Steve Smith or Mario Manningham? (1 Viewer)

[dparker713]

That is how I've been thinking this thing would turn out. Manningham/Nicks as the starters (not sure who will be the technical #1) and Smith in the slot. Smith is destined for a slot role and he would be perfect for it.

Smith has played excellently. He's in the Toomer role for this offense, so I doubt he's going anywhere anytime soon.

 

[Jed]

Manningham is the best WR on the NYG roster and is easily the guy to own. Always was.

Incredibly wrong. By week 8 he will be fighting for time.

really? why? him and Eli seem to be clicking, as well as Eli to SSmith.Hixon hasnt impressed me and the rookie is well a rookie and both guys are hurt.

I know the Giants - huge homer. They are salivating to get Nicks back and give him work. Hixon is nothing, I agree. Nicks is the real threat to Manningham. SS will be gold no matter what is going on around him.

Wow...instant cred in my book

And your take is more informed?