he is scoring for you. Another RB would help. One who could potentially step in and give you big points. A backup to a stud or something. A true hit or miss type.

The one thing that I would change is to add another WR. With Brady and Roethlisberger, there was really no need to take Leinart. Sure, he could be at the helm of a good offense, but how many times will he outscore your top two QBs?

Overall, a good job. I just feel the Leinart pick could have been better served by going WR or RB.

 

[bicycle_seat_sniffer]

Good job guys we should be wrapped up by tomorrow

Team Sniffer:

SSL3 - 16th pick

QB- Matt Hasslebeck(5), Alex Smith(7)

Hasslebeck is obviously your guy, and very likely to finish top 5. Smith isn't much of a backup option, so you will have to hope Hass stays healthy.

QB Grade  B

RB- Brian Westbrook(9), Corey Dillon(6), Ron Dayne(4), Marshall Faulk(7)

Westbrook is money in this format, and I think Dillon still has one good year left in him. I'm not drinking the Ron Dayne kool-aid, but he's very nice as a RB3. Faulk is a servicable RB4. I like this group.

RB Grade : A-

WR- Eddie Kennison(3), Drew Bennett(7), Reggie Brown(9), Braylon Edwards(6),Marty Booker(8), Robert Ferguson(6), Charles Rogers(8)

Clearly the weak spot, as there just isn't a #1 here. Kennision and Bennett are servicable #2/3 guys, but I'd hate to have to rely on them every week. Brown/Edwards/Rogers are all hit or miss 4/5 types.

WR Grade : D+ 

TE- Antonio Gates(3)

I don't care if you don't have a backup...you still get an A with Gates.

TE Grade : A- 

K- Jeff Wilkins(7), Ted Nugent(9)

Two kickers. They don't have the same bye week. Carry on.

K Grade : A

D- Tampa Bay(4), Buffalo(8)

Two solid D's here.

Def Grade:  A

This team will go as far as its WR let it. You look great at every other position. I think this team will make it to at least week 7 or 8, even if the WR don't pan out. If you catch some breaks at WR, this team could contend.

Overall: B

I think you were a bit hard on your team. Nice work.

Thanks for the input winston.

 

[Family Matters]

Good job guys we should be wrapped up by tomorrow

Team Sniffer:

SSL3 - 16th pick

QB- Matt Hasslebeck(5), Alex Smith(7)

Hasslebeck is as solid as it gets, Alex smith only has to score for me one week, week 5 Hass's bye, and on that week I will have everyone left on my roster. Not a great option at QB2.

QB Grade B

RB- Brian Westbrook(9), Corey Dillon(6), Ron Dayne(4), Marshall Faulk(7)

I was stoked to get Westy at 1.16, if heathly he can go 800/700 with 70 catches.

I bought some of the Dayne hype after the draft with Shanny not draft another RB. Dillon at 3.16 was too good not to take. Between the two I should get solid RB2 points. Faulk can score just enough in any given week with dump off passes to make a difference.

RB Grade : B+

WR- Eddie Kennison(3), Drew Bennett(7), Reggie Brown(9), Braylon Edwards(6),Marty Booker(8), Robert Ferguson(6), Charles Rogers(8)

The obvious week point of the squad, I have 7 of them a few with nice upside. Taking Kennison as a WR1 is flawed but everyone except Rogers will start and be an everydown player. Braylon is injured, we'll see when he comes back if the pick was value or not.

If I could have it all back I'd probably take Mushin or TJ Hous (my muslim brothers) instead of Dayne in round 6. Oh well.

WR Grade : C- I'm sure others will give me lower marks

TE- Antonio Gates(3)

The joy of getting Gates plus and early bye week means I'm only taking one. I think Phil hits him & LT2 early and often.

TE Grade : B+ Not an A because I didn't draft a backup, but with my lack of WR's I really couldn't.

K- Jeff Wilkins(7), Ted Nugent(9)

A dome kicker and no bye week issues

K Grade : B

D- Tampa Bay(4), Buffalo(8)

Loves these two D's, Tampa always gets sacks and turnovers, with Dicky J and TKO Spikes healthy this Buffalo group looks solid. Buffalo was a high scoring FF D two years ago.

Def Grade: A

Overall need a break or two at WR, but I think I have a good mix of Vets and youngsters to produce on any given week. With Hass, Westy,Gates and a solid R2 punch, if I can survive Gates bye on week 3, I can make a run.

Boy picking at 16 is tough and it's not rounds 1,2,3,4, that get ya, it's much later on I felt the pinch in this draft.

Overall: B-

Good luck to all

IMO-you had a good draft. I love the Gates pick. He's huge in this format. The bye week is early and that helps but losing Gates and Kennison could be devastating if Dayne isn't getting 10+ carries per game and Dillon is sitting down. You should have Dillon I'd think and after Gates returns you're looking good. I like the team and the strategy. Good job BSS.

 

[JohnDoe]

Guys, I will be in class for the next 3 days. I will post my summary when I get back, sometime Thursday. I figure right now I will give it a "C" based on a lack of quality WR and DEF. I think my TE are good and the RB corps should be serviceable. I do have a small risk at QB with the Warner/Brees combo. Hopefully Warner can stay healthy until the NO bye week.

Twilight has my last pick, as I am heading out. Everyone have a good week.

 

[Family Matters]

Team Family Matters:

Quarterback:

Bulger (7)

Brunell(8)

The key with these 2 will be health. Clearly Bulger will be the more productive of the 2. But can he play all year for the first time?

Grade: B

Running Back:

Barber (4)

Foster (9)

White (7)

Davenport (6)

Barber is a great RB in this format. Foster & Davenport have their annual health questions. Of healthy Foster will likely produce respectable RB2 numbers. Davenport has a chance to put up a few good games. If Green is not healthy he might be the starter but only if he's healthy himself. White is wildcard. Sure they want to build around him and Young but that may not happen this year.

Grade C

Wide Receiver:

Harrison (6)

Coles (9)

Parker (3)

Jenkins (5)

Jennings (6)

Harrison is a no brainer. Coles is a good fit with his receptions but will he have a QB that can get hom the ball? If so he's a nice WR2. After that there are too many question marks. Parker might do decent if Rivers does well. Jenkins is in a hopel;ess situation with Vick who wants to run even more. Jennings could surprise but few rookies actually do.

Grade D

Tight Ends:

Stevens (5)

Watson (6)

Together these 2 might do well. Stevens and Hasselbeck have grown well together. Watson is finally showing what he's capable of and with Given gone he might see a few more bones this year.

Grade C

Kickers:

Tynes (3)

Hanson (8)

These 2 make a good combo abd should fine.

Grade B

D/ST:

Baltimore

Philly

These 2 D's are awesome in this format.

Grade A

Overall this is a middle of the road team. I will need for several things to go my way in order to have a shot:

1. Healthy QB's.

2. Foster & Davenport to be healthy. And maybe Davenport or White to be the starter.

3. Parker, Jenkins and Jennings to make some sort of impact as a WR3.

4. A healthy, decent NYJ QB for Coles.

Overall grade is a C-. If the planets align, maybe a B. If this team makes it to the final 4 it'll be a big surprise. So here's to surprises.

Have to agree with the health Qs around the QBs. If they both play 16, no sweat. If one misses an extended period, trouble.RB: Couldn't agree more with the assessment. The annual "Tiki will lose goalline carries" can't help but be of some concern.

WR: An iffy group. D is a fair grade. I'm sure that others would put it at a B- if it were their own. Honest assessment. Harrison will be the foundation and hope for the best elsewhere.

Decent job at setting up TE,D and K.

Overall, this team can actually compete! I just cannot put my finger on "why?" Maybe because FMs four criteria for competing aren't THAT far from the realm of possibility.

With my last pick I added Frerotte to back up Bulger. IMO it made the most sense. I could of added another WR (and there's a good one out there) but I felt the long term needs of backing up Bulger was more important if this team is to survive.

 

[Evilgrin 72]

QB : Culpepper, Kitna, Pennington - I waited on QBs and it shows. Had to draft 3 because Kitna and Culpepper have the same bye and Culpepper's injury woes and Kitna's competition from McCown make me nervous. This group has the potential to be good, but also a lot of ???. Grade : D+

RB - McGahee, Chester Taylor, Gore, Hicks - I think this group has upside potential. Chester Taylor and McGahee are both very capable of beiung top 10-15 backs, which is the best I could hope for, drafting from the 14 hole. Gore, if he holds off Barlow, could be an above-average #3. Grade : B-

WR - Chambers, Driver, L. Evans, Lelie, G. Lewis - This is probably the best area of my team, as I used 3 of my first 5 picks on wide-outs. Drafting #14, I wasn't going to have an elite backfield, and Manning was gone before my first pick, so I tried to focus on building a WR corps that could score some points. In Chambers and Driver, I believe I have two WR1s (in a 16-team league) and Evans has real potential as my #3. Lelie is likely on his way out in Denver, I took a late round flyer on him because he could be very productive if he lands in the right system. Greg Lewis isn't going to set the world on fire, but someone in Philly is going to cath all those passes, so if he puts up a good week here and there, that's a bonus. Grade : A-

TE - Dallas Clark, Marcus Pollard - I am happy with this pair, considering how long I waited to take a TE. With Manning likely to throw a lot more in the red zone this year with James' absence, Clark has 7-8 TD potential, and Pollard is a reliable backup. Grade : B

K - J. Scobee, B. Cundiff - Meh. Whatever. Grade : C-

D - Jacksonville, Tennessee - Jacksonville's defense is usually underrated and typically performs well. Tennessee sucks, but they were an 18th round pick. Grade : B-

Overall grade : B-/C+ : A late pick in a 16-team league typically means the team is devoid of a lot of big names, but I hope to have cobbled together a team that can compete. If I can get past the brutal week 8 I face with the bye, I should be OK. I'd be a lot happier if I had better QBs, but the run came right after my 4th round pick, so I was basically screwed.

 

[nittanylion]

With my last pick I added Frerotte to back up Bulger. IMO it made the most sense. I could of added another WR (and there's a good one out there) but I felt the long term needs of backing up Bulger was more important if this team is to survive.

Draft Wisdom (version 2006):

RULE 1:

There's not a single team in any draft - redraft, keeper, dynasty, auction or serpentine, what have you, that, if they select Marc Bulger to be their starting QB, they should make it an absolute priority to select Gus Frerotte in the later rounds. Between his ties to the coaching staff and familiarity with the offensive scheme, and Bulger, while not neccessarily being fragile, at least showing the potential to miss a game or two, that's an absolute 'must' play...Bulger/Frerotte = Leftwich/Garrard, Vick/Schaub, 2005 tandems of Culpepper/Brad Johnson and Carson/Kitna. I just don't see the offensive production slipping noticeably with the #2 QB in the game - in some cases, it might even improve...

Well done.

Discussion of my team later, but for now, let me just say the Torry Holt pick in the 2nd Rd was almost 100% due to the QB situation in STL...factor in other circumstances, and I think he's the 'safest' premium WR in the NFL, which is where I ranked Chad Johnson last year, largely due to the Palmer/Kitna QB duo...

 

[bicycle_seat_sniffer]

Team Family Matters:

Quarterback:

Bulger (7)

Frerotte (7)

Brunell(8)

The key with these 2 will be health. Clearly Bulger will be the more productive of the 2. But can he play all year for the first time?

Grade: B

Bulger/Frerotte combo make this very solid,Brunell will have some big weeks, I give you an A

Running Back:

Barber (4)

Foster (9)

White (7)

Davenport (6)

Barber is a great RB in this format. Foster & Davenport have their annual health questions. Of healthy Foster will likely produce respectable RB2 numbers. Davenport has a chance to put up a few good games. If Green is not healthy he might be the starter but only if he's healthy himself. White is wildcard. Sure they want to build around him and Young but that may not happen this year.

Grade C

I love Tiki, sometimes teams don't need rb2 in this format, you have guy that will get you points on any given week in White & Foster .  I give you a B-, just cause Foster will get hurt

Wide Receiver:

Harrison (6)

Coles (9)

Parker (3)

Jenkins (5)

Jennings (6)

Harrison is a no brainer. Coles is a good fit with his receptions but will he have a QB that can get hom the ball? If so he's a nice WR2. After that there are too many question marks. Parker might do decent if Rivers does well. Jenkins is in a hopel;ess situation with Vick who wants to run even more. Jennings could surprise but few rookies actually do.

Grade D

D is a grade too low cause you have Marv, taking Gus was the right call, butI would like 6 WR for this squad.  Parker I like, Coles I do not. C

Tight Ends:

Stevens (5)

Watson (6)

Together these 2 might do well. Stevens and Hasselbeck have grown well together. Watson is finally showing what he's capable of and with Given gone he might see a few more bones this year.

Grade C

These two are solid, Watson kinda looks to be in a TEC, with Graham and two rookies.  Like Stevens alot htough.  C

Kickers:

Tynes (3)

Hanson (8)

These 2 make a good combo abd should fine.

Grade B

Agree

D/ST:

Baltimore

Philly

These 2 D's are awesome in this format.

Grade A

Very solid D's, agree.

Overall this is a middle of the road team. I will need for several things to go my way in order to have a shot:

1. Healthy QB's.

2. Foster & Davenport to be healthy. And maybe Davenport or White to be the starter.

3. Parker, Jenkins and Jennings to make some sort of impact as a WR3.

4. A healthy, decent NYJ QB for Coles.

Overall grade is a C-. If the planets align, maybe a B. If this team makes it to the final 4 it'll be a big surprise. So here's to surprises.

Edit to add QB Frerotte

Overall, I think you were a bit harsh on your squad, B-, Marv & Tiki & solid QB's,& a decent platoon at TE.  I would have liked to have seen 6 WR's, but taking Gus is the right pick.

 

[bicycle_seat_sniffer]

Kinda hard to evaluate these sometimes since luck and timing will always have such a huge effect--but here goes!

Once again this year I ended up drafting from near the tail end, and once again decided against following the RB's in favor of WR. I couldn't pull off what razr did with SS/Gates this time but I am really interested in seeing how that plays out too after pulling it off in the WSL.

QB: Tom Brady (3.15, 6), Ben Roethlisberger (5.15, 4), Matt Leinart (17.15, 9)

The second and seventh QB's taken since I was leery of the anticipated run on them, and I'm happy with this group. Leinart was a late shot just in case he gets pt with that Arizona offense.

Grade: A

Great combo A, what's with the Leinart pick though?

RB: Willie Parker (2.02, 4), Mike Anderson (8.15, 7), Brandon Jacobs (10.02, 4), Kevin Faulk (11.15, 6)

BSS was obviously the beneficiary of me passing off on Brian Westbrook in the 1st, but I was just as happy with Willie Parker as a followup in the second. I had actually anticipated him taking both of them and I'd have gone with Gates. Anderson, Jacobs, and Faulk are all questionmarks from whom I'm hoping to get enough play to support the other positions. Hopefully the double on bye week 4 is early enough not to shoot this team down.

Grade: C

Willie parker is solid, but the rest of these guys meh, C is about right, need a break here.

WR: Steve Smith (1.15, 9), TJ Houshmandzadeh (6.02, 5), Isaac Bruce (7.15, 7), Antwaan Randle El (9.15, 8), Arnez Battle (12.02, 7)

I might should have gone with another one or two WR's here, but having 4--maybe 5--anticipated starters starting out with SS (yup--homeboy here!) and I'm confident with the output of this group.

Grade: B+

Very solid group, SS, TJ & Ike will produce plenty, these guys should make up for a weak RB2, I would have liked one more WR instead of Leinart. cause on week 7 you will only have 3 WR's to score with.

TE:  Jason Witten (4.02, 3), Chris Baker (18.02, 9)

Up until the last minute I was real happy playing only Witten at TE, particularly with his bye week. If Baker comes back with any kind of the spark he showed early last year then it's worth the late round flyer.

Grade: A-

I like Witten a ton, but Baker? not sure about that pick, maybe should have been WR6.

D/ST: Miami (13.15, 8), NYG (14.02, 4)

PK: Ryan Longwell (15.15, 6), Olindo Mare (16.02, 8)

The #11 & 12 defenses taken; and #16 & 18 kickers. They should get their chances at least, and if not kick it over the top at worst they won't cost me the week!

Grades: B

Overall:  ??  That's so hard to figure--I could have the highest scoring team but if they all fall at once it could be curtains week 3.

Guess I'd go with the average B+

K & d look fine, overall your solid at all positions, week 7 is iffy with only 3wr able to score, week 6 & 7 will be interesting across these survivor's, should be some low scores those weeks.  Solid B

 

[bicycle_seat_sniffer]

Team Footballhead

Weakest Week: Week 6

QB: P. Manning (1.13, 6), K. Holcomb (13.13, 8), J.P. Losman (16.04, 8)

Grade A: Manning is all I rely on. Hopefully Holcomb or Losman will have soemthing for me during his bye week. I didn't mean to draft 2 reserves to cover Manning's bye but in the later rd when I was targetting for a no 2 QB, it was picked up. I didn't think I need to sacrifice another high pick on this position for a no 2.

Manning is great and is in for a huge year, to be honest I my original strategy was to go Manning & best RB at 16. grade: A, dont care who your back up is

WR: T. Owens (2.04, 3), R.Smith (6.04, 4), N. Burleson (8.04, 5), Br. Johnson (17.13, 9), A. Davis (18.04, 8)

Grade B-: These guys are risky for me. Best scenario, TO shuts up and play, Rod Smith is prime target with Walker still recovering, and Nate Burleson will give the Hawks a dependable reciever besides oft injured D-Jax. Br. Johnson was always a Warner favorite and Andre Davis had connection with Holcombe at the Browns.

Huge performer at WR1 in TO, he will be huge this year, Rsmith is consistent, but I think Burleson is wr3 in Seattle after engram and then you waited 9 rounds to take WR4. grade C-, you needed one more WR.

RB: F. Taylor (3.13, 6), C. Benson (4.04, 7), D. Williams (5.13, 9), D. Staley (7.13, 4)

Grade B-: Current word is Taylor is running well, Benson may get 20+ carries, DeAngelo may share carries with Foster and Duce may get all Bettis's short goal-line carries. By August, these may still hold true or I'll have notha here.

You have got Taylor who is always banged up, and has at least 2 other runners that will get touches. Benson & Deanglo are mired in RBBC's, both will get some touched and can platoon at RB2. Overall C.

TE: K. Winslow Jr. (11.13, 6), Des. Clark (15.13, 7)

Grade B-: Winslow has shown nothing in the league yet, but getting two pass catching TE's in the later round is priceless.

I like Winslow but he is too big a wildcard to take as a TE1, Clark? Meh. your grade was too high, this is a C- at best

K: M. Stover (12.04, 7), J. Brown (14.04, 5)

Grade A: Should be top 10 kickers by the end of the year.

D/ST: Chicago (9.13, 7), Carolina (10.04, 9)

Grade A: Should be top 5 Def by the end of the year.

Kickers and D's are solid. A's are fine

Overall Grade B: Picking from the 13 spot, I decided I need to against the flow and pick best players available and not get caught into positional runs. We'll see how far this strategy take me into the season. If everything pans out as planned, week 6 would be the weak week for my team, but there are 6 teams in the NFL with bye on this week, so maybe I could survive it.

Overall I think going WR/QB hurt this squad too much, i would have taken either K.Jones, Droughns or Dunn in the 2nd. then WR instead of Taylor. Manning, Owens and not much else makes me think this team is in for an early exit. C- overall

 

[bicycle_seat_sniffer]

QB : Culpepper, Kitna, Pennington - I waited on QBs and it shows. Had to draft 3 because Kitna and Culpepper have the same bye and Culpepper's injury woes and Kitna's competition from McCown make me nervous. This group has the potential to be good, but also a lot of ???. Grade : D+

Group is tough, Kitna should start in Mad Martz's system, hopefully for you Cpep shows up around week 4-5. Grade C

RB - McGahee, Chester Taylor, Gore, Hicks - I think this group has upside potential. Chester Taylor and McGahee are both very capable of beiung top 10-15 backs, which is the best I could hope for, drafting from the 14 hole. Gore, if he holds off Barlow, could be an above-average #3. Grade : B-

EG why Mcgahee over Westbrook?? just curious. Willis will be fine, Chester seems to be a heavily favored RB2 by the sharks, I love Gore to win the job in SF.

Grade: B

WR - Chambers, Driver, L. Evans, Lelie, G. Lewis - This is probably the best area of my team, as I used 3 of my first 5 picks on wide-outs. Drafting #14, I wasn't going to have an elite backfield, and Manning was gone before my first pick, so I tried to focus on building a WR corps that could score some points. In Chambers and Driver, I believe I have two WR1s (in a 16-team league) and Evans has real potential as my #3. Lelie is likely on his way out in Denver, I took a late round flyer on him because he could be very productive if he lands in the right system. Greg Lewis isn't going to set the world on fire, but someone in Philly is going to cath all those passes, so if he puts up a good week here and there, that's a bonus. Grade : A-

Very solid group, I think you need one more to make wr=6, Evans and Chambers have the same bye. B+

TE - Dallas Clark, Marcus Pollard - I am happy with this pair, considering how long I waited to take a TE. With Manning likely to throw a lot more in the red zone this year with James' absence, Clark has 7-8 TD potential, and Pollard is a reliable backup. Grade : B

Love this platoon at TE, solid B

K - J. Scobee, B. Cundiff - Meh. Whatever. Grade : C-

D - Jacksonville, Tennessee - Jacksonville's defense is usually underrated and typically performs well. Tennessee sucks, but they were an 18th round pick. Grade : B-

K's and D's are fine B & B

Overall grade : B-/C+ : A late pick in a 16-team league typically means the team is devoid of a lot of big names, but I hope to have cobbled together a team that can compete. If I can get past the brutal week 8 I face with the bye, I should be OK. I'd be a lot happier if I had better QBs, but the run came right after my 4th round pick, so I was basically screwed.

Need that one break at QB to go far overall solid B

 

[joffer]

Pretty happy with my team. I suppose that's a given or I wouldn't have drafted it

QB

Trent Green (3)

David Carr (5)

unspectacular group, but low risk as well. Green is consistent, and Carr will put a big week here and there.

RB

Steven Jackson (7)

Reuben Droughns (6)

Marion Barber III (3)

Michael Turner (3)

James Mungro (6)

solid, especially in a ppr format. i love Jackson, Droughns will get plenty of touches. Turner showed what he can do last year even in very limited time. Mungro should vulture a few TDs.

WR

Santana Moss (8)

Plaxico Burress (4)

Donte Stallworth (7)

Brandon Stokely (6)

Brian Finneran (5)

I like this set a lot, especially after starting RB/RB. I'm nuts for Stallworth this year. NYG offense should be high-powered, and I wouldn't be surprised at all if Stokely is closer to his 2004 numbers than his 2005.

TE

Ben Troupe

Jeb Putzier

nothing special, although I think Troupe will emerge as the go-to target in Tennessee

PK

David Akers

John Carney

above average

DT

New England

New York Jets

decent

Overall: B+

 

[Steel Dillo]

QB

5.05 - Drew Bledsoe, QB7 – This will either be a boom or bust pick. Obviously, I’m hoping for BOOM!

6.12 - Byron Leftwich, QB15 – Made this pick before J. Smith quit, but I’m still OK with it.

Grade: B-

I targeted Bledsoe from the start, but knew I’d have to draft another QB early because of his injury risks & TO’s potential to rip the team apart. I’ll also admit to being leary of getting on the back end of a QB run and ending up with a A.Smith/T.Rattay type back up QB scenario like I did last year.

RB

1.05 - Edge James, RB5 – With all the fire power in the desert, Edge should get his chances

2.12 - Warrick Dunn, RB20 – Love Dunn in this format.

3.05 - Tatum Bell, RB24 – I think Bell has at least a 50/50 chance of being the 1200yd back that Denver always produces.

18.12 - Derrick Blaylock, RB76 – I’m kicking myself for not noticing M. Faulk was still on the board when I picked Pinkston @ 17.05. Oh well, here’s to hoping Blaylock can return to pre-injury form.

Grade: B+

My strongest position. I spent my 1st 3 picks on RBs, so I better be happy with the results.

WR

7.05 - Mushin Muhammed, WR30 – Grossman likes to sling it & now the Bears have a capable back up QB to get the ball to Moose when Grossman goes down.

8.12 - Terry Glenn, WR39 – TO draws the double coverage & I double up when Glenn catches a TD from Bledsoe.

9.05 - Matt Jones, WR43 – Pick made right after J. Smith retired. That means a bump up to a starter and hopefully more balls for Jones

12.12 - Travis Taylor, WR64 – Most would consider this a reach, but the man caught 60 passes in his first year in Minnesota, Burleson left town and his new HC will probably have an offense featuring the pass.

13.05 - Cedric Wilson, WR68 – Hoping for 40 – 50 catches plus a couple of trick play TDs. (Full Disclosure: homer pick)

17.05 - Todd Pinkston, WR81 – Fell off the map due to injury last year, but knows the offense better than any other WR on the team.

Grade: C

Considering I didn’t pick up a WR until the 7th round, I think I did OK. Definitely went with a shotgun style approach… i.e. Throw a lot at the target & hope that some hit.

TE

4.12 - LJ Smith, TE7 – Probably could have waited a round, but didn’t want to miss out on the guy that could lead the Eagles in catches this season.

10.12 - Jermaine Wiggins, TE18 – A good safety valve for Brad Johnson.

Grade: B

Serious man love for LJ this year & a solid second option in Wiggins.

K

14.12 - Jeff Reed, K12 – Not gonna lead the league, but he’s been solid.

15.05 - Seabass Janikowski, K13 – Wanted a back up with a secure spot

Grade: B-The conditions at Heinz Field can be scary sometimes & Seabass could be arrested tomorrow

D/ST

11.05 – Washington, DEF5 – My #1 rated D

16.12 - ST. Louis, Def24 – Hopefully, Haslett will be as successful as a D Coordinator as he was in Pittsburgh

Grade: B-I really like Washington’s D, but wish I could have gotten a better second option

Overall Grade: B-

WR is a crapshoot, but I think I’m solid everywhere else.

 

[Evilgrin 72]

QB : Culpepper, Kitna, Pennington - I waited on QBs and it shows.  Had to draft 3 because Kitna and Culpepper have the same bye and Culpepper's injury woes and Kitna's competition from McCown make me nervous.  This group has the potential to be good, but also a lot of ???.  Grade : D+

Group is tough, Kitna should start in Mad Martz's system, hopefully for you Cpep shows up around week 4-5.  Grade C

RB - McGahee, Chester Taylor, Gore, Hicks - I think this group has upside potential.  Chester Taylor and McGahee are both very capable of beiung top 10-15 backs, which is the best I could hope for, drafting from the 14 hole.  Gore, if he holds off Barlow, could be an above-average #3.  Grade : B-

EG why Mcgahee over Westbrook?? just curious.  Willis will be fine, Chester seems to be a heavily favored RB2 by the sharks, I love Gore to win the job in SF.

Grade: B

WR - Chambers, Driver, L. Evans, Lelie, G. Lewis - This is probably the best area of my team, as I used 3 of my first 5 picks on wide-outs.  Drafting #14, I wasn't going to have an elite backfield, and Manning was gone before my first pick, so I tried to focus on building a WR corps that could score some points.  In Chambers and Driver, I believe I have two WR1s (in a 16-team league) and Evans has real potential as my #3.  Lelie is likely on his way out in Denver, I took a late round flyer on him because he could be very productive if he lands in the right system.  Greg Lewis isn't going to set the world on fire, but someone in Philly is going to cath all those passes, so if he puts up a good week here and there, that's a bonus.  Grade : A-

Very solid group, I think you need one more to make wr=6, Evans and Chambers have the same bye.  B+

TE - Dallas Clark, Marcus Pollard - I am happy with this pair, considering how long I waited to take a TE.  With Manning likely to throw a lot more in the red zone this year with James' absence, Clark has 7-8 TD potential, and Pollard is a reliable backup.  Grade : B

Love this platoon at TE, solid B

K - J. Scobee, B. Cundiff - Meh.  Whatever.   Grade : C-

D - Jacksonville, Tennessee - Jacksonville's defense is usually underrated and typically performs well.  Tennessee sucks, but they were an 18th round pick.  Grade : B-

K's and D's are fine B & B

Overall grade : B-/C+ : A late pick in a 16-team league typically means the team is devoid of a lot of big names, but I hope to have cobbled together a team that can compete.  If I can get past the brutal week 8 I face with the bye, I should be OK.  I'd be a lot happier if I had better QBs, but the run came right after my 4th round pick, so I was basically screwed.

Need that one break at QB to go far overall solid B

Thanks for the input. Westbrook vs. McGahee was a coin toss. In a non-PPR league, it would have been McGahee easily, but there were a few factors that came into play:1) Even with the awful season McGahee had last year, he was RB13. Can't imagine he'll do any worse than that, so the pick was safe.

2) Westbrook seems to get hurt late in the year recently. Maybe because of his size, but I didn't want my RB1 sucking up 0s in crunch time if I make it that far.

3) At the time I made the pick, there was some talk on Sirius NFL Radio that the Eagles were looking at adding a big back to complement their current stable. The thought of no goal line carries at all occurred to me.

4) Moats may be ready to step in and play a bigger role this year. As he seems to be very similar to Westbrook in style, Westbrook may not see the # of targets he has in years past.

Even with that, it was basically a coin flip, but since it's a 16-team league, I went for the guy with lower upside/lower risk with a 1st round pick.

 

[Evilgrin 72]

Also, allow me to take this opportunity to thank Bass 'N' Brew for organizing, Twilight for housing it on your site, and the Sniffer for handling all the thread updating and such. You guys are a credit to your respective races.

 

[bicycle_seat_sniffer]

QB

Dillo let me start by saying I love the make up of this team, I wish my team looked as good as this

5.05 - Drew Bledsoe, QB7 – This will either be a boom or bust pick. Obviously, I’m hoping for BOOM!

6.12 - Byron Leftwich, QB15 – Made this pick before J. Smith quit, but I’m still OK with it.

Grade: B-

I targeted Bledsoe from the start, but knew I’d have to draft another QB early because of his injury risks & TO’s potential to rip the team apart. I’ll also admit to being leary of getting on the back end of a QB run and ending up with a A.Smith/T.Rattay type back up QB scenario like I did last year.

Bledseo is pure gold this year, leftwich is rock solid too. grade A

RB

1.05 - Edge James, RB5 – With all the fire power in the desert, Edge should get his chances

2.12 - Warrick Dunn, RB20 – Love Dunn in this format.

3.05 - Tatum Bell, RB24 – I think Bell has at least a 50/50 chance of being the 1200yd back that Denver always produces.

18.12 - Derrick Blaylock, RB76 – I’m kicking myself for not noticing M. Faulk was still on the board when I picked Pinkston @ 17.05. Oh well, here’s to hoping Blaylock can return to pre-injury form.

Grade: B+

My strongest position. I spent my 1st 3 picks on RBs, so I better be happy with the results.

Nos issues here, Edge Dunn & Bell = a solid 123 punch in this league. Grade A

WR

7.05 - Mushin Muhammed, WR30 – Grossman likes to sling it & now the Bears have a capable back up QB to get the ball to Moose when Grossman goes down.

8.12 - Terry Glenn, WR39 – TO draws the double coverage & I double up when Glenn catches a TD from Bledsoe.

9.05 - Matt Jones, WR43 – Pick made right after J. Smith retired. That means a bump up to a starter and hopefully more balls for Jones

12.12 - Travis Taylor, WR64 – Most would consider this a reach, but the man caught 60 passes in his first year in Minnesota, Burleson left town and his new HC will probably have an offense featuring the pass.

13.05 - Cedric Wilson, WR68 – Hoping for 40 – 50 catches plus a couple of trick play TDs. (Full Disclosure: homer pick)

17.05 - Todd Pinkston, WR81 – Fell off the map due to injury last year, but knows the offense better than any other WR on the team.

Grade: C

Considering I didn’t pick up a WR until the 7th round, I think I did OK. Definitely went with a shotgun style approach… i.e. Throw a lot at the target & hope that some hit.

You'll get enough points out of three of these guys every week, One week glenn and Wilson blow up, the next it's TT & Mushin. No true studs but everyone here is on the field just about every offensive play. Grade C is about right

TE

4.12 - LJ Smith, TE7 – Probably could have waited a round, but didn’t want to miss out on the guy that could lead the Eagles in catches this season.

10.12 - Jermaine Wiggins, TE18 – A good safety valve for Brad Johnson.

Grade: B

Serious man love for LJ this year & a solid second option in Wiggins.

Im targeting LJ heavily in my H2H leagues this year, Wiggins is very solid too. Grade A.

K

14.12 - Jeff Reed, K12 – Not gonna lead the league, but he’s been solid.

15.05 - Seabass Janikowski, K13 – Wanted a back up with a secure spot

Grade: B-The conditions at Heinz Field can be scary sometimes & Seabass could be arrested tomorrow

D/ST

11.05 – Washington, DEF5 – My #1 rated D

16.12 - ST. Louis, Def24 – Hopefully, Haslett will be as successful as a D Coordinator as he was in Pittsburgh

Grade: B-I really like Washington’s D, but wish I could have gotten a better second option

K & D are solid enough, although Washington seems to be sack & turnover lite.

Overall Grade: B-

WR is a crapshoot, but I think I’m solid everywhere else.

Overall this team is my favorite so far of the one's I reviewed. Grade A. Very solid Job

 

[nittanylion]

I'd imagine at some point that we're going to have to end the draft, whether the remaining teams select players or not, just to keep things fair?

I seem to recall that the entire thing rolls to a halt when time expires on the final pick, or a certain # of hours after the final pick is made...wouldn't do much good to allow someone with roster vacancies to cherry pick as situations develop (a la Jimmy Smith) around the NFL...

 

[bicycle_seat_sniffer]

Pretty happy with my team.  I suppose that's a given or I wouldn't have drafted it 

QB

Trent Green (3)

David Carr (5)

unspectacular group, but low risk as well.  Green is consistent, and Carr will put a big week here and there.

Joffer, two solid guys here, KC usually starts slow, and Im not a huge believein Hou yet, but none the less good options.  Grade B

RB

Steven Jackson (7)

Reuben Droughns (6)

Marion Barber III (3)

Michael Turner (3)

James Mungro (6)

solid, especially in a ppr format.  i love Jackson, Droughns will get plenty of touches.  Turner showed what he can do last year even in very limited time.  Mungro should vulture a few TDs.

Very nicely done, Sjax is solid, Droughns while not sexy, most of the sharks around here have high opinions of him, Turner is a talent behind a stud, maybe Marty uses him a bit more to ease the wear & tear on LT2, MB3 could be SOD, overall  grade A-.

WR

Santana Moss (8)

Plaxico Burress (4)

Donte Stallworth (7)

Brandon Stokely (6)

Brian Finneran (5)

I like this set a lot, especially after starting RB/RB.  I'm nuts for Stallworth this year.  NYG offense should be high-powered, and I wouldn't be surprised at all if Stokely is closer to his 2004 numbers than his 2005.

Rock solid group here too, how Plax made it to you in round 4 I'll never know. I almost took him over Hasslebeck at the turn at 3/4.  Moss is rock solid too. Donte has a new QB and your right about Stokley. No more than one WR off on any given bye either.  Grade = A.

TE

Ben Troupe

Jeb Putzier

nothing special, although I think Troupe will emerge as the go-to target in Tennessee

I like troupe's talent well enough he seems a bit nicked up at times and Kinney and Sciafe seem to get targets as well.  Grade : C

PK

David Akers

John Carney

above average

DT

New England

New York Jets

decent

K's & D's are fine

Overall: B+

Overall I give this team an A-, just cause TE seem a bit week, but your WR,QB & RB look very pretty,  solid job, wil move up to at least SSL2 next year.

 

[Family Matters]

I'd imagine at some point that we're going to have to end the draft, whether the remaining teams select players or not, just to keep things fair?

I seem to recall that the entire thing rolls to a halt when time expires on the final pick, or a certain # of hours after the final pick is made...wouldn't do much good to allow someone with roster vacancies to cherry pick as situations develop (a la Jimmy Smith) around the NFL...

FWIW-past rules have stated that anyone can timeout based on what the rules call for. So the last owner gets their alotted 8 hours (or whatever the time limit is) and if they timeout the draft then ends.

 

[Family Matters]

Also, allow me to take this opportunity to thank Bass 'N' Brew for organizing, Twilight for housing it on your site, and the Sniffer for handling all the thread updating and such.  You guys are a credit to your respective races.

You guys are awesome and my thanks as well!

 

[bicycle_seat_sniffer]

Also, allow me to take this opportunity to thank Bass 'N' Brew for organizing, Twilight for housing it on your site, and the Sniffer for handling all the thread updating and such.  You guys are a credit to your respective races.

You guys are awesome and my thanks as well!

No problem guys, I love drafting against the best, and really doing this in the 16 team format makes the 12 teamers seem like cake.I'm looking forward to the MBSL's and defending my double title in Hook's QSL

 

[Twilight]

I'd imagine at some point that we're going to have to end the draft, whether the remaining teams select players or not, just to keep things fair?

I seem to recall that the entire thing rolls to a halt when time expires on the final pick, or a certain # of hours after the final pick is made...wouldn't do much good to allow someone with roster vacancies to cherry pick as situations develop (a la Jimmy Smith) around the NFL...

The clock runs normally through the last pick. Then anyone who hasn't picked has 8 hrs (A full clock) to make their final picks. If not, they go shorthanded. There was at least one 17 player team last year, IIRC.

 

[dpeease]

Here it goes.

QB: Grade: C

Carson Palmer, CIN - 5

Chris Simms, TB - 4

I like Palmer even with the injury. If he is able to play at any time before the bye I'll be more than happy and my QBs will get an instant upgrade. If not, this may be a short season for this team. Simms should be marginally better than he was last year with a healthy M Clayton and a stud running back with a full year under his belt.

RB: Grade B-

Lamont Jordan, OAK - 3

Deuce McAllister, NO - 7

Kevan Barlow, SF - 7

Greg Jones, JAX - 6

Just couldn't pass up L Jordan with the #12 pick. His catches may drop off, but he should be a bit more confortable in OAK this year with a healthy Moss and Porter. I dont see R Bush coming in a taking all the carries in the NO offense. He may not even get signed until mid-late August. Duece should still get 15+ carries a game if healthy and most if not all of the goal line duty. Barlow in the 7th? I'll take it. Greg Jones ran hard when given chanes and should see action to pick up some slack. Week 7 may kill me at this position.



WR: Grade B+

Chad Johnson, CIN - 5

Reggie Wayne, IND - 6

Kevin Curtis, STL - 7

Chad Jackson, NE - 6

Jabbar Gaffney, PHI - 9

Keary Colbert, CAR - 9

Solid core with C Johnson and R Wayne. Gaffney (55/492 in Houston) may or may not shine in a group of unproven receivers in Philly. That's if he can stay on the field. Curtis should produce with an aging I Bruce. C Jackson is a reach, but you never know who is going to get the ball in NE.

TE: Grade C

Vernon Davis, SF - 7

Coutrney Anderson, OAK - 3

I dont think they'd waste a #7 pick on a TE if they didn't plan on using him sooner rather than later. SF is probably going to suck and E Johnson, if healthy, may eat into his playing time. C Anderson was a disappointment last year, but did start all but 3 games for the Raiders. Again, I'm going to need some luck at this position.

K: Grade C

Jason Elam, Den - 4

Rob Bironas,Tenn - 7

2 average kickers with different byes.



DEF:Grade C-

Dallas DEF 3

Minnesota DEF 6

If I could do it again, I would have waited a little longer to take my first defense and grabbed a 3rd QB instead.

Overall Grade: C+.

Lots of unanswered questions, but I'm hoping to do better than my last place finish in 2005.

 

[Winston Smith]

Kinda hard to evaluate these sometimes since luck and timing will always have such a huge effect--but here goes!

Once again this year I ended up drafting from near the tail end, and once again decided against following the RB's in favor of WR. I couldn't pull off what razr did with SS/Gates this time but I am really interested in seeing how that plays out too after pulling it off in the WSL.

QB: Tom Brady (3.15, 6), Ben Roethlisberger (5.15, 4), Matt Leinart (17.15, 9)

Great combo here, easily the best in the league. Leinart pick was probably wasted, but it was the 17th round.

Grade: A+

RB: Willie Parker (2.02, 4), Mike Anderson (8.15, 7), Brandon Jacobs (10.02, 4), Kevin Faulk (11.15, 6)

Parker was good value there, but he's not a real RB1 due to the lack of TD. There simply isn't a RB2 here either: MA is a RB3, and Jacobs and Faulk are RB4/5. Pretty big weakness here.

Grade: D

WR: Steve Smith (1.15, 9), TJ Houshmandzadeh (6.02, 5), Isaac Bruce (7.15, 7), Antwaan Randle El (9.15, 8), Arnez Battle (12.02, 7)

Love this group. Steve is a stud, and TJ is underrated. Bruce is still a solid #3, and Randle El and Battle will help you from time to time. Good job.

Grade: A-

TE:  Jason Witten (4.02, 3), Chris Baker (18.02, 9)

Witten is a stud, and will carry you. Probably could have done a little better for a backup though; who knows what he'll do.

Grade: B+

D/ST: Miami (13.15, 8), NYG (14.02, 4)

Two solid D's.

Grade: B+

PK: Ryan Longwell (15.15, 6), Olindo Mare (16.02, 8)

Again, two kickers without bye week problems. You get an A.

Grade: A

Love the QB and WR, but am scared about the RB. This team should last a while, but needs a surprise from Mike Anderson to stick around to the final four.

Overall: B

 

[Winston Smith]

QB : Culpepper, Kitna, Pennington

Wow. Lots of risk/reward here. I don't like Culpepper this year, with the obvious injury issues and transition to a new team. I've always been a Kitna fan, and think he will prosper in the Mad Mike system. Pennington frightens me, as watching him play for a few games last year was downright painful. I think a D, which you gave to yourself, is a little low, as Kitna should be solid.

Grade: C-

RB - McGahee, Chester Taylor, Gore, Hicks - I won't lie: I'm not a fan of McGahee, so my overally ranking may be skewed. That said, Taylor should be a nice RB2, and I wouldn't be suprised to see him emerge as your RB1. Gore and Hicks provide solid depth.

Grade: B

WR - Chambers, Driver, L. Evans, Lelie, G. Lewis - This is a nice group. Chambers, Driver, and Evans should be solid, although Chambers and Evans tend to be feast or famine, which is dangerous in this format. Lelie is apparently in the doghouse, and will be stuck behind Smith and Walker. Lewis is decent insurance. You probably should have grabbed a 6th. Still, a good bunch of wideouts.

Grade : B+

TE - Dallas Clark, Marcus Pollard - Clark is a marginal TE1, but is a threat to blow up from week to week. I think Pollard will have a solid year with Kitna at the helm.

Grade: B-

K - J. Scobee, B. Cundiff - They don't have the same bye week, but Cundiff may actually have a training camp challenge. Grade : B-

D - Jacksonville, Tennessee - Love JAX, and Tenn is a decent backup option. Grade : B

Overall: A solid group, as there are no obvious holes. If you get good performance out of the QB, you could be a contender.

Overall grade : B

 

[valence]

QB:

6.15 Aaron Brooks (3)

8.14 Steve McNair (7)

I like Brooks more than most this year. I see top 10 easily. I made the Mcnair pick when it looked like he was going to be a Raven for sure. If that still happens then I like my QB corp, given how long I waited on them.

Best case: Brooksis just what Oakland needs and finishes top 10, McNair ends up with Baltimore and reunites with Mason.

Worst Case: Moss is done, Porter continues to underachieve and Walters takes over midseason. McNair isn't traded and sits behind Volek.

B-

RB:

1.03 Larry Johnson (3),

2.14 Thomas Jones (7)

4.14 Curtis Martin (9)

13.03 Maurice Drew (6)

I got a gift with LJ at 1.03 and I'm not complaining. I'm not worried about TJ's holdout and think he gets at worst a 60\40 split with Benson. I'm in the camp that thinks that Cumart has another 1,000 yard season in him. The vastly improved O-line will keep him healthy. Drew looks great in camp. If he produces, great if not I'm not worried about this group.

Best case: LJ lights it up again, TJ and Cumart both get 1,000 and 8. Drew takes over when Taylor goes down.

Worst case: LJ takes a step back with Herm, TJ holds out, and Cumart gets injured and loses his job.

A-

WR:

3.03 Darrell Jackson (5)

5.03 Joey Galloway (4)

7.03 Jimmy Smith (7) RETIRED

9.03 Mark Clayton (7)

10.12 Mike Williams (8)

15.03 Corey Bradford (8)

17.03 Patrick Crayton (3)

Oi. Smith retiring hurts big time. The plan was to go 7 deep with 1 top 5 threat, 2 solid and consistant vets, and 4 that would have several big games throughout the year. Well I missed by 1.

I love Clayton this year regardless who is throwing to him. I see potential probowler here in the 9th round. Bradford and Crayton are great in this format because I don't have to figure out which week is going to be the big one.

Best case: DJax's knee is fine, Galloway repeats 2005, Clayton breaks out and everyone else has a few big games.

Worst case: DJax struggles with his knee, Clayton returns to form and outproduces Galloway, Mark Clayton suffers another year with Boller and everyone else rarely sees the field.

C+ (A- with Jimmy)

TE:

11.03 Erron Kinney (7)

12.15 Bubba Franks (6)

I really don't think that Troupe is going to vastly outproduce Kinney this year. He may get a few more redzone looks, but I see a similar split to last year. Bubba is being severely undervalued this year in my opinion. With no real #2 in GB, Bubba bounces back from his injury season in 2005. I got him in the 19th in WSL2, but knew he wouldn't last that long here with the FBG rankings out.

Best case: Kinney repeats with 50 catches, Franks and Favre reconnect

Worst case: Troupe takes over, Franks continues his downward spiral

C+

K:

16.14 Rian Lindell (8)

Clearly I waited to long on a Kicker. In retrospect I should have grabbed a 2nd one instead of Crayton at 17.03. By my last pick there were no clear cut starters left. The bye sucks too.

D+

D\ST:

14.14 Cincinatti (5)

18.14 Oakland (3)

I was going to just go with one D with no huge bye week conflict in week 5, but when there were no kickers left I figured I better grab one of the only 2 left to cover a few points.

C

Overall: B-

I felt like I was behind every run with the exception of RB and WR before Jimmy left me hanging. I was going to take Gonzo at 2.14 but didn't want to double up on byes that early. I thought for sure I would be able to grab LJ at 4.14, then Dillo scooped him up earlier than expected. After that it ended up being a wait and see approach.

Week 3 could be rough with LJ and Brooks out. If I make it past there then I should be fine until week 7\8 which is where I likely make my exit.

Best pick: Brooks

Worst pick: Drew

 

[Winston Smith]

Pretty happy with my team. I suppose that's a given or I wouldn't have drafted it

QB

Trent Green (3)

David Carr (5)

As you mentioned, not exciting, but really solid. I still love Green, and maybe Carr can pull it together this year. Adding Moulds should help. Adding Bush would have helped more.

Overall: B+

RB

Steven Jackson (7)

Reuben Droughns (6)

Marion Barber III (3)

Michael Turner (3)

James Mungro (6)

Well done. Jackson should only improve now that Martz left town. Droughns will benefit from adding LeCharles Bentley to the line, and I think he will score a few more TD. Barber will get touches and is a decent RB3.

Overall: A-

WR

Santana Moss (8)

Plaxico Burress (4)

Donte Stallworth (7)

Brandon Stokely (6)

Brian Finneran (5)

Moss will probably come down a bit with the additions of Lloyd and Randle El, but should be a solid co-WR1 with Burress. That's a nice combo. Stallworth is a good WR3. Stokley and Finneran can contribute. Nice group.

Overall: B+

TE

Ben Troupe

Jeb Putzier

Not exciting, but servicable.

B-

PK

David Akers

John Carney

Good kickers here.

A

DT

New England

New York Jets

Solid.

B+

Overall: I like this team quite a bit. Absolutely no weaknesses. An early favorite to be in the final four. B+

 

[nittanylion]

Team, I dub thee: "Truth is stranger than fiction"

QB: Eagles (Donovan McNabb/Jeff Garcia)/9

Let's imagine for a minute that McNabb doesn't get hurt. That will be my mantra this season, and my only chance to go somewhere with this team. It's not a good idea to go into one of these things with only 2 QB, and two major factors offset the fact that I went with the platoon I chose, which, barring injury, ought to put up some decent production from the pivot. Given the direction I went with my first 3 picks (DD, Holt and AJohnson), it was imperative that I went with a 'multi-threat' QB who would produce with his feet as well as his arm. First, they have a Week 9 bye. The field will have shrunk significantly by then, and the odds are much less in my favor of avoiding the basement. Second, despite the production I should get out of a healthy McNabb in that offense, it remains an NFC East offense, which worries me about some innoportune clunker performances vs divisional foes. However - 16 of my 18 players will be going in Week 8, so I've got a decent shot at immunity for Week 9, and ALL 17 of my other players are going in Week 9 when I won't have a QB, so at least I'll have some options, but it's a HUGE risk I'm taking gambling like this.

RB: 4.1 YPC & a cloud of receptions...

Domanick Davis, Texans/5

Laurence Maroney, Patriots/7

Mewelde Moore, Vikings/6

Cedric Cobbs, Broncos, 4

Michael Pittman, Buccaneers/4

Vernand Morency, Texans/5

My #1 RB is a health risk, and while I drafted the back I think will produce the 2nd most yards on the Texans if Davis has some absences, the two are as different as night and day. With a healthy DD, I have a back that, in a PPR format, gives me a decent amount of latitude. Maroney should see a decent amount of touches, and might even supplant Dillon, but it's equally likely that his role in that offense will be to keep Dillon as productive and healthy as possible, which would lead to that being a RBBC all season. The upside is that Maroney should be the more explosive of the two, and be capable of more 'big plays', and if the Pats are their usual dominant selves, I might get a lot of 'cheap' points out of Maroney in 2nd halfs. PPR rules dictated the picks of MMoore and Pittman, and Cobbs is the wild card. IF, and it's a mighty big if, he takes the reins of the running game in Denver, I'll be in really good shape...lots of potential with this crew but it's a 50-50 proposition that it gets realized...

WR: Holy WR3 rotation, Batman!!!

Torry Holt, Rams/6

Andre Johnson, Texans/5

Joe Jurevicius, Browns/7

Koren Robinson, Vikings/6

Roddy White, Falcons/5

What we don't have in #'s, we make up in Depth Chart Listings!!! Although I only have 5 WR, each one of them should be the #1WR on their respective teams and see plenty of targets. I think Roddy is the only one with significant competition (Crumpler) for targets...I'm actually pretty excited about this group. If I was going to go with only 5 WR, and I am, these would at least be the TYPE of WR's I would choose. Maybe not the personnel, but I'm comfortable that the theory is sound. We'll see if they come through on Sundays. If anyone in this group gets injured for any length of time, I'm due for an early exit...

TE: Solid, but unspectacular

Randy McMichael, Dolphins/8

Alex Smith, Buccaneers/4

I shouldn't have to worry about getting quality production from this duo every week. Very important that Alex Smith has a dominant performance in Week 8 and 9 - at NYG and vs Saints, due to the necessity of making a run at immunity for Week 9, and the more likely possibility that I don't have it...

PK: Loads of upside, and loads of...well, that's a tough one...

Kris Brown, Texans/5

John Hall, Redskins/8

Simply put, John Hall has to be the Redskins PK this season. Word has it that they are going to bring in some 'camp legs' to compete, but they aren't actively trying to replace him; rather, they are looking more at punters who can handle KO's so Hall will be the designated scorer. This Gibbs offense should put up #'s, so Hall will have plenty of opportunities. Kris Brown isn't a bad option as a b/u PK, but if I have to rely on him on a weekly basis as my only source of PK points, signs point to an early exit...

D/ST: I've got a theory at work here, but I'd really have to win this thing for anyone to acknowledge it's greatness...

San Diego, Chargers/3

Simple economic theory and risk management: Provided you draft a halfway decent team, you have a much better chance of surviving, all other things being equal, when there are more teams remaining in the pool. 16-Team League with 18 roster spots available; have to economize where you can...position it makes the most sense to go thin at is D/ST which cannot get 'injured' and will play every week, except for it's bye, so...find a HC/DefCoord/SpecTeams Coaching staff that you like, with decent personnel, and a decent schedule,and then go for the one with the earliest bye week. The Steelers/4 would have probably been the best choice, but likely had to be taken too early for my liking. NYG/4 or Denver/4 were the targets, but were snatched just out of my grasp, so the Chargers/3 are the consolation prize. I'm quite confident I'll still be alive after Week 3, and from there on out, don't have to worry about D/ST byes...in a perfect world, I would have used the pick I saved on another QB, but late breaking DD news convinced me to use that pick on Morency, just to be safe...

This team is all about risk/reward, and there are plenty of question marks, probably too many to expect a lengthy run; but if the stars align, I think I have a shot to go pretty deep.

Echo the thanks to BNB, Twilight and BSS for their contributions to this whole SSL Idea, and League 3 in particular. Pretty damn nice job by everyone keeping this thing moving with a minimum of hiccups. Hoping Jabroni shows up before time runs out and is able to field a complete team.

Interested in hearing others thoughts on my squad.

Best of Luck to everyone!!!

 

[bicycle_seat_sniffer]

Team, I dub thee: "Truth is stranger than fiction"

QB: Eagles (Donovan McNabb/Jeff Garcia)/9

I think Mcnabb  is also in for a solid year, not a big fan of only drafting two QB's from one team.  They have a week 9 bye, but at that point you'll be up against the better teams in the league.  BNB tried this in a WSL and went with Big Ben.  Not a strategy I like.  Grade: C

Let's imagine for a minute that McNabb doesn't get hurt. That will be my mantra this season, and my only chance to go somewhere with this team. It's not a good idea to go into one of these things with only 2 QB, and two major factors offset the fact that I went with the platoon I chose, which, barring injury, ought to put up some decent production from the pivot. Given the direction I went with my first 3 picks (DD, Holt and AJohnson), it was imperative that I went with a 'multi-threat' QB who would produce with his feet as well as his arm.  First, they have a Week 9 bye. The field will have shrunk significantly by then, and the odds are much less in my favor of avoiding the basement. Second, despite the production I should get out of a healthy McNabb in that offense, it remains an NFC East offense, which worries me about some innoportune clunker performances vs divisional foes. However - 16 of my 18 players will be going in Week 8, so I've got a decent shot at immunity for Week 9, and ALL 17 of my other players are going in Week 9 when I won't have a QB, so at least I'll have some options, but it's a HUGE risk I'm taking gambling like this.

RB: 4.1 YPC & a cloud of receptions...

Domanick Davis, Texans/5

Laurence Maroney, Patriots/7

Mewelde Moore, Vikings/6

Cedric Cobbs, Broncos, 4

Michael Pittman, Buccaneers/4

Vernand Morency, Texans/5

DD is as good as it get in this format, the other guys add depth, I would have left the RB stable at 5 though and not drafted Mornecy or Cobbs.  Overall: B+ due to DD,

My #1 RB is a health risk, and while I drafted the back I think will produce the 2nd most yards on the Texans if Davis has some absences, the two are as different as night and day. With a healthy DD, I have a back that, in a PPR format, gives me a decent amount of latitude. Maroney should see a decent amount of touches, and might even supplant Dillon, but it's equally likely that his role in that offense will be to keep Dillon as productive and healthy as possible, which would lead to that being a RBBC all season. The upside is that Maroney should be the more explosive of the two, and be capable of more 'big plays', and if the Pats are their usual dominant selves, I might get a lot of 'cheap' points out of Maroney in 2nd halfs. PPR rules dictated the picks of MMoore and Pittman, and Cobbs is the wild card. IF, and it's a mighty big if, he takes the reins of the running game in Denver, I'll be in really good shape...lots of potential with this crew but it's a 50-50 proposition that it gets realized...

WR: Holy WR3 rotation, Batman!!!

Torry Holt, Rams/6

Andre Johnson, Texans/5

Joe Jurevicius, Browns/7

Koren Robinson, Vikings/6

Roddy White, Falcons/5

This squad is nice, Holt is a stud, AJ & JJ & Krob  will give solid wr2/3 production.  Not sure about anyone in ATL except Crumpler.  Grade:  B+

What we don't have in #'s, we make up in Depth Chart Listings!!! Although I only have 5 WR, each one of them should be the #1WR on their respective teams and see plenty of targets. I think Roddy is the only one with significant competition (Crumpler) for targets...I'm actually pretty excited about this group. If I was going to go with only 5 WR, and I am, these would at least be the TYPE of WR's I would choose. Maybe not the personnel, but I'm comfortable that the theory is sound. We'll see if they come through on Sundays. If anyone in this group gets injured for any length of time, I'm due for an early exit...

TE: Solid, but unspectacular

Randy McMichael, Dolphins/8

Alex Smith, Buccaneers/4

McMike is solid, seems to fade after October every year though.  Grade B

I shouldn't have to worry about getting quality production from this duo every week. Very important that Alex Smith has a dominant performance in Week 8 and 9 - at NYG and vs Saints, due to the necessity of making a run at immunity for Week 9, and the more likely possibility that I don't have it...

PK: Loads of upside, and loads of...well, that's a tough one...

Kris Brown, Texans/5

John Hall, Redskins/8

Simply put, John Hall has to be the Redskins PK this season. Word has it that they are going to bring in some 'camp legs' to compete, but they aren't actively trying to replace him; rather, they are looking more at punters who can handle KO's so Hall will be the designated scorer. This Gibbs offense should put up #'s, so Hall will have plenty of opportunities. Kris Brown isn't a bad option as a b/u PK, but if I have to rely on him on a weekly basis as my only source of PK points, signs point to an early exit...

D/ST: I've got a theory at work here, but I'd really have to win this thing for anyone to acknowledge it's greatness...

San Diego, Chargers/3

Not a big fan of either K or draftin only one D.  K/D= C's

Simple economic theory and risk management: Provided you draft a halfway decent team, you have a much better chance of surviving, all other things being equal, when there are more teams remaining in the pool. 16-Team League with 18 roster spots available; have to economize where you can...position it makes the most sense to go thin at is D/ST which cannot get 'injured' and will play every week, except for it's bye, so...find a HC/DefCoord/SpecTeams Coaching staff that you like, with decent personnel, and a decent schedule,and then go for the one with the earliest bye week. The Steelers/4 would have probably been the best choice, but likely had to be taken too early for my liking. NYG/4 or Denver/4 were the targets, but were snatched just out of my grasp, so the Chargers/3 are the consolation prize. I'm quite confident I'll still be alive after Week 3, and from there on out, don't have to worry about D/ST byes...in a perfect world, I would have used the pick I saved on another QB, but late breaking DD news convinced me to use that pick on Morency, just to be safe...

This team is all about risk/reward, and there are plenty of question marks, probably too many to expect a lengthy run; but if the stars align, I think I have a shot to go pretty deep.

Echo the thanks to BNB, Twilight and BSS for their contributions to this whole SSL Idea, and League 3 in particular. Pretty damn nice job by everyone keeping this thing moving with a minimum of hiccups. Hoping Jabroni shows up before time runs out and is able to field a complete team.

Interested in hearing others thoughts on my squad.

Best of Luck to everyone!!!

Overall :  Only one QB & one D scoring per week will be this teams down fall.  Good RB & WR & TE.  best case could run unitl week 9 when 0 from QB = out.  Grade B-.

 

[bicycle_seat_sniffer]

QB:

6.15 Aaron Brooks (3)

8.14 Steve McNair (7)

Rock solid duo, Im after Brooks in H2H leagues great value. Solid: A

I like Brooks more than most this year. I see top 10 easily. I made the Mcnair pick when it looked like he was going to be a Raven for sure. If that still happens then I like my QB corp, given how long I waited on them.

Best case: Brooksis just what Oakland needs and finishes top 10, McNair ends up with Baltimore and reunites with Mason.

Worst Case: Moss is done, Porter continues to underachieve and Walters takes over midseason. McNair isn't traded and sits behind Volek.

B-

RB:

1.03 Larry Johnson (3),

2.14 Thomas Jones (7)

4.14 Curtis Martin (9)

13.03 Maurice Drew (6)

LJ is a stud, you got a steal with the whole time out mess by bundy1. T.Jones & C mart are a very nice RB2/3 and will produce well. Grade: A

I got a gift with LJ at 1.03 and I'm not complaining. I'm not worried about TJ's holdout and think he gets at worst a 60\40 split with Benson. I'm in the camp that thinks that Cumart has another 1,000 yard season in him. The vastly improved O-line will keep him healthy. Drew looks great in camp. If he produces, great if not I'm not worried about this group.

Best case: LJ lights it up again, TJ and Cumart both get 1,000 and 8. Drew takes over when Taylor goes down.

Worst case: LJ takes a step back with Herm, TJ holds out, and Cumart gets injured and loses his job.

A-

WR:

3.03 Darrell Jackson (5)

5.03 Joey Galloway (4)

7.03 Jimmy Smith (7) RETIRED

9.03 Mark Clayton (7)

10.12 Mike Williams (8)

15.03 Corey Bradford (8)

17.03 Patrick Crayton (3)

With Jimmy Smith this group is scary, wihtout him still good enough. Someone in Det shouldget point week to week right. If not for Jsniff retirement this is an A, but without = B

Oi. Smith retiring hurts big time. The plan was to go 7 deep with 1 top 5 threat, 2 solid and consistant vets, and 4 that would have several big games throughout the year. Well I missed by 1.

I love Clayton this year regardless who is throwing to him. I see potential probowler here in the 9th round. Bradford and Crayton are great in this format because I don't have to figure out which week is going to be the big one.

Best case: DJax's knee is fine, Galloway repeats 2005, Clayton breaks out and everyone else has a few big games.

Worst case: DJax struggles with his knee, Clayton returns to form and outproduces Galloway, Mark Clayton suffers another year with Boller and everyone else rarely sees the field.

C+ (A- with Jimmy)

TE:

11.03 Erron Kinney (7)

12.15 Bubba Franks (6)

Two solid value plays late in the draft, only true weakness but could surprise. Grade C

I really don't think that Troupe is going to vastly outproduce Kinney this year. He may get a few more redzone looks, but I see a similar split to last year. Bubba is being severely undervalued this year in my opinion. With no real #2 in GB, Bubba bounces back from his injury season in 2005. I got him in the 19th in WSL2, but knew he wouldn't last that long here with the FBG rankings out.

Best case: Kinney repeats with 50 catches, Franks and Favre reconnect

Worst case: Troupe takes over, Franks continues his downward spiral

C+

K:

16.14 Rian Lindell (8)

Clearly I waited to long on a Kicker. In retrospect I should have grabbed a 2nd one instead of Crayton at 17.03. By my last pick there were no clear cut starters left. The bye sucks too.

D+

D\ST:

14.14 Cincinatti (5)

18.14 Oakland (3)

I like Cincy, they get INT's by the bunch, oak is filler, one K is o.k. Grade: C

I was going to just go with one D with no huge bye week conflict in week 5, but when there were no kickers left I figured I better grab one of the only 2 left to cover a few points.

C

Overall: B-

I felt like I was behind every run with the exception of RB and WR before Jimmy left me hanging. I was going to take Gonzo at 2.14 but didn't want to double up on byes that early. I thought for sure I would be able to grab LJ at 4.14, then Dillo scooped him up earlier than expected. After that it ended up being a wait and see approach.

Week 3 could be rough with LJ and Brooks out. If I make it past there then I should be fine until week 7\8 which is where I likely make my exit.

Best pick: Brooks

Worst pick: Drew

overall this team is rough & tumble will progress far even with the wildcard positions not looking strong but this teams has Great QB/RB/WR combo going. Overall A-

 

[bicycle_seat_sniffer]

Here it goes.

QB: Grade: C

Carson Palmer, CIN - 5

Chris Simms, TB - 4

Palmer is risky, but if healthy this will pay off huge. If you only have Simms early this could hurt Grade: C

I like Palmer even with the injury. If he is able to play at any time before the bye I'll be more than happy and my QBs will get an instant upgrade. If not, this may be a short season for this team. Simms should be marginally better than he was last year with a healthy M Clayton and a stud running back with a full year under his belt.

RB: Grade B-

Lamont Jordan, OAK - 3

Deuce McAllister, NO - 7

Kevan Barlow, SF - 7

Greg Jones, JAX - 6

I like Lamont, but Deuce's role is very murky plus the ACL injury, I like Gore over Barlow but G.Jones is interesting, Freddy T usually plays until Halloween, but we'll see, Grade: B-

Just couldn't pass up L Jordan with the #12 pick. His catches may drop off, but he should be a bit more confortable in OAK this year with a healthy Moss and Porter. I dont see R Bush coming in a taking all the carries in the NO offense. He may not even get signed until mid-late August. Duece should still get 15+ carries a game if healthy and most if not all of the goal line duty. Barlow in the 7th? I'll take it. Greg Jones ran hard when given chanes and should see action to pick up some slack. Week 7 may kill me at this position.



WR: Grade B+

Chad Johnson, CIN - 5

Reggie Wayne, IND - 6

Kevin Curtis, STL - 7

Chad Jackson, NE - 6

Jabbar Gaffney, PHI - 9

Keary Colbert, CAR - 9

The meat and potatos of this squad, solid 1 thru 3, and I liek the upside of your bottom 3, grade A-

Solid core with C Johnson and R Wayne. Gaffney (55/492 in Houston) may or may not shine in a group of unproven receivers in Philly. That's if he can stay on the field. Curtis should produce with an aging I Bruce. C Jackson is a reach, but you never know who is going to get the ball in NE.

TE: Grade C

Vernon Davis, SF - 7

Coutrney Anderson, OAK - 3

I hope Vdavis is up to the hype cause C.anderson wont get it done. Grade: C

I dont think they'd waste a #7 pick on a TE if they didn't plan on using him sooner rather than later. SF is probably going to suck and E Johnson, if healthy, may eat into his playing time. C Anderson was a disappointment last year, but did start all but 3 games for the Raiders. Again, I'm going to need some luck at this position.

K: Grade C

Jason Elam, Den - 4

Rob Bironas,Tenn - 7

2 average kickers with different byes.



DEF:Grade C-

Dallas DEF 3

Minnesota DEF 6

K's and D are solid, I really like Dallas this year. Grade A

If I could do it again, I would have waited a little longer to take my first defense and grabbed a 3rd QB instead.

Overall Grade: C+.

Lots of unanswered questions, but I'm hoping to do better than my last place finish in 2005.

Overall, This tema is good to contend for awhile, WR's are strong but Palmer's health will decide alot. Grade: B

 

[Family Matters]

Here it goes.

QB: Grade: C

Carson Palmer, CIN - 5

Chris Simms, TB - 4

Palmer is risky, but if healthy this will pay off huge. If you only have Simms early this could hurt  Grade: C

I like Palmer even with the injury. If he is able to play at any time before the bye I'll be more than happy and my QBs will get an instant upgrade. If not, this may be a short season for this team. Simms should be marginally better than he was last year with a healthy M Clayton and a stud running back with a full year under his belt. 

RB: Grade B-

Lamont Jordan, OAK - 3

Deuce McAllister, NO - 7

Kevan Barlow, SF - 7

Greg Jones, JAX - 6

I like Lamont, but Deuce's role is very murky plus the ACL injury, I like Gore over Barlow but G.Jones is interesting, Freddy T usually plays until Halloween, but we'll see, Grade: B-

Just couldn't pass up L Jordan with the #12 pick. His catches may drop off, but he should be a bit more confortable in OAK this year with a healthy Moss and Porter. I dont see R Bush coming in a taking all the carries in the NO offense. He may not even get signed until mid-late August. Duece should still get 15+ carries a game if healthy and most if not all of the goal line duty. Barlow in the 7th? I'll take it. Greg Jones ran hard when given chanes and should see action to pick up some slack. Week 7 may kill me at this position. 



WR: Grade B+

Chad Johnson, CIN - 5

Reggie Wayne, IND - 6

Kevin Curtis, STL - 7

Chad Jackson, NE - 6

Jabbar Gaffney, PHI - 9

Keary Colbert, CAR - 9

The meat and potatos of this squad, solid 1 thru 3, and I like the upside of your bottom 3,  grade A-

Solid core with C Johnson and R Wayne. Gaffney (55/492 in Houston) may or may not shine in a group of unproven receivers in Philly. That's if he can stay on the field. Curtis should produce with an aging I Bruce. C Jackson is a reach, but you never know who is going to get the ball in NE.

TE: Grade C

Vernon Davis, SF - 7

Coutrney Anderson, OAK - 3

I hope Vdavis is up to the hype cause C.anderson wont get it done.  Grade: C

I dont think they'd waste a #7 pick on a TE if they didn't plan on using him sooner rather than later. SF is probably going to suck and E Johnson, if healthy, may eat into his playing time. C Anderson was a disappointment last year, but did start all but 3 games for the Raiders. Again, I'm going to need some luck at this position.

K: Grade C

Jason Elam, Den - 4

Rob Bironas,Tenn - 7

2 average kickers with different byes.



DEF:Grade C-

Dallas DEF  3

Minnesota DEF 6

K's and D are solid, I really like Dallas this year. Grade A

If I could do it again, I would have waited a little longer to take my first defense and grabbed a 3rd QB instead. 

Overall Grade: C+.

Lots of unanswered questions, but I'm hoping to do better than my last place finish in 2005.

Overall, This tema is good to contend for awhile, WR's are strong but Palmer's health will decide alot.  Grade: B

Sorry but when you say:

The meat and potatos of this squad

and then say:

I like the upside of your bottom

I can't help but do this